You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Nice One Wilf
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Nice One Wilf


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
scarlet Flag Turkey 15 Mar 21 10.39am

Great to see a Palace player leading the way. All lives matter. If he was white he couldn't do it without severe repercussion and that shows you how broken the idea is. This will probably be killed by the pcers but hey. ???

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 15 Mar 21 11.10am

It will probably be "Women's Lives Matter" next

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 15 Mar 21 11.11am

Kudos to Roy as well. His support for Wilf was sincere and quite articulate (for someone in football ).

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

eagles4lyf Flag croydon 15 Mar 21 11.19am

🤦🏽‍♂️That wasn’t the reason he chose to do this, he chose to do this because racism has not changed in football and never will since doing this and I totally agree with him. And no one has ever said “all lives didn’t matter” but this was used to silence BLM.

 


EAGLESSSSSSSSSSSSS.......
'BELIEVE TO ACHIEVE'

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 15 Mar 21 11.49am

Originally posted by scarlet

Great to see a Palace player leading the way. All lives matter. If he was white he couldn't do it without severe repercussion and that shows you how broken the idea is. This will probably be killed by the pcers but hey. ???

He wasn’t the first,Ivan Toney of Brentford did the same thing in Friday nights game v Blackburn.

 

eaglesdare Flag 15 Mar 21 11.52am

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

He wasn’t the first,Ivan Toney of Brentford did the same thing in Friday nights game v Blackburn.

First premier league player to do it.

A few teams in the championship have stopped taking the knee since last september.

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 15 Mar 21 12.06pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

It will probably be "Women's Lives Matter" next

They’ll be required to stand up for that. Then they can lay down for LGBTQZFGTKL rights, stand on one leg for global warming, and then adopt some other poses for other “issues “.
Set it all to some fast paced music and the routine could become more enjoyable than the game itself.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 15 Mar 21 12.33pm

Originally posted by Eaglehamster

Kudos to Roy as well. His support for Wilf was sincere and quite articulate (for someone in football ).

I don't know whether that was meant to be patronising but it clearly looks like it. But I'm about to go down the same path. I only got round to viewing Roy post-WBA last night and I was really struck by how fluently he speaks. He embarks on lengthy sentences and you wonder where they're leading, but he reaches the end with everything nicely tied up. What he has to say is sensible, interesting, wise and balanced. And I've never heard a manager (or player!) throw in some Latin (sine qua non).

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 15 Mar 21 12.35pm

Originally posted by eagles4lyf

🤦🏽‍♂️That wasn’t the reason he chose to do this, he chose to do this because racism has not changed in football and never will since doing this and I totally agree with him. And no one has ever said “all lives didn’t matter” but this was used to silence BLM.

BLM silenced themselves by proving what they really were as an organisation.

Wilf considers taking the knee an empty gesture, which he is probably correct to do. Fighting against racism in football and BLM are two entirely different things. One I agree with, the other I don’t.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 15 Mar 21 12.43pm

Originally posted by JRW2

I don't know whether that was meant to be patronising but it clearly looks like it. But I'm about to go down the same path. I only got round to viewing Roy post-WBA last night and I was really struck by how fluently he speaks. He embarks on lengthy sentences and you wonder where they're leading, but he reaches the end with everything nicely tied up. What he has to say is sensible, interesting, wise and balanced. And I've never heard a manager (or player!) throw in some Latin (sine qua non).


Brilliant, lovely image.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 15 Mar 21 1.47pm

Wilf's reasons for not taking the knee are very different to the ones I would have, but I'm not surprised to hear some of those who bought into the whole 'BLM are going to make big changes to society' thing are now frustrated. How could it ever be otherwise?

One of the many problems with BLM is that they don't have any specific, reasonable and measurable targets (apart from previously advocating that the Police be defunded, which the Tories were working on anyway, though which one of those two organisations will admit such an agenda now is unclear).

