You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Selhurst station chaos
November 16 2026 4.13am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Selhurst station chaos


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
trapperjohn Flag Horsham 07 Nov 21 4.52pm

For as long as I can remember over 50 years or so the alley way from Dagnell Park allowed access to the rear of the station hall and a gateway that could be opened for entry at the foot of the ramp to platform one, so there were two points of entry and no problems getting in. Now the “planners” have closed off the rear access (partly with a new lift) and funnel everyone from the alley out onto the main road to enter only via the main front door.

The result? Complete chaos. The queue back up the road is 100 yards long and yesterday it took 15 minutes to get into the station and as the train was due some 17 minutes after I joined the queue it was getting close. It has to be said that those queuing were on this occasion well behaved and patient. However there were pedestrians walking in the road in both directions amongst heavy traffic. And if you wanted to wait at the bus stop, good luck! Once people realise they are going to miss their train there will be pushing and queue jumping. I fear that it is only a matter of time before there is a serious accident.

Where is the crowd control? Where was the thought that allowed this stupid situation to arise in the first place? And what are the implications for an increase in capacity at the ground if 24000 crowds completely choke up Selhurst station?

 


I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.

deleted 25 Flag 07 Nov 21 10.28pm

Agree. Crazy situation

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 08 Nov 21 12.41pm

Agree, you need to have it set up for normal use, but a couple of gates that you can swing open at match time to relieve the pressure .

Norward Junction is much better managed

 

dorking Flag 08 Nov 21 2.08pm

I don't know why they don't just open the massive gate post-match (shown with a red X on the photo below)

Surely it must date back to when CPFC played at the Nest? (which was bang opposite the station)

Edited by dorking (08 Nov 2021 2.09pm)

selhurststation.JPG Attachment: selhurststation.JPG (93.89Kb)

 

dorking Flag 08 Nov 21 2.10pm

Back in the day


Edited by dorking (08 Nov 2021 2.10pm)

Edited by dorking (08 Nov 2021 2.10pm)

selhurst1920.GIF Attachment: selhurst1920.GIF (109.59Kb)

 

trapperjohn Flag Horsham 08 Nov 21 3.56pm

Originally posted by dorking

I don't know why they don't just open the massive gate post-match (shown with a red X on the photo below)

Surely it must date back to when CPFC played at the Nest? (which was bang opposite the station)

Edited by dorking (08 Nov 2021 2.09pm)

I agree totally and as the barriers in the booking hall are left open anyway, it is not as if they are checking tickets. There are points there to tap in for Oyster or similar.and there is loads of room on the platforms if the staff that they do have up there just encourage people to move down.

 


I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.

trapperjohn Flag Horsham 08 Nov 21 3.58pm

Originally posted by dorking

Back in the day


Edited by dorking (08 Nov 2021 2.10pm)

Edited by dorking (08 Nov 2021 2.10pm)

Great pic and especially interesting to see the trolley bus power lines overhead. Now surely they were “green”

 


I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.

gerry theagle Flag newbury 08 Nov 21 4.13pm

Have to agree with all that has been said, it was awful on Saturday after the match.Southern Railway need to do something to remedy this problem and quick before someone gets injured or worse.
The staffing at the Station is totally inadequate and why the large padlocked road entrance gate to the station cannot be unlocked only Southern know.
Will be contacting them shortly.

 

Barcelona Based Fan Flag No longer Barcelona, now living in... 08 Nov 21 4.27pm

Originally posted by gerry theagle

Have to agree with all that has been said, it was awful on Saturday after the match.Southern Railway need to do something to remedy this problem and quick before someone gets injured or worse.
The staffing at the Station is totally inadequate and why the large padlocked road entrance gate to the station cannot be unlocked only Southern know.
Will be contacting them shortly.

Total joke,Opening the gate is the best solution, that bottle neck back down the alleyway is madness when it meets the others queuing up on the pavement!

Well done, hopefully you'll get a reply

Edited by Barcelona Based Fan (08 Nov 2021 4.28pm)

 


TaxiMark
Sheffield Wednesday Fan
Posted 23 February 2013 - 07:49 PM
I don't mind palace to be fair. Much better club than tinpot Charlton and Brighton

gerry theagle Flag newbury 08 Nov 21 4.46pm

Thanks BBF they now have my email detailing the facts.I have suggested that Southern send members of their Safety Department to the station for the next home match on the 27th November between 16.45 and 17.30 to see the problem first hand. But I'm not holding my breath.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 08 Nov 21 5.35pm

Originally posted by gerry theagle

Thanks BBF they now have my email detailing the facts.I have suggested that Southern send members of their Safety Department to the station for the next home match on the 27th November between 16.45 and 17.30 to see the problem first hand. But I'm not holding my breath.

Good luck with that. Our local station toilet has been out of use for weeks as it is blocked. Apparently they have never heard of plumbers.

 


One more point

trapperjohn Flag Horsham 08 Nov 21 5.41pm

Originally posted by gerry theagle

Thanks BBF they now have my email detailing the facts.I have suggested that Southern send members of their Safety Department to the station for the next home match on the 27th November between 16.45 and 17.30 to see the problem first hand. But I'm not holding my breath.

Gerry, might it be worth copying in the club . Phil Alexander? As I mentioned originally it must have a potential impact on the new stand and increased capacity.

