You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Strikers
November 16 2026 4.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Strikers


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 26 May 22 2.23pm

Nothing like a good debate, so here's hoping I can start one:

There’s been talk on this site that we need to upgrade our strikers. But is there actually a need and if so, how great is it?

We simply don’t have the kind of money that would enable us to buy a proven 15 goal a season PL striker (never mind a 20 goal a season one). We are shopping in the lower leagues and less fashionable clubs overseas.

In last summer’s transfer window, there was talk of our getting Adam Armstrong from Blackburn. Southampton outbid us (£15.93m according to Transfermarkt - the figures quoted below are also from that site) and he’s basically been a nonentity there (3 goals and 3 assists in the PL). He spent most of the second half of the season on the bench.

Mitrovic at Fulham has scored some 70 goals over his last 2 Championship seasons but managed just 14 in his last 2 Premier league ones.

Basically, the gulf between the Championship and the Premier League can be massive for central strikers.

We bought Edouard and Mateta from other countries’ leagues for £14.69m and £9.9m respectively. They’ve scored 11 PL goals between them at the rate of a goal every 247 minutes. That equates to 14 goals over a full season which for a team like Palace is an OK return. Both players are 24 and IMHO will improve as they gain more PL experience (Mateta has already improved significantly since those early days under Hodgson).

I’m happy for us to keep them both and see what they can do next year and so for me, at least, there’s no urgent need to upgrade our strikers.

Over to you all!

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 26 May 22 2.42pm

Mateta got 1 goal every 227 minutes last season and was a general pest.

Give him Salah's minutes and he'd have 12. Give him Wilf's pens, he'd have 17. (Yes yes, I know...ifs and buts)

He's big, strong, quick, okay on the ground, and plays with a smile on his face. He also gets in behind teams which is a real rarity these days. Or has been for us. He also makes a good effort to press.

If he improves a nudge, we could have a real talent on our hands.

Strikers just need to think they are special and believed in. Trusted. Being a striker for us is never going to be easy.

I hope he's the main man.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

trevortheeagle Flag 26 May 22 2.43pm

Very good points, well made.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 26 May 22 2.49pm

Also, just look at the too scorers outside the big clubs. Then remove those who don't take penalties. It's incredible how low the tallies get.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Fatherken Flag 26 May 22 2.52pm

Both Edouard and Meteta are not premiership standard strikers and should be replaced . Out of the two , if we had to keep one it would be Edouard .

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 26 May 22 2.58pm

Well, I'm sure you'll fire a few people up with this topic doombear.

I happen to agree with you about Edouard and Mateta. Neither have set the world alight, but with our limited budget they have given us a reasonable return and both have time on their side. More game time next season will give them both an opportunity, with guidance from PV, to develop further.

If Wilf stays and Olise and Eze remain injury free, we have some pretty good, proven scorers at our disposal.

As always, I guess we rely on Dougie and team to work their magic by bringing in appropriate replacements.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 26 May 22 3.02pm

Originally posted by Fatherken

Both Edouard and Meteta are not premiership standard strikers and should be replaced . Out of the two , if we had to keep one it would be Edouard .

sheesh, give them a chance.
1 year to integrate into a new club, team and Country isn't really that much.

I wasn't a Mateta fan when we signed him, but he has improved no end this year. He's learned to play with the team and is looking much more settled. He'll be our first choice at the beginning of the season - and it'll be down to Edouard to dislodge him.
A third option wouldn't go a miss.

There aren't many PremierLeague standard strikers outside the premierleague ready to go, you need to buy someone with potential and bring them up to speed.


 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Croydon-Trucker Flag 26 May 22 3.38pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Well, I'm sure you'll fire a few people up with this topic doombear.

I happen to agree with you about Edouard and Mateta. Neither have set the world alight, but with our limited budget they have given us a reasonable return and both have time on their side. More game time next season will give them both an opportunity, with guidance from PV, to develop further.

If Wilf stays and Olise and Eze remain injury free, we have some pretty good, proven scorers at our disposal.

As always, I guess we rely on Dougie and team to work their magic by bringing in appropriate replacements.

Hi OP , I do agree with you on the Mateta not being good enough but i do think Edouard is ! I also think he did a good job filling in for Wilf when he was injured/banned . We also have a striker from Derby on the way Plange i think his name is we bought him and loaned him back in the last window . Dont know much about him though .

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 26 May 22 3.43pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Also, just look at the too scorers outside the big clubs. Then remove those who don't take penalties. It's incredible how low the tallies get.

This, with bloody bells on.

People go on about 20-goal strikers like they're commonplace and every club has one.

How many times have we had a player hit 20 goals in the last 20 years? AJ & Murray... I think that's it.

If Mateta can hit 10-12 goals a season from open play (and his form this season suggests that's possible), that's a very decent output for a forward at our level

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 26 May 22 3.48pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

This, with bloody bells on.

People go on about 20-goal strikers like they're commonplace and every club has one.

How many times have we had a player hit 20 goals in the last 20 years? AJ & Murray... I think that's it.

If Mateta can hit 10-12 goals a season from open play (and his form this season suggests that's possible), that's a very decent output for a forward at our level

I agree with your agreement lol

Look at the list!!!

[Link]

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 26 May 22 3.51pm

Unless Benteke goes, I don't actually think we need a striker. Even then it would be rotation/backup.

