You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Alexander Sörloth
November 22 2026 7.46pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Alexander Sörloth


Page 10 of 32 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Petereagle Flag Brockley 16 Aug 20 11.38am

Originally posted by EddieMac

But if he is being sold half way through a 2 year loan deal to a different club and we get the money then it just proves we wanted rid of him and nothing amateurish about it.

I believe there was a £5m loan to buy option? In which case £5m should be coming Palace's way?

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 16 Aug 20 11.52am

Originally posted by Petereagle

I believe there was a £5m loan to buy option? In which case £5m should be coming Palace's way?

Or was it an ' obligation ' to buy ? That's how I interpreted it and the reason why the only fee Palace can expect to get is the £6m from Trabanspor

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Putitout Flag Oxford 16 Aug 20 12.07pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Interesting do you have a link please?

It’s the Mail on line, quoting the Sun, quoting Newton.
As with all of these stories , you take their word for it or not as the case might be. The fact that he says Sorloth, is Palaces player to sell is very telling. Detail is still not there but , it would indicate , Palace have control ,if only for the minute. He is not quiet another Stan Collymore, yet.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 16 Aug 20 12.26pm

Originally posted by Putitout


If Sorloth, is still a Palace player Leipzig , have to have Palaces permission to even talk to the player. If this story is not fake, then Palace would have to be completely in on this. Which would give the impression everything is working in their own interests.


No they don't

Sorloth has a deal with his loan club for 2 years which has a buy out clause.

If Leipzig want him then the clause is used to buy out the player contract and then Leipzig can purchase him it's nothing to do with Palace they handed their rights away with that clause.

To people stating as well you need to wait the 2 years to buy is not correct you can buy for the set price at any point the 2 years is the limit so once that has expired if they do not purchase contract is done you miss out.

It works the same way as player minimum release fees the difference being the contract is with one club plus they loan the player for a set term.

CLub has no say if you have buy out/release clauses hit that you just need to agree terms with player.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Palace in the Blood Flag 16 Aug 20 12.27pm

None of us know exact terms but from what I have deduced (which could be wrong).The Buy clause is only operational at end of next season and is triggered by performance/appearance for them next season. If true this means they can not buy and sell on till then.

We still own player but they have an agreed loan till end of next season. Thus any sale now will have agreement with both parties.

This could be done by buying out their loan contract

Accepting an offer of purchase from them now

Agreeing a purchase by 3rd club with both Palace and loan club sharing the fee in some way.

Since the Turkish club is short of cash I suspect 3rd option is most likely

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 16 Aug 20 12.50pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


No they don't

Sorloth has a deal with his loan club for 2 years which has a buy out clause.

If Leipzig want him then the clause is used to buy out the player contract and then Leipzig can purchase him it's nothing to do with Palace they handed their rights away with that clause.

To people stating as well you need to wait the 2 years to buy is not correct you can buy for the set price at any point the 2 years is the limit so once that has expired if they do not purchase contract is done you miss out.

It works the same way as player minimum release fees the difference being the contract is with one club plus they loan the player for a set term.

CLub has no say if you have buy out/release clauses hit that you just need to agree terms with player.

The player belongs to Palace until anyone else buys him. How any sale is arranged is for the club to arrange . He might have to complete the loan. But Leipzig, or any other prospective buyer ,, will sooner deal now with Palace ,than wait to get ripped right off by the Turkish team. No one actually knows the terms of Sorloths loan. It’s become the thing to predict the worst of possibilities. As it’s Palace.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 16 Aug 20 1.36pm

Trabzonspor were kicked out of Europe for failing to comply with FFP, but does anyone know if it included a transfer ban, or whether they are even able to fund the purchase of Sorloth?

No one from either club has actually confirmed the terms of the deal, have they? Personally, if we could get the money back for what we paid for him then that would seem fair. He never produced anything for us and we didn't give him more time to develop, thus get our money back and move on.

 

EddieMac Flag 16 Aug 20 2.28pm

It’s all guess work. Only the clubs and players know the real situation.

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 16 Aug 20 3.10pm

What with the player and agent moaning, not long after he arrived at Palace, cos he couldn't get in the team I wonder if he is a bad egg that the club just wanted rid of as soon as possible.
If he hadn't scored a 20 plus goals for the Turkish team then I doubt anyone would care that he went on a 2 year loan with no recall (again, maybe cos they just didn't wan't him back at the club at all).

