You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Strongest starting eleven
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Strongest starting eleven


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Hutchyeagle Flag Hove 20 Aug 19 10.27am

Would be interested to see everyone’s thoughts. All I do know is Roy won’t agree with any of us

Guaita
Kelly. Tomkins. Sakho. PVA

Luca


Camarasa. Meyer

Townsend. Ayew. Zaha

I would also look at Kouyate as cover at centre back ...Far more mobile than Dann

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 20 Aug 19 10.59am

Guaita

(RB) Tomkins (CB) Cahill (CB) Sakho (LB) PVA

(DM) Meyer (DM) McCarthy

(RM) Townsend (AM) Camarasa (LM) Wilf

(CF) Ayew/Benteke (not fussed, equally unlikely to score)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 20 Aug 19 11.30am

I would suggest our best team is with Wilf and Andros up front. None of our forwards score. At a push Ayew in there.
The problem we have is a number of our players don't look fully fit - Luca, Wilf Schlup to name but 3. Hopefully things will improve but we need to get some points before the international break.

Edit Midfield - Meyer still doesn't offer enough for me and should be used off the bench when the game becomes a little more stretched. Not seen Camarasa play but he may offer some creativity in the middle we are clearly lacking.

Edited by Bexley Eagle (20 Aug 2019 11.32am)

 

Osvaldo Flag Epsom 20 Aug 19 11.41am

It doesn't mean a thing talking about the strongest squad.
SOMEONE HAS TO SCORE GOALS AND WE HAVEN'T GOT ANYONE TO DO IT!
This problem has to be addressed now otherwise we will go back to the division to which we are best suited!
I am absolutely baffled why this wasn't done as soon as last season finished!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Where has common sense and professionalism gone?
I do believe it has flown away.
Maybe the club need to look at the management structure. Plan 'A' but thereafter it ends.
Sorry, I am completely disillusioned with yet another awful start to a season, two games no goals!

 

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 20 Aug 19 11.42am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Guaita

(RB) Tomkins (CB) Cahill (CB) Sakho (LB) PVA

(DM) Meyer (DM) McCarthy

(RM) Townsend (AM) Camarasa (LM) Wilf

(CF) Ayew/Benteke (not fussed, equally unlikely to score)

Fair call

 

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 20 Aug 19 11.48am

Originally posted by Osvaldo

It doesn't mean a thing talking about the strongest squad.
SOMEONE HAS TO SCORE GOALS AND WE HAVEN'T GOT ANYONE TO DO IT!
This problem has to be addressed now otherwise we will go back to the division to which we are best suited!
I am absolutely baffled why this wasn't done as soon as last season finished!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Where has common sense and professionalism gone?
I do believe it has flown away.
Maybe the club need to look at the management structure. Plan 'A' but thereafter it ends.
Sorry, I am completely disillusioned with yet another awful start to a season, two games no goals!

The striker situation has gone on for the the past 4 (FOUR) transfer windows.

By & large, I more of an SP fan than not - BUT the striker situation & how it has not been addressed repeatedly is reprehensible AND IF we get relegated, I will have zero sympathy for SP, he's brought it on himself.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 20 Aug 19 11.57am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Guaita

(RB) Tomkins (CB) Cahill (CB) Sakho (LB) PVA

(DM) Meyer (DM) McCarthy

(RM) Townsend (AM) Camarasa (LM) Wilf

(CF) Ayew/Benteke (not fussed, equally unlikely to score)

This is exactly what I would look to do and is arguably no more vulnerable than 4-4-2 and far more dangerous in attack, plus the players are in their natural positions.

No chance of it happening with Roy though.

 


COYP

Bangell Flag Oxford 20 Aug 19 11.59am

Zaha - Ayew - Townsend

Meyer - Luka - McArthur

PVA - Sakho - Tomkins - Ward

Guaita

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 20 Aug 19 12.01pm

I would say

Guaita

Ward
Sakho
Tomkins
Van Aanholt

Luka
Camarasa
Meyer

Andros
Wilf

Wickham

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 20 Aug 19 12.01pm

Benteke needs to stop getting picked

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 20 Aug 19 12.06pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Zaha - Ayew - Townsend

Meyer - Luka - McArthur

PVA - Sakho - Tomkins - Ward

Guaita

Is a good shout for a 4-3-3 which isn’t so different to the 4-2-3-1 with those players in there, partly because there’s few options so it’s the same names and why the pressing priority to get out of this z4-4-2. Therefore 2 or more formations per match depending on the score and where the ball is (that just stays the same right now).

Interesting that MOTD2 had us as 4-3-3. I can’t remember the players but it might’ve been your lineup with Benteke instead of Ayew.

