You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Chris Wilder a possibility?
November 16 2026 5.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Chris Wilder a possibility?


Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
steven_t92 Flag Orpington 12 Mar 21 10.56am

For some reason Chris Wilder is leaving Sheffield Utd today according to the BBC, I can't understand it at all but would you have him at Palace if Roy's contract ends this summer?

 

taylors lovechild Flag 12 Mar 21 11.12am

If Roy does leave I think his hat would certainly be in the ring. He got quite an average Sheffield Utd into a great position last season, but this season injuries have taken their toll, along with the lack of quality players. The one question mark for me is he seems to have a lot of anger in him at the moment, so I question whether he might need a a break from football.

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 12 Mar 21 11.23am

The fact it is being reported that he is leaving due to his belief that the club have not invested as much as they should have in players may may well be a cautionary insight that rules him out of coming to us. It never looks good when a manager is perceived to have to spend money in order to succeed (even if it is true).

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 12 Mar 21 11.32am

Originally posted by Mwncisee

The fact it is being reported that he is leaving due to his belief that the club have not invested as much as they should have in players may may well be a cautionary insight that rules him out of coming to us. It never looks good when a manager is perceived to have to spend money in order to succeed (even if it is true).


And has been noted in the media, the two forwards signed for big money (for Sheff U) namely, McBurnie and Brewster simply haven't done the business. If they were Wilder choices, I would have to question his ability to recognize players capable of making it in the Premier League.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 12 Mar 21 11.44am

Originally posted by doombear


And has been noted in the media, the two forwards signed for big money (for Sheff U) namely, McBurnie and Brewster simply haven't done the business. If they were Wilder choices, I would have to question his ability to recognize players capable of making it in the Premier League.

There were rumours that part of Wilder's dissatisfaction stemmed from the club wanting to bring in a director of football to oversee the club's transfer policy. If he wants complete control over transfers then I doubt he'll be coming here, as Roy constantly reminds us that he has little input!

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 12 Mar 21 11.53am

Originally posted by Mwncisee

The fact it is being reported that he is leaving due to his belief that the club have not invested as much as they should have in players may may well be a cautionary insight that rules him out of coming to us. It never looks good when a manager is perceived to have to spend money in order to succeed (even if it is true).


I think Wilder, would be one of the most realistic choices open to Palace, if Hodgson, calls it a day. The main reason to say that is any new manager needs to be ready for the the restrictions imposed by Palaces financial realities, and yet be capable of getting everything out of that situation possible.
The fact that Wilder needed recruits is absolutely obvious. There is only so much can be done with any squad of players. In the Premier league, That applies more than in any other division.
He has proved he can get blood out of a stone, just as Roy, has done for two years now. Wilders squad was never as good as ours, yet he still leads two one, in results.
Palace are going to be a tough call for some time yet, but he would get an, if not great squad , a better one than the one he worked with this year..If he got out of a slightly revamped Palace, as much as he got into a Championship team playing out of its skin, for him and his tactics. We would be in good hands.


 

fromtherope Flag In the woods of deepest Surrey 12 Mar 21 11.59am

No Thanks. One decent Prem season based on a different approach, upwards momentum team spirit and a top goalie in Henderson. Always looks like he is sucking a lemon, dour northern attitude and won't work with a Director of Football apparently.

 


I am enjoying being back at Selhurst and having a beer with my mates just like we have done for the past 40 years. Through Thick and thin we stick with our club. Not chairman, players or managers, OUR CLUB!

Robk Flag 12 Mar 21 12.02pm

Strange one... he has obviously fallen out with the Owner... still you’d think he’d see the season out as they’re doomed already....

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 12 Mar 21 12.06pm

Originally posted by doombear


And has been noted in the media, the two forwards signed for big money (for Sheff U) namely, McBurnie and Brewster simply haven't done the business. If they were Wilder choices, I would have to question his ability to recognize players capable of making it in the Premier League.

And the goalie he bought from Bournemouth for approx £23m, Ramsdale, has been questioned by a lot of the fans.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 12 Mar 21 12.35pm

I like Chris Wilder - I think he demands a lot from his players (effort & work ethics wise) which to me makes him a good choice ( if indeed we are going to be in the market to make a choice) my first thoughts when seeing he is leaving Sheff Utd was to consider that he would probably end up at Newcastle Utd -
I have nothing whatsoever to support this theory just what came to mind.

 

The Dolphin Flag 12 Mar 21 1.03pm

Originally posted by fromtherope

No Thanks. One decent Prem season based on a different approach, upwards momentum team spirit and a top goalie in Henderson. Always looks like he is sucking a lemon, dour northern attitude and won't work with a Director of Football apparently.

Ditto.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Mar 21 1.04pm

Originally posted by eritheagle

And the goalie he bought from Bournemouth for approx £23m, Ramsdale, has been questioned by a lot of the fans.

Sheff Utd sold him to Bournemouth for about £1 Mill + a 15% sell-on clause.My understanding is that when they brought him back to the club they paid £18.5 Mill for his services.

Indeed I believe he has not endeared himself to the supporters of Sheff Utd.At the start of the year I heard that he had a tendency to concede goals from long range and this was labelled against De Gea when he first signed for Man Utd.


