You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

2017 Håland or Sørloth? (LOCKED)


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
mattteo Flag 26 Jan 20 7.37pm

Erling Haland (born in 2000) was 17-18 years old and had 10 goals in 9 matches for Norway at U19 and U18 level.

A little older, Sorloth (born in 1995) was 22 and had 6 goals in 14 matches for Norway U19 and Norway U18 (which one looks better, his or Haaland's goalscoring stat??), 1 goal in 10 matches for Norway U21 and 1 goal in 12 matches for Norway main national team (in a friendly against Iceland).

In January 2018 the Palace board made the decision to sign Alexander Sorloth for 8 million+add-ons.

He had at that time scored 10 goals and assisted 8 times in the Danish league season at the age of 22 in 1450 minutes.

If Palace had waited the year 2018 before making a transfer decision, the board would have seen Haaland do the same thing in the Norwegian league, but at 18 years old: 12 goals and 4 assists in 1500 minutes.

Both players also had 4 goals and 1 assist in the Europa League Qualifiers (Sorloth in 2017, Haaland in 2018 ).

Haaland left to Red Bull Salzburg in January 2019 for 7 million. He continued to score there extraordinarily for his age, 21 goals and 6 assists in 1250 minutes in Austria and 8 goals in the Champions League and has just recently been subject to a 20 million transfer to Borussia Dortmund, where he scored 5 times in his first 50 minutes on the pitch.

He is seen as the best youth prospect for the center forward position in Europe and the 20 million fee was only because Salzburg had agreed a small clause with his agents, not believing that he could prosper so fast so soon. From Borussia, he will only leave for 60 million or more.

Imagine what could have been if the Palace board would have just looked at those youth national team statistics and gotten Haaland instead of Sorloth.....

Edited by mattteo (26 Jan 2020 7.38pm)

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 26 Jan 20 7.57pm

Just imagine what would have happened had Sorloth gone to Salzburg ?

Theres a fine line between fishing without catching anything and sitting on a river bank reading a book .

 

mattteo Flag 26 Jan 20 8.33pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Just imagine what would have happened had Sorloth gone to Salzburg ?

Theres a fine line between fishing without catching anything and sitting on a river bank reading a book .

No, it's not a question that Salzburg would have made Sorloth just as good as Haaland or that if Haaland were to have come to Palace, he would have flopped in the PL too.

It's just that there's a difference in value between the 2. Haaland would have made it anywhere. He has been constantly used at levels way above his age. He is still only 19. One could see his quality since his Norway U18 or U19 levels years ago.

It was obvious to a trained mind that the better footballer was the one 4-5 years younger, who was having similar (and even better) achievements during the same time. If Palace was going to invest in a young player willing to be PL substitute (like Sorloth was), it should have gone for Haaland.

Perhaps they believed the Danish league, where Sorloth did well, was better than the Norwegian league, but there really isn't much difference. At national team level, yes, the Danes have achieved much better results, but at domestic league level it's rather similar.

I remember Roy Hodgson saying they had to pay that money for Sorloth "because he's just that good at his age". If that was true for 22 yo Sorloth, what did Roy think about 17-18 year old Haaland, who had better numbers??

 

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 26 Jan 20 8.41pm

Originally posted by mattteo

No, it's not a question that Salzburg would have made Sorloth just as good as Haaland or that if Haaland were to have come to Palace, he would have flopped in the PL too.

It's just that there's a difference in value between the 2. Haaland would have made it anywhere. He has been constantly used at levels way above his age. He is still only 19. One could see his quality since his Norway U18 or U19 levels years ago.

It was obvious to a trained mind that the better footballer was the one 4-5 years younger, who was having similar (and even better) achievements during the same time. If Palace was going to invest in a young player willing to be PL substitute (like Sorloth was), it should have gone for Haaland.

Perhaps they believed the Danish league, where Sorloth did well, was better than the Norwegian league, but there really isn't much difference. At national team level, yes, the Danes have achieved much better results, but at domestic league level it's rather similar.

I remember Roy Hodgson saying they had to pay that money for Sorloth "because he's just that good at his age". If that was true for 22 yo Sorloth, what did Roy think about 17-18 year old Haaland, who had better numbers??


