You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pick a Striker and stick
November 16 2026 4.12am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pick a Striker and stick


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
leejaneagles Flag 20 Feb 22 5.22pm

I think Vieira is getting a lot right but his insistence on mixing up the central Striker postion game to game is madness and stopping any chance of us getting a 10-15 goal a season Striker in form.

From what I’ve seen, I’m not going to be unrealistic and say there’s a 20 goal striker in our ranks but I definitely think Mateta or Edouard can score consistently once every 2-3 games to keep a steady stream of goals coming in if given the chance.

I’m of the opinion Mateta is our best out and out Striker but a lot think he’s useless and Edouard because he’s more skilful Is the way to go. Id be happy with either given a proper shot.

Strikers thrive on confidence and consistency more so than any other position. If we start one of them 2 games in a row you can see they are playing with the thought “if I don’t score by the 75th minute I’m getting swapped for the other or Benteke”.

It’s even more frustrating when we wasted about 3 seasons trying to play Benteke into form when it was clear he never would. I’m not asking for that but Vieira needs to tell whichever one he prefers ‘you have the rest of this season as main no.9.’ By the end of the season get rid if they’ve not done anything. But we will never know if we keep benching Strikers and giving Zaha a Striker position just to appease his ego.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 20 Feb 22 5.29pm

Good post. What’s the worst that can happen, we’re not scoring now anyway.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 20 Feb 22 5.40pm

There seems to be no logical explanation to team selection. Why would anyone put Schlupp in as a central midfielder? Who thought it a good idea to play Zaha as centre forward when 3 are sitting on the bench? Is Ayew a winger? Does Vieira know what he's doing? Recently I've started to doubt.
Choose the system you want to play and pick the players that fit that system, no square pegs in rounds holes. Some egos might be hurt, nevermind.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Feb 22 10.01pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

There seems to be no logical explanation to team selection. Why would anyone put Schlupp in as a central midfielder? Who thought it a good idea to play Zaha as centre forward when 3 are sitting on the bench? Is Ayew a winger? Does Vieira know what he's doing? Recently I've started to doubt.
Choose the system you want to play and pick the players that fit that system, no square pegs in rounds holes. Some egos might be hurt, nevermind.


I got the impression from his post match interviews that this was a one-off to stifle Chelsea, which, tbf, with the 4-2-3-1 system (well that's how it seemed we wet up) we did for much of the game. However, I have to agree with your point about Schlupp and also with the OP's comments about the need to give strikers a decent run to enable them to gain the confidence needed to score goals, and especially in this league.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 20 Feb 22 11.30pm

Agree. If we're going to play the ball on the ground, commit to Eduoard and back him. I'm sure he'll score.

If we're going to actually deliver crosses into the box, play Benteke. I'm sure he'll score.

Mateta isn't the answer.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Feb 22 11.43pm

Originally posted by sprites

Agree. If we're going to play the ball on the ground, commit to Eduoard and back him. I'm sure he'll score.

If we're going to actually deliver crosses into the box, play Benteke. I'm sure he'll score.

Mateta isn't the answer.

Benteke needs good service from wide areas and Olise with his excellent delivery is effective in this respect down the wide right, but Ayew has been played in this position due to his workrate and defensive responsibilities.

 

Wilbraham413 Flag 21 Feb 22 2.51am

I agree PV needs to pick a striker, any striker, and play him for at least 2-3 matches in a row.

What I don't understand is we've had Benteke for ages, who has never lived up to expectations. So PV goes out and spends big to get Edouard. Then he spends big to keep Mateta. Then he leaves all three strikers on the bench, and plays Wilf as the striker. I mean, WTF is up with that??

If he doesn't rate Benteke, Edouard, or Mateta, which I don't blame him, then please sell them all this summer, and try 3 new strikers.

Every other PL club, even Norwich, has a decent striker, and we haven't had one since Murray left 20 years ago. It's beyond ridiculous at this point.

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

The Dolphin Flag 21 Feb 22 7.18am

I agree!
With Wilf on the left and Olise on the right.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 21 Feb 22 7.42am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

I agree PV needs to pick a striker, any striker, and play him for at least 2-3 matches in a row.

What I don't understand is we've had Benteke for ages, who has never lived up to expectations. So PV goes out and spends big to get Edouard. Then he spends big to keep Mateta. Then he leaves all three strikers on the bench, and plays Wilf as the striker. I mean, WTF is up with that??

