You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Billy Vunipola and Isreal Folau
November 21 2026 11.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Billy Vunipola and Isreal Folau


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Apr 19 5.31pm

Folau sacked from rugby for stating religious views on social media. Basically citing the Bible that homosexuals will be punished.
Billy Vunipola seriously castigated for agreeing with Folau.
My take on this, is that - these people should be entitled to their religious beliefs - whether we agree with them or not.
Perhaps best not to post these beliefs on social media but it is supposedly a free world.

[Link]

 


Red and Blue Army!

Invalid user 2019 Flag 17 Apr 19 5.51pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Folau sacked from rugby for stating religious views on social media. Basically citing the Bible that homosexuals will be punished.
Billy Vunipola seriously castigated for agreeing with Folau.
My take on this, is that - these people should be entitled to their religious beliefs - whether we agree with them or not.
Perhaps best not to post these beliefs on social media but it is supposedly a free world.

[Link]

Sounds like you'll be happy to take the ISIS schoolgirl in then? I mean, she's only been being guided by her religious convictions after all. Her husbands possible crimes are not hers. Free country and all that.

When you're a member of a team, and represent your nation, I think it's preferable to act like you do. It's a privilege to be in a position where you are idolised for your abilities, and it's a shame for it to be used to push hatred and hell at people. Saying 'it's my religious belief' isn't a magic umbrella that removed responsibility for how you treat others. It's bad publicly. If you sully something that you are supposed to represent, if may impact how your contribution is received. He'd already had a warning and can't follow rules. I wouldn't have sacked him though. Instead I'd have asked the team if his self indulgent distractions were impacting the team dynamic and were an unhelpful distraction, and then base the decision on that.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 17 Apr 19 6.00pm

Originally posted by dollardays

Sounds like you'll be happy to take the ISIS schoolgirl in then? I mean, she's only been being guided by her religious convictions after all. Her husbands possible crimes are not hers. Free country and all that.

When you're a member of a team, and represent your nation, I think it's preferable to act like you do. It's a privilege to be in a position where you are idolised for your abilities, and it's a shame for it to be used to push hatred and hell at people. Saying 'it's my religious belief' isn't a magic umbrella that removed responsibility for how you treat others. It's bad publicly. If you sully something that you are supposed to represent, if may impact how your contribution is received. He'd already had a warning and can't follow rules. I wouldn't have sacked him though. Instead I'd have asked the team if his self indulgent distractions were impacting the team dynamic and were an unhelpful distraction, and then base the decision on that.

One possible difference is that neither player left their home country to join a militant group intent on causing harm to others.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Apr 19 6.01pm

Originally posted by dollardays

Sounds like you'll be happy to take the ISIS schoolgirl in then? I mean, she's only been being guided by her religious convictions after all. Her husbands possible crimes are not hers. Free country and all that.

When you're a member of a team, and represent your nation, I think it's preferable to act like you do. It's a privilege to be in a position where you are idolised for your abilities, and it's a shame for it to be used to push hatred and hell at people. Saying 'it's my religious belief' isn't a magic umbrella that removed responsibility for how you treat others. It's bad publicly. If you sully something that you are supposed to represent, if may impact how your contribution is received. He'd already had a warning and can't follow rules. I wouldn't have sacked him though. Instead I'd have asked the team if his self indulgent distractions were impacting the team dynamic and were an unhelpful distraction, and then base the decision on that.

As far as I'm aware - Islam espouses hatred towards homosexuals all of the time. It is part of their religion. They also don't like alcohol or pork just to let you know. As far as I know, Muslims are free to air these views.
You certainly have something on the representation side and on the effects on team-mates. That is why it would be best to not make these views public - in my opinion.
However, perhaps they should be allowed these views and why should their religious beliefs affect their job? That is the debate really. Not sure which side you are coming down on. Sounds like you want to sack all people with religious beliefs that don't suit your agenda.
I love the line that I must take Shamima Begum in, simply because I have stated people should be freely allowed to express views.
Nowhere did I say I agreed with the views. I just believe that Vunipola and Folau can think what they like - without getting the sack for it.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Invalid user 2019 Flag 17 Apr 19 6.20pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

As far as I'm aware - Islam espouses hatred towards homosexuals all of the time. It is part of their religion. They also don't like alcohol or pork just to let you know. As far as I know, Muslims are free to air these views.