BLM is full of meaningless, general speak. We want to end racism. We want a better world. We want things to be nicer. Trevor Philips (former head of the Commission for Racial Equality) wrote a piece in the Economist telling BLM that they needed to 'exchange sloganeering for substance'. There are mixed views about Philips, but it is of note that even he's telling BLM they are without point or clear purpose.

If anyone is serious about addressing the role racial (and other) prejudice may or may not play in the construction of our society, then they need to start by laying out exactly where they think it operates, demonstrating that it is significant, and harmful. That isn't the same as telling me about an awful experience you had, any more than it is about me telling you that as a white man I feel certain I have lived my life taking each person on their merits. We need to take our individual experiences and place them in a demonstrable statistical context. BLM can't, won't, don't do that. They are just a walking narative machine given far too much platform. They could never achieve a thing because they were never a serious, evidence based, outcomes focused organisation. They are amateurs, when what the modern world needs is professionals. That's how climate change gets addressed, or international food poverty, or structuring economies to limit the impact of things like Covid, or the rule of law. Yet for some reason, when it comes to removing hurdles from the path of a person relating to their race, gender, sexuality etc (which is truly vital work to do when necessary), we allow amateurs to take the stage, and they don't come any more amatuer than BLM.

I would love to ask Wilf if, aside from what seems a fairly constant (and utterly unacceptable) stream of abuse from trolls online, he feels he lives in a racist society. BLM may tell him that he does. I would point to a family from Africa coming to England, finding housing, work, free education and health services, and thriving in the security of a law abiding, structured, policed society. Weigh the former up against the latter, and see how it balances. You might find that the issue at hand for Wilf (online abuse) can be better understood and addressed if it were focused on as a specific, rather than being used to support a wider narrative.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (15 Mar 2021 1.50pm)

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 15 Mar 21 2.11pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Wilf's reasons for not taking the knee are very different to the ones I would have, but I'm not surprised to hear some of those who bought into the whole 'BLM are going to make big changes to society' thing are now frustrated. How could it ever be otherwise?

One of the many problems with BLM is that they don't have any specific, reasonable and measurable targets (apart from previously advocating that the Police be defunded, which the Tories were working on anyway, though which one of those two organisations will admit such an agenda now is unclear).

BLM is full of meaningless, general speak. We want to end racism. We want a better world. We want things to be nicer. Trevor Philips (former head of the Commission for Racial Equality) wrote a piece in the Economist telling BLM that they needed to 'exchange sloganeering for substance'. There are mixed views about Philips, but it is of note that even he's telling BLM they are without point or clear purpose.

If anyone is serious about addressing the role racial (and other) prejudice may or may not play in the construction of our society, then they need to start by laying out exactly where they think it operates, demonstrating that it is significant, and harmful. That isn't the same as telling me about an awful experience you had, any more than it is about me telling you that as a white man I feel certain I have lived my life taking each person on their merits. We need to take our individual experiences and place them in a demonstrable statistical context. BLM can't, won't, don't do that. They are just a walking narative machine given far too much platform. They could never achieve a thing because they were never a serious, evidence based, outcomes focused organisation. They are amateurs, when what the modern world needs is professionals. That's how climate change gets addressed, or international food poverty, or structuring economies to limit the impact of things like Covid, or the rule of law. Yet for some reason, when it comes to removing hurdles from the path of a person relating to their race, gender, sexuality etc (which is truly vital work to do when necessary), we allow amateurs to take the stage, and they don't come any more amatuer than BLM.

I would love to ask Wilf if, aside from what seems a fairly constant (and utterly unacceptable) stream of abuse from trolls online, he feels he lives in a racist society. BLM may tell him that he does. I would point to a family from Africa coming to England, finding housing, work, free education and health services, and thriving in the security of a law abiding, structured, policed society. Weigh the former up against the latter, and see how it balances. You might find that the issue at hand for Wilf (online abuse) can be better understood and addressed if it were focused on as a specific, rather than being used to support a wider narrative.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (15 Mar 2021 1.50pm)

Well said BTP. This nonsense surely has now gone far enough. You're right to identify Phillips as a voice of reason. Seems to me like a common sense kind of guy.

