You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Scottish Indy Ref October 2023.
November 21 2026 9.56pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Scottish Indy Ref October 2023.


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Matov Flag 28 Jun 22 6.52pm

I see our favourite Krankie is shooting her mouth off again.

I smell a rat. She knows it will get knocked back by our legal system (referendums require an act of Parliament) but can then proclaim that they are stymied by it. Already voicing off that if it is given the thumbs down then the SNP will only campaign on Independence come the next election.

Because let's be honest, what else can they campaign on? The increase in drug deaths under their malign rule?

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

nead1 Flag 28 Jun 22 7.06pm

What she is actually talking about is a "consultative referendum" which she hopes the Supreme Court will authorise given the refusal of the UK government to approve a formal vote.

In my view, many people living in Scotland will simply ignore any consultative vote; however, it will no doubt further her narrative of an unreasonable UK government going against the "will of the Scottish people" as Blackford so often refers to it!

Net net, it is just the constant drip feed of resentment that the SNP are so good at; as you say if they got a grip of the drug situation in Scotland and so many other social/economic issues everyone would be better off rather than campaigning endlessly for something that the majority of Scottish people don't even want want according to most polls.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 28 Jun 22 7.17pm

The break-up of the union is logical and inevitable, especially after brexit when they all voted to remain.

But it won't happen with Nicola Sturgeon.

She should resign she is only delivering Scotland to the tories.

There are only a handful of tory MPs left in Scotland, and they have all rebelled against Johnson.

The tory supreme court is hardly likely to rule in her favour.

These countries do not need Westminster at all, in fact England would be better off without it as well.

 

Behind Enemy Lines Flag Sussex 28 Jun 22 7.23pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

The break-up of the union is logical and inevitable, especially after brexit when they all voted to remain.

But it won't happen with Nicola Sturgeon.

She should resign she is only delivering Scotland to the tories.

There are only a handful of tory MPs left in Scotland, and they have all rebelled against Johnson.

The tory supreme court is hardly likely to rule in her favour.

These countries do not need Westminster at all, in fact England would be better off without it as well.

The best way for the SNP to get the independence it craves? Put up candidates in England for election. There must be enough people fed up with their constant moaning that would encourage the rest of us to be rid of them by voting them in!! Lol!

 


hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 28 Jun 22 9.28pm

Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines

The best way for the SNP to get the independence it craves? Put up candidates in England for election. There must be enough people fed up with their constant moaning that would encourage the rest of us to be rid of them by voting them in!! Lol!

Now that's a party I would vote for.

 


One more point

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 29 Jun 22 6.47am

Her politics on a referendum seems to be based on "If you roll the dice enough times, eventually you'll get a double-six".
She should concentrate on reducing alcohol/drugs deaths and getting people off benefits i.e. Home Politics.

It's as though she is forever blaming any of Scotland's fck-ups on being part of The Union. And i doubt the EU want another net-taker drinking from the pot.

Take away the military bases and there would be a massive decline in some areas. Not much mention of getting rid of the military, now that Ukraine is kicking-off ?

With every call for another referendum, she becomes further marginalised from the electorate. Go on biatch. Prove me wrong

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Jun 22 7.58am

It's quite a canny move on her part to take it to the Supreme Court. When they reject it she can then tell the Scots that they get no justice from UK law or Parliament.

One thing I do agree on is at the next GE the SNP should only have one item in their manifesto a vote for them is a vote for independence, If they get a 50% majority then they should get their referendum.

All that said the SNP has made a shocking mess of Scotland since they have been in charge. She says they are hindered by the UK but in what way? They have control over most things except foreign policy and defence. The things that really matter to most people, housing, health and education they have made worse.

I wonder if the worse thing that could happen to the SNP is to win, then what? Free from the "blame the English for everything" mantra their appalling domestic record would be under scrutiny.

The other thing is that there is only one flavour of independence available, theirs. I know plenty of Scots who want to be independent but don't like what they are offering.

 


One more point

YT Flag Oxford 29 Jun 22 8.37am

Originally posted by Badger11

It's quite a canny move on her part to take it to the Supreme Court. When they reject it she can then tell the Scots that they get no justice from UK law or Parliament.

One thing I do agree on is at the next GE the SNP should only have one item in their manifesto a vote for them is a vote for independence, If they get a 50% majority then they should get their referendum.

All that said the SNP has made a shocking mess of Scotland since they have been in charge. She says they are hindered by the UK but in what way? They have control over most things except foreign policy and defence. The things that really matter to most people, housing, health and education they have made worse.

I wonder if the worse thing that could happen to the SNP is to win, then what? Free from the "blame the English for everything" mantra their appalling domestic record would be under scrutiny.

The other thing is that there is only one flavour of independence available, theirs. I know plenty of Scots who want to be independent but don't like what they are offering.

