You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Spurs v Palace match thread
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Spurs v Palace match thread


Page 10 of 11 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 15 Sep 19 11.01pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

If anybody is saying we weren't crap then they are wrong. As for people saying Spurs were great, as I already said they weren't. They played direct and we couldn't handle it.
Fair enough, there was a degree of accuracy and urgency about what they did. I will say that. They could be in the top four at the end of the season but they don't seem as good as last season to me anyway.
Could have played Woods as a sweeper or Kouyate as a central defender. We lack pace at the back even if everyone was fit. Or am I also so wrong there? And yes some innovative tactics would not go amiss.
No point in not conceding anymore when you're already well down. You have to change things, you have to try to outscore them if you can't defend. Our team and manager seem literally unable to adapt at all.
I hardly think I'm the only one saying it. As for pundits - it doesn't make that much difference to me what Andy Gray or even Gary Neville thinks. I'm pretty sure I'm also not the only one who ignores them either.
We are Palace and the pundits have basically ignored us for years except to condescend us on the odd occasion.

You would play Woods, with just one first team start under his belt ( against Colchester ! ) as a sweeper ??! Seriously ?? Against England’s centre forward.....and if we lack pace at the back you think Kouyate would solve that ? If there’s a word for those tactics I for one wouldn’t be calling them “ innovative “.

As for outscoring teams, you may have noticed that we lack a consistent goal scorer and that prior to yesterday our defensive record was good. Hardly the basis for advocating all out attack . That would leave even more space for the opposition to play in.

It’s strange what a defeat against one of the best sides in Europe does to people.....

 


Old, Ungifted and White

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 Sep 19 11.11pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

You would play Woods, with just one first team start under his belt ( against Colchester ! ) as a sweeper ??! Seriously ?? Against England’s centre forward.....and if we lack pace at the back you think Kouyate would solve that ? If there’s a word for those tactics I for one wouldn’t be calling them “ innovative “.

As for outscoring teams, you may have noticed that we lack a consistent goal scorer and that prior to yesterday our defensive record was good. Hardly the basis for advocating all out attack . That would leave even more space for the opposition to play in.

It’s strange what a defeat against one of the best sides in Europe does to people.....

Other teams change and bring on subs when clearly things aren't working. It was clear nothing was working early in the first half. The rhetorical question is when were our changes. There isn't a question mark. I'm tired of the team not responding when necessary. Around half of our performances so far this season have been poor; Villa was a decent performance. Man U was lucky. Everton solid.
You are right we can't score. God forbid we practice set pieces or something as innovative as that. If you can't score change something. We have who we have - do something different with them. Catch an opponent out. We are far too predictable and we have been worked out.

 


Red and Blue Army!

salop-eagle Flag 16 Sep 19 7.17am

I think Saturday shows just how important James McArthur is to our midfield. For all his faults, and he has a few, his energy, harassing and ability to work box to box for 90 mins was sadly lacking. He epitomises the work rate and discipline that we need against the top teams!

Edited by salop-eagle (16 Sep 2019 7.19am)

 

EddieMac Flag 16 Sep 19 8.52am

We were battered by the Champions League finalists who had a very good day and one of those days when all their chances hit the back of the net.

They have much better players than us all the way from 1 to 11.

Nobody expected us to win and we didnt win so move on and except the fact that we are no where near their level.

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 16 Sep 19 8.58am

Originally posted by EddieMac

We were battered by the Champions League finalists who had a very good day and one of those days when all their chances hit the back of the net.

They have much better players than us all the way from 1 to 11.

Nobody expected us to win and we didnt win so move on and except the fact that we are no where near their level.

Perfect summation of the situation . We will have better days and probably worse days that is football at any club. COYP

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 16 Sep 19 9.32am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Genius. Out of interest, who would you play in the sweeper role ?

How about Eddie McGoldrick. I seem to remember that working extremely well at Liverpool a few decades ago

 

OneWayTicketToMars Flag Selsdon 16 Sep 19 9.43am

This:
We were battered by the Champions League finalists who had a very good day and one of those days when all their chances hit the back of the net.

They have much better players than us all the way from 1 to 11.

Nobody expected us to win and we didnt win so move on and except the fact that we are no where near their level.

