You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Loaning players you cannot buy, a fools errand
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Loaning players you cannot buy, a fools errand


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Maine Eagle Flag USA 07 Oct 18 11.53am

I said at the time we got TFM and RLC in that getting high quality loan players is a double edged sword.

We are missing Cabaye this year but I think we are missing RLC more. Go back and watch the 5-0 against Leicester and you will see just how important and quality the guy was for us.

Getting loan players in that you cannot buy is the ultimate short term move in football. Now we have not only a Cabaye shaped hole, which is impacting Luka big time, but we have a massive gap where RLC was.

Getting these loan players in looks great at face value but when you start to rely on them, and they become integral to your system, you have to expect a hangover when they disappear.

Loaning players from big clubs is great for the player and the big club, but If we don’t have an option to buy it’s a short term move for us that can then bite us hard.

Watch that Leicester game again.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 07 Oct 18 12.51pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I said at the time we got TFM and RLC in that getting high quality loan players is a double edged sword.

We are missing Cabaye this year but I think we are missing RLC more. Go back and watch the 5-0 against Leicester and you will see just how important and quality the guy was for us.

Getting loan players in that you cannot buy is the ultimate short term move in football. Now we have not only a Cabaye shaped hole, which is impacting Luka big time, but we have a massive gap where RLC was.

Getting these loan players in looks great at face value but when you start to rely on them, and they become integral to your system, you have to expect a hangover when they disappear.

Loaning players from big clubs is great for the player and the big club, but If we don’t have an option to buy it’s a short term move for us that can then bite us hard.

Watch that Leicester game again.


I agree with everything you say here. However, i still wish we has RLC on loan for this season.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 07 Oct 18 12.52pm

RLC was a great addition to the team last season but not sure that he was pivotal to us winning a huge amount of games last season. Taking players from the bigger clubs seems the only benefit in the loan system as they seem to be the players that perform, many others do not. Even then it isn't a sure hit. TFM didn't do a lot last season in my opinion. As far as I am aware we have 1 loan place free, maybe RLC will come in Jan ?

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 07 Oct 18 12.52pm

i dont agree with your stance.

loans usually suit all parties, but nowadays were just doing it on a larger scale, we used to get james vaughan & forsell. now we get players like RLC. max meyer will be filling the cabaye role when he gets his slot full time.

i agree we miss RLC, but i would rather have had him for a season & miss him when he leaves than never having seen him play in red & blue.

the mistake fans made was pinning their hopes on RLC coming back.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


mattteo Flag 07 Oct 18 1.14pm

Agreed with the OP. They help short term but do more damage long term cause they leave just when the other players get used to how they move and where they pass.

If you can't keep the player for at least 2 years and don;t have an option to buy, no point in loaning him.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 07 Oct 18 2.43pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Agreed with the OP. They help short term but do more damage long term cause they leave just when the other players get used to how they move and where they pass.

If you can't keep the player for at least 2 years and don;t have an option to buy, no point in loaning him.

Sorry disagree. I agree with Braunstone. Never heard people moan when we loaned Paul Stewart, who helped us win promotion but was never going to sign for us.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 07 Oct 18 3.14pm

RLC is so over rated he spent almost half the time injured and then when he did play it's not a if he was scoring bunch of goals or offering up loads of assists.

He was what we needed at the time due to injury problems but if we had him now I can't see how he would offer anything we need also Roy would just end up playing him on the wing

the big problem with loan system now is the big clubs are holding other ransom for them they dictate high fees yet have no interest in even using the players RLC is example not even featuring for Chelsea yet not gone out on loan again because they are being greedy with fees otherwise I think Palace would of got him again

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 07 Oct 18 4.26pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

RLC is so over rated he spent almost half the time injured and then when he did play it's not a if he was scoring bunch of goals or offering up loads of assists.

