This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Aray
Not so long ago there was a team doing quite well in the top league but then they got ahead of themselves thinking they should go to the next level. That didn't work out too well for them. Is that simple enough for you? Oh I got it. But it's not the same, is it? Charlton we're doing quite well. We are not. They were looking to go to the next level they don't belong in. We just want to have enough players in crucial positions, not leave transfers too late, not take liberties with the manager, not chuck a portion of the season away, things like that. Oh and as you mention going to the next level, what was the Pardew expansive football project or the Frank De Bulksh1t the interview all about then? I suppose that's excused? It's not the next level we should be at. It's an acceptable level of resources to a manager, heeding his warnings, and another established and respected (is he) leaving. Simple enough for you?
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
That old chestnut gets dragged out once a week by those who have run out of proper arguments. As a matter of interest one could always show the opposite side of the coin by telling a similar story about Manchester City Not so long ago there was a team doing quite well in the top league but then they got ahead of themselves thinking they should go to the next level. That worked out very well for them. You're not seriously comparing Charlton and man city....
|
|
|
Originally posted by alaneagle1
Rudi you keep repeating the same posts daily on different threads. Alan, you keep saying very little, bringing absolutely nothing to the discussions. If we had the resources necessary to a manager we would probably be clear of relegation, not thinking 'oh fvck, we've come out of 2 or 3 winnable games with 2 points and now have 4 of the top 6 to play in a row that will leave us in the relegation zone.' I'll remind you again. We chuck 3-4 games every season at least. This season it was 7. You work it out. So there's not only those but also games when there's no striker or left back or whatever. Btw, it's not my world, it's the real world that happens on a football pitch. Reading that 'your world' is probably why the same thing gets repeated. We then get examples of Charlton, Parish risking his money, us not having the money in the first place and other reasons that do not exist. What does exist is what you need to not put yourselves in danger unnecessarily, because it is every year, unnecessary. Edited by Rudi Hedman (14 Feb 2018 10.31am)
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by alaneagle1
Rudi,I might be saying very little because the sensible posters cannot get a word in. Rubbish because there's been a load of posters posting the same excuses that I've just listed. I'll repeat again for you. There's no excuses for starting the season with 1 striker and 2 keepers, then going through the next window with 2 keepers. Nobody else does it. Nobody. Did you see Sunderland finally get relegated once Defoe was injured? (Yes they had cover but not good enough) What position? It's not about the position we finish in or are in now. It's about how many results you're clear of danger and how many matches you go into with a competitive team. We do that more than we've planned for and we're fine.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by alaneagle1
Rudi,I might be saying very little because the sensible posters cannot get a word in. If we had an extra goalie we could well be in exactly the same position as even the best make mistakes but if we had bought another half decent striker back in August we should be a few goals to the better and therefore a bit higher up the table. Of course our brand new striker could have broken his leg in the first game he played but on the balance of probabilities he should have improved our side
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Alan, you keep saying very little, bringing absolutely nothing to the discussions. If we had the resources necessary to a manager we would probably be clear of relegation, not thinking 'oh fvck, we've come out of 2 or 3 winnable games with 2 points and now have 4 of the top 6 to play in a row that will leave us in the relegation zone.' I'll remind you again. We chuck 3-4 games every season at least. This season it was 7. You work it out. So there's not only those but also games when there's no striker or left back or whatever. Btw, it's not my world, it's the real world that happens on a football pitch. Reading that 'your world' is probably why the same thing gets repeated. We then get examples of Charlton, Parish risking his money, us not having the money in the first place and other reasons that do not exist. What does exist is what you need to not put yourselves in danger unnecessarily, because it is every year, unnecessary. Edited by Rudi Hedman (14 Feb 2018 10.31am) That is key so are people who are questioning parish doing so on ability or £££? If it's the latter then clearly no he is not. he is not nearly wealthy enough. If it is the former, then I think he is, I believe he is learning his lesson when he makes mistakes. We finally seem to have an infrastructure for scouting and recruitment that has been sadly lacking for a few years. Not helped by the McKay fiasco. Unfortunately the results will probably take a few windows to be realised.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Rubbish because there's been a load of posters posting the same excuses that I've just listed. I'll repeat again for you. There's no excuses for starting the season with 1 striker and 2 keepers, then going through the next window with 2 keepers. Nobody else does it. Nobody. Did you see Sunderland finally get relegated once Defoe was injured? (Yes they had cover but not good enough) What position? It's not about the position we finish in or are in now. It's about how many results you're clear of danger and how many matches you go into with a competitive team. We do that more than we've planned for and we're fine. Absolutely correct Rudi. mismanagement of last two windows is indefensible even for the Parish apologists.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Rubbish because there's been a load of posters posting the same excuses that I've just listed. I'll repeat again for you. There's no excuses for starting the season with 1 striker and 2 keepers, then going through the next window with 2 keepers. Nobody else does it. Nobody. Did you see Sunderland finally get relegated once Defoe was injured? (Yes they had cover but not good enough) What position? It's not about the position we finish in or are in now. It's about how many results you're clear of danger and how many matches you go into with a competitive team. We do that more than we've planned for and we're fine. OK I’m not going to get a position from you fair enough.
