You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dementia Tax
November 21 2026 11.34pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dementia Tax


Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Mapletree Flag Croydon 12 Jun 17 11.24pm

OK, so most people know my views. Here is the exam question. How do we stop older people bankrupting the younger generation with their increasing health needs despite them sitting on gold mines in pension pots and housing equity.

My first move, put NIC on pensions. It's bizarre that older people burn disproportionate amounts of social funds yet don't contribute any more. Move the thresholds up if necessary.

Edited by Mapletree (12 Jun 2017 11.25pm)

 

gambler Flag Kent 13 Jun 17 12.01am

Originally posted by Mapletree

OK, so most people know my views. Here is the exam question. How do we stop older people bankrupting the younger generation with their increasing health needs despite them sitting on gold mines in pension pots and housing equity.

My first move, put NIC on pensions. It's bizarre that older people burn disproportionate amounts of social funds yet don't contribute any more. Move the thresholds up if necessary.

Edited by Mapletree (12 Jun 2017 11.25pm)

Yes, but surely they've paid in plenty during their working lives? Old age comes to us all - well hopefully anyway.l

 

europalace Flag Europe 13 Jun 17 5.31am

Originally posted by Mapletree

OK, so most people know my views. Here is the exam question. How do we stop older people bankrupting the younger generation with their increasing health needs despite them sitting on gold mines in pension pots and housing equity.

My first move, put NIC on pensions. It's bizarre that older people burn disproportionate amounts of social funds yet don't contribute any more. Move the thresholds up if necessary.

Edited by Mapletree (12 Jun 2017 11.25pm)


They also spend their 'pension pots' in the economy during the plenty of time they have each day and every day. The 'housing equity' often gets sold and another, different property bought, so even more money into the economy.

 

dannyboy1978 Flag 13 Jun 17 5.59am

No one seems to mention interest rates were at 14% when people were paying of there houses so being aloud to keep £100.000 Is taking the piss. Especially if there are 2 or more sibblings. Oh I'll get £33.000,big wow.
Secondly houses have gone up in value because the government didn't build enough houses for the millions of migrants so the government are trying to benefit from their own cock up. You couldn't make it up.
Thirdly the government promoted house ownership, from Margaret thatcher "Through thrift and hard work, went the theory, ordinary families should be able to buy their own homes. It would give them security, dignity and freedom and liberate them from the nannying of local council landlords. It would make them better citizens, with their own stake in the economic wellbeing of the country, they would have an incentive to contribute to national prosperity."

So just because the government have cocked up and can't balance the books I don't want to pay for their miss managment.


 

becky Flag over the moon 13 Jun 17 7.52am

Originally posted by Mapletree

OK, so most people know my views. Here is the exam question. How do we stop older people bankrupting the younger generation with their increasing health needs despite them sitting on gold mines in pension pots and housing equity.

My first move, put NIC on pensions. It's bizarre that older people burn disproportionate amounts of social funds yet don't contribute any more. Move the thresholds up if necessary.

Edited by Mapletree (12 Jun 2017 11.25pm)


Can we just dispel this myth please - if you worked in the Public sector or for a large company, you would have got a final-salary pension scheme (and let's remember that even these were contributory), if you worked for a medium sized company you MAY have got a non-final salary pension scheme........and then there is the rest of us (and all the self-employed)who had no pensions schemes at all, and who may (or may not have been able to afford it) have contributed fully to provide themselves with a small annuity (which would have been a comfortable annuity if Gordon Broon hadn't wrecked it!).

As for NIC on pensions, don't forget that having already paid tax on the money that was contributed to my personal private pension scheme, I am now taxed on it again as it is lumped in with my State Retirement pension for taxation purposes, so how many more times must I pay tax on the same bloody hard earned money?

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 Jun 17 8.26am

Originally posted by becky


As for NIC on pensions, don't forget that having already paid tax on the money that was contributed to my personal private pension scheme, I am now taxed on it again as it is lumped in with my State Retirement pension for taxation purposes, so how many more times must I pay tax on the same bloody hard earned money?

Is that so? I'm a bit rusty on pensions but I thought that one got tax relief on pension contributions

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 13 Jun 17 8.49am

Originally posted by becky


Can we just dispel this myth please - if you worked in the Public sector or for a large company, you would have got a final-salary pension scheme (and let's remember that even these were contributory), if you worked for a medium sized company you MAY have got a non-final salary pension scheme........and then there is the rest of us (and all the self-employed)who had no pensions schemes at all, and who may (or may not have been able to afford it) have contributed fully to provide themselves with a small annuity (which would have been a comfortable annuity if Gordon Broon hadn't wrecked it!).

