You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > HS2 Review
November 21 2026 9.17pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

HS2 Review


Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Lyons550 Flag Shirley 21 Aug 19 2.48pm

So yet again, another big project is under threat due to escalating costs, campaigners against etc...will ANYTHING ever be built again as planned?

[Link]

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 21 Aug 19 2.54pm

Spot on.

A recent addition to the list is crossrail - whatever happened there, thought it was finished.

Now lapsed into 6 monthly bailouts not opening for 2 years.

The costs of HS2 are mind-boggling, a true money-pit.


 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 21 Aug 19 2.59pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Spot on.

A recent addition to the list is crossrail - whatever happened there, thought it was finished.

Now lapsed into 6 monthly bailouts not opening for 2 years.

The costs of HS2 are mind-boggling, a true money-pit.


Most infrastructure projects are though...its the financial pay off in the long run that matters and the benefit to the country as a whole.

£30bn overrun is less than what we'd be paying the EU!

Get it done as far as Birmingham...THEN review stage 2!

I'd prefer them to then look at The Northern Powerhouse rail project instead, which aims to connect East to West and would light a fire under the Northern economy.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Aug 19 3.04pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

Get it done as far as Birmingham...THEN review stage 2!

The existing rail link from London to Birmingham is already quick enough though.

I do have a vested interest as the second stage runs 150 yards from my house

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 21 Aug 19 3.20pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The existing rail link from London to Birmingham is already quick enough though.

I do have a vested interest as the second stage runs 150 yards from my house


I've often wondered what the benefit of a reduced time of 60mins is actually worth? for me its more about connecting the parts of the country that are struggling, or at the very least that HS2 would increase goods traffic as well, taking the burden off of the roads.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 21 Aug 19 3.54pm

You may well ask what benefit is HS2 anyway?

Does it connect to Heathrow, Europe, things modern Britain needs?

No, it connects to Euston.

Enjoy your time-saving - you will be able to use the tube just like everybody else.

 

jeeagles Flag 21 Aug 19 11.11pm

It's a line that goes though several "key marginal constituencies" and a "brave" political decision.

Best to get a inquiry in place before an election and ensure the outcome of it is announced afterwards to minimise the impact on votes.

Phase 1 on its own offers the lowest benefit. It may even have been better to start in the north and work their way down, but it's been assessed as a stand alone project.

For phase 1 land had been bought and construction has started. Stopping halt way through would cost loads and deliver £0 economic benefit. Might as well finish it, especially if some of the funding is borrowed money from private sources.

The real benefits will come when phases 2 and beyond are added.

 

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 22 Aug 19 1.25am

It takes an hour 50 mins to get from Warrington to Euston on Glasgow express Virgin West coast. We have never needed HS2 just need the line from L/pool to Leeds fully electrified and updated. Cost would have been a fraction of what has already been wasted.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 22 Aug 19 8.18am

Originally posted by jeeagles

It's a line that goes though several "key marginal constituencies" and a "brave" political decision.

Best to get a inquiry in place before an election and ensure the outcome of it is announced afterwards to minimise the impact on votes.

Phase 1 on its own offers the lowest benefit. It may even have been better to start in the north and work their way down, but it's been assessed as a stand alone project.

For phase 1 land had been bought and construction has started. Stopping halt way through would cost loads and deliver £0 economic benefit. Might as well finish it, especially if some of the funding is borrowed money from private sources.

The real benefits will come when phases 2 and beyond are added.

I really cannot make my mind up about HS2. The line to Manchester may not save much time and in isolation is not worth it. However if the plan is to build a high link up the spine of the country to Scotland linking the major cities and also have branches to Wales and the Southwest then it maybe justified.

as jeeagles states it probabley would have been better to start in the north.

 


One more point

Midlands Eagle Flag 22 Aug 19 8.43am

Originally posted by Badger11

However if the plan is to build a high link up the spine of the country to Scotland linking the major cities then it maybe justified.

You may have to stop for passport control at the Scottish border if Ms Sturgeon gets her own way

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 22 Aug 19 8.57am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

You may have to stop for passport control at the Scottish border if Ms Sturgeon gets her own way

If Scotland has gone independent then we won't be building it to their border. They can pay to link it to the UK network.

 


One more point

davenotamonkey Flag 22 Aug 19 10.04am

Originally posted by steeleye20

Spot on.