Palace 13th 2017/18. |
|
|
Originally posted by alaneagle1
OK I’m not going to get a position from you fair enough. Sunderland underinvested for many years. It's not about the position being predicted. You have a striker available at all times and you get more points. You don't chuck 3/4-7 games away and you get more points and safety. It's like focusing in a job early in your career with good experience. The money will come. Or in a meritocracy like sales or similar. Focus on the work and the sales and wages follow. Chelsea? Who cares? John Terry? Now? Couldn't care less.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch
That is key so are people who are questioning parish doing so on ability or £££? If it's the latter then clearly no he is not. he is not nearly wealthy enough. If it is the former, then I think he is, I believe he is learning his lesson when he makes mistakes. We finally seem to have an infrastructure for scouting and recruitment that has been sadly lacking for a few years. Not helped by the McKay fiasco. Unfortunately the results will probably take a few windows to be realised. Thats all well and good by its the premier league, no time for everyone to get comfy with their feet under the table. No such patience is given to premier league managers, well apart from super Al so why should we expect results from the 'best recruitment environment we've had'. Seriously every team is mainly looking at the same players anyway for goodness sake. Just excuses.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch
That is key so are people who are questioning parish doing so on ability or £££? If it's the latter then clearly no he is not. he is not nearly wealthy enough. If it is the former, then I think he is, I believe he is learning his lesson when he makes mistakes. We finally seem to have an infrastructure for scouting and recruitment that has been sadly lacking for a few years. Not helped by the McKay fiasco. Unfortunately the results will probably take a few windows to be realised. I was talking about resources at the manager's disposal. Freedman it seems is a scout. It appears somebody still needs to speak out or be taken notice of if they are.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by MonsterMunch
Thats all well and good by its the premier league, no time for everyone to get comfy with their feet under the table. No such patience is given to premier league managers, well apart from super Al so why should we expect results from the 'best recruitment environment we've had'. Seriously every team is mainly looking at the same players anyway for goodness sake. Just excuses. Fair point sack the scouts more money for players
|
|
|
Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch
Fair point sack the scouts more money for players Now theres an idea - would it make one iota of difference I wonder? We would lose Dougies little black book though so thats a bummer. Edited by MonsterMunch (14 Feb 2018 11.34am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Alan, you keep saying very little, bringing absolutely nothing to the discussions. If we had the resources necessary to a manager we would probably be clear of relegation, not thinking 'oh fvck, we've come out of 2 or 3 winnable games with 2 points and now have 4 of the top 6 to play in a row that will leave us in the relegation zone.' I'll remind you again. We chuck 3-4 games every season at least. This season it was 7. You work it out. So there's not only those but also games when there's no striker or left back or whatever. Btw, it's not my world, it's the real world that happens on a football pitch. Reading that 'your world' is probably why the same thing gets repeated. We then get examples of Charlton, Parish risking his money, us not having the money in the first place and other reasons that do not exist. What does exist is what you need to not put yourselves in danger unnecessarily, because it is every year, unnecessary. Edited by Rudi Hedman (14 Feb 2018 10.31am) In the last August window over £30 million was spent ad more would have been spent if late transfers had gone through. I think there is an argument that we should not have spent the money on Sakho but instead used money over 2 or 3 players. However places like this were screaming out for him after his performances the previous season. This left a thin squad. We are close to our FPP limits. This to me does not look like giving inadequate resources to manager. in the latest transfer window our closeness to FPP was a factor. I think there is £30 million