You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Your XI when everyone is back from injury?
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Your XI when everyone is back from injury?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Zaha127 Flag 19 Jan 20 4.08pm

For me I would want 4-2-3-1

Guaita

Riedewald
Sakho
Tomkins
Ward

Kouyate
Mccarthur

Sclupp
Ayew
Zaha

Tosun

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 19 Jan 20 4.17pm

Guaita

Ward
Tomkins
Cahill
Riedewald

Kouyate
McArthur

Zaha
Ayew
Tosun
PVA

attack attack attack

 

mattteo Flag 19 Jan 20 4.19pm

Guaita
Right back is hard (I'd prefer new signing)
Tomkins
Cahill
PVA
Kouyate
Macca
Townsend
Ayew
Zaha
Tosun

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 19 Jan 20 4.40pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Guaita
Right back is hard (I'd prefer new signing)
Tomkins
Cahill
PVA
Kouyate
Macca
Townsend
Ayew
Zaha
Tosun

It may be better if we stick to McArthur and McCarthy, so we all know who we're talking about, rather than this Macca/Jimmy Mac nonsense.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

mattteo Flag 19 Jan 20 4.51pm

Originally posted by bexleydave

It may be better if we stick to McArthur and McCarthy, so we all know who we're talking about, rather than this Macca/Jimmy Mac nonsense.

McArthur man, definitely. McCarthy has just 1 great game in the last 3 years (been injured for 2)

 

New Forest Eagle Flag Darlington 19 Jan 20 6.59pm

Originally posted by Zaha127

For me I would want 4-2-3-1

Guaita

Riedewald
Sakho
Tomkins
Ward

Kouyate
Mccarthur

Sclupp
Ayew
Zaha

Tosun

Why the hell would you pick Sakho over Cahill? The blokes a liability.

 

Palace Passion Flag Bromley, South London 19 Jan 20 7.52pm

Guaita

Tomkins--Cahill--Sakho--PVA


McArthur--Riedewald


Townsend------Ayew------Zaha

Tosun

 


|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|||||||||||P|A|L|A|C|E|||||||||||
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||


***Oliver Glasner's RED BLUE ARMY***
Be loud.. Be proud.. Be PALACE!

staffie - missed but never forgotten 19/04/15

The Dolphin Flag 19 Jan 20 8.24pm

Guaita

Ward
Tomkins
Cahill
Reidewald

Luis
Kouyate

Townsend
MaCarthy
Wilf

Tosun

Edited by The Dolphin (19 Jan 2020 8.24pm)

 

sprites Flag Auckland 19 Jan 20 8.42pm

4-3-3 for me.

Guiata

Ward-Tonks-Sakho-PVA

Luka-Riderwald-McArthur

Townsend-Wickham-Zaha

 

robct91 Flag Bridgend 19 Jan 20 8.59pm

4-2-3-1

Guaita

New RB
Tomkins
Cahill
Reidewald

Luka/McArthur
Kouyate

Wilf
Mayer
Townsend

Tosun

 

sprites Flag Auckland 19 Jan 20 11.14pm

Originally posted by Palace Passion

Guaita

Tomkins--Cahill--Sakho--PVA


McArthur--Riedewald


Townsend------Ayew------Zaha

Tosun

Really? Completely out of position? He's even slower than Kelly...would get skinned every game!

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 19 Jan 20 11.46pm

Start with Guaita, Cahill and Tomkins and go from there

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

coulsdoneagle Flag London 19 Jan 20 11.48pm

VG

Ward—Cahill—Tonks—PVA

MacArthur——Luka——Kouyate

Ayew————Tosun————Zaha

For me the team currently picks itself when fully fit. We would have a strong bench. I think Townsend has a fight on his hand to get his place back, but him in form would be great to have a more natural wide player on both sides. Sakho is so useful in playing out from the back and helping Luka kick start breaks with good interplay, but defensively he is so much more of a liability than Cahill and Tomkins.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 20 Jan 20 12.22am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

VG

Ward—Cahill—Tonks—PVA

MacArthur——Luka——Kouyate

Ayew————Tosun————Zaha

For me the team currently picks itself when fully fit. We would have a strong bench. I think Townsend has a fight on his hand to get his place back, but him in form would be great to have a more natural wide player on both sides. Sakho is so useful in playing out from the back and helping Luka kick start breaks with good interplay, but defensively he is so much more of a liability than Cahill and Tomkins.