He was what we needed at the time due to injury problems but if we had him now I can't see how he would offer anything we need also Roy would just end up playing him on the wing

the big problem with loan system now is the big clubs are holding other ransom for them they dictate high fees yet have no interest in even using the players RLC is example not even featuring for Chelsea yet not gone out on loan again because they are being greedy with fees otherwise I think Palace would of got him again

i would suggest RLC is not over-rated, you are however of course correct he didnt score or set up bucketloads of goals but he was so strong & assured in possession, also you could tell wilf absolutly loved playing alonngside him.

when he really got into his stride 2nd half of the season he really was a class above anybody else doing that job in our team.

the thing i do like about loaning players is lets say he cost us £5m last season, he is a £30m player allday long and reslly that is actually a smart way of imrpoving your squad for a season.

you could also argue that loaning sakho really was the difference in us staying up or getting relegated season before last.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


AERO Flag 07 Oct 18 5.31pm

RLC overrated and too injury prone , will be injured more than playing if we get him again

 

Robk Flag 07 Oct 18 6.10pm

Don’t agree that he’s overrated.... think he fits the system well and he doesn’t look like he’ll be playing much at Chelsea he might as well come back.. agree that will suit and help Wilf.....

 

Casual Flag Orpington 07 Oct 18 6.32pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I said at the time we got TFM and RLC in that getting high quality loan players is a double edged sword.

We are missing Cabaye this year but I think we are missing RLC more. Go back and watch the 5-0 against Leicester and you will see just how important and quality the guy was for us.

Getting loan players in that you cannot buy is the ultimate short term move in football. Now we have not only a Cabaye shaped hole, which is impacting Luka big time, but we have a massive gap where RLC was.

Getting these loan players in looks great at face value but when you start to rely on them, and they become integral to your system, you have to expect a hangover when they disappear.

Loaning players from big clubs is great for the player and the big club, but If we don’t have an option to buy it’s a short term move for us that can then bite us hard.

Watch that Leicester game again.


I think calling TFM high quality is stretching the truth a tad.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 07 Oct 18 10.54pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

i dont agree with your stance.

loans usually suit all parties, but nowadays were just doing it on a larger scale, we used to get james vaughan & forsell. now we get players like RLC. max meyer will be filling the cabaye role when he gets his slot full time.

i agree we miss RLC, but i would rather have had him for a season & miss him when he leaves than never having seen him play in red & blue.

the mistake fans made was pinning their hopes on RLC coming back.

I definitely get that sentiment but how often do managers, players and ex-players talk about familiarity with teammates being a huge factor.

When you get someone like RLC in you basically have a 10% chance of getting them permanently, if that. Hoping for such a player to be really successful at the club seems totally counter intuitive to me.

Its the ultimate in short term, lack of "joined up" thinking. If the guy does well, especially in the opponents half, then he disappears there is going to be a hangover period.

Just watch that Leicester game, I know its only 1 game, and their heads dropped and they went down to 10, but the way we passed and moved in that game was a million miles from what we saw yesterday.

We havent replaced Cabaye which is criminal (we have some career criminals working in our player recruitment dept) but the lack of power, dynamism, great passing and forward thinking from RLC is really hurting us.

We had so long to replace both players and we failed, based on how things look currently. I would rather just have 1 hole in midfield, rather than a 2nd one which is self inflicted.

Time to have a long term strategy at our club, and that should not include loaning world class players we cannot buy IMHO.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

essetwentyone Flag london 08 Oct 18 5.52am

Taking top players in on loan is a good thing even if it is difficult to replace them when they return to their mother club. The loss is no different to losing a new purchase to long term injury ( eg Connor Wickham ).

Due to the World Cup plus the shortened transfer window RLC didn’t have a long time to make his decision but he opted to try his luck staying at Chelsea which so far has been a big mistake for him and bad news for us. Hopefully he will change his mind in January.

The loan system needs changing to limit how many players a club can loan out which would stop clubs like Chelsea from manipulating the market.

 

dannyboy1978 Flag 08 Oct 18 7.38am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I said at the time we got TFM and RLC in that getting high quality loan players is a double edged sword.