As for NIC on pensions, don't forget that having already paid tax on the money that was contributed to my personal private pension scheme, I am now taxed on it again as it is lumped in with my State Retirement pension for taxation purposes, so how many more times must I pay tax on the same bloody hard earned money?

Not only did you have the opportunity to pay no tax on your pension contributions, you have never paid any NIC on them or on the benefits you now draw. Most people 'paid in' to the social system for 40 to 45 years, they retire now with an expectation of at least 30 years of no NI contribution and a high expectation of health services. Does anyone really feel that their contribution and that of their employer is anywhere near enough to give them free health support in perpetuity? I see no reason why payment should stop at retirement, it's surely the same argument as for tax. It is of course dependent upon earning enough to hit the threshold.

Simply sponging from the younger generations that will have to fund them, then controlling the young people through their dominance over housing, the National Trust (don't get me started) and the promise of an inheritance at some point.

Theresa surely had a logic - and she wouldn't have launched such an unpopular initiative without cause.

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 13 Jun 17 9.08am

If we stop providing for every scrounger from overseas that put a huge drain on our NHS and Welfare system we would not have to make the elderly pay for their own care.
My Nan has been put in a home recently, She had a house worth £375,000 and had to sell it to pay for her own care at £1200 per week. 3/4 of the other residents pay nothing as they do not have the means. When my Nans money runs out it will be free. We have been told the reason the price is so high each week is to help top up the under payment from the government for the others care. So not only is she paying for her own care but contributing for others. Makes me so angry that others come to England just to scrounge and minipulate the ridiculas welfare system we have. Wanting to take NIC on pensions is just another way of nicking money off the elderly. They have paid their dues.

 

i_8_clowns Flag Dorset 13 Jun 17 9.21am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Is that so? I'm a bit rusty on pensions but I thought that one got tax relief on pension contributions

You're right, no tax would have been paid initially on the pension contributions.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 13 Jun 17 9.27am

Originally posted by bubble wrap

If we stop providing for every scrounger from overseas that put a huge drain on our NHS and Welfare system we would not have to make the elderly pay for their own care.
My Nan has been put in a home recently, She had a house worth £375,000 and had to sell it to pay for her own care at £1200 per week. 3/4 of the other residents pay nothing as they do not have the means. When my Nans money runs out it will be free. We have been told the reason the price is so high each week is to help top up the under payment from the government for the others care. So not only is she paying for her own care but contributing for others. Makes me so angry that others come to England just to scrounge and minipulate the ridiculas welfare system we have. Wanting to take NIC on pensions is just another way of nicking money off the elderly. They have paid their dues.

So all the other people in the care home didn't pay into the system, or didn't pay enough? They are somehow different from 'English' people?

Have you heard of the NHS surcharge?

Edited by Mapletree (13 Jun 2017 9.28am)

 

npn Flag Crowborough 13 Jun 17 9.28am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Not only did you have the opportunity to pay no tax on your pension contributions, you have never paid any NIC on them or on the benefits you now draw. Most people 'paid in' to the social system for 40 to 45 years, they retire now with an expectation of at least 30 years of no NI contribution and a high expectation of health services. Does anyone really feel that their contribution and that of their employer is anywhere near enough to give them free health support in perpetuity? I see no reason why payment should stop at retirement, it's surely the same argument as for tax. It is of course dependent upon earning enough to hit the threshold.

Simply sponging from the younger generations that will have to fund them, then controlling the young people through their dominance over housing, the National Trust (don't get me started) and the promise of an inheritance at some point.

Theresa surely had a logic - and she wouldn't have launched such an unpopular initiative without cause.

So if, as you seem to be saying, you should be hitting the elderly again for more tax or removing health benefits because they haven't paid in enough to cover it, does that also mean you plan on hitting the unemployed, as they've not contributed enough either? Or is it just the elderly you have issue with "sponging from the younger generation"? Aren't the unemployed sponging from all generations? And don't get me started on free dental care for kids - what have THEY ever contributed?

Last bit was tongue in cheek to emphasise the point by the way.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Jun 17 9.33am

Originally posted by Mapletree

So all the other people in the care home didn't pay into the system, or didn't pay enough? They are somehow different from 'English' people?

Have you heard of the NHS surcharge?

Edited by Mapletree (13 Jun 2017 9.28am)

I think Bubblewrap might be referring to those foreign families who climb to the top of the local council's social housing waiting list.

We had high care costs for grandfather from his 'estate.' It wasn't as high as it is now though, even taking into account lower house sale prices.

