You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Captain?
November 16 2026 6.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Captain?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Casual Flag Orpington 10 Mar 19 8.25pm

Luka has zero personality , Dann couldn’t handle it when he was made captain.
The last real captain was Jedinak. Hughes, Thomas, Cannon were great.
We need one , “ he’s from Serbia, he’ll f*ckinc murder ya” what a f*cking joke he melted yesterday in the biggest game of the season , at home.
Is there a real leader in the squad? If not we need to buy one.

 

Master Coin Flag 10 Mar 19 8.47pm

f***ing ludicrous. He took a kicking yesterday and laughed it off. He was also cool under pressure and handled the responsibilities of the penalty (as ever). He’s a fine captain. I get being angry about yesterday but this isn’t the place to vent. The issue was a turgid central midfield display with most of the fault at the doorstep of Schlupp, Macca and Andros who conceded possession constantly.

 

Tom R Flag Huddersfield 10 Mar 19 9.00pm

Absolute rubbish. As MC said he took a battering yesterday but still stood up and was one of the best players on the pitch

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 10 Mar 19 9.03pm

He didn’t melt. That is rubbish.

Fine captain and leader out there.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Casual Flag Orpington 10 Mar 19 9.06pm

Originally posted by Master Coin

f***ing ludicrous. He took a kicking yesterday and laughed it off. He was also cool under pressure and handled the responsibilities of the penalty (as ever). He’s a fine captain. I get being angry about yesterday but this isn’t the place to vent. The issue was a turgid central midfield display with most of the fault at the doorstep of Schlupp, Macca and Andros who conceded possession constantly.

Not at all. We’ve needed a leader since Jedinak left and have chosen Luka. He a reasonable midfielder, sometimes better than average , sometimes worse.
Good penalty taker , but never a captain. He laughed off the kicking from yesterday? Couldn’t see that from the Holmesdale , looked like the only players laughing were Dunk and his mates after the game.
Thought the whole midfield may aswell have stayed at home yesterday , but for me the first change should have been Luka for Kouate, after about 30 minutes.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 10 Mar 19 9.07pm

Originally posted by Tom R

Absolute rubbish. As MC said he took a battering yesterday but still stood up and was one of the best players on the pitch

Was he? Passing it backwards to Dann, who passed it to pva who gave the ball away.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 10 Mar 19 9.10pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

He didn’t melt. That is rubbish.

Fine captain and leader out there.

Is he. When he took a corner did he get the ball and raise his hands up to get the Palace fans going ? Did he f*ck.
he put his head down, no interaction with the fans and chipped in a corner with back spin aiming at no one..
He’s good enough to be in the eleven , never a leader.

 

Tom R Flag Huddersfield 10 Mar 19 9.28pm

I was talking about 90 minutes, not just one pass but you obviously don't have the mental ability to concentrate that long. Luka has been consistently a good leader and player throughout his time and the club so as I said before you are talking absolute rubbish.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 10 Mar 19 9.34pm

Certainly could have done with someone demanding some passion and intensity out there. Can't say that Luka's not committed, but we needed a Jedinak or a Delaney this weekend who would f***ing demand that we get at Brighton. Instead we strolled around as if we were sitting on a 2-0 lead.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 10 Mar 19 9.38pm

Originally posted by Tom R

I was talking about 90 minutes, not just one pass but you obviously don't have the mental ability to concentrate that long. Luka has been consistently a good leader and player throughout his time and the club so as I said before you are talking absolute rubbish.

I can’t remeber him making one forward pass yesterday. Remember him making a few “Hollywood passes” and none of them reaching our player. I don’t dislike the player , think he is pretty average , but does he puff out his chest in a derby and look like he understands the history? No, he never has.
Never a captain , as much as we want him to be, would probably play better without it to be honest. We are a team of 11 and no one has the bo**ocks to lead. Where’s Michael Hughes with his sleeves rolled up?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 10 Mar 19 9.40pm

Originally posted by Casual

I can’t remeber him making one forward pass yesterday. Remember him making a few “Hollywood passes” and none of them reaching our player. I don’t dislike the player , think he is pretty average , but does he puff out his chest in a derby and look like he understands the history? No, he never has.
Never a captain , as much as we want him to be, would probably play better without it to be honest. We are a team of 11 and no one has the bo**ocks to lead. Where’s Michael Hughes with his sleeves rolled up?

He’s a defensive midfielder. If you watch he is the one who constantly looks for the ball from then back 4. He’s having to try and do everything. Be creative and a destroyer. He isn’t the former.

He never shys away though. And does lead from the front.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 10 Mar 19 9.42pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Certainly could have done with someone demanding some passion and intensity out there. Can't say that Luka's not committed, but we needed a Jedinak or a Delaney this weekend who would f***ing demand that we get at Brighton. Instead we strolled around as if we were sitting on a 2-0 lead.