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 16 Aug 20 4.12pm

I suppose one good thing to come out of this is, we may have another £6-8m to reinvest during this window

 

lefty27 Flag ipswich 16 Aug 20 5.01pm

Not sure that’s correct. Palace hold his registration as he is a palace player. The Turkish team can buy him at the end of two years, they cannot buy him today for 6 million.
The athletic seem to think we could recall him for a fee which is why we are reluctant to do so.
Also he can choose to end his loan early and force a move to another club, the option to buy was still dependent on him agreeing person terms with the club.


No they don't

Sorloth has a deal with his loan club for 2 years which has a buy out clause.

If Leipzig want him then the clause is used to buy out the player contract and then Leipzig can purchase him it's nothing to do with Palace they handed their rights away with that clause.

To people stating as well you need to wait the 2 years to buy is not correct you can buy for the set price at any point the 2 years is the limit so once that has expired if they do not purchase contract is done you miss out.

It works the same way as player minimum release fees the difference being the contract is with one club plus they loan the player for a set term.

CLub has no say if you have buy out/release clauses hit that you just need to agree terms with player.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 16 Aug 20 5.50pm

Originally posted by lefty27

Not sure that’s correct. Palace hold his registration as he is a palace player. The Turkish team can buy him at the end of two years, they cannot buy him today for 6 million.
The athletic seem to think we could recall him for a fee which is why we are reluctant to do so.
Also he can choose to end his loan early and force a move to another club, the option to buy was still dependent on him agreeing person terms with the club.


No they don't

Sorloth has a deal with his loan club for 2 years which has a buy out clause.

If Leipzig want him then the clause is used to buy out the player contract and then Leipzig can purchase him it's nothing to do with Palace they handed their rights away with that clause.

To people stating as well you need to wait the 2 years to buy is not correct you can buy for the set price at any point the 2 years is the limit so once that has expired if they do not purchase contract is done you miss out.

It works the same way as player minimum release fees the difference being the contract is with one club plus they loan the player for a set term.

CLub has no say if you have buy out/release clauses hit that you just need to agree terms with player.

So if this is correct and AS chooses to end his loan to force a move, all transfer fee comes to Palace?

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 16 Aug 20 6.25pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

So if this is correct and AS chooses to end his loan to force a move, all transfer fee comes to Palace?

Minus 1 years loan fee. Why not? The Turks owe us anyway if he completes two years. Until they pay up and complete the transfer he is ours .
This was Newton’s, point Sorloth, will only complete the loan if we don’t sell him , as their manager he should know.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 16 Aug 20 6.29pm

Originally posted by Putitout

Minus 1 years loan fee. Why not? The Turks owe us anyway if he completes two years. Until they pay up and complete the transfer he is ours .
This was Newton’s, point Sorloth, will only complete the loan if we don’t sell him , as their manager he should know.

Fingers crossed then. Maybe we won’t have to pay loan fee if player ends loan. Could be some bonus money in transfer pot, be interesting to know how much Leipzig value him at.

 

daven Flag Hailsham 16 Aug 20 7.33pm

Please forgive me for dragging up the past, but can anyone remember where the information came from that we don't have a return clause. I looked on the cpfc website and it just says that he has gone on a 2 year loan.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 16 Aug 20 7.38pm

Originally posted by daven

Please forgive me for dragging up the past, but can anyone remember where the information came from that we don't have a return clause. I looked on the cpfc website and it just says that he has gone on a 2 year loan.

There was a £5m loan 2 buy option. Not Friedman's finest moment, but at that stage, Palace wanted to get rid. Hindsight's a wonderful thing!

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 17 Aug 20 12.34pm

Originally posted by Putitout

Minus 1 years loan fee. Why not? The Turks owe us anyway if he completes two years. Until they pay up and complete the transfer he is ours .
This was Newton’s, point Sorloth, will only complete the loan if we don’t sell him , as their manager he should know.

exactly - he is our player so if an offer comes in and the player wants to go then the deal can go through. We will need to pay Turks for breaking the loan deal 1 year early.

He is contracted to Palace until 2022, the buy out option is at the end of the 2021 season, not now.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 17 Aug 20 1.43pm

The Club will not willingly reveal any detail of the deal unless they can put a positive spin on it.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

EddieMac Flag 17 Aug 20 2.05pm

Everyone seems to be just presuming that the club made a pigs ear of this deal. No of us know the facts on this one.

 

daven Flag Hailsham 17 Aug 20 2.25pm

Thats what I was wondering, where was it reported about the clauses or lack of them in this deal. If anyone can remember,

 

Page 10 of 32 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Alexander Sörloth