You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Calling any lefty economists ...
November 21 2026 10.40pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Calling any lefty economists ...


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 24 May 20 4.43pm

I'm cr*p at economics and grown up stuff to do with property, capital and regulations. However, I was wondering once the economic slump really hits home and the govt has to keep us all going if there is a possibility of doing a simple, at-a-stroke, legal change to do with property that would release masses of people from debt (based on mortgages and rent) and leave an owner class unable to rake in all the money that creates the hole that most of us mugs have to fill. The sensible talk is that there are two options: keep the rich rich by paying for the lockdown with printing money and borrowing, or get the rich to cough up by restructuring the tax system. But can any of you with a better grasp of these things than me explain what would happen if they, for example, turned all land from private property to common land, like in the days before enclosure. Travellers aren't allowed to settle because there is no common land - the consequences could cause some major economic collapse, but would they? Our economy is just a series of managed property bubbles, it's why not enough houses are built, it would deflate prices. I just want to know the dynamics - is there a way, by disallowing money owed to lenders and owners through a reclassification of property, we could lower everybody's need to earn to pay for their property, and the main losers would just be small sector who are already economically secure. I realise there could be some dramatic destructive domino effect to do with banks and lenders, but is there a way of changing property rights that might damage the 'debt engine' but help the majority. I might be better off on another forum, but I've read enough on here to see some posters might have a constructive suggestion.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 24 May 20 4.46pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

I'm cr*p at economics and grown up stuff to do with property, capital and regulations. However, I was wondering once the economic slump really hits home and the govt has to keep us all going if there is a possibility of doing a simple, at-a-stroke, legal change to do with property that would release masses of people from debt (based on mortgages and rent) and leave an owner class unable to rake in all the money that creates the hole that most of us mugs have to fill. The sensible talk is that there are two options: keep the rich rich by paying for the lockdown with printing money and borrowing, or get the rich to cough up by restructuring the tax system. But can any of you with a better grasp of these things than me explain what would happen if they, for example, turned all land from private property to common land, like in the days before enclosure. Travellers aren't allowed to settle because there is no common land - the consequences could cause some major economic collapse, but would they? Our economy is just a series of managed property bubbles, it's why not enough houses are built, it would deflate prices. I just want to know the dynamics - is there a way, by disallowing money owed to lenders and owners through a reclassification of property, we could lower everybody's need to earn to pay for their property, and the main losers would just be small sector who are already economically secure. I realise there could be some dramatic destructive domino effect to do with banks and lenders, but is there a way of changing property rights that might damage the 'debt engine' but help the majority. I might be better off on another forum, but I've read enough on here to see some posters might have a constructive suggestion.

No

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 24 May 20 4.59pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

I'm cr*p at economics and grown up stuff to do with property, capital and regulations. However, I was wondering once the economic slump really hits home and the govt has to keep us all going if there is a possibility of doing a simple, at-a-stroke, legal change to do with property that would release masses of people from debt (based on mortgages and rent) and leave an owner class unable to rake in all the money that creates the hole that most of us mugs have to fill. The sensible talk is that there are two options: keep the rich rich by paying for the lockdown with printing money and borrowing, or get the rich to cough up by restructuring the tax system. But can any of you with a better grasp of these things than me explain what would happen if they, for example, turned all land from private property to common land, like in the days before enclosure. Travellers aren't allowed to settle because there is no common land - the consequences could cause some major economic collapse, but would they? Our economy is just a series of managed property bubbles, it's why not enough houses are built, it would deflate prices. I just want to know the dynamics - is there a way, by disallowing money owed to lenders and owners through a reclassification of property, we could lower everybody's need to earn to pay for their property, and the main losers would just be small sector who are already economically secure. I realise there could be some dramatic destructive domino effect to do with banks and lenders, but is there a way of changing property rights that might damage the 'debt engine' but help the majority. I might be better off on another forum, but I've read enough on here to see some posters might have a constructive suggestion.


