This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Farawayeagle at 02 Jul 2014 8.57am
At his age I really don't see the point in prison. An Open prison -- which it seems possible he would get --- or at most a Category C prison would cost the taxpayers around 160 to 200 thousand pounds over 8 years. It would be better to fine him a few million and donate it to a sexual abuse organisation. As for those saying where is the punishment? I think losing your whole life achievement and all the official accolades you have had. Being disowned by your hometown and country and becoming a social pariah wherever you go -- and having the music and art you created ignored -- would be more than enough punishment. Edited by Farawayeagle (02 Jul 2014 9.00am) I think you have a point, but there is an issue beyond the norm of rehabilition here, we're talking about someone who was a prolific and unrepentant offender, over decades with a dozen plus victims (it would seem). Whilst I don't hold with the idea that punishment for its own sake is justified, it has to serve a rehabilitive process, we're not talking about someone who is a low risk offender. Had these crimes been committed recently, and come to life, he'd be looking at a life sentence as a serial sexual predatory offender considered to be a permanent and persistant threat to society (possibly even a whole life tariff). It'll probably cost 40-60k a year to keep him in prison, but thats money well spent. Him, Hall, Savile etc aren't just dirty old men. They are dedicated, persistant sex offenders, who abused children over a period of decades.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Fair enough (didn't know that about Glitters NBA pay out - and have to say I'm quite shocked) but as it was used in the punishment context, I can't see his paintings being any kind of asset until long after he's dead. The 90% figure is from a Radio Times piece from yesterday. But the link keeps on crashing my web browsers so I'll refrain from posting it.
Lend me a Tenor 31 May to 3 June 2017 John McIntosh Arts Centre with Superfly in the chorus |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Farawayeagle at 02 Jul 2014 11.07am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Jul 2014 10.11am
Quote Farawayeagle at 02 Jul 2014 8.57am
At his age I really don't see the point in prison. An Open prison -- which it seems possible he would get --- or at most a Category C prison would cost the taxpayers around 160 to 200 thousand pounds over 8 years. It would be better to fine him a few million and donate it to a sexual abuse organisation. As for those saying where is the punishment? I think losing your whole life achievement and all the official accolades you have had. Being disowned by your hometown and country and becoming a social pariah wherever you go -- and having the music and art you created ignored -- would be more than enough punishment. Edited by Farawayeagle (02 Jul 2014 9.00am) I think you have a point, but there is an issue beyond the norm of rehabilition here, we're talking about someone who was a prolific and unrepentant offender, over decades with a dozen plus victims (it would seem). Whilst I don't hold with the idea that punishment for its own sake is justified, it has to serve a rehabilitive process, we're not talking about someone who is a low risk offender. Had these crimes been committed recently, and come to life, he'd be looking at a life sentence as a serial sexual predatory offender considered to be a permanent and persistant threat to society (possibly even a whole life tariff). It'll probably cost 40-60k a year to keep him in prison, but thats money well spent. Him, Hall, Savile etc aren't just dirty old men. They are dedicated, persistant sex offenders, who abused children over a period of decades.
Isn't that what tax is for though, the things you generally wouldn't want to pay for. I'm happy to pay to keep paedophiles and other threats to the public in prison. I'm a bit dubious about the money spent on say Trident or the Olympics. But prison services are something we should be spending more on. The offences are such that just levying a fine (and giving it to charity) wouldn't really serve as an example of justice being done to those victims. Plus criminals rarely if ever pay fines (as they're in prison, theres not really much you can do to levy on them).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 02 Jul 2014 10.24am
Quote Superfly at 02 Jul 2014 10.04am
Disagree - that's precisely how it works. Initial estimates are that his painting have dropped by 90% in value. And when was the last time you heard a Gary Glitter record played?
Still, the reality is that art is art and how people respond to it differs. Berry's music is still played......The BBC have art by a pedophile right outside their entrance....If I remember correctly. Glitter's music is played around the world.....The man doesn't have to work.....I think he made £130,000 thanks to his music being played during the NBA finals. Initial estimates by who? They aren't worth anything. Hitler's paintings weren't put in the bin you know.....And he wasn't that good. If I remember correctly one of his went for nearly a hundred grand a few years back. There is a very healthy market in 'black art'. The price of 'Jim'll Fix it' badges, has risen dramatically in the last few years. Whilst the art value of Rolf's works will drop in the short term, chances are that there are people who collect objects of interest related to notorious criminals: esp when the individual has died, and the stigma about profiting from such objects diminishes. The face value may have decreased, unique, one of objects such as a painting by a celebrity criminal will hold its value very well, especially in certain markets. You woulnd't have got a fiver for a hitler painting in 1945, now, they go for a hundred grand, and he couldn't paint. The art world isn't exactly strangers to people who were deviants, perverts and weirdos.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Forest Hillbilly at 02 Jul 2014 11.31am
Prison. * Punishment, and to some extent retribution from the victim(s) , and society.
Edited by Forest Hillbilly (02 Jul 2014 11.32am) But not as bad as people like to imagine. The problem is really on how we operate prisons and treat prisoners isn't that well suited to rehabilition, esp when it comes to 'cost cuttings'. But thats besides the point, old Harris isn't going to be rehabilitated, too old. I never used to agree with the punishment aspect, but HoL has brought me around to the way of thinking that an element of 'justice' must be seen to be done on behalf of the victims. As far as I'm concerned he, hall etc should spend the rest of their lives in secure captivity.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote black eagle. at 02 Jul 2014 11.46am
i met Rolf Harris as a kid doing work experience at a radio station,still a bit shocked by all this,never in a million years did he come across as a paedo. still Harris will have to go through public humiliation in prison of everyone trying to have a pop at him something that Saville got away with it. i hope he suffers in prison before he dies,again something Saville never had to endure. It should hopefully serve as a warning, that child sex offenders, for the most part aren't really any different than anyone else. In many ways it shouldn't have been a surprising as it was, predatory paedophiles seek out access to children and often cultiate a sense of trust and nievity as a cover. And have beards and wear sandals.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 02 Jul 2014 1.03pm
I reckon there's too many of you happy to dust down your pitchfolk and torch. Brooks innocent and Harris guilty.......I don't have much faith in either. Difference is that Brooks defence was aiming at reasonable doubt, where as Rolfs seems to be based on being innocent. Hats off to Brooks, she was quite happy to be made to look incompetant, a bad manager of her staff and stupid, rather than guilty, in court (as well as selling Coulson down the river). Where as rolfy, big mistake was having a witness that whilst they get the year wrong, manages to describe all the event, you claim you were never at, and then have the prosecution produce incontrovertable film and photographic evidence that puts you at the scene as described by the witness. When its your word against theres, never ever get caught out in a blantent lie. Were it Brookes, in that situation, they'd have said they don't remember being there because it was so long ago. Its a very subtle important difference than a catagorical denial. Purjering yourself in court and getting caught never ends well.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote adrian b at 02 Jul 2014 3.56pm
When I left school I found a job as an entertainer at a holiday camp in Wales. While I was there I indulged in all the testerone induced 'fun' I could muster, with as many women as I could induce to join in. I was 18, some of the women were mothers, some wives, some may have been grandmothers, and I have no idea how old the unmarried ones were. They looked ok, old enough and were as willing, if not more so, than me. After 50 years where does that put me? And there were many young bands doing the tours in those days and 100s of girls who wanted to score, add a notch to their experience. Where does that put them? All a bit confusing for most of us I suppose. But Savil and Harris, seems pretty obvious. Were they all over 16? Were they capable of informed consent? If so, you're fine. If not you're a rapist, and possibly a nonsey one too.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.