------------------------------------------------

I totally agree .... we will have are up and down days this season ... this was one of them. Very one of of spurs players is top class and I expected to get beat maybe by one or two .. it is what it is ... get past this game and on to the next. COYP

 


Record crowd 51,482 - The Whitehorse was rocking - Second Div Champs 1978 - 79 ... 'wot a night !

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Sep 19 10.21am

I was expecting us to be defeated but never expected to lose by 4 goals. I was horrified with the H/T score - at least we drew the second half.

At the end of the day, Hodgson’s target is to keep us in the PL and he believes that the style of play is best suited to achieve that objective.Functional, not attractive, a hard watch and this will continue until the end of the season. Bournemouth play very much on the front foot whereas we are all about shape discipline etc etc.

We will struggle to win games, and supporters just have to accept that we are not going to be entertained and the team might just pull off an unlikely win or two.Long hard season devoid of entertainment but if we remain in the PL many will feel that end justified the means.


 

cpj Flag Kent 16 Sep 19 10.57am

We are a poor team.

We have a poor keeper who lets any shot in that goes at his near post. We have two full-backs who cannot defend and criminally we have no backup for either position. Our centre-halves are slow and ageing. Our midfielders have no creativity in them (indeed thay can barely pass to their own team) - yet we have two creative midfielders on the bench every week. Our wide players seem to have forgotten how to take people on and cross the ball, and out forward's main talent is that he's good at running about.

I've followed Palace for over 50 years and have been a season ticket holder for 35, yet I cannot remember a time when I've been less enthusiastic about going to watch them play. Even in the dark days of the mid-80s there were players at the club I wanted to see play. Hodgson has sucked the life out of the players he has and has just one method of playing. How often do we score an early goal? We must be the lowest first-half scorers in recent years. Football is meant to be entertainment - if this is the best we can expect from Hodgson then it is time he went and took his overdue retirement. Not all his fault of course - the appalling transfer policy in recent times has left him with an expensive, ageing squad of players that are not going to get any better. Rather than risk signing youngsters from the Championship, we go for expensive PL castoffs or foreign players who rarely seem to make the grade for us.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Sep 19 11.11am

Originally posted by cpj

We are a poor team.

We have a poor keeper who lets any shot in that goes at his near post. We have two full-backs who cannot defend and criminally we have no backup for either position. Our centre-halves are slow and ageing. Our midfielders have no creativity in them (indeed thay can barely pass to their own team) - yet we have two creative midfielders on the bench every week. Our wide players seem to have forgotten how to take people on and cross the ball, and out forward's main talent is that he's good at running about.

I've followed Palace for over 50 years and have been a season ticket holder for 35, yet I cannot remember a time when I've been less enthusiastic about going to watch them play. Even in the dark days of the mid-80s there were players at the club I wanted to see play. Hodgson has sucked the life out of the players he has and has just one method of playing. How often do we score an early goal? We must be the lowest first-half scorers in recent years. Football is meant to be entertainment - if this is the best we can expect from Hodgson then it is time he went and took his overdue retirement. Not all his fault of course - the appalling transfer policy in recent times has left him with an expensive, ageing squad of players that are not going to get any better. Rather than risk signing youngsters from the Championship, we go for expensive PL castoffs or foreign players who rarely seem to make the grade for us.

The sentiments expressed will strike a chord with many supporters.

Many just don’t look forward to attending home games any more, my good self included but Hodgson is setting us up with what he feels he needs to do to stave off relegation with the players he has at his disposal. Boring, negative dross on account of a poor squad.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 16 Sep 19 11.13am

Originally posted by EddieMac

We were battered by the Champions League finalists who had a very good day and one of those days when all their chances hit the back of the net.

They have much better players than us all the way from 1 to 11.

Nobody expected us to win and we didnt win so move on and except the fact that we are no where near their level.


We dont have one player who would get in their team and im including Wilf in that whos value is dropping with every game

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 16 Sep 19 11.19am

Watched the highlights. Looks like Sakho definitely wasn't ready to start, but with no other fit options and 5 CBs in the squad that's not something that can really be complained about.

However, I maintain as I have since AWB was sold that neither of our full-backs should be starters.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Sep 19 11.27am

Originally posted by Bangell

Watched the highlights. Looks like Sakho definitely wasn't ready to start, but with no other fit options and 5 CBs in the squad that's not something that can really be complained about.

However, I maintain as I have since AWB was sold that neither of our full-backs should be starters.