But, now we've got Haringey Council spending £186k to rename Black Boy Lane on their turf despite the residents being quite happy with it. Named after King Charles 11 and been there 300 years. Nonsense. Black is merely a colour - it's not racist.

There's a Black Swan and a Black Horse pub near me. One of them 400 years old. Good too. Hope they don't feel obliged to rename them.

My local is the White Horse. Is that alright?

Sorry, nothing to do with Wolf, who I've supported on his stand in other threads, but the same issue I feel.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 15 Mar 21 2.12pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Well said BTP. This nonsense surely has now gone far enough. You're right to identify Phillips as a voice of reason. Seems to me like a common sense kind of guy.

But, now we've got Haringey Council spending £186k to rename Black Boy Lane on their turf despite the residents being quite happy with it. Named after King Charles 11 and been there 300 years. Nonsense. Black is merely a colour - it's not racist.

There's a Black Swan and a Black Horse pub near me. One of them 400 years old. Good too. Hope they don't feel obliged to rename them.

My local is the White Horse. Is that alright?

Sorry, nothing to do with Wolf, who I've supported on his stand in other threads, but the same issue I feel.


Or even Wilf! Bloody pre-emptive text!

 

taylors lovechild Flag 15 Mar 21 6.21pm

Maybe Wilf noticed that people seem to be getting far more upset about kneeling than they were about racism and thought 'What's the point?'

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 15 Mar 21 7.28pm

Almost certainly Wilf could sense there was a growing unrest about the way that kneeling was losing it's impact.

His lonely 'stand tall' approach must have been difficult for him, but it sure did make a statement.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 15 Mar 21 7.45pm

Originally posted by scarlet

Great to see a Palace player leading the way. All lives matter. If he was white he couldn't do it without severe repercussion and that shows you how broken the idea is. This will probably be killed by the pcers but hey. ???

He didn't do it to specifically say all lives matter....

he did it to say that talk is cheap... getting on a knee is the most some people do, which isn't enough... actions speak louder than words.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Crazy_Eagle Flag South London 16 Mar 21 6.13pm

Originally posted by scarlet

Great to see a Palace player leading the way. All lives matter. If he was white he couldn't do it without severe repercussion and that shows you how broken the idea is. This will probably be killed by the pcers but hey. ???

I very, very much doubt Zaha was thinking 'All Lives Matters' in his head.

Good for Zaha on standing up (literally), although I wonder what he would think to see comments like this. The whole All Lives Matter response completely misses the point of why players are taking the knee.

 


R.I.P. DJ Hardline

CPFC2010

CT Charlie Flag 17 Mar 21 3.23pm

Isn't the BLM movement simply a way of trying to cast a light on the fact that it's more difficult for Blacks (and others) to make their way through life than Whites? That racism is real? And that these things shouldn't be so?

In my opinion, social justice is about ensuring that not only the laws of a society but that the PEOPLE of a society follow the Golden Rule in both action and attitude. Whenever I have the opportunity to engage a critic of BLM, I simply ask them this: Would you prefer to have been born black or white? Why? Until their answer is, "In this culture/country, it really makes no difference whatsoever," I think we ought to keep working, individually and collectively, to effect change.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 17 Mar 21 4.44pm

Originally posted by CT Charlie

Isn't the BLM movement simply a way of trying to cast a light on the fact that it's more difficult for Blacks (and others) to make their way through life than Whites? That racism is real? And that these things shouldn't be so?

In my opinion, social justice is about ensuring that not only the laws of a society but that the PEOPLE of a society follow the Golden Rule in both action and attitude. Whenever I have the opportunity to engage a critic of BLM, I simply ask them this: Would you prefer to have been born black or white? Why? Until their answer is, "In this culture/country, it really makes no difference whatsoever," I think we ought to keep working, individually and collectively, to effect change.

