This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
On BBC Sport website atm and all the talk post weekend games. Thought I'd give my two cents but very interested to hear from others: What constitutes a handball?: For me, it is the ball hitting an outfield player's arm/hand... that is it. Now the ball being blasted at you from close range might be the only instance in which it is harsh however 'themz' should be the 'rulez'! I've played football my entire life since discovering walking and I have never once been penalised for a 'handball'. Body position, phases of play, intent, proximity etc etc all fudging ridiculous in my eyes. The game is 'football', one of the key take-aways from the name should be the fact you cannot touch said ball with your arm/hand. I recognise one key downfall might well be deliberate actions by some players, many of whom will be S.American (racism or fact??) however equally I feel sometimes defenders know what they can and can't get away with. You don't need your hand to control the ball and if you do it's a foul, you can't use your hand to block a shot, stop a cross, intercept a ball etc and if you do it is a foul. I find the current legislation around it absolutely bonkers at best and utter bo!!ocks at worst. My second rant in two days on 'football talk', I'll give it a rest for now and just nurse the stomach ulcer I've been working on! I really have no idea what handball is anymore. The inconsistency of decisions is making it even more unclear. We got lucky against Villa but having seen the one at Arsenal, which was not given, I really don’t know anymore ( still anything that goes against the scousers is ok by me)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I really have no idea what handball is anymore. The inconsistency of decisions is making it even more unclear. We got lucky against Villa but having seen the one at Arsenal, which was not given, I really don’t know anymore ( still anything that goes against the scousers is ok by me) For the purposes of determining handball offences, the upper boundary of the arm is in line with the bottom of the armpit. Not every touch of a player’s hand/arm with the ball is an offence. It is an offence if a player: 1. Deliberately touches the ball with their hand/arm, for example moving the hand/arm towards the ball 2. Touches the ball with their hand/arm when it has made their body unnaturally bigger. A player is considered to have made their body unnaturally bigger when the position of their hand/arm is not a consequence of, or justifiable by, the player’s body movement for that specific situation. By having their hand/arm in such a position, the player takes a risk of their hand/arm being hit by the ball and being penalised 3. Scores in the opponents' goal: Clearly, subjectivity can play a part which of course can lead to claims of 'Inconsistency'. Edited by Willo (10 Oct 2022 2.09pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
On BBC Sport website atm and all the talk post weekend games. Thought I'd give my two cents but very interested to hear from others: What constitutes a handball?: For me, it is the ball hitting an outfield player's arm/hand... that is it. Now the ball being blasted at you from close range might be the only instance in which it is harsh however 'themz' should be the 'rulez'! I've played football my entire life since discovering walking and I have never once been penalised for a 'handball'. Body position, phases of play, intent, proximity etc etc all fudging ridiculous in my eyes. The game is 'football', one of the key take-aways from the name should be the fact you cannot touch said ball with your arm/hand. I recognise one key downfall might well be deliberate actions by some players, many of whom will be S.American (racism or fact??) however equally I feel sometimes defenders know what they can and can't get away with. You don't need your hand to control the ball and if you do it's a foul, you can't use your hand to block a shot, stop a cross, intercept a ball etc and if you do it is a foul. I find the current legislation around it absolutely bonkers at best and utter bo!!ocks at worst. My second rant in two days on 'football talk', I'll give it a rest for now and just nurse the stomach ulcer I've been working on! It can't possibly be racist to generalise about someone South American. Prejudiced, possibly, but not racist. Your suggestion is, basically, to be like field hockey, where a ball hitting the foot or leg, regardless of the circumstances, is penalised without question. It's an interesting idea, which would virtually eliminate all controversy.....apart from the in-built failure to spot handball offences by the Big 6 clubs when playing the Less Big 14.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
It can't possibly be racist to generalise about someone South American. Prejudiced, possibly, but not racist. Your suggestion is, basically, to be like field hockey, where a ball hitting the foot or leg, regardless of the circumstances, is penalised without question. It's an interesting idea, which would virtually eliminate all controversy.....apart from the in-built failure to spot handball offences by the Big 6 clubs when playing the Less Big 14. Yes, good comparison YT. I am aligned to that usage of the rule. My comments about S.Americans was an image I had in my own mind of a player who we'll just call 'L Suarez' for now... maybe that's a bit too obvious... let's call him 'Luis S' perhaps entering the box with a defender standing him up and deliberately 'flicking' the ball towards an arm. As for prejudice over racism, I would consider the two somewhat interchangeable however went for the latter given my ghostly whiteness comparative to any nation that sees the sun more often if not just occasionally. My ethnic background was one built for labouring on a rainy Irish farm, not anything tropical! As for the 'in-built failure' I think it has been scientifically proven that the favour of decisions for the big 6 is nothing short of coincidence so no need whatsoever for anyone to investigate bias, corruption, mental fragility or anything like that you know.. ahem.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