When I witnessed Sakho coming on against A.Villa I thought he was carrying more weight than previously.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 16 Sep 19 12.46pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Other teams change and bring on subs when clearly things aren't working. It was clear nothing was working early in the first half. The rhetorical question is when were our changes. There isn't a question mark. I'm tired of the team not responding when necessary. Around half of our performances so far this season have been poor; Villa was a decent performance. Man U was lucky. Everton solid.
You are right we can't score. God forbid we practice set pieces or something as innovative as that. If you can't score change something. We have who we have - do something different with them. Catch an opponent out. We are far too predictable and we have been worked out.

If we are poor as you keep bleating on about, how are we third on current form this calendar year?

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 16 Sep 19 1.15pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

How about Eddie McGoldrick. I seem to remember that working extremely well at Liverpool a few decades ago

9 lucky goals
What you meant to do about that then

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 16 Sep 19 1.33pm

Originally posted by cpj

We are a poor team.

We have a poor keeper who lets any shot in that goes at his near post. We have two full-backs who cannot defend and criminally we have no backup for either position. Our centre-halves are slow and ageing. Our midfielders have no creativity in them (indeed thay can barely pass to their own team) - yet we have two creative midfielders on the bench every week. Our wide players seem to have forgotten how to take people on and cross the ball, and out forward's main talent is that he's good at running about.

I've followed Palace for over 50 years and have been a season ticket holder for 35, yet I cannot remember a time when I've been less enthusiastic about going to watch them play. Even in the dark days of the mid-80s there were players at the club I wanted to see play. Hodgson has sucked the life out of the players he has and has just one method of playing. How often do we score an early goal? We must be the lowest first-half scorers in recent years. Football is meant to be entertainment - if this is the best we can expect from Hodgson then it is time he went and took his overdue retirement. Not all his fault of course - the appalling transfer policy in recent times has left him with an expensive, ageing squad of players that are not going to get any better. Rather than risk signing youngsters from the Championship, we go for expensive PL castoffs or foreign players who rarely seem to make the grade for us.

Poor keeper? Lets bring back Hennessey then he lets them in near post far post, high, low, all over.......wonder why you bother going at all??..Our lack of goalscorers is much more important than the keeper!

 

PatrickA Flag London 16 Sep 19 1.54pm

It’s a strange situation.
As others have pointed out we are in the top 6 for form over the calendar year.
Yet it doesn’t feel that way.
We are bottom of the goalscoring chart this season and seem unlikely to move too far up the chart anytime soon.
I was fortunate to witness terrific victories last season at Manchester City, Newcastle and Arsenal.
But I also sat through terrible performances v Brighton, Southampton (h), Wolves (h) and Newcastle (h).
Perhaps this is just the life of a football supporter.
But I do question whether Hodgson is getting the best out of the current squad and I don’t like his negative philosophy.
Yes he has 40 years more experience in the game than me and is a respected manager.
But I still have my doubts while acknowledging he can organise a defence.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 Sep 19 2.40pm

Originally posted by Painter

If we are poor as you keep bleating on about, how are we third on current form this calendar year?

We're worse than last year. We were uninspiring for much of that. I have put forward my reasons - why not tell me why I'm wrong instead of just citing a form table that's of no relevance to the actual league table. I have predicted 16th. From what you say you must think we're going to finish third. I wonder who's being realistic.

 


Red and Blue Army!

HerneBayPalace Flag Herne Bay 16 Sep 19 2.52pm

I like many fans at the ground headed back down to the bar after 30 mins, only to leave at half time. What a waste of time and money that was.

We were absolutely useless.

Roy picked the right team for what he had available against a good side who were up for it. I can't blame Roy at all, as I don't really know what he could have done differently.

I do think we need to remember we were playing Spurs, last years Champions League finalists.

We can't expect to be putting in performances every week against top 4 clubs.

The manor of the defeat hurts but I will pick myself up and head over to Selhurst on Sunday to do it all again expecting a reaction.

Don't waste your energy or time being annoyed by this result.

There are 3 things you can be certain of in life - death, taxes and our full backs being roasted in the 19/20 season.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 16 Sep 19 2.58pm

Most teams try to improve there team if they can, Batshuayi and AWB were key players and were not replaced even if that had been loans, so we are undoubtedly worse off, I expect loans will be found in January lets hope its not too late.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Page 10 of 11 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Spurs v Palace match thread