Well, my answer to your question would be ‘I have seen no evidence that in this culture/country, one’s race makes a significant difference whatsoever to ones life chances, despite having read BLMs website on more than one occasion’.

I would then ask you (and it would be a sincere, genuine question) to show me evidence of societal racism in action. Where is the network or pattern across our social institutions or cultures? I would press you for something systemic, corporate, common or widespread, rather than instances or examples of racism, however awful they may be. My criticism of BLM is that they appear unable to make that distinction. My criticism of the BBC et al is that they refuse to even acknowledge how vital it is to do so. A society that has some racists in it is not the same as a racist society, and the solution depends very much on an accurate prognosis of the problem.

To return to Wilf, he has experienced nasty, s***ty social media trolls. I haven't heard him speak of anything beyond that.

Against which you have the evidence of the Zaha’s, a black African family who came to the UK and got access to work, housing, education, health, and a safe, structured and secure society in which they did better than they would have done in the Ivory Coast. It wasn’t easy for them (Wilf has spoken about being evicted as a kid), but it’s not easy for most of us.

Weigh up Wilf’s negative (racist) experiences against the positives. Where is the argument that his life is materially harder than any person receiving threats or abuse on line, of whom there are thousands all the time?

I would certainly listen to what you had to tell me, because I can’t find anything of substance in BLM to consider. I would also ask you to understand that the notion of Britain as a racist society is at odds with my own experience, and frankly a bit offensive to me as one part of that society.

I am a white working class male from a traditional background, who likes football, the pub, and all the usual stuff, but who also went to Uni, and got a career in a relatively intellectual profession where I have worked at managerial level for a long time. My work affects places and people directly and indirectly. As a working class lad with a middle class life I have a foot in both of the camps where one might look to find racism, and all I can say is that if it pervades then I’ve missed the memo. I might also ask when it became OK to accuse a society of being racist to the point that change must be made without proving it?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 17 Mar 21 5.04pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Well, my answer to your question would be ‘I have seen no evidence that in this culture/country, one’s race makes a significant difference whatsoever to ones life chances, despite having read BLMs website on more than one occasion’.

I would then ask you (and it would be a sincere, genuine question) to show me evidence of societal racism in action. Where is the network or pattern across our social institutions or cultures? I would press you for something systemic, corporate, common or widespread, rather than instances or examples of racism, however awful they may be. My criticism of BLM is that they appear unable to make that distinction. My criticism of the BBC et al is that they refuse to even acknowledge how vital it is to do so. A society that has some racists in it is not the same as a racist society, and the solution depends very much on an accurate prognosis of the problem.

To return to Wilf, he has experienced nasty, s***ty social media trolls. I haven't heard him speak of anything beyond that.

Against which you have the evidence of the Zaha’s, a black African family who came to the UK and got access to work, housing, education, health, and a safe, structured and secure society in which they did better than they would have done in the Ivory Coast. It wasn’t easy for them (Wilf has spoken about being evicted as a kid), but it’s not easy for most of us.

Weigh up Wilf’s negative (racist) experiences against the positives. Where is the argument that his life is materially harder than any person receiving threats or abuse on line, of whom there are thousands all the time?

I would certainly listen to what you had to tell me, because I can’t find anything of substance in BLM to consider. I would also ask you to understand that the notion of Britain as a racist society is at odds with my own experience, and frankly a bit offensive to me as one part of that society.

I am a white working class male from a traditional background, who likes football, the pub, and all the usual stuff, but who also went to Uni, and got a career in a relatively intellectual profession where I have worked at managerial level for a long time. My work affects places and people directly and indirectly. As a working class lad with a middle class life I have a foot in both of the camps where one might look to find racism, and all I can say is that if it pervades then I’ve missed the memo. I might also ask when it became OK to accuse a society of being racist to the point that change must be made without proving it?

Well said. Personally I’m sick to death of being told I’m fundamentally racist because I don’t actively support my accusers. It’s the most ridiculous argument I’ve ever heard.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Nice One Wilf