You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Freedman is back
November 16 2026 9.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Freedman is back


Page 10 of 12 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Midlands Eagle Flag 22 Aug 17 10.00am

Originally posted by Flightsequence

He made his bed and should be made to lay in it. However, he has just ordered a new king size! I just don't get it. Although, it's true, we don't know the whole story. But still feel uncomfortable with the appointment.

Isn't that a rather childish attitude and does it really matter if you feel comfortable with the appointment or not as he is not the club's chairman or manager but Steve Parish has appointed Freedman to assist him and he should be allowed to choose whoever he trusts to advise him

 

mixed nuts Flag 22 Aug 17 10.14am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Yet Holloway later claimed that the team that Dougie had assembled was so good that it didn't need a manager as it managed itself

..and ever so slightly dull to watch, very many on here hated it, but we did have an awsome home record.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 22 Aug 17 10.16am

As has been said before Freedman recruited the likes of Murray, Jedinak, Bolasie, Delaney and Ward for a relative pittance who formed the core of the side that kept us in the Prem for the first two seasons.

There will always be signings that don't work with any manager but clearly knows a player and only he and SP / 2010 really know what went on.

As regards chasing money he probably missed out on the really big bucks as a player.

 

eagle184 Flag Sutton 22 Aug 17 10.29am

Originally posted by HerneBayPalace

Is it almost inevitable that FdB fails, Dougie steps in and saves us for the fourth time?

Regardless of what happened and him leaving, he's still such a hero of mine and glad he is back at the club!


THIS

 

lefty27 Flag ipswich 22 Aug 17 10.46am

Really happy with the return of DF, like has been said he knows a player.
For those who haven't already I recommend listening to the interview he gave hol radio.

 

thechaddyboy Flag Peterborough 22 Aug 17 10.52am

DF is Palace through & through but there's nothing wrong with ambition. Just listened to the interview he gave from May 2016 & there's no doubting his love for this club but he's quick to admit the Bolton move was a rash decision which he regretted pretty much immediately, many promises were made in order for him to jump ship & the promises never materialised. If DF is able to find the quality of players we know he's sourced in the past that can only be a good thing. I'd take DF over Dowie or Bruce anyday.

 


Red & Blue since 73'

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 22 Aug 17 11.27am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

He certainly didn't fail with us as a manager as we were on course for an automatic promotion place under Freedman until he left.

You may not trust Dougie but there again you don't have to as Steve Parish (whom you trust totally) has appointed him to assist him and he obviously does trust him

which is what I was saying. Many football fans are a fickle ,passionate, emotive and sometimes volatile bunch.
Thank goodness we don't run the club.

We have to trust and back the owners on their appointments as we'll never be privy to the business details.
DF must have a massive set of testicles to want to return to Selhurst, knowing the kind of reaction it might provoke amongst fans.(like dowie and Bruce)

Let's see what he can do

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 22 Aug 17 12.08pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

[Link]

All here

Like many I had mixed feelings towards Dougie and was somewhat confused with this appointment. Listening to this has helped me understand a little more about the man and would recommend it to anyone feeling the same.

 

Mr Fenandes Flag 22 Aug 17 12.34pm

Glad SP and DF have put their differences behind them. They're both a little older and wiser, they've done a few years in football management/chairmanship, and it looks like they're both willing to put ego to one side which is encouraging.

DF's recruitment was very effective. Excited to see him back and hopefully he'll have the chance to re-establish himself as a legend again.

Edited by Mr Fenandes (22 Aug 2017 12.35pm)

 


Check out our Croydon-based football comedy series 'Road to F.A. Cup'!
All episodes available FREE here: [Link]

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Aug 17 12.42pm

Originally posted by babylonjohn

Like many I had mixed feelings towards Dougie and was somewhat confused with this appointment. Listening to this has helped me understand a little more about the man and would recommend it to anyone feeling the same.

There are some supporters who might conclude that this was a well thought out and rehearsed disingenuous defence of his actions introducing an element of "Sackcloth and ashes" with the financial package the key driver for his decision to leave our club.

Edited by Willo (22 Aug 2017 12.45pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Aug 17 12.48pm

Originally posted by Mr Fenandes

Glad SP and DF have put their differences behind them. They're both a little older and wiser, they've done a few years in football management/chairmanship, and it looks like they're both willing to put ego to one side which is encouraging.

DF's recruitment was very effective. Excited to see him back and hopefully he'll have the chance to re-establish himself as a legend again.

