You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Churchill was a prick
November 22 2026 12.40am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Churchill was a prick


Page 10 of 14 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Part Time James Flag 30 Jan 15 9.26am

Quote serial thriller at 23 May 2013 10.03pm

Quote nickgusset at 23 May 2013 9.57pm

Serial, why are you going for most provocative poster this early in the campaign? The new season hasn't even started yet!

Or perhaps yer starting with some low level stuff before coming out with the big guns (why Mullery was our greatest manager ever FACT)next April.


Damn, you caught me!

I'll have to scrap my 'Why Communism should be given another chance', 'All Hail the return of Our Lord and Saviour Tony Blair!' and 'Staffie is a C*nt' thread ideas now...

Edited by serial thriller (23 May 2013 10.04pm)


He won't be happy seeing his name spelt with a capital 'S'.

 




Hoof Hearted 30 Jan 15 9.56am

At least Churchill didn't have to "sex up" documents to prosecute an illegal war.

-.-'

 

OldFella Flag London 30 Jan 15 10.09am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 30 Jan 2015 9.56am

At least Churchill didn't have to "sex up" documents to prosecute an illegal war.

-.-'

Agreed! But oh no, here come all the loony lefties......


 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Jan 15 10.14am

Churchill was probably a prick he certainly seems like one, but he was the right prick for the job, and got it done (admittedly several hundred thousand people died in order to facilitate that success, I think leaders tend to get a bit too much credit - Churchill didn't win the war, he was just in charge of the country at the time and played his part).

That Bomber Harris seemed like a right c**t as well, but if you're going to have someone in charge of Bomber command during an all out, balls to the wall, war, you want someone I suppose who can give the kind of orders that result in Dresden.

Churchill, wasn't actually that much of a great politician outside of that period - Very much a War Time Leader, a bit of a drunk, plagued by depression, partial to cocaine, amazingly charismatic and quite witty (or cutting). Between 1939 and 1945 he was pretty vital.

Doesn't stop him being a prick. You can't really be a politician without being a prick.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

sydtheeagle Flag England 30 Jan 15 10.44am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Jan 2015 10.14am

Churchill was probably a prick he certainly seems like one, but he was the right prick for the job, and got it done (admittedly several hundred thousand people died in order to facilitate that success, I think leaders tend to get a bit too much credit - Churchill didn't win the war, he was just in charge of the country at the time and played his part).

That Bomber Harris seemed like a right c**t as well, but if you're going to have someone in charge of Bomber command during an all out, balls to the wall, war, you want someone I suppose who can give the kind of orders that result in Dresden.

Churchill, wasn't actually that much of a great politician outside of that period - Very much a War Time Leader, a bit of a drunk, plagued by depression, partial to cocaine, amazingly charismatic and quite witty (or cutting). Between 1939 and 1945 he was pretty vital.

Doesn't stop him being a prick. You can't really be a politician without being a prick.

Agree with all this. With regard to the highlighted bit, Russia did that.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

TheJudge Flag 30 Jan 15 10.52am

You can say what you like about Churchill but it might be more pertinent to look at how Roosevelt was happy to allow the Russians to be given eastern Europe to keep them onside and Stalin himself and his brutal regime of tyranny. He was worse than Hitler.
Yes we can all second guess decision making from the past but it is a pointless pursuit. Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 30 Jan 15 11.15am

Quote TheJudge at 30 Jan 2015 10.52am

Yes we can all second guess decision making from the past but it is a pointless pursuit. Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

So what you're saying equates to "let's ignore a discussion of history because it can't teach us anything of use for the future."

On the contrary, NOT pointless at all. Hindsight isn't the only by-product of re-examining such events.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Jan 15 11.27am

Quote TheJudge at 30 Jan 2015 10.52am

You can say what you like about Churchill but it might be more pertinent to look at how Roosevelt was happy to allow the Russians to be given eastern Europe to keep them onside and Stalin himself and his brutal regime of tyranny. He was worse than Hitler.
Yes we can all second guess decision making from the past but it is a pointless pursuit. Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

Stalin or Roosevelt. I'm not really sure Stalin can be classed as worse than Hitler, on a parr maybe, but having read Mein Kampf, I can safely tell you what Hitler's long term plan was for 'Eastern Europe' was most certainly not as positive as the communist regimes that dominated Eastern Europe after 1945 - Which isn't a defense of those regimes.

