You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rating the centre backs
November 16 2026 5.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rating the centre backs


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
BM Flag 29 Oct 20 8.09pm

We have loads of options at CB but how do they rank in order of ability and importance? Here’s my top 7...
1. Sakho
2. Tomkins
3. Kouyate
4. Dann
5. Cahill
6. Kelly
7. Woods

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 29 Oct 20 8.12pm

Originally posted by BM

We have loads of options at CB but how do they rank in order of ability and importance? Here’s my top 7...
1. Sakho
2. Tomkins
3. Kouyate
4. Dann
5. Cahill
6. Kelly
7. Woods

Wind up

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 29 Oct 20 9.44pm

That's what it looks like and I'm not going to bite!

Edited by doombear (29 Oct 2020 9.44pm)

 

the.universal 29 Oct 20 10.03pm

As far as wind ups go, it’s not very subtle is it.

 


Vive le Roy!

sprites Flag Auckland 30 Oct 20 2.25am

I think you need to separate ability and importance.
If the rankings are on pure ability, you're probably not far off. But in terms of importance, it'd look a bit different. Cahill and Dann's experience and leadership, for example, is invaluable. So while Sakho might be a bettter football player (and I believe he is)...is he that much better to warrant leaving those experienced guys out? Not sure. For me, having one of each makes sense. So I think when everyone's fit, a Sakho-Tomkins or Sakho-Cahill partnership works bestt.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 30 Oct 20 2.42am

Originally posted by BM

We have loads of options at CB but how do they rank in order of ability and importance? Here’s my top 7...
1. Sakho
2. Tomkins
3. Kouyate
4. Dann
5. Cahill
6. Kelly
7. Woods

I dont think theres any doubting from a pure class point of view Sakho was unreal when he first came to us... Unfortunately he has that mental streak in him and can, at any given moment just do something completely mental..

However now hes been here a while I genuinely think the guy has no commitment. Hes just picking up a large pay cheque and I doubt if half his injuries he picks up are even genuine... That's just my opinion.. The sooner hes off the wage bill the better cos I just dont think the guy wants to be here.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

BM Flag 30 Oct 20 8.35am

Originally posted by sprites

I think you need to separate ability and importance.
If the rankings are on pure ability, you're probably not far off. But in terms of importance, it'd look a bit different. Cahill and Dann's experience and leadership, for example, is invaluable. So while Sakho might be a bettter football player (and I believe he is)...is he that much better to warrant leaving those experienced guys out? Not sure. For me, having one of each makes sense. So I think when everyone's fit, a Sakho-Tomkins or Sakho-Cahill partnership works bestt.

Thanks for a sensible response. Why on earth would my choices be a wind-up? The downer people have on Sakho is weird and wrong. He reads situations brilliantly, is immensely strong and his passing is crucial in launching attacks. Yes, he has an error in him but they all do and his get scrutinised far more than other defenders (eg. Ward v Brighton).
He and Tomkins were our first choice for a long time and I still think they are our best two, although we are lucky to have such strength in that position.
I respect what Cahill has achieved in his career but I think many Palace fans have an inflated view of how good he is. For me he looks to knock it back to Guiata too often rather than be a bit braver in his passing options.

 

OldFella Flag London 30 Oct 20 8.52am

Originally posted by BM

Thanks for a sensible response. Why on earth would my choices be a wind-up? The downer people have on Sakho is weird and wrong. He reads situations brilliantly, is immensely strong and his passing is crucial in launching attacks. Yes, he has an error in him but they all do and his get scrutinised far more than other defenders (eg. Ward v Brighton).
He and Tomkins were our first choice for a long time and I still think they are our best two, although we are lucky to have such strength in that position.
I respect what Cahill has achieved in his career but I think many Palace fans have an inflated view of how good he is. For me he looks to knock it back to Guiata too often rather than be a bit braver in his passing options.

Continued wind up. Or just attention seeking. Also not biting.

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

stayloa Flag Beckenham 30 Oct 20 9.00am

Originally posted by BM

We have loads of options at CB but how do they rank in order of ability and importance? Here’s my top 7...
1. Sakho
2. Tomkins
3. Kouyate
4. Dann
5. Cahill
6. Kelly
7. Woods

Can't agree with this at all personally. Mine woudl be:

1. Cahill
2. Tomkins
3. Dann
4. Kouyate
5. Sakho
6. Kelly
7. Woods

Cahill whilst slow is absolutely immense in terms of positioning and leadership. Him and Tomkins (when fit) are my top 2.

Kouyate has been amazing stepping in, but prefer him at DM when he can get forward more. Dann pips third place for me as he's stepped up when needed having been out of the team for an age and has been superb.

Sakho on his day could be #1, but too many flicks, attemped Cruyff turns, stumbling or just plain falling over for no reason means he can't be higher up the list for me. There's a howler every game and it often costs a goal. Give me slow and dependable any day!

