This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
My God,someones been up all night googling, couldn't you get to sleep?
|
|
|
Are you in self-isolation W12?
|
|
|
I think I'll wait for WE to respond to this first. Edited by Midlands Eagle (11 Mar 2020 9.38am)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Some thought provoking questions there. I don't normally join in with threads about race or religion but I have often wondered when people go on about diversity being good, why it is good as I don't think that I have ever heard an explanation A few black teenage girls did a feature on bbc tv London news. Must’ve been Tuesday yesterday. They highlighted they don’t have any white friends. They could but don’t. They ventured into Havering, the whitest London borough. They went into some day centre event for the retired and they said the reason they aren’t mixing with ethnic minorities is because of socio economics or something it sounded they had the answer ready for.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I think I'll wait for WE to respond to this first. Edited by Midlands Eagle (11 Mar 2020 9.38am) That will be a lot of highlighted replies.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
A few black teenage girls did a feature on bbc tv London news. Must’ve been Tuesday yesterday. They highlighted they don’t have any white friends. They could but don’t. They ventured into Havering, the whitest London borough. They went into some day centre event for the retired and they said the reason they aren’t mixing with ethnic minorities is because of socio economics or something it sounded they had the answer ready for. Bit of a random point, but I have been pondering, there are a only few black women/girls in my department, none of whom I think work in the same team, but who insist on all sitting together at lunch. It's strange, as I do not know all of them well but a few I have regular dealings with and they are all lovely and sociable yet create quite a visible division with their eating habits, or when socialising/not working. Is there really such a cultural divide between them and the rest of the office and is this a microcosm of society as a whole? Brings me back to Muhammed Ali's quote of 'Black birds like to fly with blackbirds, bluebirds fly with bludebirds etc.". Edited by Nicholas91 (11 Mar 2020 9.51am)
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I think I'll wait for WE to respond to this first. Edited by Midlands Eagle (11 Mar 2020 9.38am) You will be waiting a very long time!
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You will be waiting a very long time! You type slowly then ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Speronilover69 8=D~~
Diversity isn't necessarily good or bad, it's the economic benefits that come with it. The case that you have made seems to imply that diversity is a necessity not that it is good. There are still 1.3m people unemployed and presumably claiming benefits so couldn't a case be made for some or all of the long term unemployed filling some of the positions currently being taken by immigrant labour? Some of the more skilled jobs like nursing are only filled by immigrants because the UK Nursing Council make it so difficult for British people to get into the industry. You need a university degree plus funding for your training to get into nursing in this country whereas in the Philippines one needs to do well at school before going to nursing college so the entry standards are much lower
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
The case that you have made seems to imply that diversity is a necessity not that it is good. There are still 1.3m people unemployed and presumably claiming benefits so couldn't a case be made for some or all of the long term unemployed filling some of the positions currently being taken by immigrant labour? Some of the more skilled jobs like nursing are only filled by immigrants because the UK Nursing Council make it so difficult for British people to get into the industry. You need a university degree plus funding for your training to get into nursing in this country whereas in the Philippines one needs to do well at school before going to nursing college so the entry standards are much lower A case could be made for that. However, convincing British people to pick fruit in a field, for example, is easier said than done. It's long, grueling hours which British people would rather not have to do. The only way to get British people to do the jobs that a lot of immigrants are doing would be to pay them more - which would increase the price of our produce. The same could be said for pretty much any industry (removing immigration will increase the price of goods and services and be detrimental to our economy). I find it funny how 'right-wingers' always claim to prioritize the economy above all else but will happily ignore the needs of the economy when it suits them
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Some of the more skilled jobs like nursing are only filled by immigrants because the UK Nursing Council make it so difficult for British people to get into the industry. You need a university degree plus funding for your training to get into nursing in this country whereas in the Philippines one needs to do well at school before going to nursing college so the entry standards are much lower This is something I have direct, current and personal experience of. If anyone really wants to know how and why please PM me. That the NMC (Nursing and Midwifery Council) have raised standards by making nursing a degree course is beyond doubt. That they have done so is, partly at least, to ease the pressures on doctors and prepare the NHS for it's future. That the move from bursary funding to student loans has reduced the numbers applying for the courses is true. Hence the £5000 per year grant announced by the Government in December which will probably be confirmed in today's budget. This should help encourage more to enter the profession, whose loans are very unlikely ever to be paid back in full anyway. Raising the status, and salaries, of graduate nurses is going to be the real answer though, in my own opinion. The idea that it's easier in the Philippines is though very wrong. It's a 5 year course there, and not 3 as it is here, but the standards are not so high, hence the need for a 6 month adaptation if they join the NHS. The key sticking point though is money. Entry is easy. The nursing colleges are commercial enterprises and if you can pay their fees and meet the minimal entry requirements, then you are accepted. The fees though are very high for an average middle class Filipino family, who will often have to borrow heavily in the hope that their student will eventually repay them with enough extra for their older years. As the drop out rate is high you can imagine the consequences. If you are poor then you need a sponsor, often a family member who is themselves working abroad. It's no wonder you don't see too many Filipino nurses in the UK in social situations, but only in hospitals. They are too busy working and then sending most of what they earn back home. Even if every place on offer in the Universities for Nursing degrees was full (and there aren't so many vacancies now) we would still need to recruit overseas. If we doubled the number of our students I think we would still need to do so. How long though it would take us to double the number of training places, let alone for the NHS itself to cope with the extra demand to look after students on placements, are quite other questions. So overseas recruitment of nurses is going to be necessary for the foreseeable future.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I picked the Philippines at random partly because my wife works with several Filipino nurses but without checking I am sure that it's also easier to get into nursing in pakistan and India too. One of the disadvantages of making the entry into nursing so academic is that you end up with the wrong sort of people in the profession as those with the aptitude for the job don't have the academic qualifications for entry whilst those that do aren't necessarily the most suitable. On the subject of diversity in nursing though one of the positives is that there are a large number of Muslim nurses at my wife's hospital who are happy to work Christmas Day (at double time) so wifey can always get the day off
