This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
It isn't Gab's or Torba's way, it's simply the first amendment.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It isn't Gab's or Torba's way, it's simply the first amendment. Which is, like most things, capable of being understood in a variety of ways. There is an industry of first amendment scholars opining on these matters In any case, there is a great deal more than just the US Constitution involved here. The world has moved on quite a long way since 1791. Torba expresses opinions on many issues. The first amendment says he is free to express them, but not to force others to agree with him. I asked if people did, or not. Not whether he has the freedom to express his own.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Which is, like most things, capable of being understood in a variety of ways. There is an industry of first amendment scholars opining on these matters In any case, there is a great deal more than just the US Constitution involved here. The world has moved on quite a long way since 1791. Torba expresses opinions on many issues. The first amendment says he is free to express them, but not to force others to agree with him. I asked if people did, or not. Not whether he has the freedom to express his own. I don't see an issue here. If they don't wish to comply with German law that is their right. It is the right of the German government to block their site if they believe it contravenes German law.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Thinking that the first amendment is going to be altered is about as realistic as thinking Mitt Romney had/has a chance of the Republican leadership. That said, I would rather like it if the Democrats tried or actually could put Trump in jail as this guy also wants. It would speed up the separation of the US....something I predicted years ago and which appears to still be well on course. Anyway for now, this desire for leftist authoritarianism on free speech will have to wait. I will add though that when this guy was red carded on this platform I was personally messaged by one of his chief 'fans' over the ban (I don't know why as I have no power or influence with mods). I won't divulge the person or the details other than the fact that an appeal to 'free speech' was paramount. So I find the tenor of this thread on the desired restricting of free speech for others somewhat ironic. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Sep 2021 9.28am) Why on earth do you imagine I think, or even want, the first amendment to be altered? That's for the Americans to determine, and as there is plenty of scope already available in its interpretation, it seems unlikely. This has almost nothing to do with the first amendment, other than in Torba's mind and those of his fan base, like you. It has absolutely nothing to do with Trump's situation directly. His only connection is that he is still able to use Torba's platform to spread "alternative facts". Aka lies. It is actually also nothing to do with left or right politics, although the right appear to believe it is. This has much more to do with whether and how a country, acting with the authority of its people via their elected representatives, can ensure they create a safe and responsible environment for their people. That's not authoritarianism at all. It's democracy. I have argued many times totally unrestricted free speech in a democracy is a myth. It doesn't exist and never has. As soon as laws are written, some restrictions exist. Only anarchists can genuinely argue for unrestricted free speech. That's not a "leftist" desire at all. It's just a mark of democracy, which imposes responsibilities alongside rights. I was briefly "red carded" through a misunderstanding, which was quickly corrected. Being able to freely exchange views in a democracy is an essential and precious right. So long as it is done responsibly and causes no harm to others. Which is why you can think whatever you like, and freely express it in private. Do so elsewhere, and some laws apply because you don't own that space. We all do. The Germans own theirs. It's going to be interesting.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Germans banning words they don't like. I almost feel like it may have happened before sometime. Anyway, as it's them, I'm sure it'll all be fine. It's not words that are the issue here. It's the idea that demonstrably incorrect and dangerous misinformation can be circulated without any kind of checks and balances. If lies can be presented as truths often enough, then they start to be believed by those susceptible to such things. In the internet age this can have profound implications for all of us. Of course, it needs to be supervised and managed effectively with transparent oversight subject to constant review and challenge. In my view it isn't though that a line needs to be drawn but only where it needs to be. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (22 Sep 2021 1.29pm)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
This guy is an exercise in the abuse of words. Anyway I'll leave him to his waffle. Just in case anyone needs that translating, what it really means is as that he has no answers to the actual questions asked he will revert to his standard modus operandi of personal insult.