This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Might ask the same question about Scott Banks - anyone know?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Uphill
Might ask the same question about Scott Banks - anyone know? Yeah. Like Mayer, thought he could be "the one". Depressing when they fizzle out to nothing and end up eking out an existence in 3rd tier Scottish football.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Uphill
Might ask the same question about Scott Banks - anyone know? He was on loan with Dunfermline until the end of the season which ended for them on 8 May, so I imagine he’s back now. He made substitute appearances in the last two games - the promotion play-offs. He did miss a few matches in April, perhaps with a knock, but before that he was playing quite regularly I believe. The fans seem to have liked him by all accounts.
"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt." |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Every time someone complains that our youngsters aren't given a chance, and that we won't know what they might be capable of until they get a game for our first team, several of us pop up to rehash the same response. The club has a pretty good idea of how good the youth lads are likely to be. Not a definitive, scientific formula to prove exact potential, but a good idea. They seem to come in three camps: a. Good enough to play for us now. Most youth players are in C, then some in B, with a rare few in A. Those players must stand out like sore thumbs. Moses, Watson, Wilf, Clyne, AWB and Mitchell did not go on loan, they just played, and never came out of the first-team squad. Most lads in group B go out on loan so that we can find out if they are good enough. Most of the time they prove that they aren't. Innis did, I expect Woods, McGregor, Kirby and Banks are doing so right now. Pierrick seemed to be rated higher than the others, but not to the point that he moved into group A. Sadly, there is no real surprise to it if he doesn't turn out to be good enough. I'd love to be pleasantly surprised by the lad of course, but I'd expect a player who is good enough for us to stand out when on loan in a lower league, like Reece James did at Wigan. None of ours have.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Every time someone complains that our youngsters aren't given a chance, and that we won't know what they might be capable of until they get a game for our first team, several of us pop up to rehash the same response. The club has a pretty good idea of how good the youth lads are likely to be. Not a definitive, scientific formula to prove exact potential, but a good idea. They seem to come in three camps: a. Good enough to play for us now. Most youth players are in C, then some in B, with a rare few in A. Those players must stand out like sore thumbs. Moses, Watson, Wilf, Clyne, AWB and Mitchell did not go on loan, they just played, and never came out of the first-team squad. Most lads in group B go out on loan so that we can find out if they are good enough. Most of the time they prove that they aren't. Innis did, I expect Woods, McGregor, Kirby and Banks are doing so right now. Pierrick seemed to be rated higher than the others, but not to the point that he moved into group A. Sadly, there is no real surprise to it if he doesn't turn out to be good enough. I'd love to be pleasantly surprised by the lad of course, but I'd expect a player who is good enough for us to stand out when on loan in a lower league, like Reece James did at Wigan. None of ours have. Surely, for the lads in Group B, the standard of coaching that they receive whilst out on loan could be a major factor as to how well or badly they develop?
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Every time someone complains that our youngsters aren't given a chance, and that we won't know what they might be capable of until they get a game for our first team, several of us pop up to rehash the same response. The club has a pretty good idea of how good the youth lads are likely to be. Not a definitive, scientific formula to prove exact potential, but a good idea. They seem to come in three camps: a. Good enough to play for us now. Most youth players are in C, then some in B, with a rare few in A. Those players must stand out like sore thumbs. Moses, Watson, Wilf, Clyne, AWB and Mitchell did not go on loan, they just played, and never came out of the first-team squad. Most lads in group B go out on loan so that we can find out if they are good enough. Most of the time they prove that they aren't. Innis did, I expect Woods, McGregor, Kirby and Banks are doing so right now. Pierrick seemed to be rated higher than the others, but not to the point that he moved into group A. Sadly, there is no real surprise to it if he doesn't turn out to be good enough. I'd love to be pleasantly surprised by the lad of course, but I'd expect a player who is good enough for us to stand out when on loan in a lower league, like Reece James did at Wigan. None of ours have. Not for the first time you make some very good points very clearly.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Every time someone complains that our youngsters aren't given a chance, and that we won't know what they might be capable of until they get a game for our first team, several of us pop up to rehash the same response. The club has a pretty good idea of how good the youth lads are likely to be. Not a definitive, scientific formula to prove exact potential, but a good idea. They seem to come in three camps: a. Good enough to play for us now. Most youth players are in C, then some in B, with a rare few in A. Those players must stand out like sore thumbs. Moses, Watson, Wilf, Clyne, AWB and Mitchell did not go on loan, they just played, and never came out of the first-team squad. Most lads in group B go out on loan so that we can find out if they are good enough. Most of the time they prove that they aren't. Innis did, I expect Woods, McGregor, Kirby and Banks are doing so right now. Pierrick seemed to be rated higher than the others, but not to the point that he moved into group A. Sadly, there is no real surprise to it if he doesn't turn out to be good enough. I'd love to be pleasantly surprised by the lad of course, but I'd expect a player who is good enough for us to stand out when on loan in a lower league, like Reece James did at Wigan. None of ours have. Very good points. Just look at the youngsters who play for England at U16. They are supposed to be the elite youngsters, they dont all go on to make a career in the pro game.
|
|
|
Originally posted by becky
Surely, for the lads in Group B, the standard of coaching that they receive whilst out on loan could be a major factor as to how well or badly they develop? I think the borrowing club would argue that their contribution to the players development starts and ends with giving him a far better chance of game time than he was getting with us. Something is terribly wrong with our staff if we're sending players out on loan for better coaching. It's all just for game time. That said, if you were brought up at Man City or Barcelona or somewhere then I can imagine it might be a challenge to play for a real long ball merchant in league two. You'd think the lending club would avoid borrowing clubs who played totally differently to them (unless they wanted the player toughened up a bit), but I'm not sure we have such a definite tactical style that the way our borrowing clubs play would be baffling to our lads. They should be able to adapt and impress in league one or two if they are going to be in our team in the next year or so.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Every time someone complains that our youngsters aren't given a chance, and that we won't know what they might be capable of until they get a game for our first team, several of us pop up to rehash the same response. The club has a pretty good idea of how good the youth lads are likely to be. Not a definitive, scientific formula to prove exact potential, but a good idea. They seem to come in three camps: a. Good enough to play for us now. Most youth players are in C, then some in B, with a rare few in A. Those players must stand out like sore thumbs. Moses, Watson, Wilf, Clyne, AWB and Mitchell did not go on loan, they just played, and never came out of the first-team squad. Most lads in group B go out on loan so that we can find out if they are good enough. Most of the time they prove that they aren't. Innis did, I expect Woods, McGregor, Kirby and Banks are doing so right now. Pierrick seemed to be rated higher than the others, but not to the point that he moved into group A. Sadly, there is no real surprise to it if he doesn't turn out to be good enough. I'd love to be pleasantly surprised by the lad of course, but I'd expect a player who is good enough for us to stand out when on loan in a lower league, like Reece James did at Wigan. None of ours have. Have to disagree there.... Wilf developed when we literally had no one because the club was rock bottom. He was allowed the time to improve whist being in the first team when he was particularly raw and wouldn’t have had such a chance in a better team AWB was set to go out on loan but got his chance due to injury, he perhaps would not have got his chance Mitchell same as above I don’t think loaning young players with Premiership aspersions to teams below tChampionship level
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Very good points. Just look at the youngsters who play for England at U16. They are supposed to be the elite youngsters, they dont all go on to make a career in the pro game. Even Jamie Smith played for England U21s..............!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Does anyone know what happened to Luke Dreher? He recently came back from long term injury but hasn't been in the last two games. Unfortunately he's injured again
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.