for the 2018 windows combined. This is why we were looking to loan players with a right to buy as this will free more money. We brought in a striker and centre back and a young midfielder in on loan so have increased depth of squad for about £10 million. The goalkeeper we wanted was out of contract in summer and his club decided not to release and wanted full market value for him. At the time We would have been mad to pay it as that £8 million is another player to bolster our paper thin squad. ( I think that there will be an announcement over next 2 days of an international keeper coming in on a free)The other player we were after was Amadou We wanted on loan with right to buy and his club wanted a sale not a loan. Again I don't think that is inadequate resources
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace in the Blood
We have a striker, centre back and midfielder out for the rest of the season so the three purchases / loans that you have mentioned haven't actually increased the depth of the squad at all
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Oh I got it. But it's not the same, is it? Charlton we're doing quite well. We are not. They were looking to go to the next level they don't belong in. We just want to have enough players in crucial positions, not leave transfers too late, not take liberties with the manager, not chuck a portion of the season away, things like that. Oh and as you mention going to the next level, what was the Pardew expansive football project or the Frank De Bulksh1t the interview all about then? I suppose that's excused? It's not the next level we should be at. It's an acceptable level of resources to a manager, heeding his warnings, and another established and respected (is he) leaving. Simple enough for you? Yes. Thank you. My simple argument is that we could do a lot worse than this and those that think we're bigger than we are risk making the same mistake as Charlton. I like simple arguments me as I find the complicated ones are full of sh!t. And that brings me back to your various points on Charlton. Of course Charlton had several years of being mid-table on a consistent basis. Not many clubs have achieved this - as its the nether region of the premier league. You cant compete with the expanding number of big boys with billionaire owners using the club to buy publicity or respectability. Seems like your argument hinges on Charlton wanting to be part of a group they didn't belong to. Then I'd say the OP and others are making the same mistake as their fans did back then. I'd argue surviving is as much as we can expect while we consolidate in the top league. No? Then what is our level? Southampton? Ah they are struggling too. Who else? West Brom? Ooops. Next? Burnley? Oh how many games have they won since their key defender got injured? This season injuries are killing us and the club is borrowing money to buy players so Parish has to find bargains. That is our level. As for the rest of your response. Of course it is "excusable" that Parish - with Pardew and FdB wanted to take us to another footballing level. Just dont do it while leaving us short of a left-back (Pardew admitted it was his mistake) or with only a few short weeks of training. In retrospect he should have gone for Roy then. But lets face it - we all wanted a young dynamic progressive man. I doubt Dyche would have come - his next club will be bigger. Which brings us to another key point. The role of the manager in all this. The likes of Curbishly don't come around very often. Sorry but Pulis and Allardyce are not in that mode. Coppell was our last equivalent and a previous chairman threw away that legacy. We seem to disagree on the qualities of the current one. Good day
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I do not disagree on the qualities of Roy. The keeper situation just shows how Parish must view the manager once he's got him in. When he hires him it's full of promises but when he's in the necessities aren't delivered. We'll need Guaita and the Ronnow fella next season. Therefore aim for both and if it's only one in then fine. But no, can't do that and satisfy the man we have when he's in charge and him to stay. Edited by Rudi Hedman (14 Feb 2018 12.08pm) Maybe I wasn't clear who the subject was in my sentence. I was talking about the chairman's qualities. I agree however we definitely need another keeper. Like yesterday. We should be picking up a free agent soon. Maybe Parish agreed the strategy with Roy...
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.