You certainly have something on the representation side and on the effects on team-mates. That is why it would be best to not make these views public - in my opinion.
However, perhaps they should be allowed these views and why should their religious beliefs affect their job? That is the debate really. Not sure which side you are coming down on. Sounds like you want to sack all people with religious beliefs that don't suit your agenda.
I love the line that I must take Shamima Begum in, simply because I have stated people should be freely allowed to express views.
Nowhere did I say I agreed with the views. I just believe that Vunipola and Folau can think what they like - without getting the sack for it.

This has occurred primarily due to the high profile of the individual involved.

So whoever in his position said this and whatever the religion it would've ignited. That said, I do think within society there has been a hands off approach with certain religions for too long, and it helps no-one resulting in parallel societies and values that are worlds apart.

My comments about taking Shamima Begum in were tongue in cheek. I'm all over that thread saying that we should never let her back into the country. I do however appreciate that there are aspects of freedom of speech to her situation. I understand that in taking the stance I did, I'm saying that I don't particularly think that someone making unnecessary and extreme statements based on a religious belief should be given endless benefit of the doubt or a free pass in society.


Edited by dollardays (17 Apr 2019 6.28pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Apr 19 6.36pm

Originally posted by dollardays

Sounds like you'll be happy to take the ISIS schoolgirl in then? I mean, she's only been being guided by her religious convictions after all. Her husbands possible crimes are not hers. Free country and all that.

When you're a member of a team, and represent your nation, I think it's preferable to act like you do. It's a privilege to be in a position where you are idolised for your abilities, and it's a shame for it to be used to push hatred and hell at people. Saying 'it's my religious belief' isn't a magic umbrella that removed responsibility for how you treat others. It's bad publicly. If you sully something that you are supposed to represent, if may impact how your contribution is received. He'd already had a warning and can't follow rules. I wouldn't have sacked him though. Instead I'd have asked the team if his self indulgent distractions were impacting the team dynamic and were an unhelpful distraction, and then base the decision on that.

I'm sorry but comparing the expression of religious beliefs about what would happen to people in the imaginary hereafter with the realities of someone who joins an actual group dedicated to actually throwing homosexuals off of roof tops and anyone else who gets in their way is sheer hyperbole.

If somebody doesn't like homosexuality it is a disgrace that they get their living taken away. Thoughts are not action.

I don't like gay activists, there was a time when it was a noble thing but now in fact I think they are among the biggest pain in the arses around. I think the correctness of making homosexuality legal where it isn't greeted with state interference or punishment has slowly turned into the absurd situation where any expression of not supporting it is greeted with punishment.

Clown world.


Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Apr 2019 6.40pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Apr 19 6.43pm

Social conservatives voted in liberalism because they listened to fair arguments.

Now social conservatives are the persecuted.....they keep their heads down in many professions because of stuff like this.

What were liberals then turned into authoritarians once they gained hegemony.

Seems a rather nasty lesson to me.


Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Apr 2019 6.45pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Invalid user 2019 Flag 17 Apr 19 6.49pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I'm sorry but comparing the expression of religious beliefs about what would happen to people in the imaginary hereafter with the realities of someone who joins an actual group dedicated to actually throwing homosexuals off of roof tops and anyone else who gets in their way is sheer hyperbole.

If somebody doesn't like homosexuality it is a disgrace that they get their living taken away. Thoughts are not action.

I don't like gay activists, in fact I think they are among the biggest pain in the arses around. I think the correctness of making homosexuality legal has slowly turned into the absurd situation where any expression of not supporting it is greeted with punishment.

Clown world.

She went to live with someone with extreme views, who may have taken things further. My point, in a absolutist freedom of speech point of view is that I have no reason to believe she's actually done anything harmful other than holding abhorrent and extreme religous views and that when I said that I didn't want her let back into the country, I factored that in and still came to the same decision.

Gay activists didn't make this decision. Ordinary people by and large don't agree with extreme statements like these. I don't care if anyone supports homosexuality or not. Repeatedly publicly proclaiming that people are going to hell despite being warned goes beyond an act of non support, and is certainly not helpful to anyone.