The funny thing was he and possibly others were helping out while they there. I'd encourage retirement homes before care homes. String that out for longer.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (13 Jun 2017 9.34am)

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Jun 17 9.38am

Sugar tax. Obesity is the biggest cause of costs to the NHS. If you get fat, you're likely to get sick. The human body isn't built to have a BMI of 30, 35, 40 and being the weight of 2 people.

Unless you're suffering psychologically, those pasties, crisps, chocolate and litres of coke everyday containing lots of sugar syrup is going to make you fatter.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (13 Jun 2017 9.38am)

 


COYP

Mapletree Flag Croydon 13 Jun 17 9.43am

Originally posted by npn

So if, as you seem to be saying, you should be hitting the elderly again for more tax or removing health benefits because they haven't paid in enough to cover it, does that also mean you plan on hitting the unemployed, as they've not contributed enough either? Or is it just the elderly you have issue with "sponging from the younger generation"? Aren't the unemployed sponging from all generations? And don't get me started on free dental care for kids - what have THEY ever contributed?

Last bit was tongue in cheek to emphasise the point by the way.

I am happy for unemployed people to be surcharged as long as they can afford it. That is the point. I don't propose we should increase taxation on anyone that doesn't have money. Just on those who have benefited in a one-off fashion from unrepeatable benefits. No Defined Benefit pension scheme of which I am aware pays for itself, they all took/are taking extra payments from their companies in the private sector and are a long term drain in the public sector. Many private schemes had payment holidays to boot, so the employees often paid little or nothing.

House prices went through a period of massive inflation and we have a generation that seems to think they worked for that benefit. Well they just struck lucky and the effect is the next generation won't only not have that opportunity, they start in a far worse place where few will be able to buy housing without a great deal of help.

By the way, it is interesting I am a lone voice on this site. I guess it shows the demographic of HOL contributors. Including myself.

Edited by Mapletree (13 Jun 2017 9.44am)

 

europalace Flag Europe 13 Jun 17 10.04am

Originally posted by Mapletree

I am happy for unemployed people to be surcharged as long as they can afford it. That is the point. I don't propose we should increase taxation on anyone that doesn't have money. Just on those who have benefited in a one-off fashion from unrepeatable benefits. No Defined Benefit pension scheme of which I am aware pays for itself, they all took/are taking extra payments from their companies in the private sector and are a long term drain in the public sector. Many private schemes had payment holidays to boot, so the employees often paid little or nothing.

House prices went through a period of massive inflation and we have a generation that seems to think they worked for that benefit. Well they just struck lucky and the effect is the next generation won't only not have that opportunity, they start in a far worse place where few will be able to buy housing without a great deal of help.

By the way, it is interesting I am a lone voice on this site. I guess it shows the demographic of HOL contributors. Including myself.

Edited by Mapletree (13 Jun 2017 9.44am)


Why do people have to 'buy' housing? Most of continental Europe lives very happily with a far higher quality of life simply renting their homes. In Germany, private rents can't go up by more than 10% in any 3 year period. If you think you're being overcharged you go to the town hall where you give a description and sqm of your apartment/house and they decide if you're being overcharged. If so, the landlord must pay back the difference plus interest. When I lived there, nobody talked about property. Renting also makes for a much more flexible workforce and for the individual, much easy to move city for work. A brilliant system overall.

 

becky Flag over the moon 13 Jun 17 10.24am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Not only did you have the opportunity to pay no tax on your pension contributions, you have never paid any NIC on them or on the benefits you now draw. Most people 'paid in' to the social system for 40 to 45 years, they retire now with an expectation of at least 30 years of no NI contribution and a high expectation of health services. Does anyone really feel that their contribution and that of their employer is anywhere near enough to give them free health support in perpetuity? I see no reason why payment should stop at retirement, it's surely the same argument as for tax. It is of course dependent upon earning enough to hit the threshold.

Simply sponging from the younger generations that will have to fund them, then controlling the young people through their dominance over housing, the National Trust (don't get me started) and the promise of an inheritance at some point.

Theresa surely had a logic - and she wouldn't have launched such an unpopular initiative without cause.


Since it was some while ago, they may actually have been a allowance for Income Tax deducted from the premiums for the annuity, but NIC most certainly WAS paid on all my earnings - including, during several periods of payment, higher rates on earnings related contributions.

Oh, and just for the record, I made all those payments, continuously for just over 46 years, and do you know what, no matter what you or anyone else may say I do not and never will feel like a 'scrounger' I held down 3 jobs (one full time and 2 part time) over several years just to afford the deposit on my first wreck of a maisonette - my start on the housing ladder.
Better than sitting on my a*se whining that I couldn't afford it!