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Why on earth do you imagine I think, or even want, the first amendment to be altered? That's for the Americans to determine, and as there is plenty of scope already available in its interpretation, it seems unlikely. This has almost nothing to do with the first amendment, other than in Torba's mind and those of his fan base, like you. It has absolutely nothing to do with Trump's situation directly. His only connection is that he is still able to use Torba's platform to spread "alternative facts". Aka lies. It is actually also nothing to do with left or right politics, although the right appear to believe it is. This has much more to do with whether and how a country, acting with the authority of its people via their elected representatives, can ensure they create a safe and responsible environment for their people. That's not authoritarianism at all. It's democracy. I have argued many times totally unrestricted free speech in a democracy is a myth. It doesn't exist and never has. As soon as laws are written, some restrictions exist. Only anarchists can genuinely argue for unrestricted free speech. That's not a "leftist" desire at all. It's just a mark of democracy, which imposes responsibilities alongside rights. I was briefly "red carded" through a misunderstanding, which was quickly corrected. Being able to freely exchange views in a democracy is an essential and precious right. So long as it is done responsibly and causes no harm to others. Which is why you can think whatever you like, and freely express it in private. Do so elsewhere, and some laws apply because you don't own that space. We all do. The Germans own theirs. It's going to be interesting. To summarize. You want to censor anything you don't agree with whilst claiming to love free speech and only the people who you disagree with tell bad lies. The lies you and your like minds tell are OK of course. Good god, you are deluded.... And boring.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
We could wonder: are they banning Twitter, apparently thousands of racist tweets according to Sky Sports News and BBC? A point well made.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
We could wonder: are they banning Twitter, apparently thousands of racist tweets according to Sky Sports News and BBC? Yep, excellent points....Facebook has been used to live stream murders, that obviously wasn't their intent. Then again, it was always obvious that steaming would be used, for dark awful purposes. Facebook accept the inevitable abuse of their services if it suits a greater fiscal purpose....and the left hold fire because it's their tribe. If you look for it on Youtube you can find people being stabbed to death and other murders. Yet, have a social media platform holding opinions they don't like....suddenly it's beyond the pale. First they told them, if you don't like it build your own platforms, then when they build them they still do all they can to destroy them. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Sep 2021 7.35pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I subscribe to Gab's emails and keep an eye on their site, making the occasional comment. Today I received this missive:- Whilst I am pretty sure a couple of regular posters will agree wholeheartedly with everything that Torba writes, I wonder what others think? Do you think Germany has a "tyrannical" government? Do you think because a company is based in the USA they can, or even ought to, ignore the laws of other countries, if they offer their services there? Or are, in the internet age, companies free to ignore laws they don't like? Do you think "fake news" is whatever a Government says it is, or is it demonstrable untruths which are considered dangerous by elected representatives? Do you think that the appeals to God as the ultimate authority, and justification, is wise, given that there are echoes of the reasoning used by extremists of other faiths to be heard? Should unrestricted free speech exist online, or should companies be expected to respond to complaints of dangerous misinformation and, having verified the transgression, remove them from their platforms? In our increasingly borderless world, if individual countries are unable to determine what is acceptable, or not, who can? Reading it, they seem like nutters. There isn't anything I've spotted that infringes on anyone else freedoms, or anything that is deliberately deceptive. It's quite obvious to the reader that it's an opinion piece and a bit strange that Germany wants to take action against them. The story itself could be fake news? In previous generations these people would be wearing tin foil on their heads claiming the government could read our minds.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
We could wonder: are they banning Twitter, apparently thousands of racist tweets according to Sky Sports News and BBC? Good point. Multi Billionaire dollar social networks are no doubt harder to push around and have public opinion on their side due to widespread use-age. They very much hold influence and an active relationship with governments in a way that smaller sites do not.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
To summarize. You want to censor anything you don't agree with whilst claiming to love free speech and only the people who you disagree with tell bad lies. The lies you and your like minds tell are OK of course. Good god, you are deluded.... And boring. I would never describe you as boring! Ridiculous, prejudiced and often unpleasant, but not boring. You are too funny for that! So thanks again. I needed a laugh this morning. That's no more a summary of my views than it is a summary of Einstein's theory of special relativity! I won't bother to explain why. Anyone sensible will already understand, whilst those who see any alternative view as a lie, like yourself, won't.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
We could wonder: are they banning Twitter, apparently thousands of racist tweets according to Sky Sports News and BBC? This is an argument for more intervention from social media companies and not less, which is what Andrew Torba is demanding. I presume the sites you mention all co-operate with and respect the German authorities and German laws. Gab does not. It is, in this instance, for the Germans to decide what are their priorities. As Gab is a hotbed of misinformation, particularly at the moment about the efficacy of vaccines, my guess is that they have determined urgent action is needed. Whether they are are working with the companies on the other issues you highlight, either alone or with the wider international community, is unknown. Some form of internationally recognised standards, and oversight, do though seem needed and overdue. Acting alone in the internet age is a little pointless.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.