In addition to previously saying that you have gay family members, you've also rattled on repeatedly about how homosexuality is a 'lifestyle you don't like'. If someone can't even be bothered to empathise with and support the challenges of those within their own family, It's hardly rocket science to see how they're going to perceive issues like this.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Apr 19 6.54pm

Folau will be a huge loss to Aussie rugby. Basically their best player.
Billy Vunipola seems like he is going to tow the line - happily for England rugby.
Should Folau have been sacked? One question I would like to ask is this - surely it is wrongful dismissal to be sacked for expressing religious beliefs? I'm not sure of Australian law (surely similar to ours). Obviously can't comment on his contract. Put yourself in his shoes - would you be entitled to large compensation - or are we in a world where these views are policed enough to lose your job?
I know I would not post plenty of my beliefs on social media. I would be far more guarded. Is that really how things should be?

 


Red and Blue Army!

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 17 Apr 19 6.58pm

I don't agree with the comments made by Folau but neither do I like the "group think" mentality that has sprung up.

If we represent our country do we all have to think the same now? So what happening to embracing diversity or does that only count if it's the right type of diversity.

If he had made these comments about a fellow player I can understand sacking him as it is personal and insulting. I would have preferred it if the Aussie RFU had made it clear that these were his views not theirs and left it at that.

Oh well 4 legs good...

 


One more point

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Apr 19 7.05pm

Originally posted by dollardays

She went to live with someone with extreme views, who may have taken things further.

Well yeah, if you want to reduce it down as much as possible....but that makes it sound like she just went down the road just because she liked some iffy bloke.


Originally posted by dollardays

My point, in a absolutist freedom of speech point of view is that I have no reason to believe she's actually done anything harmful other than holding abhorrent and extreme religous views and that when I said that I didn't want her let back into the country, I factored that in and still came to the same decision.

I've listened to both sides on this and there are points of principle on both sides, I'm probably 60/40 against. When the child was alive I was strongly in favour of provision for the child.....now this is about a hundred miles from a hill I care that much about.

Originally posted by dollardays

Gay activists didn't make this decision. Ordinary people by and large don't agree with extreme statements like these. I don't care if anyone supports homosexuality or not. Repeatedly publicly proclaiming that people are going to hell despite being warned goes beyond an act of non support, and is certainly not helpful to anyone.

In addition to previously saying that you have gay family members, you've also rattled on repeatedly about how homosexuality is a 'lifestyle you don't like'. If someone can't even be bothered to empathise with and support the challenges of those within their own family, It's hardly rocket science to see how they're going to perceive issues like this.

With respect if you are going to comment on my personal life....which is fine as I gave out that info....then you have to understand that you don't know much about the situation. So deducing this or that from where you are is a bit pointless.

I do have some empathy for situations around this, but I also have stronger convictions around fairness generally and I don't believe in taking away people's livelihoods because they say they don't like this or that group....the response is far too extreme itself

Sure it may be distasteful to say people are going to hell but it's religiously consistent from a certain religious perspective. I of course disagree with him but there was no incitement there....Muhammad Ali called all white people 'devils' and white people continued to give him millions. That's because he lived in a society that was far fairer than this one.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Apr 2019 7.08pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Apr 19 7.06pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I don't agree with the comments made by Folau but neither do I like the "group think" mentality that has sprung up.

If we represent our country do we all have to think the same now? So what happening to embracing diversity or does that only count if it's the right type of diversity.

If he had made these comments about a fellow player I can understand sacking him as it is personal and insulting. I would have preferred it if the Aussie RFU had made it clear that these were his views not theirs and left it at that.

Oh well 4 legs good...

It almost seems that we are trying to promote freedom by restricting freedom. A strange conundrum. As you say - just stick to the narrative you are supposed to have - or else.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Invalid user 2019 Flag 17 Apr 19 7.27pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

1 I've listened to both sides on this and there are points of principle on both sides, I'm probably 60/40 against. When the child was alive I was strongly in favour of provision for the child.....now this is about a hundred miles from a hill I care that much about.

2 With respect if you are going to comment on my personal life....which is fine as I gave out that info....then you have to understand that you don't know much about the situation. So deducing this or that from where you are is a bit pointless.

3 I do have some empathy for situations around this, but I also have stronger convictions around fairness generally and I don't believe in taking away people's livelihoods because they say their don't like this or that group....It may be distasteful but there was no incitement there....Muhammad Ali called all white people 'devils' and white people continued to give him millions. That's because he lived in society that was far fairer than this one.