What are you smoking?

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Midlands Eagle Flag 24 May 20 6.35pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

What are you smoking?

Same as usual probably

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 24 May 20 6.45pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle


What are you smoking?

I think he means we all become financially equal so dip your hand in a pot and pull out a wad and away you go. I've heard of parties like that but with car keys. Difference being you take yours home after. The car as well

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 24 May 20 8.37pm

I asked for lefty economists not right wing w*nkers And as for the other question it's definitely not skunk, I'm just high on life. I'm not trying to write a new communist manifesto, but if there was a simple change to property law which made a lot of the property bureaucracy (estate agents, mortgage brokers, related lawyers, surveyors) redundant, meant the propertied rich got less rich but were still rich, and also meant wage slaves had to pay much less to keep a roof over their head I'd like to know what it is. I'd also like to know what the downside consequences would be, and if there was a realistic way of lessening them to overall satisfaction. Power to the people (except for Brexit)!

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 24 May 20 8.49pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

I asked for lefty economists not right wing w*nkers And as for the other question it's definitely not skunk, I'm just high on life. I'm not trying to write a new communist manifesto, but if there was a simple change to property law which made a lot of the property bureaucracy (estate agents, mortgage brokers, related lawyers, surveyors) redundant, meant the propertied rich got less rich but were still rich, and also meant wage slaves had to pay much less to keep a roof over their head I'd like to know what it is. I'd also like to know what the downside consequences would be, and if there was a realistic way of lessening them to overall satisfaction. Power to the people (except for Brexit)!

This idea like communism is based on the concept that some people will have to give up their wealth for the greater good. Many of us are NIMBYS as long as the other fellow is paying more tax it's fine by me when it's me hang on a minute...

So what do you do when those who would lose out refuse to accept it, this inevitably leads to violence and in turn oppression by the state for the greater good.

Far better to have a tax system that ensures most people pay a reasonable amount of tax. I don't understand why the very rich are not in a special tax bracket with a minimum tax threshold so they can have the cleverest accountants in the world but at the very least they must pay the taxman X or greater if applicable.

The very rich will get no sympathy from the public if they complain they have to pay a fair minimum whatever that amount is.

 


One more point

Stirlingsays Flag 24 May 20 9.03pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

I asked for lefty economists not right wing w*nkers And as for the other question it's definitely not skunk, I'm just high on life. I'm not trying to write a new communist manifesto, but if there was a simple change to property law which made a lot of the property bureaucracy (estate agents, mortgage brokers, related lawyers, surveyors) redundant, meant the propertied rich got less rich but were still rich, and also meant wage slaves had to pay much less to keep a roof over their head I'd like to know what it is. I'd also like to know what the downside consequences would be, and if there was a realistic way of lessening them to overall satisfaction. Power to the people (except for Brexit)!

The idea that all property is theft is literally communism.

As a young man I was heavily attracted to this idea because there is an inherent fairness about it. However, I never become a communist because the importance of supporting meritocracy was so obvious to me. Still, only a fool denies the powerful arguments and criticisms that Marx and Engels had concerning capitalism....they just had no realistic answers. And hundreds of millions of people died proving that.

It's fundamental failing is that it exerts ideology over human nature.....I see the left making the same mistake today.

The property owning class are essential to capitalism. The problems of housing are very real and it's a damning summary on governments of the last half century which deserves regular scorn....But that's not only the lack of social and normal house building but also the increase in population without the infrastructure to support it.

All short term easy methods to improve GDP which long term suck the blood from and worsen the future.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 24 May 20 10.07pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

I asked for lefty economists not right wing w*nkers And as for the other question it's definitely not skunk, I'm just high on life. I'm not trying to write a new communist manifesto, but if there was a simple change to property law which made a lot of the property bureaucracy (estate agents, mortgage brokers, related lawyers, surveyors) redundant, meant the propertied rich got less rich but were still rich, and also meant wage slaves had to pay much less to keep a roof over their head I'd like to know what it is. I'd also like to know what the downside consequences would be, and if there was a realistic way of lessening them to overall satisfaction. Power to the people (except for Brexit)!