Edited by Mr Fenandes (22 Aug 2017 12.35pm)

Parish will have looked at the business done with Freedman's signings and used his business head. But it should be noted it's because of promotion and their performance in the prem. Now we are prem the seller price increases as soon as we make contact with selling club.

But Mutch and Sako in particular have been a waste and Lee no better. Made me laugh when vs Sunderland we needed a fresh pair of legs on the left and instead of bringing on a fit Lee, Pardew brings on the unfit Sako lump. We concede from his side and draw. He continues to pick Sako. What a pr1ck. 3 wastes in a squad when we could pay 2. Then there's the loan debacles.

Freedman is a good judge of British Isles talent.

 


COYP

Mstrobez Flag 22 Aug 17 12.55pm

Originally posted by Willo

There are some supporters who might conclude that this was a well thought out and rehearsed disingenuous defence of his actions introducing an element of "Sackcloth and ashes" with the financial package the key driver for his decision to leave our club.

Edited by Willo (22 Aug 2017 12.45pm)

Whatever happened with Dougie, I think this is a good apppintment and I will always have a soft spot for him. He f***ed up, it's as simple as that but at the end of the day he created some of the most memorable moments I can remember as a Palace fan and that definitely includes when he was a manager. The run of games prior to Holloway, palace were playing with a real identity, you could see the potential of how far the group could go as a team. I'm still of the firm belief that we owe probably more than we realise to him for the position we currently find ourselves in. Whether he admits it or not, he would've known he messed up and he got his just deserts in the less than impressive managerial career he's had since going to Bolton. Continuing a grudge is a Palace fans right, but for me it just seems pointless, especially when it's quite clear he loves the club himself.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

weaselpop Flag Southeast London and damn proud of... 22 Aug 17 1.17pm

Well, I've re-listened to the HOL interview, I've read the whole thread here, and I STILL don't understand this appointment, its timing, or how it actually happened. There was no hint or rumour that we were looking right now, no gossip (that I've seen), no other names in the frame, no betting odds for us to lol over, none of the usual media paraphenalia. So did SP just ring him up and say "Hi Dougie, I've got a job for you, let bygones be bygones, and btw you start on Monday".

Other posters have argued that we have needed a Director for a while, so why now? And then there's the 'theory' that he's there in case FDB fails badly - laughable to me. So maybe SP has been mulling this for a while but the timing wasn't right before, maybe he also ran it past FDB from the start but wasn't able to activate it until now... But as I say, without any kind of information (fact or fiction) I can't begin to get my head round it. Personally I've no objection to the post, I've no great hatred for DF because of past errors of judgement, and I think he's a pretty shrewd thinker - apart from the Bolton debacle...

 

colinandsued Flag Haywards Heath 22 Aug 17 2.08pm

Appointing a Sporting Director (or Director of Football, or Recruitment Director - different titles but essentially similar remits and responsibilities I imagine) seems to be a logical step. Don't most Premier clubs employ one? They can have a significant and positive effect e.g. Steve Walsh at Leicester (now Everton). FdB has gone on official record to say he's comfortable with the concept, indeed to the extent of recommending it to Steve Parish.

The appointment of Dougie Freedman however, was totally unexpected and was inevitably going to be a seen as divisive. A much revered former player who then became a surprise choice as manager and who did much to stabilise the club after a disastrous 6 months under George Burley. He then upset a lot of people by suddenly moving to Bolton and taking virtually the whole of his back room staff with him. This was followed by a strange "textgate" episode involving an attempt by Palace's then Sporting Director, Ian Moody, to obtain an opponent's team details which somehow got sent to DF's phone.

On the negative side, DF upset a lot of people in the manner of his departure and failed as a manager at Bolton then subsequently at Notts Forest.

On the positive side, he knows the culture of Crystal Palace inside out, left a squad behind him that Iain Holloway managed to get promoted at the end of the season, and the bulk of that squad under Tony Pulis avoided relegation. Steve Parish has referred in the past to his meticulous planning, desire to do the very best for the club within limited budgetary constraints and a comprehensive footballing knowledge. My understanding is that he is a successful businessman in his own right outside of football.

So, for me, DF seems to have many of the pre-requisites needed to be a successful Sporting Director. Nothing can alter what happened when he left. Clearly, everyone has is entitled to their own opinion.

I was sorry to see him go and sad at the way it happened. However, I'm delighted he's back and, for me, Crystal Palace is a better place for having him around and I wish him all success.

And yes, of course it's almost inevitable I suppose he'll leave again in the future. Let's worry about that when it happens.

