This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Palaceexile - I had no idea what you meant by Triggers Broom so looked it up, and now it’s opened up a whole new avenue of discussion involving Cartesian philosophy as well as input from Plutarch and Theseus [Link] Anyone with a philosophy or classics degree out there to take this further? 😀
Audentis fortuna iuvat (Virgil, 19BC) |
|
|
Originally posted by roman eagle
The way I see it is the amateur club folded in 1876 because of the pitch problems, but 20 years later the landlords (Crystal Palace Company) think they can make some money if they re-form the club, which takes another ten years to actually happen in 1905. So strictly speaking it’s not the same club. But strictly speaking the current club was started in 2010. Many clubs and organisations are resurrected or re-formed after a break. In terms of football history both Wanderers and Clapham Rovers have been re-formed in 20th century. So we can regard CPFC1905 not as a continuation but a re-formation of CPFC1861. So in answer to the original question, on balance I think we can claim 1861 as our founding date. If The '1861 Lie' article is Accurate, and it certainly reads that way to me, the Club was not Re-Formed in 1905, completely disassociating itself with any previous incarnations. It was a new entity. Quotes like It's a great fairy tale, and one That I really Want to be true, but you can't change history to make it so.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by roman eagle
Anyone with a philosophy or classics degree out there to take this further? 😀 Given how easy it is to critique the impure reasons that motivated the change, I see little point in taking it further. Any Kantian knows damn well we were founded in 1905. There's nothing left to talk about here.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
And realistically - it doesn't give us anything except perhaps bragging rights but if the links are as tenuous as they seem & that 20 year gap honestly to me it doesn't seem a good look -
Originally posted by crvenaeagle
Stevie P is is always desperately looking for new ways to make our club more marketable, which is appreciated as it's building blocks for our future, but this one however is just cringey for me. We can't fabricate a false history simply for the sake of claiming a title as "the oldest". It looks tacky to me, and it will look tacky to others.
|
|
|
Originally posted by roman eagle
The way I see it is the amateur club folded in 1876 because of the pitch problems, but 20 years later the landlords (Crystal Palace Company) think they can make some money if they re-form the club, which takes another ten years to actually happen in 1905. So strictly speaking it’s not the same club. But strictly speaking the current club was started in 2010. Many clubs and organisations are resurrected or re-formed after a break. In terms of football history both Wanderers and Clapham Rovers have been re-formed in 20th century. So we can regard CPFC1905 not as a continuation but a re-formation of CPFC1861. So in answer to the original question, on balance I think we can claim 1861 as our founding date. I have to respectfully disagree with your description of Wanderers as a "re-formed" club. This a new club that has simply plundered the football history dressing-up box. The same applies to the new Clapham Rovers club. The current Wanderers club were founded in 2009 and chose their name in tribute to the Wanderers who won the FA Cup five times in the 1870s.The original Wanderers ceased to exist and played their last game in 1888 at the Oval. The 2009 Wanderers have adopted, some might say stolen, the history of their namesakes and have backdated their foundation date by 150 years to 1859. Sounds familiar?
|
|
|
Originally posted by crvenaeagle
Stevie P is is always desperately looking for new ways to make our club more marketable, which is appreciated as it's building blocks for our future, but this one however is just cringey for me. We can't fabricate a false history simply for the sake of claiming a title as "the oldest". It looks tacky to me, and it will look tacky to others. Yep.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
If The '1861 Lie' article is Accurate, and it certainly reads that way to me, the Club was not Re-Formed in 1905, completely disassociating itself with any previous incarnations. It was a new entity. Quotes like It's a great fairy tale, and one That I really Want to be true, but you can't change history to make it so. For the avoidance of doubt the 1861 lie article was written by Gordon Law. Gordon is editor of The HOL (Penge Eagle). Gordon released a book in November called Palace Pioneers. I don’t think the club’s line on its history matches what is in the book, although I haven’t read it.