All that said, any of those top 6 are decent and premier league quality, so no complaints from me!

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 30 Oct 20 9.05am

Kouyate and Cahill best two, Tomkins next

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Arthur Blackpudding Flag 30 Oct 20 9.51am

1. Cahill
2. Tomkins
3. Kouyate
4. Dann
5. Sakho
6. Kelly
7. Woods

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 30 Oct 20 10.33am

The order is subjective, I get that.

The only nailed on position is Cahill at number one. After that they can fight among themselves.

60 plus England caps, champion league winner etc. None of the others ever got close to this. How he would be anyone’s number five shows you are either a wind up merchant, know f@ck all about football or both.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

taylors lovechild Flag 30 Oct 20 10.37am

Sakho has the ability to go from the sublime to the ridiculous. Sadly the latter has become more common in the last year. If he could stay fit and get a run in the team then his fitness and concentration levels seem to improve drastically, but he only seems capable of staying fit for two or three games and as such has become a bit of a liability. It's a shame as I really like him.

Cahill and Tomkins for me is the best partnership if they can stay fit. Dann is good when we sit deep, but he is so slow these days that if we push up we are exposed. Kouyate is the best athlete and I always feel fairly confident with him in the backline. When you think Liverpool are crying about losing VVD and I'm not sure we've had the same centre-back pairing for more than two or three games running this year. We are lucky to be well stocked in that area.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 30 Oct 20 10.45am

Originally posted by BM

Thanks for a sensible response. Why on earth would my choices be a wind-up? The downer people have on Sakho is weird and wrong. He reads situations brilliantly, is immensely strong and his passing is crucial in launching attacks. Yes, he has an error in him but they all do and his get scrutinised far more than other defenders (eg. Ward v Brighton).
He and Tomkins were our first choice for a long time and I still think they are our best two, although we are lucky to have such strength in that position.
I respect what Cahill has achieved in his career but I think many Palace fans have an inflated view of how good he is. For me he looks to knock it back to Guiata too often rather than be a bit braver in his passing options.

There's little doubt that Sakho on his day is decent. However, you cannot simply ignore his regular clangers, which often cause goals. This is why your post isn't being taken seriously.

If you had to rely on Palace to get a result on the final day of the season to stay up, Tompkins, Cahill, Dann & Kouyate are all more reliable and would give most fans more confidence. The Sakho time bomb goes off roughly one in three games. This makes him a liability.

The downer is not weird and wrong. He's our highest paid defender so should be our best and he's not living up to it at the moment. That's part of the territory when you're earning over £100k per week.

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 30 Oct 20 11.43am

1. Cahill
2. Tomkins
3. Sakho
4. Dann
5. Kouyate
6. Kelly
7. Ward

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 30 Oct 20 11.50am

Sakho

Positives: the best ball playing centre half we have. Negatives: he is poor in the air given his size and the position he plays.
Always liable to make a mistake (probably because of the positive mentioned).
His wages are high.
He's always injured.

On the balance the negatives far out weigh the positives.

I would say our best pairing at the moment is Kouyate and Cahill or Kouyate and Dann.

Kelly very underated and has never let us down.
Tomkins - the injuries are mounting up but an excellent centre half when fully fit.

We are lucky to have such experience, quality and depth in this position.

 

Foxy0208 Flag Blackpool 30 Oct 20 11.59am

I agree with Bexley Eagle. I think right now its a really strong position for us assuming we can keep the majority of them fit.

What concerns me more is next season and beyond as they are all getting on a bit and the injuries are likely to increase.

I hope we are researching some younger replacements.


 


Some people think football is a matter of life and death. I don't like that attitude. I can assure them it is much more serious than that.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 30 Oct 20 12.11pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

Sakho

Positives: the best ball playing centre half we have. Negatives: he is poor in the air given his size and the position he plays.
Always liable to make a mistake (probably because of the positive mentioned).
His wages are high.
He's always injured.

On the balance the negatives far out weigh the positives.

I would say our best pairing at the moment is Kouyate and Cahill or Kouyate and Dann.

Kelly very underated and has never let us down.
Tomkins - the injuries are mounting up but an excellent centre half when fully fit.

We are lucky to have such experience, quality and depth in this position.

Absolutely bang on with regard to each player. Hopefully Woods steps up in the next year or so as a decent replacement for one of the older players otherwise we might as well release him.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 30 Oct 20 12.30pm

Moving forward and hoping that they could be both fit at the same time, I'd like to see a pairing of Kouyate and Tomkins.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 01 Nov 20 11.37am

Tomkins and Cahill top it for me, assuming Cahill can return to full fitness.

Kouyate has done a great job filling in and is next up - he doesn't really deserve to lose his place although he can play elsewhere. As for the others, Dann okay a but but slowing up a bit. Kelly still good cover, and Sakho, excellent one moment but a disaster the next, and his blunders are becoming a little too frequent to overlook.

I haven't seen enough of Woods to comment.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rating the centre backs