Ah! It'll be Brexit all over again then, with perennial arguments about which independence people did or didn't vote for.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Matov Flag 29 Jun 22 10.00am

Originally posted by YT

Ah! It'll be Brexit all over again then, with perennial arguments about which independence people did or didn't vote for.


If Scotland does vote to leave then I suspect it will potentially be far worse than that. That sectarian stuff will really come into play up there in a BIG way. Will be bloody nasty.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Matov Flag 29 Jun 22 10.02am

Originally posted by YT

Ah! It'll be Brexit all over again then, with perennial arguments about which independence people did or didn't vote for.


If Scotland does vote to leave then I suspect it will potentially be far worse than that. That sectarian stuff will really come into play up there in a BIG way. Will be bloody nasty.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 29 Jun 22 12.15pm

As any Irish person knows, just have a referendum until you get the correct result. I think we had two on Nice and two on Maastricht. My memory could be wrong. Could be three on one of them. They barely even waited. It wasn't hidden - a "No" vote was unacceptable and delusional, no votes were no longer required. I was struck off of the register without being informed, as were many others.

 


Red and Blue Army!

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 29 Jun 22 2.42pm

To be fair ,the SNP is only existing because of the independence issue- so thats her job to push for it, again and again. And after all, they only want FREEDOM-something we all know about only to well!

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 29 Jun 22 2.53pm

It looks inevitable doesn't it? But a no this time has to put it to bed.

 


Red and Blue Army!

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 29 Jun 22 3.10pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

It looks inevitable doesn't it? But a no this time has to put it to bed.

You can"t blame them if they watch our gov spokesmen on tv defending bungle- it"s enough to make anyone want out!

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 29 Jun 22 3.45pm

Originally posted by croydon proud

You can"t blame them if they watch our gov spokesmen on tv defending bungle- it"s enough to make anyone want out!

Therein lies the problem. Scotland could vote out in a protest vote over the current situation, rather than any long term reality for their own country.
The kind of independence the SNP want would probably take 50-100 years before establishing much - depends on how much they get subsidised by UK and EU.
Major issues: North Sea Oil, Military and defence - particularly RAF and Navy, the EU and immigration, exports, imports. Not quite as straight forward as colouring book geographers in the SNP would like. And there will certainly be boundary issues too. I'm guessing they want Berwick back - they all want their kilts and eat it.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Jun 22 4.36pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Therein lies the problem. Scotland could vote out in a protest vote over the current situation, rather than any long term reality for their own country.
The kind of independence the SNP want would probably take 50-100 years before establishing much - depends on how much they get subsidised by UK and EU.
Major issues: North Sea Oil, Military and defence - particularly RAF and Navy, the EU and immigration, exports, imports. Not quite as straight forward as colouring book geographers in the SNP would like. And there will certainly be boundary issues too. I'm guessing they want Berwick back - they all want their kilts and eat it.

Immigration will be an issue. The SNP favour a significant population increase quite how the locals will feel if this happens remains to be seen.

However the issue is that the UK will not allow Scotland to become a back door for immigrants flying into Scotland and then jumping on a train to London. How then does the UK stop that? A hard border?

We also have the problem of Scots moving freely from the Auld country to work in the UK, why should they get preference over others?

I can see an EU residency style registration process in the UK after which the Scots will be on a par with the rest of the world. I can see many Scots giving it the braveheart in the pub whilst hanging onto to their UK passport to get round this.

 


One more point

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Jun 22 4.50pm

Originally posted by croydon proud

You can"t blame them if they watch our gov spokesmen on tv defending bungle- it"s enough to make anyone want out!

Will they be able to survive without Westminster funding? Presumably all funding will be removed, hopefully!

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Jun 22 4.52pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Immigration will be an issue. The SNP favour a significant population increase quite how the locals will feel if this happens remains to be seen.

However the issue is that the UK will not allow Scotland to become a back door for immigrants flying into Scotland and then jumping on a train to London. How then does the UK stop that? A hard border?

We also have the problem of Scots moving freely from the Auld country to work in the UK, why should they get preference over others?

I can see an EU residency style registration process in the UK after which the Scots will be on a par with the rest of the world. I can see many Scots giving it the braveheart in the pub whilst hanging onto to their UK passport to get round this.

And here lies the problem. They want independence but will still want all the benefits of being in the UK

 

W12 29 Jun 22 5.23pm

I would gladly see the dissolution of the act of union as constitutionally it would undo all of the unjust laws and statutes that have been put in place under the likes of Blair and Cameron. All would be null and void.

Wouldn't like to lose the Scots though as I see them as our brothers.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Jun 22 5.36pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Will they be able to survive without Westminster funding? Presumably all funding will be removed, hopefully!

According to Alex Salmon the Scots do not owe us anything regarding the national debt. Well if the SNP walk away without paying their fair share of the bill good luck to them getting finance in the international money markets, nobody likes a welcher.

 


One more point

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Scottish Indy Ref October 2023.