|
|
|
I doubt the people that wrote the bit about triggers broom ever considered it a discussion point for philosophy degrees. I am assuming that your talking about the only fools & horses trigger & his broom ? Or is this a whoooooosh moment? Originally posted by roman eagle
Palaceexile - I had no idea what you meant by Triggers Broom so looked it up, and now it’s opened up a whole new avenue of discussion involving Cartesian philosophy as well as input from Plutarch and Theseus [Link] Anyone with a philosophy or classics degree out there to take this further? 😀
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
I doubt the people that wrote the bit about triggers broom ever considered it a discussion point for philosophy degrees. I am assuming that your talking about the only fools & horses trigger & his broom ? Or is this a whoooooosh moment? I'm afraid it might be Dave. I think it was just a joke but there is solid ground for a philosophical discussion IMHO.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
For the avoidance of doubt the 1861 lie article was written by Gordon Law. Gordon is editor of The HOL (Penge Eagle). Gordon released a book in November called Palace Pioneers. I don’t think the club’s line on its history matches what is in the book, although I haven’t read it. So are you suggesting that the author selected sources to support his narrative? There are two from the 1940s which are pretty irrelevant the handbook can be interpreted in both ways , for and against.
|
|
|
Originally posted by lefty27
So are you suggesting that the author selected sources to support his narrative? There are two from the 1940s which are pretty irrelevant the handbook can be interpreted in both ways , for and against. When you say "legend is cool" I assume you put feelings ahead of facts. I think it's pretty clear in the article with lots of evidence that both CP cricket and football clubs folded. Do you have any counter evidence that states this is false?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
When you say "legend is cool" I assume you put feelings ahead of facts. I think it's pretty clear in the article with lots of evidence that both CP cricket and football clubs folded. Do you have any counter evidence that states this is false? No because I’ve just read a couple of short articles sourcing documents that back their narrative. I’m not a historian with a lot of time on my hands so to most people it’s down to which story you prefer or which suites your agenda.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I'm afraid it might be Dave. I think it was just a joke but there is solid ground for a philosophical discussion IMHO. It's interesting that the 'Trigger's broom' gag has been brought into the discussion. For 'Trigger's broom' is itself a resurrection of a joke that has prevailed for centuries ie it wasn't invented by John Sullivan. Previous manifestations were: 'King Henry's sword'...'Cromwell's pike'...'Grandad's hammer/axe/rake/shovel etc etc'. I can even vaguely recall the joke being used on TV about 'Grandma's rocking chair', although I can't remember where and when (possibly it was 'The Waltons' or - for those of us of a certain age - 'The Beverly Hillbillies'
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
It's interesting that the 'Trigger's broom' gag has been brought into the discussion. For 'Trigger's broom' is itself a resurrection of a joke that has prevailed for centuries ie it wasn't invented by John Sullivan. Previous manifestations were: 'King Henry's sword'...'Cromwell's pike'...'Grandad's hammer/axe/rake/shovel etc etc'. I can even vaguely recall the joke being used on TV about 'Grandma's rocking chair', although I can't remember where and when (possibly it was 'The Waltons' or - for those of us of a certain age - 'The Beverly Hillbillies' Goes back even further than that! The Ship of Theseus thought puzzle was proposed by Greek philosophers such as Heraclitus and Plato with the premise of if the ship of Theseus were kept in a harbour and every part on the ship were replaced one at a time, would it then be a new ship? I prefer the Trigger's broom version personally
The trouble with computers, of course, is that they're very sophisticated idiots |
|
|
Originally posted by SnapperKain
Goes back even further than that! The Ship of Theseus thought puzzle was proposed by Greek philosophers such as Heraclitus and Plato with the premise of if the ship of Theseus were kept in a harbour and every part on the ship were replaced one at a time, would it then be a new ship? I prefer the Trigger's broom version personally Yes, someone else referred to the philosophical point earlier in the thread. I was, of course, talking about it being used as a source of humour, and then the irony of it being used in an argument about the age of the club. Incidentally - is there any chance of the 'Fake News' story on the front page of HOL being replaced any time soon, I wonder? I'm a bit bored "of" seeing it each time I log in, and I suspect most people don't particularly care.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
If The '1861 Lie' article is Accurate, and it certainly reads that way to me, the Club was not Re-Formed in 1905, completely disassociating itself with any previous incarnations. It was a new entity. Quotes like It's a great fairy tale, and one That I really Want to be true, but you can't change history to make it so. Even though its a quote from a long time ago, im not sure if its exactly 100% true. There definitely was a connection.
Live in Melbourne or Victoria, Australia? Well join the Crystal Palace Melbourne Supporters Club: Adelaide, South Australia? Join here: |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.