If he doesn't rate Benteke, Edouard, or Mateta, which I don't blame him, then please sell them all this summer, and try 3 new strikers.

Every other PL club, even Norwich, has a decent striker, and we haven't had one since Murray left 20 years ago. It's beyond ridiculous at this point.

Your right it is hard to understand, Edouard was a bit of a gamble never having played in any of the top leagues, but he has seen Mateta train everyday, and seen him play a lot of games, either 1. he rates him but doesn't think he is ready, 2, The deal wasn't what was said and we had to sign him, or 3, Parish/Freedman has gone over his head, Wilf and Olise will always be used as inverted wingers so what you say is right sell Edouard while he still has a value, give Benteke away on a free so someone may take him a buy someone else, maybe Plange is better than we know?

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

southnorwoodhill Flag 21 Feb 22 8.33am

Please do stop mentioning Benteke as some kind of solution, his record is out there for all to see, and for a striker it's appalling. He stopped the club from moving on in this area, because his initial cost and salary, the club couldn't throw that sort of money at a replacement; he became irreplaceable. No other club wanted him (hardly a suprise given his salary and lack of goals) and so we were stuck. To compound the disaster, after a few half decent games knowing his contract was due to expire, rather incredibly the club gave him new one! Live and learn, eh?
Be thankful Ayew came in for a bargain £2m and totally outperformed Benteke during his stint up front during the 2019/20 season, scoring 9 crucial goals and becoming POTY.
As for Eduoard and Mateta, one would have thought that the club did all the due diligence necessary, liked what it saw, liked the price, and took the plunge. Vieira sees them everyday in training, and they have scored this season, so why he should think that Zaha should be some kind of solution is a complete mystery.
My personal opinion is that the confusion with Vieira's team selection and substitions, is a reflection of his confused thinking as how to proceed in the latter half of the season. How could it be otherwise?
As the original poster suggests, get a grip, make up your mind, stick to a team the fits the plan with the right players for the task, stop tinkering.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (21 Feb 2022 8.34am)

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 21 Feb 22 8.44am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Please do stop mentioning Benteke as some kind of solution, his record is out there for all to see, and for a striker it's appalling. He stopped the club from moving on in this area, because his initial cost and salary, the club couldn't throw that sort of money at a replacement; he became irreplaceable. No other club wanted him (hardly a suprise given his salary and lack of goals) and so we were stuck. To compound the disaster, after a few half decent games knowing his contract was due to expire, rather incredibly the club gave him new one! Live and learn, eh?
Be thankful Ayew came in for a bargain £2m and totally outperformed Benteke during his stint up front during the 2019/20 season, scoring 9 crucial goals and becoming POTY.
As for Eduoard and Mateta, one would have thought that the club did all the due diligence necessary, liked what it saw, liked the price, and took the plunge. Vieira sees them everyday in training, and they have scored this season, so why he should think that Zaha should be some kind of solution is a complete mystery.
My personal opinion is that the confusion with Vieira's team selection and substitions, is a reflection of his confused thinking as how to proceed in the latter half of the season. How could it be otherwise?
As the original poster suggests, get a grip, make up your mind, stick to a team the fits the plan with the right players for the task, stop tinkering.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (21 Feb 2022 8.34am)

[Link]
This article posted on ‘what is our best team’ may be relevant

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 21 Feb 22 8.56am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

[Link]
This article posted on ‘what is our best team’ may be relevant

Thanks. The article further compounds my recent thoughts on Vieira, based on his team selection and substitutions, which, as I mention above, send out mixed messages about what he wants and how to achieve it. At this stage of the season every effort must be focused on maintaining our PL status - No dithering, no tinkering.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 21 Feb 22 9.05am

Lets not take Viera not playing a striker against Chelsea as though he has lost the plot.

They are very good, we played pretty well, and had we been more clinical might have won it.