Also its important to remember that the holocaust is only the tip of the Hitler / National Socialist genocide. When you include the depopulation and genocide following operation Barbarossa, the decades of soviet pogroms and '5 year plan famines' start to look positively tame (bearing in mind the Nazi's achieved something like 10-12m deaths in the space of a few years).

In truth, when genocide and whole sale murder is part of your domestic and/or foreign policy, you're 'as bad' as any other of the major murder junky c**ts of history. Its just a question of scale.

Murdering two people doesn't make you better or worse than someone who murders one person. You're still a murderer, its only a quantitative difference.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Jan 15 11.29am

Quote sydtheeagle at 30 Jan 2015 11.15am

Quote TheJudge at 30 Jan 2015 10.52am

Yes we can all second guess decision making from the past but it is a pointless pursuit. Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

So what you're saying equates to "let's ignore a discussion of history because it can't teach us anything of use for the future."

On the contrary, NOT pointless at all. Hindsight isn't the only by-product of re-examining such events.

Worked quite well for Europe post 1945, remembering the horrors and instead of seeking dominance, seeking collaboration, interdependence and shared benefit has created a modern Europe that survived the cold war and has increasingly become driven as much by common cause, as direct competition.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 30 Jan 15 2.09pm

Quote OldFella at 30 Jan 2015 10.09am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 30 Jan 2015 9.56am

At least Churchill didn't have to "sex up" documents to prosecute an illegal war.

-.-'

Agreed! But oh no, here come all the loony lefties......


Wasn't it the looney lefties that were against the war right from the start?

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 30 Jan 15 2.26pm

Christ, nice bump whoever brought this back from the grave!

It's pretty difficult defending views that I expressed a couple of years ago because they've obviously altered. Churchill to me is an iconic figure who is mythologised in a way which severely distorts, downplays and accentuates certain fundamental aspects of his ideology and actions. History is purely interpretation, so I guess it's what you take and what you leave as to whether you see him as a prick or not.

In my mind, Churchill was a savage imperialist who oversaw and was complicit in acts of extreme atrocities in the remaining British colonies. His reaction in his second term in office to rebellion was almost always violent, thus the Malayan War and various other conflicts which sought to repress and subjugate were fought under his name.

To my mind such an ideology can't just be brushed under the carpet because he won the war, or was a good writer. People love to plug this line about without him there would be no free speech, but let's not pretend this was a man who was interested in universal freedoms. His aggressive colonial policy and support of disabled sterilisation show that his concept of liberty was just as divisive and sparing as those of the Nazis and the Soviets.

I wouldn't go so far as to call him a prick, but he's not someone I think we should look on so fondly.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

moorgreendude Flag Nottingham 30 Jan 15 3.43pm

Interesting to examine Churchill's role during the General Strike of 1926. He understood the importance of the need to control rather than allow free speech at critical times when the state / capitalism was experiencing a degree of strain.

 

20 Spaces Isnt Enoug Flag Bolton 30 Jan 15 4.00pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Jan 2015 11.27am

Quote TheJudge at 30 Jan 2015 10.52am

You can say what you like about Churchill but it might be more pertinent to look at how Roosevelt was happy to allow the Russians to be given eastern Europe to keep them onside and Stalin himself and his brutal regime of tyranny. He was worse than Hitler.
Yes we can all second guess decision making from the past but it is a pointless pursuit. Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

Stalin or Roosevelt. I'm not really sure Stalin can be classed as worse than Hitler, on a parr maybe, but having read Mein Kampf, I can safely tell you what Hitler's long term plan was for 'Eastern Europe' was most certainly not as positive as the communist regimes that dominated Eastern Europe after 1945 - Which isn't a defense of those regimes.

Also its important to remember that the holocaust is only the tip of the Hitler / National Socialist genocide. When you include the depopulation and genocide following operation Barbarossa, the decades of soviet pogroms and '5 year plan famines' start to look positively tame (bearing in mind the Nazi's achieved something like 10-12m deaths in the space of a few years).

In truth, when genocide and whole sale murder is part of your domestic and/or foreign policy, you're 'as bad' as any other of the major murder junky c**ts of history. Its just a question of scale.

Murdering two people doesn't make you better or worse than someone who murders one person. You're still a murderer, its only a quantitative difference.


By coincidence,Jamie, Stalin is supposed to have said something
like " One death is a tragedy, a million deaths is a statistic"

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 30 Jan 15 4.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Jan 2015 10.14am

Churchill was probably a prick he certainly seems like one, but he was the right prick for the job, and got it done (admittedly several hundred thousand people died in order to facilitate that success, I think leaders tend to get a bit too much credit - Churchill didn't win the war, he was just in charge of the country at the time and played his part).