|
|
| W12 11 Mar 20 11.53am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
This is something I have direct, current and personal experience of. If anyone really wants to know how and why please PM me. That the NMC (Nursing and Midwifery Council) have raised standards by making nursing a degree course is beyond doubt. That they have done so is, partly at least, to ease the pressures on doctors and prepare the NHS for it's future. That the move from bursary funding to student loans has reduced the numbers applying for the courses is true. Hence the £5000 per year grant announced by the Government in December which will probably be confirmed in today's budget. This should help encourage more to enter the profession, whose loans are very unlikely ever to be paid back in full anyway. Raising the status, and salaries, of graduate nurses is going to be the real answer though, in my own opinion. The idea that it's easier in the Philippines is though very wrong. It's a 5 year course there, and not 3 as it is here, but the standards are not so high, hence the need for a 6 month adaptation if they join the NHS. The key sticking point though is money. Entry is easy. The nursing colleges are commercial enterprises and if you can pay their fees and meet the minimal entry requirements, then you are accepted. The fees though are very high for an average middle class Filipino family, who will often have to borrow heavily in the hope that their student will eventually repay them with enough extra for their older years. As the drop out rate is high you can imagine the consequences. If you are poor then you need a sponsor, often a family member who is themselves working abroad. It's no wonder you don't see too many Filipino nurses in the UK in social situations, but only in hospitals. They are too busy working and then sending most of what they earn back home. Even if every place on offer in the Universities for Nursing degrees was full (and there aren't so many vacancies now) we would still need to recruit overseas. If we doubled the number of our students I think we would still need to do so. How long though it would take us to double the number of training places, let alone for the NHS itself to cope with the extra demand to look after students on placements, are quite other questions. So overseas recruitment of nurses is going to be necessary for the foreseeable future. So if the arguments for mass immigration are purely either economic or practical (and not moral) then where does this end, obviously immigrants age the same as indigenous people. At what point would we be able to stop immigration following the current ponzi model? Also if the arguments are mainly economic this means that the average person coming into the country needs to be a net benefit to the economy which means they need to earn in the range of £40k, not be playing benefit system, not having large numbers of kids and not committing any crime. If so, how does this justify immigration from violent tribal societies from the 3rd world that are clearly living completely separately from the indigenous people? (It's natural and I don't blame them for this btw). Apart from all this it's telling how WE & Co completely ignore the more fundamental societal issues like why diversity is a good idea or is anything more then less white indigenous people.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I picked the Philippines at random partly because my wife works with several Filipino nurses but without checking I am sure that it's also easier to get into nursing in pakistan and India too. One of the disadvantages of making the entry into nursing so academic is that you end up with the wrong sort of people in the profession as those with the aptitude for the job don't have the academic qualifications for entry whilst those that do aren't necessarily the most suitable. On the subject of diversity in nursing though one of the positives is that there are a large number of Muslim nurses at my wife's hospital who are happy to work Christmas Day (at double time) so wifey can always get the day off As I am sure your wife will confirm HCAs (Health Care Assistants) now take on much of the work that lower level nurses used to do and are often the backbone in any ward. They provide a vital service which is often much under appreciated. However recruiting HCAs is likely to get much more difficult as it seems to me that this job won't qualify in the proposed points based system. Maybe this will have to be one of the first exemptions.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by W12
So if the arguments for mass immigration are purely either economic or practical (and not moral) then where does this end, obviously immigrants age the same as indigenous people. At what point would we be able to stop immigration following the current ponzi model? Also if the arguments are mainly economic this means that the average person coming into the country needs to be a net benefit to the economy which means they need to earn in the range of £40k, not be playing benefit system, not having large numbers of kids and not committing any crime. If so, how does this justify immigration from violent tribal societies from the 3rd world that are clearly living completely separately from the indigenous people? (It's natural and I don't blame them for this btw). Apart from all this it's telling how WE & Co completely ignore the more fundamental societal issues like why diversity is a good idea or is anything more then less white indigenous people.
If the NHS would fail unless you permit the recruitment of staff from overseas then no amount of concern about "societal issues" can justify not allowing it. You tackle the societal issues separately, with total determination to overcome them but with a matching attitude that brooks no behaviour that deviates from our accepted norms. Permitting needed immigration and ensuring we retain a homogeneous, well ordered, society are not mutually exclusive. It just requires effort.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
If the NHS would fail unless you permit the recruitment of staff from overseas then no amount of concern about "societal issues" can justify not allowing it. You tackle the societal issues separately, with total determination to overcome them but with a matching attitude that brooks no behaviour that deviates from our accepted norms. Permitting needed immigration and ensuring we retain a homogeneous, well ordered, society are not mutually exclusive. It just requires effort. Here we go again with that old baloney. What happens when the immigrants outnumber the original population? Whose morals and codes do we follow then?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.