Édouard should be given time to improve. Zaha will become a striker. Mateta will improve a bit with experience.

Reinvigorating midfield and RB is more important, and maybe in goal too. Eze has looked good in the past few weeks, so getting him and Olise to where we hope they can get to would give us as many options as buying a centre forward would do. The game is way more fluid these days, and teams are less reliant on a target man anyway.

Ultimately it depends on what we have to spend and who is available, but striker is not where I would see the most urgent need to invest. Replacing Gallagher and the ageing midfield is more important.

 

pssguy Flag 26 May 22 4.45pm

I agree this is not the priority. We should have six players Zaha, Olise, Mateta, Edouard, Ayew, Benteke+ Rak-Sakyi/Plange that can play in the advanced three positions. With more subs allowed 1 or 2 should be regularly playing the final third of games

Gallagher's replacement; youngish back-ups at central defender and goalkeeper would be higher on my list

Here's hoping we can make some noise in the cup competitions and qualify for Europe so we can sustain a bigger, quality squad

Edited by pssguy (26 May 2022 4.46pm)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 26 May 22 5.08pm

It can all be boiled down to the simplicity of:

1. To do well in league, win cups etc. you need to win games
2. To win games you need to score goals, more than the opponent.
3. To score goals you need a good striker
4. There must be some hidden gem out there that we should be able to find and therefore buy for under £20 million and all will be OK with the world as they'll knock in 50 a season.

Unfortunately the world does not work like that.

Far from the OP (I forgotseded who?) being controversial I think the original post was very good. I myself often fall victim to the thought pattern demonstrated above. Asides from Kane, Haaland, Mbappe and a veteran Lewandowski I fail to see many forwards in the game who'd guarantee goals.

Again, very good OP and if funds are available I'd like some additions/reinforcement in midfield and maybe a new RB please. AWB is a romantic thought but I actually thought Clyne was getting back to top level past few months and again, unless we have a sure bet gem, I'm happy to wait another season if necessary.

Guaita

Clyne - Anderson - Guehi - Mitchell

New player, Hughes/Kouyate/McArthur

Gallagher replacement/Eze

Olise Mateta Zaha

Butland
New, promising CB perhaps?
Ward (a new and improved one for me, looks better and better)
One of those mentioned above
JMac/replacement/One of those mentioned above
Schlupp
Ayew/new winger perhaps... or preferably
Edouard
I've forgotten how many will be on subs bench next season

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Uphill Flag Bedford 26 May 22 5.20pm

Originally posted by Qwijibo

Unless Benteke goes, I don't actually think we need a striker. Even then it would be rotation/backup.

Édouard should be given time to improve. Zaha will become a striker. Mateta will improve a bit with experience.

Reinvigorating midfield and RB is more important, and maybe in goal too. Eze has looked good in the past few weeks, so getting him and Olise to where we hope they can get to would give us as many options as buying a centre forward would do. The game is way more fluid these days, and teams are less reliant on a target man anyway.

Ultimately it depends on what we have to spend and who is available, but striker is not where I would see the most urgent need to invest. Replacing Gallagher and the ageing midfield is more important.

I am in full agreement.
Mateta is a 'worker' but lacks skills whereas Edouard is more skilful and moves better and should be given a chance - but we desperately need a more creative midfield. Kouyate, Luka can't pass creatively. Hughes is better and McArthur works his socks off but none of these can be called a 'midfield general'

I genuinely believe that Christian Eriksen could be the answer.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 26 May 22 5.38pm

Mateta is the best we have at the moment, Edouard has to improve a lot to be even as good as Mateta, Benteke is total rubbish, Plange we dont know about yet.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 26 May 22 5.40pm

Maybe its easier to by a right footed left winger and play wilf as CF

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 26 May 22 6.01pm

Our manager has said we need to improve in our decision making in the final third and take the chances we create. This is a nudge to the players that they are not producing. Unless they improve the manager will be wanting new strikers. I suspect he has his doubts about them.COYP

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 26 May 22 6.21pm

Chances are created, in the main, from midfield. We don't need at this moment to change the strike force. We need to upgrade our midfield players, particularly with Gallagher going. Also getting numbers into the box when we attack, another thing that Gallagher added with his energetic play.
I'd expect to see another hard working box to box midfield general player come in, to complement Eze's natural ability.
Schlupp, Kouyate, Hughes, don't have it in them. McArthur will probably be a bit part player, Jairo will probably leave so the midfield is an area where we need investment, not the forward line.

 

Robk Flag 26 May 22 6.52pm

JP Mateta should certainly be given more time.. he’s improved significantly under Viera and that’s only the start.. think he will continue to improve.. he’ll definitely score more goals.. his pressing is really good... I think Luke Plange is a completely different sort of player who’ll probably play off Mateta... Edouard is also a completely different again... we have a great mix...

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 26 May 22 8.12pm

A lot of sense getting spoken today!

The strikers are decent, not top draw but decent.

Being the size club we are, we cant afford to buy the finished article. We have to find these 15m players and take a bit of a gamble.

JPM looked like a gamble to fair, but has now come good. OE started great, but has gone off the boil.

But as someone else stated, its only really the top couple of clubs that have superstar strikers. And our attacking unit is really strong.

If the goals are spread amongst the team, the role of the front man isn't so focused on scoring.


Take West Ham for example, they only really have Antonio up front, and he hardly ever scores.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Strikers