You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Which players to keep...in your opinion ?
November 16 2026 4.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Which players to keep...in your opinion ?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 22 May 21 2.22pm


the other thread, on here , asks you to wield the knife.

And so, which Eagles do you most value. Would you certainly want to see at Selhurst next season.

For openers :

Guaita, Andros Townsend, Tomkins, Eze, Wilfried, Ward, Ayew, Kouyate,

there are 2 or 3 other players i like but not enough to mention here. This list is for strong certainties in your own mind.

what players ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 22 May 21 2.29pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio


the other thread, on here , asks you to wield the knife.

And so, which Eagles do you most value. Would you certainly want to see at Selhurst next season.

For openers :

Guaita, Andros Townsend, Tomkins, Eze, Wilfried, Ward, Ayew, Kouyate,

there are 2 or 3 other players i like but not enough to mention here. This list is for strong certainties in your own mind.

what players ?

I think it's cash in time for Wilf. He doesn't seem interested anymore and also, it's not fair to keep him from "living his dream".

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

aashman12 Flag 22 May 21 5.12pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio


the other thread, on here , asks you to wield the knife.

And so, which Eagles do you most value. Would you certainly want to see at Selhurst next season.

For openers :

Guaita, Andros Townsend, Tomkins, Eze, Wilfried, Ward, Ayew, Kouyate,

there are 2 or 3 other players i like but not enough to mention here. This list is for strong certainties in your own mind.

what players ?

Mitchell and schlupp are 100%

 

aashman12 Flag 22 May 21 5.12pm

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

I think it's cash in time for Wilf. He doesn't seem interested anymore and also, it's not fair to keep him from "living his dream".

Be mad to let wilf go when eze is out injured.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 22 May 21 5.41pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio


the other thread, on here , asks you to wield the knife.

And so, which Eagles do you most value. Would you certainly want to see at Selhurst next season.

For openers :

Guaita, Andros Townsend, Tomkins, Eze, Wilfried, Ward, Ayew, Kouyate,

there are 2 or 3 other players i like but not enough to mention here. This list is for strong certainties in your own mind.

what players ?

Ward and Ayew - really - have you actually watched any games this season...!!

They would both be at the top of my list to “ship out”..!!

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 22 May 21 6.42pm

Originally posted by aashman12

Be mad to let wilf go when eze is out injured.


Not so sure. We rely on Wilf too much. The opposition know that and stifle him and we don't have a Plan B. If Wilf goes (and I doubt we'd get more than £35m for him) the DF might be allowed to spend it on a couple of decent players and we would have to set up differently and learn to play as a team instead of keep looking for Wilf and trying to get the ball to him.

 

aj36094 Flag Derbyshire 22 May 21 7.19pm

Benteke = Release... 4 games doesn't allow for 4 years

Schlupp = Keep... versatile

PVA = Keep... one of few players with pace

Andros = Keep... no replacement options especially due to eze injury

Sakho = Release... Donkey & injured

Clyne/ Ward = Keep 1 (2nd most important summer signing)

Jim Macs= keep both if available at a fair wage

Cahill = Keep... old but gold

Dann= Release... legs have gone

Wayne = Release... 3rd choice

Henderson = Release... have an U23 as a sub in cup ties

Kelly/ Wickham = Release... Sick notes

 

jeeagles Flag 22 May 21 7.19pm

Originally posted by aashman12

Be mad to let wilf go when eze is out injured.

11 goals, 2 assists from 28 starts.
You're absolutely right.
With Eze injured and tomorrow's fixture being a dead rubber, I'd rest him until next season.

I'm not overly concerned with any one on the list. But we need a squad. Each one will cost at least £20m to replace.

We may be in a position of seeing who wants to re-sign and then go from there.

 

adelaar Flag Edgware 22 May 21 9.30pm

Originally posted by aj36094

Benteke = Release... 4 games doesn't allow for 4 years

Schlupp = Keep... versatile

PVA = Keep... one of few players with pace

Andros = Keep... no replacement options especially due to eze injury

Sakho = Release... Donkey & injured

Clyne/ Ward = Keep 1 (2nd most important summer signing)

Jim Macs= keep both if available at a fair wage

Cahill = Keep... old but gold

Dann= Release... legs have gone

Wayne = Release... 3rd choice

Henderson = Release... have an U23 as a sub in cup ties

Kelly/ Wickham = Release... Sick notes


PVA is 100% off, and we should keep Benteke. The rest I agree with. We need a young centre back with pace, and I'd love to see Mateus Pereira play the Eze role. A bonus is if the fans actually get to see Ferguson as right back, especially ahead of Ward.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 22 May 21 9.55pm

keep Jairo, McArthur, Schlupp (get rid of Luka and MCarthy)

keep Kouyate - versatility makes him key squad player

keep Cahill, Tomkins, Kelly (get rid of Sakho, Dann)

keep Eze, Townsend, Ayew, Mateta (get rid of Benteke and Zaha, neither want to stay, Batshuyai obviously get rid of))

keep Mitchell, Ferguson, (get rid of PVA, I want to get rid of Ward but he is our ONLY right back atm)

keep Guita, Butland (get rid of Hennessy)

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 22 May 21 10.20pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

keep Jairo, McArthur, Schlupp (get rid of Luka and MCarthy)

keep Kouyate - versatility makes him key squad player

keep Cahill, Tomkins, Kelly (get rid of Sakho, Dann)

keep Eze, Townsend, Ayew, Mateta (get rid of Benteke and Zaha, neither want to stay, Batshuyai obviously get rid of))

keep Mitchell, Ferguson, (get rid of PVA, I want to get rid of Ward but he is our ONLY right back atm)

keep Guita, Butland (get rid of Hennessy)