Mortgage Brokers, Surveyors, Lawyers and Estate agents don’t keep people poor, they are just cogs in an antiquated process.

There’s only one reason why property is so expensive, supply and demand.

You can call me a right wing w&nker if you wish but the absolute truth is that exponential house price rises coincide directly with our open door immigration policy.

Wish it didn’t as we already have tens of thousands of pages in here covering immigration, however that’s the truth. The more people who live here, the more property is worth. Simple logistics.


 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

the.universal 24 May 20 10.19pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Mortgage Brokers, Surveyors, Lawyers and Estate agents don’t keep people poor, they are just cogs in an antiquated process.

There’s only one reason why property is so expensive, supply and demand.

You can call me a right wing w&nker if you wish but the absolute truth is that exponential house price rises coincide directly with our open door immigration policy.

Wish it didn’t as we already have tens of thousands of pages in here covering immigration, however that’s the truth. The more people who live here, the more property is worth. Simple logistics.

Rough numbers but net migration over last 20 years 200k, say 4m. Clearly that’s a lot of people but ‘only’ represents 7% of UK population. In that time house prices roughly tripled. So it doesn’t seem immigration answers all the growth.

My view is people living longer + smaller household sizes and also more women earning proper wages all contribute. My feeling is the latter is a big driver of the increase.

Ps, you’re a right wing w&nker :0)

 


Vive le Roy!

Matov Flag 24 May 20 10.21pm

The notion of 'Universal Property Rights' is one of the founding principles of Western civilisation. Essentially if a recognized state acknowledge your ownership of a piece of land and that is then recorded through a publicly accessible record then any nation state that attempted to rescind that becomes an outcast state and its economy would be fundamentally weakened. Because why would anybody then want to invest if the state could just step in and remove it?

What your left-wing economist would do is seek to essentially dilute that ownership through a land tax or similar. Or make capital gains tax payable on ALL profits or tax rental income at say 75%. They could also introduce rent caps along with altering tenancy laws and so on. And mess about with inheritance laws and regulations, throwing together a pick & mix a variety of all of the above along with tougher licensing and so on.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 24 May 20 10.28pm

Originally posted by the.universal

Rough numbers but net migration over last 20 years 200k, say 4m. Clearly that’s a lot of people but ‘only’ represents 7% of UK population. In that time house prices roughly tripled. So it doesn’t seem immigration answers all the growth.

My view is people living longer + smaller household sizes and also more women earning proper wages all contribute. My feeling is the latter is a big driver of the increase.

Ps, you’re a right wing w&nker :0)

I’d agree with all the above. Last sentence particularly.

I believe these to all be factors which add to the demand. Whilst I’m not disagreeing with you regarding your figures on immigration, I am dubious. In some parts of London it’s as if every other person has arrived in the last 20 years and the white working class have all left.

Half my tenants are Eastern European.

As for your sentence regarding women now earning proper wages, well we should never have given them the f@cking vote

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Stirlingsays Flag 24 May 20 10.45pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

I’d agree with all the above. Last sentence particularly.

I believe these to all be factors which add to the demand. Whilst I’m not disagreeing with you regarding your figures on immigration, I am dubious. In some parts of London it’s as if every other person has arrived in the last 20 years and the white working class have all left.

Half my tenants are Eastern European.

As for your sentence regarding women now earning proper wages, well we should never have given them the f@cking vote

Amen.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

BlueJay Flag UK 24 May 20 10.55pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

I’d agree with all the above. Last sentence particularly.

I believe these to all be factors which add to the demand. Whilst I’m not disagreeing with you regarding your figures on immigration, I am dubious. In some parts of London it’s as if every other person has arrived in the last 20 years and the white working class have all left.