 


COYP

stayloa Flag Beckenham 20 Aug 19 1.02pm

Originally posted by Shifty97

I would say

Guaita

Ward
Sakho
Tomkins
Van Aanholt

Luka
Camarasa
Meyer

Andros
Wilf

Wickham

Absolutely this - with Ayew and Benteke options to come on. I still think with decent service from our wingers (of whom Wilf is bloody one!!), he may score a few off his head. Wickham has looked strong with good agility when he's come on though.

People calling for Tomkins at right back are forgetting he has no pace. Ward has been decent to be fair to him.

McCarthur works like a nutter, but Luka is the enforcer and this formation would allow Camarasa and Meyer to play centrally ahead of him creating things with Andros and Wilf out wide.

It may be a bit overkill having two creative midfielders though, so perhaps Kouyate/McCarthur/McCarthy could be swapped in for Meyer for balance?

Anyway, Roy will start with the same team and formation I'm sure and we'll get buried 5-0 by United.

Please at least stick Cahill in for Dann. He's past it...

Edited by stayloa (20 Aug 2019 1.02pm)

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 20 Aug 19 1.28pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Is a good shout for a 4-3-3 which isn’t so different to the 4-2-3-1 with those players in there, partly because there’s few options so it’s the same names and why the pressing priority to get out of this z4-4-2. Therefore 2 or more formations per match depending on the score and where the ball is (that just stays the same right now).

Interesting that MOTD2 had us as 4-3-3. I can’t remember the players but it might’ve been your lineup with Benteke instead of Ayew.

I think it would work well both offensively and defensively - with the ball, we have Meyer in a more central position to receive and distribute, with three forward players. Defensively, you'd have Andros drop back to take his place on the right side of a bank of four.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 20 Aug 19 1.49pm

Camarasa himself said his best position is as a supporting forward. This is where he got Cardiff's players' POTY award from last season. I'm hanging my hopes on him being the link we so desperately need, as in the last two games there has appeared to be this massive void between the midfield and our front two.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 20 Aug 19 1.50pm

Forget Zaha, despite what he says he ain't interested, and he certainly isn't going to put himself in positions where be could get injured mea ing he could lose out on that January move.

We basically have a choice of Wickham or Benteke upfront (or both).

So, it no use playing some intricate pass and move game with them, they are not going to endlessly run channels etc.

Get people out wide to deliver crosses into the box. The probably means Townsend and Ayew on the flanks, but they must deliver the ball early or from the dead ball line.

Depending on whether we play 1 or 2 upfront, means 2 or 3 midfielders. I think Camarrasa must play, a holding midfielder (either luka or Kouyate), then if playing a 3 midfield then either Meyer or McCarthy.

At back, Sakho and Tompkins (Cahill to come in if either not avail), schlupp at LB and Ward at RB.

Giuita in Goal.

This wont happen though, we all know that.

 

Neilsym26 Flag Bromley 20 Aug 19 10.51pm

Originally posted by Shifty97

Benteke needs to stop getting picked

100% because the players around him can't seem to cross or create any chances for him. Put any striker in the world up front for us and he'd have the same issues!!

 

bromleysteve01 Flag Bromley 21 Aug 19 8.53am

Guaita

Kouyate (RB)
Tomkins
Sakho
Ward (LB)

Luca (DM)
McCarthy
McArthur

Ayew
Wickham
Zaha

SUBS
Camarasa
Townsend
Cahill
Kelly
Hennessey

 

bromleysteve01 Flag Bromley 21 Aug 19 9.01am

Sorry + Meyer on the Bench

Don’t make squad = Dann, Benteke, Schlupp and PVA

 

EddieMac Flag 21 Aug 19 10.12am

Guita

Ward Tomkins Sakho PVA

Luca

Townsend McCarthy Zaha

Camarasa

Benteke

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 21 Aug 19 10.23am

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

Forget Zaha, despite what he says he ain't interested, and he certainly isn't going to put himself in positions where be could get injured mea ing he could lose out on that January move.

We basically have a choice of Wickham or Benteke upfront (or both).

So, it no use playing some intricate pass and move game with them, they are not going to endlessly run channels etc.

Get people out wide to deliver crosses into the box. The probably means Townsend and Ayew on the flanks, but they must deliver the ball early or from the dead ball line.

Depending on whether we play 1 or 2 upfront, means 2 or 3 midfielders. I think Camarrasa must play, a holding midfielder (either luka or Kouyate), then if playing a 3 midfield then either Meyer or McCarthy.

At back, Sakho and Tompkins (Cahill to come in if either not avail), schlupp at LB and Ward at RB.

Giuita in Goal.

This wont happen though, we all know that.

How many top teams play like this nowadays?

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Strongest starting eleven