We are missing Cabaye this year but I think we are missing RLC more. Go back and watch the 5-0 against Leicester and you will see just how important and quality the guy was for us.

Getting loan players in that you cannot buy is the ultimate short term move in football. Now we have not only a Cabaye shaped hole, which is impacting Luka big time, but we have a massive gap where RLC was.

Getting these loan players in looks great at face value but when you start to rely on them, and they become integral to your system, you have to expect a hangover when they disappear.

Loaning players from big clubs is great for the player and the big club, but If we don’t have an option to buy it’s a short term move for us that can then bite us hard.

Watch that Leicester game again.

I disagree, Luka is making un forced errors nothing to do with cabaye. Mcarther is firing on all cylinders ok?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 08 Oct 18 8.28am

I disagree with "Loaning players you cannot buy, a fools errand" as if one uses the system well it benefits all parties. Our problem is that we haven't used the system as well as some of the other clubs and we take on strikers with a terrible record of injuries then complain when he's out for most of the season injured.

I do agree that clubs should be limited in the number of players that they can loan out and believe that the authorities are looking at this at the moment which will be extremely painful for Chelsea who have over 40 players out on loan

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 08 Oct 18 9.20am

If you accept that we will have 1-2 quality loan signings each season then it's not a short term fix, it's part of our strategy to have a squad that can compete in the Prem and fits our finances.

 

essetwentyone Flag london 08 Oct 18 11.56am

If we hadn’t used the loan system we’d probably still be in the Championship ! Wilf was our best loan ever without doubt!

 

Aray Flag South London 08 Oct 18 12.47pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I definitely get that sentiment but how often do managers, players and ex-players talk about familiarity with teammates being a huge factor.

When you get someone like RLC in you basically have a 10% chance of getting them permanently, if that. Hoping for such a player to be really successful at the club seems totally counter intuitive to me.

Its the ultimate in short term, lack of "joined up" thinking. If the guy does well, especially in the opponents half, then he disappears there is going to be a hangover period.

Just watch that Leicester game, I know its only 1 game, and their heads dropped and they went down to 10, but the way we passed and moved in that game was a million miles from what we saw yesterday.

We havent replaced Cabaye which is criminal (we have some career criminals working in our player recruitment dept) but the lack of power, dynamism, great passing and forward thinking from RLC is really hurting us.

We had so long to replace both players and we failed, based on how things look currently. I would rather just have 1 hole in midfield, rather than a 2nd one which is self inflicted.

Time to have a long term strategy at our club, and that should not include loaning world class players we cannot buy IMHO.

I dont understand this. Meyer played the holding role for Shalke last season. the same position Cabaye played for us. Shalke finished 2nd last year or summat. Why he isn't starting I have no idea but we did replace Cabaye.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 08 Oct 18 1.56pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

If you accept that we will have 1-2 quality loan signings each season then it's not a short term fix, it's part of our strategy to have a squad that can compete in the Prem and fits our finances.

Absolutely agree but where is our strong, skillful, high quality midfield player for this loan season?

On the whole our loan business has been poor. If we get in similar types of players each year then this could be called a long term strategy, trouble is we don’t do anything like that.

When you build systems around temporary players you are going to struggle when they leave. I believe we are unable to carve out any clear goal scoring opportunities right now because our midfield is not functioning as it did towards the back end of last season, as per that Leicester game. A big part of that problem is we don’t have anyone remotely similar to RLC in the squad this year.

It was nice to see him play for us last year, but not so nice this year to see what I believe is a problem tactically caused by him not being around anymore.

Something has changed big time from the end of last season to the start of this one, I am sure we can all agree on that at least. We looked hopeless against Wolves,

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 08 Oct 18 1.56pm

Originally posted by essetwentyone

If we hadn’t used the loan system we’d probably still be in the Championship ! Wilf was our best loan ever without doubt!

I fully support loans with an option to buy.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Loaning players you cannot buy, a fools errand