Nail on head. I watched their keeper celebrate each of their goals with their fans , and their players run up to the away end at the end and was sad that we had no one that really gave a f*ck, Wright, bright, grey , thomas , hughes , rhilati etc. I Callled dunk a c*nt all game , but he never played like one.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 10 Mar 19 9.46pm

Originally posted by robdave2k

He’s a defensive midfielder. If you watch he is the one who constantly looks for the ball from then back 4. He’s having to try and do everything. Be creative and a destroyer. He isn’t the former.

He never shys away though. And does lead from the front.

Agree. He’s a defensive midfielder, and not a bad one.
What are the other midfielders doing, and as captain why isn’t he telling them what to do ?

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 10 Mar 19 10.17pm

Originally posted by Master Coin

f***ing ludicrous. He took a kicking yesterday and laughed it off. He was also cool under pressure and handled the responsibilities of the penalty (as ever). He’s a fine captain. I get being angry about yesterday but this isn’t the place to vent. The issue was a turgid central midfield display with most of the fault at the doorstep of Schlupp, Macca and Andros who conceded possession constantly.

It's not f@cking ludicrous. Luka is a decent enough player but he does not have any physical presence about him. Jedi could not run with the ball, his passing was sh@t and he had limited ability, but boy did he put himself about. Luka has some good qualities but Casual makes some good points.
Yesterday Luka was out muscled and that hasn't been the first time.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 10 Mar 19 10.37pm

Seems I'm in the minority, but I completely agree with the original post.

He's a good player, but not a captain. He got crunched early yesterday and rolled over. A derby game where someone has done you and the ref is letting stuff go and you don't retaliate with a hard challenge of your own? Embarrassing. I also think he's left Wilf completely unprotected all season. He's got the right to get in the ref's face as Captain but doesn't. He should've had a lot more yellows for studding people in retaliation for what Wilf has been getting and as for letting Deeney come onto our pitch after what happened at Vicarage road and what he said after? Captain to Captain that should've gone off in the tunnel let alone on the pitch.
We're seen as soft, you can tell if only by yesterday. Kick'em hard and you won't see them all game, that's what the opponents have sussed.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 10 Mar 19 11.12pm

When I look at the squad Dann is the obvious captain material but he isn't a first teamer.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 10 Mar 19 11.22pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

When I look at the squad Dann is the obvious captain material but he isn't a first teamer.

I dunno, I'm not sure he's vocal enough and he didn't seem to thrive when Pardew bestowed it on him. Nobody really jumps out, but if pushed I'd go with Tommo.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 10 Mar 19 11.39pm

First and foremost a captain has to have the respect of his players which, I believe he has. Whilst it would be nice to see some outward signs of this, it is not in my opinion a key requirement. The players respect is.
I agree that yesterday needed to see passion for that game given the occasion but and with particular reference to Luka he took one hell of a kick which, would have put any lesser person out of the game and of course that was Brighton’s/ Knockaerts intentions. How he held himself together for what was the full 90 minutes when clearly in pain was a tremendous testament to his commitment and strength of purpose. There must be nothing worse when you see a player get up and stay on when you have well and truly pole axed him plus smile!!
My concern is that he doesn’t impose himself on refs (verbally) in the way that Roy Keane did and protect the likes of Zaha.
My overall opinion of the mood of the players yesterday was that they just didn’t look up for it which, extended to the crowd. Was it complacency or frustration at Roy’s tactical rigidity?
My conclusion - very unfair to call out Luka as a poor captain and let’s all hope that his tes**cles are still in one piece!

 


Bring back Brolin

Maine Eagle Flag USA 10 Mar 19 11.47pm

Originally posted by Casual

Is he. When he took a corner did he get the ball and raise his hands up to get the Palace fans going ? Did he f*ck.
he put his head down, no interaction with the fans and chipped in a corner with back spin aiming at no one..
He’s good enough to be in the eleven , never a leader.

Wtf are you going on about mate? He is supposed to do a jig every time he takes a corner? How about some pom poms?

This must be a wind up.

He takes sh*t corners but that has nothing to do with his chops as our skipper.

Edited by Maine Eagle (10 Mar 2019 11.48pm)

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Casual Flag Orpington 11 Mar 19 12.51am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Wtf are you going on about mate? He is supposed to do a jig every time he takes a corner? How about some pom poms?

This must be a wind up.

He takes sh*t corners but that has nothing to do with his chops as our skipper.

Edited by Maine Eagle (10 Mar 2019 11.48pm)

You’ve never seen. Hughes, thomas , jedinak, Gazza, Adams, Terry, Gerrard , Robson , Keane, etc raise their hands or beat their chest with their fist and raise their hand to the crowd when the ball goes off the pitch in a big game?
He hasn’t got enough about him to lead a group of men.
Fair enough. He was probably listening to garage music on his beats headphones like the rest of our lot as the Brighton players were celebrating with their fans on our pitch at the end.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Captain?