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 Jun 17 10.35am

Originally posted by Mapletree

By the way, it is interesting I am a lone voice on this site. I guess it shows the demographic of HOL contributors. Including myself.

You're not a lone voice actually but I expect that you'd hate to find that you are of the same opinion as me on something

You read all these stories about old people being forced to sell their houses that they worked all their lives for whilst people that live in rented accommodation will have their care costs paid for but that is a false picture.

Taking my own family as an example my parents bought their detached house in a leafy Surrey suburb just over 40 years ago. I've no idea how much it's now worth but I'd guess at North of £650,000 but they only paid £8,500 for it and probably finished paying for it 15 plus years ago so they are the lucky recipients of ridiculous house price inflation over the years. Compare that to people who have paid rent all their lives and possibly after 60 years still are.

Secondly you did say that the elderly should pay NIC on their income and again I agree with you as long as the income limits are sensible. Just because someone is elderly doesn't mean that they are necessarily poor and in fact I have earned considerably more since I turned 65 than I ever did when younger

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 13 Jun 17 10.38am

Originally posted by Mapletree

OK, so most people know my views. Here is the exam question. How do we stop older people bankrupting the younger generation with their increasing health needs despite them sitting on gold mines in pension pots and housing equity.

My first move, put NIC on pensions. It's bizarre that older people burn disproportionate amounts of social funds yet don't contribute any more. Move the thresholds up if necessary.

Edited by Mapletree (12 Jun 2017 11.25pm)

The current approach is 'prevention', that's why expensive A&E's are being closed/moved at the same time these new Super Surgeries are being built.

It encourages people to not appear at the 'acute' part of the system for a cut or twisted ankle allowing Hospitals to be the 'last resort'.

Alongside this closer working between Health Partners and Social care is developing, improving education and support in how we can live longer healthier lives.

As I said on another thread...surely it wont be too long before at 60 you get a Gym Pass instead of Bus Pass.

There is already evidence in a number of studies that Dementia is likely to decline, due to the improvement in our general well being as a society.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 13 Jun 17 10.46am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Sugar tax. Obesity is the biggest cause of costs to the NHS. If you get fat, you're likely to get sick. The human body isn't built to have a BMI of 30, 35, 40 and being the weight of 2 people.

Unless you're suffering psychologically, those pasties, crisps, chocolate and litres of coke everyday containing lots of sugar syrup is going to make you fatter.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (13 Jun 2017 9.38am)


I agree entirely with taxing the f*** out of the contributory factors for ill health; AS LONG AS it's ring fenced solely for the purposes of the Health System...which is where the problem lies...as its not.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

npn Flag Crowborough 13 Jun 17 10.56am

Originally posted by Mapletree

I am happy for unemployed people to be surcharged as long as they can afford it. That is the point. I don't propose we should increase taxation on anyone that doesn't have money. Just on those who have benefited in a one-off fashion from unrepeatable benefits. No Defined Benefit pension scheme of which I am aware pays for itself, they all took/are taking extra payments from their companies in the private sector and are a long term drain in the public sector. Many private schemes had payment holidays to boot, so the employees often paid little or nothing.

House prices went through a period of massive inflation and we have a generation that seems to think they worked for that benefit. Well they just struck lucky and the effect is the next generation won't only not have that opportunity, they start in a far worse place where few will be able to buy housing without a great deal of help.

By the way, it is interesting I am a lone voice on this site. I guess it shows the demographic of HOL contributors. Including myself.

Edited by Mapletree (13 Jun 2017 9.44am)

It all depends on how you define "can afford it". If someone has scrimped and saved over their entire working lives to ensure a comfortable retirement, is it right that they are now penalised because they "can afford it"? I had this when my parents retired - never owned a house (unluckily went down the private landlord rather than council route or they would probably have had a right to buy) and then suddenly everything they had saved was going on rent, as they watched their peers who had never put anything aside getting housing benefit instead, and were, quite understandably, asking themselves why they'd bothered being frugal when they would have ended up in exactly the same position, but having had less luxuries up to that point.

The point of tax relief on pensions is surely to encourage people to put money away for a retirement and not then be a burden on the state? Start making it not cost effective to save, and you get an even bigger increase in elderly people running out of cash and needing support.

The inheritance tax I totally get - the recipient has not earned the money and therefore there's a good argument that it should be increased and, as I will be getting no inheritance regardless, it doesn't really apply to me anyway, but pensions, nah!

 

Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dementia Tax