You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team vs. Sheffield Utd
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Team vs. Sheffield Utd


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
AppleSource Flag Tel Aviv 26 Jan 20 11.32am

Some pertinent questions ahead of this game:

- Does Luka return in place of McCarthy?
- Does Roy revert back to Ayew up top and Meyer out wide to keep the game tight against SU?
- Does Ward replace Kelly against SU's marauding wing-back?
- Does van Aanholt return to lineup (having returned to full training over one week ago)?

This would be my starting lineup:

Guaita

PVA Tomkins Cahill Ward

Milivojevic McArthur Kouyate

Zaha Ayew

Tosun

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 26 Jan 20 11.41am

I'm not sure if PvA should come straight back. Reidewald, although he didn't have a good game against Southampton, has been playing well. On the other hand I think we have missed Patrick's forays down the wing.

Mmm, I'll leave that one to Roy.

As for Luka I am inclined toward bringing him back in.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 26 Jan 20 11.47am

Originally posted by AppleSource

Some pertinent questions ahead of this game:

- Does Luka return in place of McCarthy?
- Does Roy revert back to Ayew up top and Meyer out wide to keep the game tight against SU?
- Does Ward replace Kelly against SU's marauding wing-back?
- Does van Aanholt return to lineup (having returned to full training over one week ago)?

This would be my starting lineup:

Guaita

PVA Tomkins Cahill Ward

Milivojevic McArthur Kouyate

Zaha Ayew

Tosun

After the Southampton debacle Luka is a must - Also if Hodgson is going to play same tactics (of course he will) then I would not play Tosun and use Ayew as the main / only front man. Perhaps Meyer right of midfield as Townsend still out Alongside Kouyate, Luka, McArthur. Still not sure on McCarthy, so bench for me? Ward is a must with hopefully PVA back at left?

 

Bud Flag 26 Jan 20 11.54am

Who ever he picks it will be ultra defensive and hope we nick a goal same as always.

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 26 Jan 20 1.38pm

Ayew to play closer to tosun as I think they'll link up well but can drop back when out of possession. Riedewald deserves to continue but pushed further forwards. We really missed PVAs pace, counter attack football is nothing without pace. In possession he's good and I could see Roy use him here as he also is able to do a sound job defensively. Which will be needed with Sheffield's overlapping play. I think Luka will come back in but choosing the middle 2 out of Luka, Cheick, MacArthur and McCarthy is difficult mainly because there is no real standouts.

Guaita

Ward Cahill Tomkins PVA

Zaha MacArthur Kouyate/Luka Riedewald

Ayew
Tosun

Edited by samprior (26 Jan 2020 1.40pm)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 26 Jan 20 1.45pm

Originally posted by samprior

Ayew to play closer to tosun as I think they'll link up well but can drop back when out of possession. Riedewald deserves to continue but pushed further forwards. We really missed PVAs pace, counter attack football is nothing without pace. In possession he's good and I could see Roy use him here as he also is able to do a sound job defensively. Which will be needed with Sheffield's overlapping play. I think Luka will come back in but choosing the middle 2 out of Luka, Cheick, MacArthur and McCarthy is difficult mainly because there is no real standouts.

Guaita

Ward Cahill Tomkins PVA

Zaha MacArthur Kouyate/Luka Riedewald

Ayew
Tosun

Edited by samprior (26 Jan 2020 1.40pm)

As Sheffield attack down the flanks Roy probably won’t go 4-4-2. More likely to stick to 4-3-3 with the two wide forwards helping out with defence on the wings.

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 26 Jan 20 3.48pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

As Sheffield attack down the flanks Roy probably won’t go 4-4-2. More likely to stick to 4-3-3 with the two wide forwards helping out with defence on the wings.

Ye I was thinking a more 4411 in possession and 451 out of possession so that we'd still have plenty of cover. Wilf protecting Ward and Riedewald protecting PVA would offer more protection IMO than recent selections of Meyer and Ayew which at times has left the fullbacks looking very vulnerable.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 26 Jan 20 4.43pm

No idea who will be fit, but Ward DEFINITELY in for Kelly.

 

fishbone Flag London 26 Jan 20 5.38pm

I do like how the top clubs try out their younger talents rather than h as be them as bench warmers !!!!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 26 Jan 20 6.01pm

It will not make any difference who we pick, it will end up like the Southampton game with more then likely the same score, it's just the way they play and what they've been doing away from home all season ..we sadly won't like it at all and everyone on here will go bonkers again, expect nothing that's what I advise all of you to do.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 26 Jan 20 6.02pm

Originally posted by Bangell

No idea who will be fit, but Ward DEFINITELY in for Kelly.