For the purposes of determining handball offences, the upper boundary of the arm is in line with the bottom of the armpit. Not every touch of a player’s hand/arm with the ball is an offence. It is an offence if a player: 1. Deliberately touches the ball with their hand/arm, for example moving the hand/arm towards the ball 2. Touches the ball with their hand/arm when it has made their body unnaturally bigger. A player is considered to have made their body unnaturally bigger when the position of their hand/arm is not a consequence of, or justifiable by, the player’s body movement for that specific situation. By having their hand/arm in such a position, the player takes a risk of their hand/arm being hit by the ball and being penalised 3. Scores in the opponents' goal: Clearly, subjectivity can play a part which of course can lead to claims of 'Inconsistency'. Edited by Willo (10 Oct 2022 2.09pm) Yep I do actually know the rules but was being facetious as, in every game, it seems different
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Yes, good comparison YT. I am aligned to that usage of the rule. My comments about S.Americans was an image I had in my own mind of a player who we'll just call 'L Suarez' for now... maybe that's a bit too obvious... let's call him 'Luis S' perhaps entering the box with a defender standing him up and deliberately 'flicking' the ball towards an arm. As for prejudice over racism, I would consider the two somewhat interchangeable however went for the latter given my ghostly whiteness comparative to any nation that sees the sun more often if not just occasionally. My ethnic background was one built for labouring on a rainy Irish farm, not anything tropical! As for the 'in-built failure' I think it has been scientifically proven that the favour of decisions for the big 6 is nothing short of coincidence so no need whatsoever for anyone to investigate bias, corruption, mental fragility or anything like that you know.. ahem. My apologies. I had forgotten about that key research study carried out by Toxteth Polytechnic.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Yep I do actually know the rules but was being facetious as, in every game, it seems different Incidents can vary of course, and there are so many factors to consider eg distance the ball has travelled, positioning of the hands, whether they were moved towards the ball and whether they were in an unnatural position etc etc so subjectivity can enter the equation.Not forgetting of course that the incidents happen at pace and the referee has to make an instant decision.
|
|
|
Originally posted by YT
My apologies. I had forgotten about that key research study carried out by Toxteth Polytechnic.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Incidents can vary of course, and there are so many factors to consider eg distance the ball has travelled, positioning of the hands, whether they were moved towards the ball and whether they were in an unnatural position etc etc so subjectivity can enter the equation.Not forgetting of course that the incidents happen at pace and the referee has to make an instant decision.
Yep. There's also the fact most referees do not understand football on a practical level and/or are unable to think logically or objectively. Add into that their genetically inferior spines and uncodified, contractual obligation for subservience to bigger clubs and what do we expect? Edited by Nicholas91 (10 Oct 2022 3.16pm)
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Yep. There's also the fact most referees do not understand football on a practical level and/or are unable to think logically or objectively. Add into that their genetically inferior spines and uncodified, contractual obligation for subservience to bigger clubs and what do we expect? Edited by Nicholas91 (10 Oct 2022 3.16pm) With respect, I do not share your view on this matter.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
With respect, I do not share your view on this matter. I would suggest there is far more evidence for my suggestion Willo than an argument against. The words 'demonstrably' comes to my mind!
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I would suggest there is far more evidence for my suggestion Willo than an argument against. The words 'demonstrably' comes to my mind! Referees are not beyond reproach and do err from time to time but by-and-large perform with some aplomb under great pressure in games of great alacrity and intensity. Edited by Willo (10 Oct 2022 3.33pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Incidents can vary of course, and there are so many factors to consider eg distance the ball has travelled, positioning of the hands, whether they were moved towards the ball and whether they were in an unnatural position etc etc so subjectivity can enter the equation.Not forgetting of course that the incidents happen at pace and the referee has to make an instant decision.
