This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
Heavy title. Can be done in many ways. Religion, social conditioning (hierarchical empathy). I've seen Nazism and communism in action. Many of you are very intelligent (in spite of posting on a football forum). Discuss Unfortunately, adversarial politics requires a lot of time wasted just criticising the other side. I'd prefer that we used our time for sensible discussion, but there are those who are incapable of objectivity or taking off their party tie. Discussion with them is a waste of time. I'm sure that since its invention and common use, the television has become the biggest weapon in conditioning people's mind. Advertising, so called news and even the perpetuation of traditional influences like religion can all be sent straight to the home. Now we have the internet to add to the saturation. We are now seeing those that have the most influence on the planet trying to mould people's minds to suit their agendas. It is Orwell's 1984 except that he was a little premature with his date.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
Heavy title. Can be done in many ways. Religion, social conditioning (hierarchical empathy). I've seen Nazism and communism in action. Many of you are very intelligent (in spite of posting on a football forum). Discuss You may be mixing politics with opinions.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Interesting subject. I’m not a lover of any of the political parties, mainly because they don’t ever fulfill their major election promises, let alone the minor ones. I find myself swayed towards conservative policies but I also find myself agreeing with other parties ideals. This even filters down to relationships such as that between say the public and the Police. When I was a kid we were all scared witless by the old bill and you would treat them with total respect. Bit of a difference now when you see the youth and Police conversing, but this is just an example of how the whole world has gone. No respect, no trust. People lurch from one extreme to the other. A sensible criticism of the mainstream has segued into having no critical filter for any old sh!t that's posted on social media. It's certainly done a number on many. Their drug of choice in fact.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
I would probably say that the conditioning was far more effective in the past than it is now. Brexit for example. Huge swathes of the Media, almost the entire political system, 99% of the entertainment business, all telling us to vote Remain. And failing miserably. Ditto with Trump in the US. All the 'experts' constantly telling us that Trump never stood a chance of even gaining the nomination, let alone winning. And then only losing after the system was gamed, with record numbers of Hispanic and African-Americans voting for him. The reason why there is such a clamp down on freedom of speech at the moment is because the conditioning is failing. You make a very valid point. Inevitably, people become used to propaganda so more Draconian measures are employed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
You make a very valid point. Inevitably, people become used to propaganda so more Draconian measures are employed. When you think about it most people, up until maybe even as recently as say 10 years ago, only had maybe two or three sources of media. Certainly in terms of the big stories then perhaps just the single one. Most people bought a daily newspaper and most people sat down at a fixed time to watch a news bulletin. The stream of information was narrow and therefore much more controllable. But now? People bemoan social media and often with some justification but it has also opened up the world and made many many more people accountable for their actions. Would Jimmy Saville have hidden in the shadows for so long in the spotlight of social media? Would have girls up north have been abused for so long in the spot light of social media? Hence why I am so so wary of any and every attempt to limit what people are allowed to watch and listen to. Now I don't count myself as a 'fan' of Tommy Robinson and have long harboured suspicions that he is a state player in some guise of the other but the way he has been ostracised and treated by our legal system (I never realised but for somebody who is meant to be this hardened criminal they have never once allowed him to be adjudged by a jury) makes me realise have pernicious the attempts to control the narrative we are allowed to hear and learn about actually are. Of course the usual suspects are now going to come on here and throw all the usual BS around (I know, its not his real name) but I would challenge any of them to, if possible, take a step back and ask themselves about the treatment meted out to him and wonder if that is actually a system they fully support. Because it could turn its attention in their direction one day, hence why we all have to oppose almost all attempts at censorship.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
When you think about it most people, up until maybe even as recently as say 10 years ago, only had maybe two or three sources of media. Certainly in terms of the big stories then perhaps just the single one. Most people bought a daily newspaper and most people sat down at a fixed time to watch a news bulletin. The stream of information was narrow and therefore much more controllable. But now? People bemoan social media and often with some justification but it has also opened up the world and made many many more people accountable for their actions. Would Jimmy Saville have hidden in the shadows for so long in the spotlight of social media? Would have girls up north have been abused for so long in the spot light of social media? Hence why I am so so wary of any and every attempt to limit what people are allowed to watch and listen to. Now I don't count myself as a 'fan' of Tommy Robinson and have long harboured suspicions that he is a state player in some guise of the other but the way he has been ostracised and treated by our legal system (I never realised but for somebody who is meant to be this hardened criminal they have never once allowed him to be adjudged by a jury) makes me realise have pernicious the attempts to control the narrative we are allowed to hear and learn about actually are. Of course the usual suspects are now going to come on here and throw all the usual BS around (I know, its not his real name) but I would challenge any of them to, if possible, take a step back and ask themselves about the treatment meted out to him and wonder if that is actually a system they fully support. Because it could turn its attention in their direction one day, hence why we all have to oppose almost all attempts at censorship.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Agree, the downside of it is it can be used to slaughter the innocent although I think that’s what you are also alluding to.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
No programming here. Now green as I feel they are the only party understanding the issues of today. And I campaigned for Ted Heath (no wonder he lost!). Have an open mind, if events show you were wrong, do not be afraid to change. Looking back I would suggest that Tony Blair's government was a reasonable mix of mild toryism with social justice. But Thatcher really changed Britain, and as we are now seeing, for the worst, a nasty selfish generation.
But a generation generally with money in its pocket. Who do you know now who doesn’t have a decent TV and kids who seem to have all they want, whether the parents are on benefits or not? I remember as a kid having to save up for everything I wanted. Maybe I’m lucky having made a decent life for myself however as much as people hate Thatcher, the opportunity to earn money was there during her tenure.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
as much as people hate Thatcher, the opportunity to earn money was there during her tenure. without Thatcher, the UK would be more similar to Sweden or Ireland. Countries where you are often better off unemployed than bothering to find gainful employment. And the fabric of society all falling apart.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
No programming here. Now green as I feel they are the only party understanding the issues of today. And I campaigned for Ted Heath (no wonder he lost!). Have an open mind, if events show you were wrong, do not be afraid to change. Looking back I would suggest that Tony Blair's government was a reasonable mix of mild toryism with social justice. But Thatcher really changed Britain, and as we are now seeing, for the worst, a nasty selfish generation.
Get over yourself as you benefitted much like most.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The brave new world of information, via responsible search engines like Google, is indeed a wonderful thing. Unfortunately many people get fed much more disinformation via social media which they accept at face value and never check. Disinformation is not just an opinion. It is a deliberate attempt to deceive. If it originates, as if clearly often does, from places determined to sow disharmony in the west, it's dangerous. Disinformation cannot just be ignored and treated as just another opinion. It is as big a security risk to us as any other kind of attack on our democracy. We fight terrorism. We must fight disinformation and it's our patriotic duty to support that fight. If we lose this fight there will be no more free speech for any of us.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.