That Bomber Harris seemed like a right c**t as well, but if you're going to have someone in charge of Bomber command during an all out, balls to the wall, war, you want someone I suppose who can give the kind of orders that result in Dresden.

Churchill, wasn't actually that much of a great politician outside of that period - Very much a War Time Leader, a bit of a drunk, plagued by depression, partial to cocaine, amazingly charismatic and quite witty (or cutting). Between 1939 and 1945 he was pretty vital.

Doesn't stop him being a prick. You can't really be a politician without being a prick.


Dead set against bombing Dresden apparently. The Soviets pretty much insisted in order to take out a major rail intersection. This completely overstated its strategic importance and the fact that the rail infrastructure could have been damaged in other ways. Harris wanted to concentrate all efforts on Berlin but was ordered to make the order to appease our allies in the East.

 

ghosteagle Flag 30 Jan 15 5.20pm

Quote silvertop at 30 Jan 2015 4.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Jan 2015 10.14am

Churchill was probably a prick he certainly seems like one, but he was the right prick for the job, and got it done (admittedly several hundred thousand people died in order to facilitate that success, I think leaders tend to get a bit too much credit - Churchill didn't win the war, he was just in charge of the country at the time and played his part).

That Bomber Harris seemed like a right c**t as well, but if you're going to have someone in charge of Bomber command during an all out, balls to the wall, war, you want someone I suppose who can give the kind of orders that result in Dresden.

Churchill, wasn't actually that much of a great politician outside of that period - Very much a War Time Leader, a bit of a drunk, plagued by depression, partial to cocaine, amazingly charismatic and quite witty (or cutting). Between 1939 and 1945 he was pretty vital.

Doesn't stop him being a prick. You can't really be a politician without being a prick.


Dead set against bombing Dresden apparently. The Soviets pretty much insisted in order to take out a major rail intersection. This completely overstated its strategic importance and the fact that the rail infrastructure could have been damaged in other ways. Harris wanted to concentrate all efforts on Berlin but was ordered to make the order to appease our allies in the East.

This version of events comes from a British interpreter who was present at Yalta and was exposed some time ago as cold war propaganda. Harris actually wanted the attack to cover a larger area, Chemnitz, Leipzig and Dresden. Dresden was ultimately settled on as a centre of rail, telephone systems and utilities and the design was to cause chaos among the civilian population.

 

Kosowski Flag Standing at the top of B Block 30 Jan 15 5.25pm

To General Anders (the victor of Monte Casino):

"You can rest assured about the future of Poland..."

In fairness I think he did what he could and genuinely respected the contribution of Poland to the Allied cause.

Roosevelt was the f***ing idiot.

 


Block B comment of 2011/2012 Season:

"That's better Palace, better...but still fucking shit!"

----------------------------------------------------------------

Dann to Much, Much to Yong.

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 30 Jan 15 5.44pm

This the programme that I was talking about, I think it is pretty even handed. Although it contradicts some of the "HOL facts" on the thread, for example, his wish to bomb Dresden, he wanted it.

[Link]

It neatly puts Winnie into the context of his time and strips away the myth and revisionism that built up around the man.

Edited by pefwin (30 Jan 2015 5.45pm)

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

ghosteagle Flag 30 Jan 15 5.49pm

Quote Kosowski at 30 Jan 2015 5.25pm

To General Anders (the victor of Monte Casino):

"You can rest assured about the future of Poland..."

In fairness I think he did what he could and genuinely respected the contribution of Poland to the Allied cause.

Roosevelt was the f***ing idiot.


?

 

TheJudge Flag 30 Jan 15 7.20pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 30 Jan 2015 11.15am

Quote TheJudge at 30 Jan 2015 10.52am

Yes we can all second guess decision making from the past but it is a pointless pursuit. Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

So what you're saying equates to "let's ignore a discussion of history because it can't teach us anything of use for the future."

On the contrary, NOT pointless at all. Hindsight isn't the only by-product of re-examining such events.

That's not what I'm saying.
Learning from history is one thing. Vilifying someone after the event for his decision making, especially as the outcome was ultimately successful, is pointless.
If we want to aim our bile at someone, aim it at Hitler. He was solely responsible for wrecking Europe and making us all poorer to the extent that it is still felt today.

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 30 Jan 15 7.28pm

pretty offensive post 'cereal.
not the first time.
usual bollox.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

Page 10 of 14 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Churchill was a prick