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 22 Aug 17 2.50pm

Originally posted by Medway Eagle

I don't think i mentioned spending money? So not sure where your pompous pontificating opinion came from, This forum is for people to voice there opinions both you and me ok, maybe support your local team if you don't like the comments i make


but your entitled to your

FROM YOUR POST ON AUG 12TH

"I think to judge our situation after one game is premature. But I will say that for Steve Parish to appoint a manager that's philosophy of how to play is so foreign from the game we have traditionally played over the past few seasons, And to not back him in the market is unbelievable, But typical of his style. To say he is an astute Chairman, look at some of his appointments, Holloway, Warnock, Pardew he leaves so much to be desired. We currently have one recognised striker, we are a goalkeeper short and need someone to lead the defence, Today's game reminded me of the Pardew days where we were conceding so many goals, The board need to back Frank in the market, For him its like fighting with one arm behind his back,"

From your post above I would say it IS about spending money... As you say these boards are for every one of us to voice our opinions and views so don't get all up in the air and throw your toys out of your pram and throwing mud around. And as a last point I do support my local team and have done for many years now but who do you support ???

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Flightsequence Flag 22 Aug 17 2.58pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Isn't that a rather childish attitude and does it really matter if you feel comfortable with the appointment or not as he is not the club's chairman or manager but Steve Parish has appointed Freedman to assist him and he should be allowed to choose whoever he trusts to advise him

It's how I feel. I was disappointed like most when he jumped ship, and then the Cardiff text gate came to light, which left a bitter taste. That's why I feel uncomfortable. Most people move on in jobs, and although may have bad feelings, they don't act childish as you say and start grassing people up. Weren't the reasons for moving to Bolton, a lot more money (a good enough reason), but also because he couldn't have it all his own way at Palace, as he pointed out in his interview. Could that have been childish maybe?

 

Leecpfc Flag Praying for love in a lapdance... 22 Aug 17 3.06pm

Glad to have Dougie back where he belongs. Yeah he made a mistake, but he's done enough for Palace over his career to warrant forgiveness and a second chance.

I do wonder how many fair weather fans even know who he is. You know, like the ones who haven't seen us play Chanpionship football.

Edited by Leecpfc (22 Aug 2017 3.06pm)

 


Raised on a diet of broken biscuits

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 22 Aug 17 3.15pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Whatever happened with Dougie, I think this is a good apppintment and I will always have a soft spot for him. He f***ed up, it's as simple as that but at the end of the day he created some of the most memorable moments I can remember as a Palace fan and that definitely includes when he was a manager. The run of games prior to Holloway, palace were playing with a real identity, you could see the potential of how far the group could go as a team. I'm still of the firm belief that we owe probably more than we realise to him for the position we currently find ourselves in. Whether he admits it or not, he would've known he messed up and he got his just deserts in the less than impressive managerial career he's had since going to Bolton. Continuing a grudge is a Palace fans right, but for me it just seems pointless, especially when it's quite clear he loves the club himself.

Good post, I for one was angry when he left us for Bolton, and was pleased that he failed, I joined in with the greedman clan, but having worshiped him as a player, that always tipped the balance with the love him, hate him thing, he made a massive mistake and he knows it, I am now quite happy to forget the past and welcome back a club legend.

 

leejaneagles Flag 22 Aug 17 3.27pm

Understandably after everything that's happened, people are debating if we need a Director of Football, If FDB is happy with it, if we forgive Dougie for what happened, if it's just a ruse to get Dougie the Manager job.

They are all very exciting points to talk about which is probably why this subject has been glossed over a bit - what the hell qualifications or experience does Dougie have to do this job?

He was a player, than a coach, then a FAILED manager, now a Premier League Director Of Football.

That doesn't seem right to me. I'd love to at least know that since his last Management stint, he's been to University and done a degree in this field.

Going back to the point about whether FDB is happy to have a DoF, I think it's evident he is as he has always had one but why would he listen to the likes of Freedman? He's not a DoF, he's a random club legend that has been slapped with a new Title.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 22 Aug 17 4.12pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

They are all very exciting points to talk about which is probably why this subject has been glossed over a bit - what the hell qualifications or experience does Dougie have to do this job?

He was a player, than a coach, then a FAILED manager, now a Premier League Director Of Football.

That doesn't seem right to me. I'd love to at least know that since his last Management stint, he's been to University and done a degree in this field.

As I have already posted, the two most successful directors of football in the Premiership have less experience than Dougie of managing a football club and it doesn't seem to be relevant for what Steve Parish wants him to do

 

Page 10 of 12 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Freedman is back