But VAR doesn’t happen at pace does it
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
With respect, I do not share your view on this matter. We know, not unexpected from the poster who thought Clattenburg was above reproach
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
But VAR doesn’t happen at pace does it There is of course pressure to arrive at a decision which doesn't take an eternity but I can only repeat that subjectivity can enter the equation and there can be nuances between incidents.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
We know, not unexpected from the poster who thought Clattenburg was above reproach With the greatest of respect, I don't wish to gallivant down this line of debate as in the past they have been the catalyst for those dastardly 'Willo Threads' which led to scurrilous allegations and numerous debates being de-railed by animus.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Referees are not beyond reproach and do err from time to time but by-and-large perform with some aplomb under great pressure in games of great alacrity and intensity. Edited by Willo (10 Oct 2022 3.33pm) Of course I am exaggerating and somewhat parodying the usual cries heard from football fans though have to disagree now VAR is in use. The pressure is huge yes. A referee cannot see everything, at every angle, all of the time of course not. Some decisions will have to be made subjectively yes. The referees are operating under pressure/incentive from 'bigger clubs'/the FA/corporations/other influences - about as provable as it is possible to dismiss entirely. The manner in which the match is officiated will always be down to the referee's prerogative which therefore inevitably will always be open to scrutiny and usually have more attention from the 'aggrieved' side, yes. Ultimately, with VAR now in usage the basis of, and motivation for the implementation is one that would suggest the officiating of games is more accurate and officials are less open to scrutiny. We are not seeing this and have a catalogue of controversies and bad decisions each week. It may even be worse now. Now, I am inclined to suggest that the further upon further complication of the rules has made things a lot harder and certainly not any clearer. This has made referees lean further towards application of frequently ambiguous wordings as opposed to their own opinions on footballing decisions. Everybody always now refers to 'the rules' as if we're playing an entirely different game now. My final stance however is that whilst all the above is relevant, I feel as though referees too frequently make decisions which suggest bias and more so a lack of footballing understanding. The logic or thought process seems missing far too often which, along with the obfuscation of rules, has made the situation far worse. I think footballing bodies have tried to take the focus off of referees and also protect them however they seem to be making things worse. I still don't understand why referees cannot explain their decisions and are protected from accountability to such an extreme. Does not have to be in front of a camera, immediately pre-match however I think this would go a long way, especially in dismissing corruption rumours. Were I, by some unfortunate parallel universe shift, a PL referee and officiating a neutral game (wouldn't be many these days) as I should be, I would have no qualms in explaining any controversy and having to face the music where called out for not doing my job properly - in which instance I would issue an apology. All the danger that might bring must surely still be in existence and more toxic as things stand now.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Of course I am exaggerating and somewhat parodying the usual cries heard from football fans though have to disagree now VAR is in use. The pressure is huge yes. A referee cannot see everything, at every angle, all of the time of course not. Some decisions will have to be made subjectively yes. The referees are operating under pressure/incentive from 'bigger clubs'/the FA/corporations/other influences - about as provable as it is possible to dismiss entirely. The manner in which the match is officiated will always be down to the referee's prerogative which therefore inevitably will always be open to scrutiny and usually have more attention from the 'aggrieved' side, yes. Ultimately, with VAR now in usage the basis of, and motivation for the implementation is one that would suggest the officiating of games is more accurate and officials are less open to scrutiny. We are not seeing this and have a catalogue of controversies and bad decisions each week. It may even be worse now. Now, I am inclined to suggest that the further upon further complication of the rules has made things a lot harder and certainly not any clearer. This has made referees lean further towards application of frequently ambiguous wordings as opposed to their own opinions on footballing decisions. Everybody always now refers to 'the rules' as if we're playing an entirely different game now. My final stance however is that whilst all the above is relevant, I feel as though referees too frequently make decisions which suggest bias and more so a lack of footballing understanding. The logic or thought process seems missing far too often which, along with the obfuscation of rules, has made the situation far worse. I think footballing bodies have tried to take the focus off of referees and also protect them however they seem to be making things worse. I still don't understand why referees cannot explain their decisions and are protected from accountability to such an extreme. Does not have to be in front of a camera, immediately pre-match however I think this would go a long way, especially in dismissing corruption rumours. Were I, by some unfortunate parallel universe shift, a PL referee and officiating a neutral game (wouldn't be many these days) as I should be, I would have no qualms in explaining any controversy and having to face the music where called out for not doing my job properly - in which instance I would issue an apology. All the danger that might bring must surely still be in existence and more toxic as things stand now. I garland your comments with praise for your eloquent, cerebral and rhetorical panache but with respect I do not stand four-square behind each and every point you have raised. Edited by Willo (10 Oct 2022 4.18pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.