Yes, but if my aunty had bollocks she would be my uncle.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Jan 20 10.55pm

I can see Russia from my house.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Casual Flag Orpington 27 Jan 20 6.29am

Don’t mate. I’m still gutted that we picked the wrong one out of Wickham and Kane. Also Zeki fryers and Danny Rose. Don’t get me started on Camarasa and Busquets. Arrrrrrrrrr!!!!!

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 27 Jan 20 7.45am

It’s a fine line picking players. Klopp is undoubtedly up there. Big Sam brought us some quality. Since then, whoever is choosing isn’t on your wavelength matteo sadly

Edited by dreamwaverider (27 Jan 2020 7.46am)

Edited by dreamwaverider (27 Jan 2020 7.48am)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 27 Jan 20 7.55am

Who knows what was discussed at the time, but Haaland's age may have put Palace (and other clubs) off, if we had even looked at him that is. We needed a first-team striker and as you have said elsewhere it is a lot to ask for a young kid to come from a small league and drop straight into a PL team. Sorloth didn't manage it and he was older. We seem to be looking at buying young players with talent for the future now, so maybe someone like Banks will be the fish we caught rather than the one that got away. Every club has there 'what ifs' and given the much bigger scouting networks of clubs like Man Utd and Chelsea it should be more a question of how a player like Haaland slipped through their net, not ours.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 27 Jan 20 8.46am

More realistically, he would have at the very most ended up of the subs bench and got 5 minutes here and there, eventually being loaned out.

 

crvenaeagle Flag 27 Jan 20 8.52am

There's a lot of 17 year old who bang them away and then disappear into oblivion later on.

 

mattteo Flag 27 Jan 20 9.13am

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

There's a lot of 17 year old who bang them away and then disappear into oblivion later on.

Not really. I mean, yeah, maybe some are ovwrrated at this age, but who scores a tone in international games usually makes it to professional football.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 27 Jan 20 9.51am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Who knows what was discussed at the time, but Haaland's age may have put Palace (and other clubs) off, if we had even looked at him that is. We needed a first-team striker and as you have said elsewhere it is a lot to ask for a young kid to come from a small league and drop straight into a PL team. Sorloth didn't manage it and he was older. We seem to be looking at buying young players with talent for the future now, so maybe someone like Banks will be the fish we caught rather than the one that got away. Every club has there 'what ifs' and given the much bigger scouting networks of clubs like Man Utd and Chelsea it should be more a question of how a player like Haaland slipped through their net, not ours.

Agreed, all the big clubs would like to sign him now so yes we missed him but so did they.

 


One more point

Bangell Flag Oxford 27 Jan 20 10.02am

Yes yes Matteo, if only you were in charge

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 27 Jan 20 10.27am

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

There's a lot of 17 year old who bang them away and then disappear into oblivion later on.

Sounds like one of my dreams

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 27 Jan 20 10.30am

Originally posted by Badger11

Agreed, all the big clubs would like to sign him now so yes we missed him but so did they.

Exactly.

The original post makes it sound like it was only us who missed out on him. Every club in England did!

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 27 Jan 20 10.32am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Sounds like one of my dreams

 


Red and Blue Army!

Only 10 a year!! Flag 27 Jan 20 11.11am

I am sure Håland's team had a plan for him which involved exposure to European Competitions etc and would not have included coming to a Palace or similar middle to low end Premiership side.

Also, aren't the RB teams heavily involved with certain agents?

Wasn't our choice at the time between Sørloth and Hugill? A fairly uninspiring pair.

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 27 Jan 20 11.54am

I'm still trying to get over the fact we decided to sign Walter Del Rio instead of picking up Lionel Messi for peanuts when he was 10! What if eh!

Edited by samprior (27 Jan 2020 11.54am)

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 27 Jan 20 12.13pm

OMG...seriously?! What a pointless thread.

 

mattteo Flag 27 Jan 20 12.44pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Exactly.

The original post makes it sound like it was only us who missed out on him. Every club in England did!

You're wrong here. We were the club interested in that Northern market (especially because Roy coached there before). There were 2 Norwegians who looked top level-promising (Haaland more than Sorloth, cause he was even better at an earlier age).

We got 1 of them. Sorloth. This was the transfer depaetment's decision. We were really close to Haaland.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic