You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ref: Palace v Burnley
November 16 2026 9.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ref: Palace v Burnley


Page 10 of 14 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 02 May 17 1.46pm

Originally posted by peterg

The conspiracy theory is very far-fetched. Much easier to believe that Madley is an incompetent ref who should not be allowed near a football pitch. He made a ludicrous decision when he booked Jimmy Mac in the 'Boro match and his performance in the Burnley match was totally inept. His mistake in the 'Boro match did not cost us, but those in the Burnley match certainly did - and could even send us down.

No one seriously thinks there are conspiracies against any club let alone Palace. The truth is that with all the TV cameras and technology every decision can be analysed and debated like never before, which has let to fans of every club believing all refs are terrible and every decision is wrong. I'm not in favour of video refs as I believe it takes out the passion of the moment but I realise the need to bring it in even if it's just to pacify people.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 02 May 17 1.49pm

.

Trolley.jpg Attachment: Trolley.jpg (69.14Kb)

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

smiffyseagles Flag London 02 May 17 1.59pm

Willo. I was sitting in the main stand on saturday and it was quite obvious to me and the people beside me wilf was onside. I understand running the line is tough, ive done it and its challenging, but thats a simple decision to make and he guessed.

The link shows the full highlights but click a bit in and you can see the burnley last man is panicking so quickly runs forward

[Link]

Originally posted by Willo

If you firmly believe I am a "Troll", I would re-consider whether your judgement is sound on this matter.I can assure you I am NOT a 'Troll' in any shape or form - just a supporter of our club since the 60s and giving you my honest opinions on HOL.

You mention "Highlights" - All I have seen has been the Zaha penalty incident and goals which if I am NOT mistaken appeared on 'Goals On Sunday'.Ive certainly NOT seen the Zaha 'Offside' incident apart from on a photograph.

Regards the photo, I would dearly like to see the incident in motion so that I can try and offer an explanation as to quite why the Assistant flagged for offside.If anybody could provide a video clip I would be delighted.Many Thanks.

At the end of the day, referees and assistants err in high-pressure situations and we shouldn't expect anything else.I have stated this umpteen times but somehow my detractors continue with the mantra that I never admit that officials get it wrong from time to time.


Edited by Willo (02 May 2017 12.49pm)


 

Asian Eagle Flag Cebu City 02 May 17 2.02pm

Never mind the ref, we lost cause we were not switched on for this crucial game.

Edited by Asian Eagle (02 May 2017 2.05pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 May 17 2.05pm

Originally posted by smiffyseagles

Willo. I was sitting in the main stand on saturday and it was quite obvious to me and the people beside me wilf was onside. I understand running the line is tough, ive done it and its challenging, but thats a simple decision to make and he guessed.

The link shows the full highlights but click a bit in and you can see the burnley last man is panicking so quickly runs forward

[Link]

Thank you for the link.
I am clicking but nothing is happening. Help !

 

chateauferret Flag 02 May 17 2.07pm

Originally posted by Andy_G

No one seriously thinks there are conspiracies against any club let alone Palace. The truth is that with all the TV cameras and technology every decision can be analysed and debated like never before, which has let to fans of every club believing all refs are terrible and every decision is wrong. I'm not in favour of video refs as I believe it takes out the passion of the moment but I realise the need to bring it in even if it's just to pacify people.

I don't think there's a conspiracy against particular clubs but there is institutionalised favouritism which was described very well by someone higher up on this thread, and which was characterised by Clattenburg's chumminess with Sir Alex Ferguson just before the cup final followed by his abysmal and clearly partial performance; and there is also a vested interest in keeping the league exciting for as long as possible which I am not convinced the media moguls are above trying to exploit. We are not directly discriminated against, more collateral damage.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 May 17 2.12pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

I don't think there's a conspiracy against particular clubs but there is institutionalised favouritism which was described very well by someone higher up on this thread, and which was characterised by Clattenburg's chumminess with Sir Alex Ferguson just before the cup final followed by his abysmal and clearly partial performance; and there is also a vested interest in keeping the league exciting for as long as possible which I am not convinced the media moguls are above trying to exploit. We are not directly discriminated against, more collateral damage.

What should he have done ?
Be rude and ignore him ?
Reading far too much into this.

Anyway, must go out now and deliver some Tory leaflets for the local elections !

 

chateauferret Flag 02 May 17 2.21pm

We have been into all that before, Willo, but in case you've forgotten he should a) not have been anywhere near Sir Alex in the first place; and b) refereed the match impartially.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 02 May 17 2.28pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

Don't get me wrong, if we're still too exhausted to go and beat 10 man Burnley from that position then the fault lays entirely on the team but I can't see how you can claim to be a fan but be looking to defend the Officials in every situation, when the team could now be safe in the Premier League if that decision was called correctly.

Just one small point of order: we're all working on the assumption that, sans offside flag, Madley would've sent off Heaton for the challenge on Zaha. On the basis that he got so much wrong during the game, I am about 50/50 on him bottling it and giving a yellow.

We'd still have a 10-page "Willo thread" going, but it would've been about whether the nearby defender could be classified as providing cover or not (he wasn't).

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

leejaneagles Flag 02 May 17 2.35pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

Just one small point of order: we're all working on the assumption that, sans offside flag, Madley would've sent off Heaton for the challenge on Zaha. On the basis that he got so much wrong during the game, I am about 50/50 on him bottling it and giving a yellow.

We'd still have a 10-page "Willo thread" going, but it would've been about whether the nearby defender could be classified as providing cover or not (he wasn't).

Having watched the replay again, focusing more on that rather than the offside, it's a free-kick anyway, not a penalty.

So you're right, I'd say there was a good chance that useless ref would have bottled the red and we'd of been left with a free-kick and a yellow for Heaton, which doesn't change much.

Edited by leejaneagles (02 May 2017 2.35pm)

 

chateauferret Flag 02 May 17 2.46pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

Just one small point of order: we're all working on the assumption that, sans offside flag, Madley would've sent off Heaton for the challenge on Zaha. On the basis that he got so much wrong during the game, I am about 50/50 on him bottling it and giving a yellow.

We'd still have a 10-page "Willo thread" going, but it would've been about whether the nearby defender could be classified as providing cover or not (he wasn't).

Good point. It would only have been the fourth bottled red card against us in a week. Sheesh.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Palace BANANA Flag Ringmer, Lewes, East Sussex 02 May 17 3.17pm

Just a further thought to the "offside" incident.. although the lino flagged for offside, albeit incorrectly, play continued and Wilf was taken out by Heaton. My thoughts are that although the ref was going to give a free kick to Burnley, which technically made the ball was dead, Wilf and Heaton did not know this so Heaton taking Wilf out would normally be a RED card, certainly at least a yellow. Why wasn't Heaton spoken to and still punished for his "off the ball" challenge. If during a game an outfield player was kick an opposing player up in the air in an off the ball incident, whether the ball is dead or not, he would probably be sent off so why not in this incident...

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 02 May 17 3.20pm

Originally posted by Palace BANANA

Just a further thought to the "offside" incident.. although the lino flagged for offside, albeit incorrectly, play continued and Wilf was taken out by Heaton. My thoughts are that although the ref was going to give a free kick to Burnley, which technically made the ball was dead, Wilf and Heaton did not know this so Heaton taking Wilf out would normally be a RED card, certainly at least a yellow. Why wasn't Heaton spoken to and still punished for his "off the ball" challenge. If during a game an outfield player was kick an opposing player up in the air in an off the ball incident, whether the ball is dead or not, he would probably be sent off so why not in this incident...


I have wondered about this too. However, at worst, the ref would've given Heaton a yellow, and there's very little chance of a 'keeper getting a second card during the game - except perhaps towards the very end for time wasting.

It's frustrating because that was a leg-break hack job on Zaha. I can't imagine how we would've all felt if we'd watched Wilf being carted off the pitch with his lower leg flapping in the breeze, and the 'keeper going unpunished because it was incorrectly ruled a dead ball situation.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 May 17 4.21pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

We have been into all that before, Willo, but in case you've forgotten he should a) not have been anywhere near Sir Alex in the first place; and b) refereed the match impartially.

1. He never went looking for Ferguson nor would have known his movements.They happened to end up in the same place.

2. He certainly, as always, refereed the match impartially but clearly not to your likeing.

 

Palace BANANA Flag Ringmer, Lewes, East Sussex 02 May 17 4.46pm

1. He never went looking for Ferguson nor would have known his movements.They happened to end up in the same place.

... Ok Willo, just of interest, please explain how you would know this.. what inside information do you have

2. He certainly, as always, refereed the match impartially but clearly not to your likeing.

... The way he refereed the Cup Final was very questionable, did not show impartiality with some very important decisions, which were not to the liking of many neutrals too not just us Palace fans .. even the pundits questioned his so called "impartial" performance and decisions..

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 May 17 4.51pm

Originally posted by Willo

So you accept that 'Demotion' does occur based on performances.And so it should.

I shall treat all the 'Political clout' with derision.
If Mark had performed like Attwell he would have suffered the same consequences.

At the end of the day there is robust system for measuring the performances of PL referees after each and very game.
Each PL game is evaluated with scrutinisation of every decision using the match footage and 'ProZone' to measure the referee's performance in great detail. Match delegates assess the accuracy and consistency of decision making and their management of the game.
So yes there is a 'Forensic' analysis of the referee's performance after each and every game.

Edited by Willo (01 May 2017 11.20am)

Absolute b******s, he has admitted getting decisions wrong in the Cup Final, millions of world-wide viewers saw them....what happened to him/ F*** all

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 May 17 4.56pm

Originally posted by Palace BANANA

1. He never went looking for Ferguson nor would have known his movements.They happened to end up in the same place.

... Ok Willo, just of interest, please explain how you would know this.. what inside information do you have

2. He certainly, as always, refereed the match impartially but clearly not to your likeing.

... The way he refereed the Cup Final was very questionable, did not show impartiality with some very important decisions, which were not to the liking of many neutrals too not just us Palace fans .. even the pundits questioned his so called "impartial" performance and decisions..

The pundits are entitled to their opinions and NO referee is above criticis, "Goes with the territory" and all that.

I have already commented on HOL about some decisions in the Final and I am sure that many believe I was just trying to be a provocative stimulus on HOL. Far from it - as I mentioned on HOL I made the exact comments to a Chelsea supporter in my 'Local' - He commented that I was being very gracious and honest and my wife said words to the affect "He is very fair".So what I said outside I said on HOL - I was just giving my 'Take' on some of the decisions.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 May 17 5.08pm

Originally posted by Willo

Obviously "Calmed down" in the cold-light of day ! One can see things differently when one looks at the TV footage.

Like the offside decision that you still wont accept!!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 May 17 5.32pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Like the offside decision that you still wont accept!!

Have you not read my posts ?

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 02 May 17 5.46pm

Why do we gave to go through this every time we have a s**t ref. Willo is never going to say a ref had a bad game, so why argue with him. Pointless.

 

Page 10 of 14 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ref: Palace v Burnley