The formation and team selection looked right for how we tried to play

 

PatrickA Flag London 21 Feb 22 9.08am

Interesting article about the lack of clarity in Vieira’s football philosophy at Nice.
I’m not sure it’s strictly relevant to his time at Palace so far.
From the outset he made it clear that he was going to play 433 and he has not really tinkered with this formation apart from last Saturday and in occasional spells in other games when he has used two up front.
Where there appears to be a lack of clarity of thought is in the front 3, in particular the striker role.
You can kind of understand the ‘horses for courses’ selection of either Ayew or Olise in the right side position depending upon who we are playing.
Zaha has occupied the left side position for some time and it would be a brave call to leave him out, even though his form on occasions may warrant his exclusion.
That leaves the central position.
For the moment Benteke seems to have been discarded as an option, even not being used as an option from the bench.
Mateta mysteriously went from being on the verge of being sold to becoming seemingly first choice in a matter of weeks.
Edouard started in a blaze of optimism but does not seem trusted in the central role and has looked more effective drifting in from the left.
There definitely appears to be confused thinking from Vieira here.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 21 Feb 22 9.12am

Originally posted by sprites

Agree. If we're going to play the ball on the ground, commit to Eduoard and back him. I'm sure he'll score.

If we're going to actually deliver crosses into the box, play Benteke. I'm sure he'll score.

Mateta isn't the answer.

If Olise plays I'd like to see Benteke given a go, MO does put a lot of crossed in the box. All 3 forwards have differet attributes, for me OE is the best of the lot but has struggled with the central striker role. He was ok against Brentford.

 

beak Flag croydon 21 Feb 22 9.14am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Interesting article about the lack of clarity in Vieira’s football philosophy at Nice.
I’m not sure it’s strictly relevant to his time at Palace so far.
From the outset he made it clear that he was going to play 433 and he has not really tinkered with this formation apart from last Saturday and in occasional spells in other games when he has used two up front.
Where there appears to be a lack of clarity of thought is in the front 3, in particular the striker role.
You can kind of understand the ‘horses for courses’ selection of either Ayew or Olise in the right side position depending upon who we are playing.
Zaha has occupied the left side position for some time and it would be a brave call to leave him out, even though his form on occasions may warrant his exclusion.
That leaves the central position.
For the moment Benteke seems to have been discarded as an option, even not being used as an option from the bench.
Mateta mysteriously went from being on the verge of being sold to becoming seemingly first choice in a matter of weeks.
Edouard started in a blaze of optimism but does not seem trusted in the central role and has looked more effective drifting in from the left.
There definitely appears to be confused thinking from Vieira here.


Vieira is under a lot of pressure, as a player he coped very well,oddly he doesn't seem to cope so well as a manager.I think we are heading for trouble. Other teams in the bottom half are playing great football,we are all over the place.

 

The Dolphin Flag 21 Feb 22 9.20am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Lets not take Viera not playing a striker against Chelsea as though he has lost the plot.

They are very good, we played pretty well, and had we been more clinical might have won it.

The formation and team selection looked right for how we tried to play

Spot on!

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 21 Feb 22 2.58pm

Originally posted by beak

....Other teams in the bottom half are playing great football,we are all over the place.

All over the place? Really?
We lose by a last-minute goal to the European and world club champions, and we're 'all over the place'?

With all due respect I think you're bonkers.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 21 Feb 22 3.57pm

Originally posted by beak


Vieira is under a lot of pressure, as a player he coped very well,oddly he doesn't seem to cope so well as a manager.I think we are heading for trouble. Other teams in the bottom half are playing great football,we are all over the place.

Based on what?!

 

est1905 Flag 21 Feb 22 5.06pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

I think Vieira is getting a lot right but his insistence on mixing up the central Striker postion game to game is madness and stopping any chance of us getting a 10-15 goal a season Striker in form.

From what I’ve seen, I’m not going to be unrealistic and say there’s a 20 goal striker in our ranks but I definitely think Mateta or Edouard can score consistently once every 2-3 games to keep a steady stream of goals coming in if given the chance.

I’m of the opinion Mateta is our best out and out Striker but a lot think he’s useless and Edouard because he’s more skilful Is the way to go. Id be happy with either given a proper shot.

Strikers thrive on confidence and consistency more so than any other position. If we start one of them 2 games in a row you can see they are playing with the thought “if I don’t score by the 75th minute I’m getting swapped for the other or Benteke”.

It’s even more frustrating when we wasted about 3 seasons trying to play Benteke into form when it was clear he never would. I’m not asking for that but Vieira needs to tell whichever one he prefers ‘you have the rest of this season as main no.9.’ By the end of the season get rid if they’ve not done anything. But we will never know if we keep benching Strikers and giving Zaha a Striker position just to appease his ego.

Agree, been saying this for a while. Personally I dont care between Mateta or Edouard. Just pick one and give him a run of 8/10 games to see what he can do.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pick a Striker and stick