Half my tenants are Eastern European.

As for your sentence regarding women now earning proper wages, well we should never have given them the f@cking vote

It's a funny old world because half of your tenants being Eastern European is indicative of the white working class both leaving and arriving!

 

jeeagles Flag 24 May 20 11.11pm

In terms of residential properties, most rented properties are owned by people who own one or two houses as a nest egg. The slow down in house prices since the referendum certainly shows that migration does have an impact but it's not that great.

When bar jobs and saturday jobs traditionally undertaken by teenages living with their mum and dad started to get dominated by migrant works, then it was bound to put a strain on the housing stock.

However, we also weren't building enough and our planning system, labour costs, and an insecure market for the last decade has put this off.

That said under Labour's 3 terms in power it became increadibly easy to rent second homes and changing policy would have been a very unpopular move.

The Tories have made minor changes to the rental sector, such as thresholded of £0 and an increased stamp duty on second homes, but that's more likely to protect the interest of the status quo.

If you try and add direct taxes onto the rich, then they will find a way around it. However, indirect taxes are probably the best way around that, such as increased VAT on luxery goods. Want to buy a super car, the government will tax you 50%. An easy way of getting money off people.

Commercial property is far more likely to be owned by the mega rich. They earn money off everyone, for pretty much doing nothing. A lot of companies are likely to refuse to pay rent and landlords will probably have to accept that, but you can be almost certain companies wont pass this saving on.

Many of the big property owners are trust/pension funds. If the pension fund goes under than it will end up affecting the poor most.

Having said that, a lot of big investers in UK property have been coming from abroad, particularly Russia and China. The government should put in embargo's to protect its own people. Especially with China, they stopped all domestic flights but still let people leave the country on international flights with Coronavirus.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 24 May 20 11.21pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

It's a funny old world because half of your tenants being Eastern European is indicative of the white working class both leaving and arriving!


Yeah as funny as dental surgery.

Edited by Stirlingsays (24 May 2020 11.22pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

BlueJay Flag UK 24 May 20 11.31pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays


Yeah as funny as dental surgery.

Edited by Stirlingsays (24 May 2020 11.22pm)

Funny as in curious and unusual rather than hilarious

 

Matov Flag 24 May 20 11.38pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

I realise there could be some dramatic destructive domino effect to do with banks and lenders, but is there a way of changing property rights that might damage the 'debt engine' but help the majority. I might be better off on another forum, but I've read enough on here to see some posters might have a constructive suggestion.

I guess a Government could essentially replace the banks/Buidling societies by taking over as the lender and then allow people to benefit from the BOE lending rate.

Even offer to suspend mortgages altogether in exchange for the property once the owners die so that more housing stock falls into public ownership.

In terms of leaseholds, then there is a lot of tinkering that could take place (and might well be overdue anyway).

The key to any market is scarcity and by opening up planning regulations for social housing a left-wing Government could effectively dilute the private rental market to such an extent that rents tumble. Essentially look to outcompete the private market.

That is what happened initially with the great public housing building boom of the 50's and 60's whereby local authorities sort to replace private landlords. In fact the decline of people actually paying rent for Council flats as opposed to those on housing benefits is one of the best indicators of how the role of the state changed in terms of being a social housing provider.

My Grandfather for example actually sold his house and moved into a council flat because he believed that no real socialist should own their own home. Council housing was seen as a real positive step forward. Something to be proud of living in.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Stirlingsays Flag 24 May 20 11.57pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

Funny as in curious and unusual rather than hilarious

I find you regarding it as curious and unusual.....also curious and unusual.

Edited by Stirlingsays (24 May 2020 11.57pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

BlueJay Flag UK 25 May 20 12.04am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I find you regarding it as curious and unusual.....also curious and unusual.

Edited by Stirlingsays (24 May 2020 11.57pm)

You'll have to take this up with Patryk the Plumber..

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Calling any lefty economists ...