1 I considered that too. The child did complicate things as he wasn't be blame for the incredibly foolish situation of his mother. That that baby died, seemed almost tragically in line with the whole sorry mess of her life.

2 In most families someone being gay isn't a 'situation'. It's a non event unless it's not allowed to be. 'homosexuality is a lifestyle I don't like' ad infinitum likely is the situation, since it hardly screams acceptance.

3 Yes as I've already said, I'd be more inclined to put this to the team. It's a team sport and maintaining a meaningful and close knit team dynamic is what's important. If repeatedly firing off extreme comments that turn millions of people off and take the attention away from the team is good with them, I'd go with that. if it's not , I'd go with that. Of course in a commercial environment, anything that rings alarm bells rather than tills draws attention too, so whether right or wrong, that too factors in.


Edited by dollardays (17 Apr 2019 7.36pm)

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 17 Apr 19 7.33pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Folau will be a huge loss to Aussie rugby. Basically their best player.
Billy Vunipola seems like he is going to tow the line - happily for England rugby.
Should Folau have been sacked? One question I would like to ask is this - surely it is wrongful dismissal to be sacked for expressing religious beliefs? I'm not sure of Australian law (surely similar to ours). Obviously can't comment on his contract. Put yourself in his shoes - would you be entitled to large compensation - or are we in a world where these views are policed enough to lose your job?
I know I would not post plenty of my beliefs on social media. I would be far more guarded. Is that really how things should be?

Child marriage appears to align in a rather unfortunate manner with some religions. If a player was in the team posting pictures of young girls on Instagram and saying 'If only I could marry this one' and more concerning comments, would you support that too? It's the same principle. Religious texts, including Christianity, contain all kind of beliefs that are either considered extreme or shocking in the modern world. Are you saying that anything written within these books is perfectly legitimate just because it's based on religious belief?

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 17 Apr 19 7.35pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

One possible difference is that neither player left their home country to join a militant group intent on causing harm to others.

I spend an entire thread offering various reasons why I don't think she should be let back into the country. None of those involved believing she is any kind of physical threat towards anyone though, as I don't believe that she is or that most other people believe that she is. It is her worldview that I find disturbing and of course that would factor into how her children were raised and so on.

Some made the arguments about her age and so on as reason why we should give her another chance. I considered though that in making the decision to put herself in the fray it was hard to take that back. Ultimately though, there are very obviously freedom of speech elements to this, but I decided against since she was out of the country and that seemed like a good way to end this. She wasn't exactly adding to the pot.

Edited by dollardays (17 Apr 2019 7.40pm)

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 17 Apr 19 7.36pm

That's a good, balanced article on the link you posted. Sums up any reasonable person's view.

You never know, this might be the excuse they needed to get shot of him. In isolation it seems an extreme over reaction.

The bloke is entitled to have a view and express it. Could there be grounds for wrongful dismissal?

An internal disciplinary procedure would've been appropriate if an impartial investigation found he broke the rules on bringing the organisation into disrepute I suppose.

Seems like yet another lefty, knee jerk reaction made through panic of the effects of faux outrage to me.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Apr 19 7.50pm

Originally posted by dollardays


2 In most families someone being gay isn't a 'situation'. It's a non event unless it's not allowed to me. 'homosexuality is a lifestyle I don't like' ad infinitum likely is the situation, since it hardly screams acceptance.

'Acceptance'? I accept homosexuality as a part of nature. What is.....is what will be. I have no desire to see people punished for a consensual sexual preference same as I have no desire to see thought punished.

I don't support homosexuality no. I'd like my biological line to be continued thanks, and most homosexuals aren't driven towards that. If I had one son and they turned out to be gay with no desire for biological reproduction that would devastate me.....Would I love them any less? I don't think that could be possible....so yeah, there is some internal conflict there.

Still, there are plenty of homosexuals I admire.....usually socially conservative homosexuals....but I'm not going about thinking, 'this guy/woman is great or terrible because sexuality'.

So yeah, like most things, it's the person and what they believe in for the good of society generally.....that's more important.

Originally posted by dollardays

3 Yes as I've already said, I'd be more inclined to put this to the team. It's a team sport and maintaining a meaningful and close knit team dynamic is what's important. If repeatedly firing off extreme comments that turn millions of people off and take the attention away from the team is good with them, I'd go with that. if it's not , I'd go with that. Of course in a commercial environment, anything that rings alarm bells rather than tills draws attention too, so whether right or wrong, that too factors in.