And in that connection One way to increase travel capacity from Norwood Junction is to stop the 12 carriage Thameslink trains at NJ on a Saturday.

 


I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.

gerry theagle Flag newbury 08 Nov 21 6.55pm

Unfortunately can't send Palace exactly what I said to Southern as it was on one of their fill in the boxes complaint forms,have had an automated reply to confirm that they have received it.
Will phone the club tomorrow and try to speak to someone with more clout than myself, hopefully Palace are just as concerned about the safety of the fans getting to and from the ground not just inside it.

 

trapperjohn Flag Horsham 08 Nov 21 7.23pm

Originally posted by gerry theagle

Unfortunately can't send Palace exactly what I said to Southern as it was on one of their fill in the boxes complaint forms,have had an automated reply to confirm that they have received it.
Will phone the club tomorrow and try to speak to someone with more clout than myself, hopefully Palace are just as concerned about the safety of the fans getting to and from the ground not just inside it.

I am obviously happy to chip in as well if that will help.

 


I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 09 Nov 21 3.50pm

Originally posted by gerry theagle

Unfortunately can't send Palace exactly what I said to Southern as it was on one of their fill in the boxes complaint forms,have had an automated reply to confirm that they have received it.
Will phone the club tomorrow and try to speak to someone with more clout than myself, hopefully Palace are just as concerned about the safety of the fans getting to and from the ground not just inside it.

Unfortunately I don't share your optimism on that.

But it may well be worth contacting the ORR (Office of Rail and Road), which is responsible for safety. They have a website, with instructions on how to get in touch with them, under various headings, including Health and Safety.

 

HeathMan Flag Purley 10 Nov 21 8.47am

There is a lot happening in the background on this,

 

trapperjohn Flag Horsham 10 Nov 21 8.53am

Originally posted by HeathMan

There is a lot happening in the background on this,

Do tell

 


I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 10 Nov 21 11.15am

Its worth considering the angle coming from them
Its a small station at the end of the day, only really busy on football days.

There were crushing situations where two streams of queues came together in the ticket area or when side door was open.
Remember crushing at hillsborough, lesson were learned, people at the back keep pushing, crushing and killing the ones at front, coming from several areas.

I have come from the side path and been well and truly crushed at Selhurst ticket area, so much so I now use Norward Junction to go home. Plus tight queues, pickpocket heaven!! If Selhurst had a back entrance, like Norwood, then the situation is improved.

Therefore having the one queue forming into the ticket office area at Selhurst to prevent two queues crushing will go on... allow time, safety considerations with the present access to the bottom of the platforms, will need to be there without fail...
Selhurst is what it is.. old.... like our club 1861!!!

 

trapperjohn Flag Horsham 10 Nov 21 4.27pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

Its worth considering the angle coming from them
Its a small station at the end of the day, only really busy on football days.

There were crushing situations where two streams of queues came together in the ticket area or when side door was open.
Remember crushing at hillsborough, lesson were learned, people at the back keep pushing, crushing and killing the ones at front, coming from several areas.

I have come from the side path and been well and truly crushed at Selhurst ticket area, so much so I now use Norward Junction to go home. Plus tight queues, pickpocket heaven!! If Selhurst had a back entrance, like Norwood, then the situation is improved.

Therefore having the one queue forming into the ticket office area at Selhurst to prevent two queues crushing will go on... allow time, safety considerations with the present access to the bottom of the platforms, will need to be there without fail...
Selhurst is what it is.. old.... like our club 1861!!!

If that is indeed their view then I think it is misconceived on a number of points.

It is always busy on a match day and they have to deal with that. We are their customers. They know when the matches are scheduled and could easily plan for the necessary staffing and access as suggested earlier through the gates highlighted in a previous post.

Plus I have occasionally been in a crush at Selhurst but firstly: Pre COVID I could have a drink in the RednBlue bar, make my way down at 5:15 and walk straight in for a 5:30 train. Now you hit a 100 yard queue. People will start to get nasty when they miss a train and there is not another one for an hour. Or is their view that as football fans we should leave the game early?

Secondly But more importantly the crush is now alongside a busy road which is far more dangerous.

Thirdly it actively blocks the pavement for other pedestrians of whom there seemed to be several who were very unhappy at having to walk in the road and it renders the bus stop unusable. That will create a negative reaction to CPFC

As I have mentioned the crush still exists but is now of far longer duration which must increase the dangers you refer to.

Finally I have been equally caught in a crush at NJ ( one time after a Sunderland game was particularly memorable). At least there the crush is off the main road. I have also been marooned on the platform at NJ because Southern decided to run just a four coach train southbound that gets crammed full to the point where nobody else can get on. So I don’t think that is an answer. A great increase in numbers at Norwood will hardly help matters there.

Finally will the club get beaten over the head with the “lack”of infrastructure argument as a reason not to allow the new stand?

 


I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.

deleted 25 Flag 12 Nov 21 6.40pm

Think after the Brighton game fans that were travelling on East Grinstead line had to get cabs from East Croydon due to reduced service and delays getting into Selhurst ;

some fans got a replacement bus onwards from Oxted, but others had to wait for about an hour to get a bus to Edenbridge

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Selhurst station chaos