Edited by Willo (12 Mar 2021 1.06pm)

 

Speronilover69 8=D~~ Flag Horsham 12 Mar 21 1.05pm

I pray we get this one done. I was hoping we would get Wilder in at the end of the season but didn't think Sheffield would let him go. Really stupid decision on their part, he could have done a Sean Dyche and got them back into the prem first time of asking

 

JohnB Flag 12 Mar 21 1.06pm

Chris Wilder handed his resignation in to Sheff U on 3rd Jan, ironically after losing to us. The players heard he had resigned and that's what led to Mousset writing his lambo off as a few of the players got together and had a load of drinks.

The board rejected his resignation and Wilder even asked to be paid off as part of his resignation. There was a stalemate for a few days but in the 9-10 days between then and the next game, they managed to sort it out, but he's wanted to leave pretty much since he resigned.

The rumours are true that he will leave or has left and I've asked my mate if he walked or was pushed.

Personally, I would take him. He overachieved last season but also lost 2-3 key players in Henderson, O'Connell and Berge to injury/end of loan. If you look at the rest of the squad, to have done what they did last season was a miracle.

In terms of signings, I don't accept that. Berge is quality, Brewster I still think will make it and Burnie was signed at a time when the amount of players that would have wanted to go to them was limited so he was the best they could entice. Our first season we got Dwight Gayle who didn't exactly set the world alight.

Just been messaged by my mate whilst typing this, who told me the above, it's a mutual decision but he's sort of taking it as a sacking for the pay off. Apparently he could get a quick return to management at either end of the country though in Celtic or Bournemouth. Likelihood is Celtic and Bournemouth are now talking to Howe and Van Winckel.

 

Speronilover69 8=D~~ Flag Horsham 12 Mar 21 1.07pm

He'd also be able to get us playing a more attractive style of football without compromising our defense

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 12 Mar 21 1.29pm

Originally posted by Speronilover69 8=D~~

He'd also be able to get us playing a more attractive style of football without compromising our defense

Would he though? I don't know enough about his tactical prowess to agree with you.

Right now I remain unconvinced.

 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 12 Mar 21 1.40pm

I remember the game at Selhurst last season when they basically kicked us off the park (bad reffing). For all of Roy's faults He doesn't send our teams out to do that. If we can afford him and can afford to see our good name go bad then he would be in the hat but a no from me.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

TheBigToePunt Flag 12 Mar 21 2.17pm

Think I might be missing something here.

Wilder has done a good job at Sheffield United. I would think there are plenty of good managers who would have fancied their chances of getting a club that size out of league 1, though fair play to Wilder for actually doing it, and for then achieving a very impressive promotion to the big league. Credit too for keeping them up with what was partly the league 1 squad he started with.

Thereafter he couldn't do anything to arrest a massive, humiliating, season long capitulation. They have literally been in the running to be record breakers. He hasn't been able to overhaul the team that did so well for him in the lower leagues, despite buying and borrowing some highly rated players.

The list of managers to get clubs promoted into the premier league isn't exactly short, but the list of those to do well once in that league is. Wilder has earned his place on the first list, but not on the second.

What exactly has he done to make him the right man to build a new team, on a relatively limited budget, at a club who have hit the glass ceiling in the top flight? Does he have any obvious track record of developing young players? Has he integrated new signings into a side with success?

Shouldn't think he'll have to wait too long before a good championship club makes him an offer, but I genuinely can't see why he'd be suitable for us.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (12 Mar 2021 2.18pm)

 

Come to Daddy Flag 12 Mar 21 2.26pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Think I might be missing something here.

Wilder has done a good job at Sheffield United. I would think there are plenty of good managers who would have fancied their chances of getting a club that size out of league 1, though fair play to Wilder for actually doing it, and for then achieving a very impressive promotion to the big league. Credit too for keeping them up with what was partly the league 1 squad he started with.

Thereafter he couldn't do anything to arrest a massive, humiliating, season long capitulation. They have literally been in the running to be record breakers. He hasn't been able to overhaul the team that did so well for him in the lower leagues, despite buying and borrowing some highly rated players.

The list of managers to get clubs promoted into the premier league isn't exactly short, but the list of those to do well once in that league is. Wilder has earned his place on the first list, but not on the second.

What exactly has he done to make him the right man to build a new team, on a relatively limited budget, at a club who have hit the glass ceiling in the top flight? Does he have any obvious track record of developing young players? Has he integrated new signings into a side with success?

Shouldn't think he'll have to wait too long before a good championship club makes him an offer, but I genuinely can't see why he'd be suitable for us.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (12 Mar 2021 2.18pm)

Exactly. He strikes me as very much a "new Warnock" with all the good/bad/ limitations that come with that. It seems like it's just an "anyone but Hodgson" suggestion because, other than that, he looks a significant downgrade.

When you add in the stuff abt refusing to work with a DoF it seems to reinforce that he's better suited to the Championship. Given what he's spent over £80m on in the past couple of seasons he maybe needs to look at that policy anyway!

 

nead1 Flag 12 Mar 21 2.27pm

I agree. If it was a choice between Wilder and Hodgson, I cannot see any reason why they would go for Wilder. To me, he also appears quite full of himself and hence probably difficult to manage.

I also doubt very much, if Freedman has anything to do with it, that he would feature on any short list.

Time will tell and maybe these will be famous last words!

 

Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Chris Wilder a possibility?