Well, I could understand that but personally If I were his boss I'd ask him to delete his social media stop giving interviews on non sporting matters and focus on his sport.

Not because I think he should be punished for religious views but simply because what he thinks about the price of fish isn't important.
If he refused I'd state that this player's views are his own.

But eventually I agree that I would sack someone if they continued to ignore requests from their employer to be reasonable......upon the basis that their was a lack of professionalism between employer and employee.

I don't know what has gone on ....on balance I always side upon protecting expression....but they both have rights here.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Apr 2019 9.43pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Invalid user 2019 Flag 17 Apr 19 8.18pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

1 I don't support homosexuality no. I'd like my biological line to be continued thanks, and most homosexuals aren't driven towards that. If I had one son and they turned out to be gay with no desire for biological reproduction that would devastate me.....Would I love them any less? I don't think that could be possible....so yeah, there is some internal conflict there.


2 Well, I could understand that but personally If I were his boss I'd ask him to delete his social media stop giving interviews on non sporting matters and focus on his sport.

Not because I think he should be punished for religious views but simply because what he thinks about the price of fish isn't important.....or more importantly....are they funny.

If he refused I'd state that this player's views are his own.

But eventually I agree that I would sack someone if they continued to ignore requests from their employer to be reasonable......upon the basis that their was a lack of professionalism between employer and employee.

I don't know what has gone on ....on balance I always side upon protecting expression....but they both have rights here.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Apr 2019 7.54pm)

1 It may be useful to separate sexual attraction from opt in political movements. 'I don't support homosexuality no' comes across as very critical of something that either is or isn't a part of someones nature regardless of your take on it. Whereas for instance saying that you don't like oversexualised gay pride events would be more a comment of a politicisation of sexuality and would make more sense. Plenty of people, gay and straight, would share that view.

2 Yes, this sounds reasonable to me and would be my approach. I do think it's an issue in team sport when one player becomes the focus or everything and for whatever reason refuses to dial it down despite repeated opportunities to do so.

Social media does tend to be a disaster zone for a myriad of reasons for those with a public persona. As you say there is something to be said for listening to your boss and also of thinking of the team first and foremost. None of this has done them any favours.

Edited by dollardays (17 Apr 2019 8.23pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Apr 19 9.00pm

Originally posted by dollardays

1 It may be useful to separate sexual attraction from opt in political movements. 'I don't support homosexuality no' comes across as very critical of something that either is or isn't a part of someones nature regardless of your take on it. Whereas for instance saying that you don't like oversexualised gay pride events would be more a comment of a politicisation of sexuality and would make more sense. Plenty of people, gay and straight, would share that view.

Edited by dollardays (17 Apr 2019 8.23pm)

As the years have gone by on some things I seem to have become more socially conservative, perhaps that is in reaction to society's increasing liberalisation or just something natural that happens to aging males....or both.

I tend to agree with those who say 'why upset people' for no reason. For example while I'm quite the anti Islamic I kind of agree with the idea that you don't draw pictures just to upset people. But then again..... on the other hand I'd kind of like the liberty to do so. When it turns out that I'm required to bend my knee on it.....I suddenly discover that I've lost all flexibility in my knees.

Nowadays, I react when I find that what can be a perfectly reasonable request for civilised behaviour then moves on from a desire for respect to a requirement for it.....Where people get sacked if they say stuff like I'm not for this or not for that.....I find myself remembering those Muhammad Ali days and I know what's being lost.

It seems a disfigurement of the kind of tolerance I wanted when I was younger.....Now I'm just a cynic. I realise that it's ...'meet the new boss, it's the same as the old boss'.

Same puritans, just different rules.


Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Apr 2019 9.04pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

blackheatheagle Flag Beckenham 17 Apr 19 9.08pm

This incident has reminded me one of my favourite caricature.

So called religious beliefs full of hate and their demand from people to be respectful about their beliefs

[Link]

By the way, i would not ban but condemn. It is awkward that whole religious leaders (who believes non-believers and gays will burn in hell) are honored by society but a rugby player is banned.

Edited by blackheatheagle (17 Apr 2019 9.09pm)

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Billy Vunipola and Isreal Folau