Lol judging by the previous replies it certainly doesn't.

Questions: LB could be PVA, Schlupp or Jairo. Strong case for all.
CM: Does Luka come back in? Some say yes, some say no.
Wing: Ayew or Townsend?
Striker: Is Tosun actually any better than Wickham?

Edited by sprites (20 Jan 2020 12.23am)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Jan 20 8.32am

The first question is:
Whose system are we to work with?
On the basis that Roy seems to prefer some form of 433, I would be looking at:

VG

Ward
Tomkins
Cahill
PVA

Macarthur
Luka
Kouyate

Ayew
Tosun
Zaha

We know Luka can do it and he now knows that if he doesn't get back to previous heights there are two players ready to take his place (McCarthy and Riederwald). PVA will also be looking over his shoulder.
I know Tosun has only played one and a bit games for us, but imo he's shown more striker nous and instinct than we've seen from any of our other options and I'm happy to give him an extended run in the role to confirm or otherwise that ability.
As for Andros, an up and down season (played brilliantly against Liverpool but often not in the game). Would like to see him as an impact sub option for the last 25-30 minutes.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Jan 20 8.34am

Originally posted by doombear

The first question is:
Whose system are we to work with?
On the basis that Roy seems to prefer some form of 433, I would be looking at:

VG

Ward
Tomkins
Cahill
PVA

Macarthur
Luka
Kouyate

Ayew
Tosun
Zaha

We know Luka can do it and he now knows that if he doesn't get back to previous heights there are two players ready to take his place (McCarthy and Riederwald). PVA will also be looking over his shoulder.
I know Tosun has only played one and a bit games for us, but imo he's shown more striker nous and instinct than we've seen from any of our other options and I'm happy to give him an extended run in the role to confirm or otherwise that ability.
As for Andros, an up and down season (played brilliantly against Liverpool but often not in the game). Would like to see him as an impact sub option for the last 25-30 minutes.

should read "but often not in the game in other matches.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 20 Jan 20 9.00am

Originally posted by sprites

Lol judging by the previous replies it certainly doesn't.

Questions: LB could be PVA, Schlupp or Jairo. Strong case for all.
CM: Does Luka come back in? Some say yes, some say no.
Wing: Ayew or Townsend?
Striker: Is Tosun actually any better than Wickham?

Edited by sprites (20 Jan 2020 12.23am)

That’s why I said for me it does. PVA is our best left back when fit and on form. He has the most going forward and links up with Wilf well. He hasn’t been in form but at the moment he is still our best option.

Luka comes in as he has the best range of passing and can build attacks from the back. While he hasn’t had his best season, the scapegoating of him has hardly been fair. He has frequently had the most forward passes, key passes, and passes in the oppositions half when he plays as well as among the highest tackle rates in our 11. If we can get him back to his best he offers the most going forward other than Macca of our CDM options.

Ayew keeps his place for me, I’d say it’s more a question of Tosun or Townsend for me. Either Tosun up top with Ayew out wide, or Ayew up top with Townsend playing out wide.


On current viewing I’d say yes he is a better option. He had a fantastic match with his back to goal and offered a threat to the goal throughout.

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 20 Jan 20 12.12pm

Guaita

Ward
Cahill
Tomkins
Van Aanholt

Kouyaté
McArthur
McCarthy

Ayew
Tosun
Zaha

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 20 Jan 20 12.19pm

Guaita

Ward
Cahill
Tomkins
Van Aanholt

Kouyaté / Luka
McArthur
Riedewald

Ayew
Tosun
Zaha

I'd love to see Riedewald get a run in midfield once PVA is back. He's the only player who currently looks to play an inventive pass and I think he'd be great in helping Ayew and Zaha to get on the ball more. McCarthy is a great back up for any of the midfield when they are injured/in need of a rest. Luka has real competition for his spot when he returns.

 

Aray Flag South London 20 Jan 20 1.08pm


Guaita

Ward--Tomkins--Cahill--PVA

Riedewald

McArthur--Kouyate
Ayew---- Tosun------Zaha

Harsh on McCarthy who is showing he's a real contender for a permanent starting midfield slot but Riedewald's passing is really needed.

Luka and Andros need to win their places back. Sakho too.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Your XI when everyone is back from injury?