A recent addition to the list is crossrail - whatever happened there, thought it was finished.

Now lapsed into 6 monthly bailouts not opening for 2 years.

The costs of HS2 are mind-boggling, a true money-pit.


Scrap it, suck up the sink-costs (dreadful as they are), ensure the consultants are never retained by HMG ever again. Next steps:

Plough money into the aforementioned Northern Powerhouse lines, AND a rapid high-freight-volume connection between Tyneside and Liverpool.

Then establish free ports in both. State aid in both regions to kick start industry and economy feeding off the Free ports. Ensure all bidding contractors will use UK labour as much as possible.

All possible if we leave the EU. Not possible (as under the Withdrawal Agreement) if we're told we can't diverge from their "economic model", subject to their state-aid rules, customs union and procurement diktats.

The south has had enough money pumped into it. It's time we re-balanced this country.

 

davenotamonkey Flag 22 Aug 19 10.05am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

You may have to stop for passport control at the Scottish border if Ms Sturgeon gets her own way

Maybe if she charges us to get in, she can try to recoup some of that 7% deficit she's running (highest in Europe, and well outside the limits for EU membership)

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 22 Aug 19 10.21am

I read they are considering reducing the speed of HS2 to try and stop the costs escalating, so you probably wont get there much quicker anyway.

Well they are already out of control, who would pay 56 billions plus to rip up and re-place a railway line, at the cost of other necessary improvements to the UK railway system that would give far more benefit.

You despair of any reason or rationality, it is as though the UK is unable to think anything through.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 22 Aug 19 10.26am

Originally posted by steeleye20

You may well ask what benefit is HS2 anyway?

Does it connect to Heathrow, Europe, things modern Britain needs?

No, it connects to Euston.

Enjoy your time-saving - you will be able to use the tube just like everybody else.

I find myself in the awkward position of agreeing with you 100%.

I'm off for a lie-down.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

jeeagles Flag 22 Aug 19 10.31am

Originally posted by davenotamonkey

Scrap it, suck up the sink-costs (dreadful as they are), ensure the consultants are never retained by HMG ever again. Next steps:

Consultants fees are more likely to be a result of civil servants not making make their minds up and coming up with stupid processes to justify their own existence. Consultants come and go all the time, civil servants are unsackable.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 22 Aug 19 12.18pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

I read they are considering reducing the speed of HS2 to try and stop the costs escalating, so you probably wont get there much quicker anyway.

Well they are already out of control, who would pay 56 billions plus to rip up and re-place a railway line, at the cost of other necessary improvements to the UK railway system that would give far more benefit.

You despair of any reason or rationality, it is as though the UK is unable to think anything through.

If the politicians who ran this country acted like adults this would not be necessary. Infrastructure is a long term investment whereas politicians are only thinking about this week.

A sensible policy would be to have a infrastructure committee with experts nominated by all the major parties. They would plan for the future with the parties agreeing in principle to the plan. The only thing the politicians would then do is decide how much and how quickly to adopt the plan. So maybe in times of austerity they slow it down or speed it up but the plan is the same.

Fat chance any of this happening.

 


One more point

W12 22 Aug 19 1.05pm

If they are estimating £56bn then you know it's going to cost at least twice that. We have a nation debt of £1.8 trillion mostly thanks to Tony Blair and unless we want the economy to implode then we need to take drastic steps to reduce this. This one is a no brainer.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Aug 19 2.48pm

Funny how the Victorians could do this and more easily. And entrepreneurs would pay for it.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 22 Aug 19 2.51pm

Originally posted by davenotamonkey

Scrap it, suck up the sink-costs (dreadful as they are), ensure the consultants are never retained by HMG ever again. Next steps:

Plough money into the aforementioned Northern Powerhouse lines, AND a rapid high-freight-volume connection between Tyneside and Liverpool.

Then establish free ports in both. State aid in both regions to kick start industry and economy feeding off the Free ports. Ensure all bidding contractors will use UK labour as much as possible.

All possible if we leave the EU. Not possible (as under the Withdrawal Agreement) if we're told we can't diverge from their "economic model", subject to their state-aid rules, customs union and procurement diktats.

The south has had enough money pumped into it. It's time we re-balanced this country.

This...and include Hull in the mix

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > HS2 Review