Agree with all of these apart from Benteke. If he can keep the kind of form he's been showing lately he would be good for 12-15 goals next season. I can't see how we can afford to let him go. Just realised you said we should keep Ayew. We absolutely shouldn't. He's a Championship player at best.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 22 May 21 10.53pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

keep Jairo, McArthur, Schlupp (get rid of Luka and MCarthy)

keep Kouyate - versatility makes him key squad player

keep Cahill, Tomkins, Kelly (get rid of Sakho, Dann)

keep Eze, Townsend, Ayew, Mateta (get rid of Benteke and Zaha, neither want to stay, Batshuyai obviously get rid of))

keep Mitchell, Ferguson, (get rid of PVA, I want to get rid of Ward but he is our ONLY right back atm)

keep Guita, Butland (get rid of Hennessy)


He still has 2 years on his contract so isn't going anywhere unless a decent offer comes in

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 22 May 21 11.06pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

11 goals, 2 assists from 28 starts.
You're absolutely right.
With Eze injured and tomorrow's fixture being a dead rubber, I'd rest him until next season.

I'm not overly concerned with any one on the list. But we need a squad. Each one will cost at least £20m to replace.

We may be in a position of seeing who wants to re-sign and then go from there.


Benteke 9 goals and 1 assist from 21 starts (plus that Brighton goal off the bench and yet half the people on here want to get rid of him. Wilf's return since New Year is unimpressive just 3 goals and 0 assists in 12 starts. However, he hasn't seemed quite right since his injury in the Newcastle game.


 

jeeagles Flag 23 May 21 12.35am

Originally posted by doombear


Benteke 9 goals and 1 assist from 21 starts (plus that Brighton goal off the bench and yet half the people on here want to get rid of him. Wilf's return since New Year is unimpressive just 3 goals and 0 assists in 12 starts. However, he hasn't seemed quite right since his injury in the Newcastle game.

He scored against Villa. He's also been on the wing a bit more. Our points ratio playing 4-5-1 is much better than 4-4-2.

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 23 May 21 1.03am

Originally posted by aj36094

Benteke = Release... 4 games doesn't allow for 4 years

Schlupp = Keep... versatile

PVA = Keep... one of few players with pace

Andros = Keep... no replacement options especially due to eze injury

Sakho = Release... Donkey & injured

Clyne/ Ward = Keep 1 (2nd most important summer signing)

Jim Macs= keep both if available at a fair wage

Cahill = Keep... old but gold

Dann= Release... legs have gone

Wayne = Release... 3rd choice

Henderson = Release... have an U23 as a sub in cup ties

Kelly/ Wickham = Release... Sick notes

Steve Parish will be choking on his protein shake reading comments like these.
His two Liverpool mega-buys (Benteke £30m, Sakho £27m) need to be bombed out according to fans.
Let's be honest, getting the chequebook out has been a disaster, particularly bailing out Liverpool's mistakes (see Ibe and Solanki at Bournemouth).
So don't be surprised if the club are careful about spending big because the owners have been financially killed when they dare to do this.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 23 May 21 7.38am

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

Steve Parish will be choking on his protein shake reading comments like these.
His two Liverpool mega-buys (Benteke £30m, Sakho £27m) need to be bombed out according to fans.
Let's be honest, getting the chequebook out has been a disaster, particularly bailing out Liverpool's mistakes (see Ibe and Solanki at Bournemouth).
So don't be surprised if the club are careful about spending big because the owners have been financially killed when they dare to do this.

A big 6 club will spend £50m on a player and if it doesn't work out then rinse and repeat. Almost every player we sign has to be a success and if they are not there is no guarantee we will replace them quickly.

 


One more point

daven Flag Hailsham 23 May 21 8.13am

The players that are out of contract in the summer cease to become our players, so they are all free agents.
The club will use this to reduce the wage bill as it will become a market where the players without contracts will be worried about their futures.
I would be very surprised if we paid any transfer fees this summer because there will be a pool of players from the other clubs who need a contract.
Players who have performed well will take the best offer from whatever club and we could lose players that we want to keep because they have been offered better contracts elsewhere.
So except for Zaha and a few others with contracts I expect that we could start next season unrecognisable to todays team. Which underlines the reason why the timing of Roys departure was ineviatable.
So the only players that I would keep are the ones with contracts.

 

daven Flag Hailsham 23 May 21 8.29am

Players in contract;
Zaha 2023
Kouyate 2022
Tomkins 2022
Luka 2023
McCarthy 2022
Eze 2025
Butland 2023
Ayew 2022
Guiata 2024
Reidewald 2024
Mitchell 2025
Anyone else will have to compete with other players from other clubs also out of contract.

 

aashman12 Flag 23 May 21 9.03am

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Ward and Ayew - really - have you actually watched any games this season...!!

They would both be at the top of my list to “ship out”..!!

If you're saying ward then you haven't watched any games this season, he's been solid.

 

aashman12 Flag 23 May 21 9.10am

Originally posted by daven

Players in contract;
Zaha 2023
Kouyate 2022
Tomkins 2022
Luka 2023
McCarthy 2022
Eze 2025
Butland 2023
Ayew 2022
Guiata 2024
Reidewald 2024
Mitchell 2025
Anyone else will have to compete with other players from other clubs also out of contract.

Kelly, schlupp and macarthur are contracted too

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Which players to keep...in your opinion ?