Yes, Kelly will not be helpful at all.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 26 Jan 20 6.10pm

Originally posted by Bud

Who ever he picks it will be ultra defensive and hope we nick a goal same as always.

If we try as you desire to attack at will and in the same fashion as Sheffield United the score will end up even worse then the loss I predict, we have players who can only operate in the way they're playing now, mainly because they're not good enough to do otherwise.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 26 Jan 20 6.13pm

Originally posted by fishbone

I do like how the top clubs try out their younger talents rather than h as be them as bench warmers !!!!

Doesn't apply to us.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 26 Jan 20 6.46pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

It will not make any difference who we pick, it will end up like the Southampton game with more then likely the same score, it's just the way they play and what they've been doing away from home all season ..we sadly won't like it at all and everyone on here will go bonkers again, expect nothing that's what I advise all of you to do.

Have you and Roy Hodgson ever been seen together in the same room? Just asking.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 27 Jan 20 12.29pm

I’m sorry but I’m still really on a downer from the Saints game and I don’t see an improvement in result for this one.

I was at the Blades game earlier in the season and we were woeful, disinterested and just outfought and out harried. They’ll do exactly the same to us this time and we’ve shown recently we just don't have the appetite for this type of game.

Definitely Ward in for Kelly. Kelly has done well as a centre back but my god he’s been so exposed as a right back and has cost us so many times recently. I can’t blame him entirely as he just shouldn’t be playing right back but he has, so the sooner we have a better fit for that position the better.

As much as Luka has been off the pace recently too I’d probably put him straight back in to see if that can shake things up in order to stop a repeat of the Southampton performance.

Up top I’d definitely select Tosun as we need to see some more of him and I really think there’s a good player / finisher in there somewhere.

I’m really not looking forward to it but I’ll be there all the same hoping for some kind of miracle that we actually play some entertaining football for a change.

Edited by Phil’s Barber (27 Jan 2020 12.30pm)

Edited by Phil’s Barber (27 Jan 2020 12.31pm)

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 28 Jan 20 9.41am

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

I’m sorry but I’m still really on a downer from the Saints game and I don’t see an improvement in result for this one.

I was at the Blades game earlier in the season and we were woeful, disinterested and just outfought and out harried. They’ll do exactly the same to us this time and we’ve shown recently we just don't have the appetite for this type of game.

Definitely Ward in for Kelly. Kelly has done well as a centre back but my god he’s been so exposed as a right back and has cost us so many times recently. I can’t blame him entirely as he just shouldn’t be playing right back but he has, so the sooner we have a better fit for that position the better.

As much as Luka has been off the pace recently too I’d probably put him straight back in to see if that can shake things up in order to stop a repeat of the Southampton performance.

Up top I’d definitely select Tosun as we need to see some more of him and I really think there’s a good player / finisher in there somewhere.

I’m really not looking forward to it but I’ll be there all the same hoping for some kind of miracle that we actually play some entertaining football for a change.

-----------------------------------------

Intensity isn't us especially at home, when Zaha's on the ball we are momentarily better but he is so inconsistent now that we cannot build any pressure and any pressure we do try will easily be destroyed by their wingbacks, so yes you're right I fear it will not be pretty.

Edited by Tickled pink (28 Jan 2020 8.41pm)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 28 Jan 20 10.17am

After the shambles of Soton, I expect a positive reaction whichever team Roy puts out. As to which team and a predicted score, I'll wait until I've heard the injury update and how many great signings we make in the next 80 odd hours (tongue in cheek).

 

Galv Flag Wallington 28 Jan 20 10.41am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

It will not make any difference who we pick, it will end up like the Southampton game with more then likely the same score, it's just the way they play and what they've been doing away from home all season ..we sadly won't like it at all and everyone on here will go bonkers again, expect nothing that's what I advise all of you to do.

I think you are correct, high press, high energy who dares wins attitude.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 28 Jan 20 11.54am

Got to be honest, Im not looking forward to it.
I really hope we get Luka back and Ayew in no.9 position.
Put Tosun on bench for the usual 73rd minute sub.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 29 Jan 20 3.05am

Guaita

Ward-Tonks-Cahill-PVA

McArthur-Luka-Reiderwald

Ayew - Wickham - Zaha

PVA comes straight in for me, as does Luka.
Wickham still our best striker for me.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team vs. Sheffield Utd