You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs Brentford - Match Thread
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace vs Brentford - Match Thread


Page 10 of 12 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 31 Aug 22 6.19pm

Interesting to read today’s comments compared to those made immediately after the game. Still a sense that PV’s substitutions didn’t work and would have been better left on the bench but a bit more acknowledgment that his decision to respond to Brentford’s changes wasn’t the sign of a tactically inept manager. Edouard for Mateta (56 min) and Ayew for Schlupp (73 min) were sensible decisions. Bringing Luca on for Eze at the same time exposes the limitations of our squad in midfield but had it been a fit Jimmy Mac would have been a sensible move. We lost control in midfield after that. Maybe that was because Eze came off as people here suggest or maybe because Franck loaded midfield. Either way he responded 4 minutes later by going 5 at the back with Mitchell on for Olise - the same 5 who played so well against Liverpool. Reasonable to expect they’d cope with Brentford for the last 10 mins plus.

Also seeing recognition that the defence has to take its share of the blame. We defended deeper and deeper and failed to clear our lines properly with Zaha and Ayew we had options for the out ball but couldn’t find them. If JW was indeed “confused” about his role in 5 at the back he has a short memory given where he played against Liverpool. We failed to stop the cross at source, allowed a free header in the box, have a keeper who’s scared of crosses, and lack a Gary Cahill type leader in defence.

Finally, Wilf scored a worldly but when it comes to tactical knowledge he’s no Pep Guardiola. I agree with the comment that he should have kept his opinions for the dressing room.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 31 Aug 22 6.23pm

We are missing the aerial presence and experience of Kouyate imo.

Edited by steeleye20 (31 Aug 2022 6.24pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Aug 22 7.10pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

We are missing the aerial presence and experience of Kouyate imo.


Edited by steeleye20 (31 Aug 2022 6.24pm)

Kouyate has made 2 appearances from the bench for Nottm For in the PL.

Offers far more than Milivojevic does and I suspect had he been a substitute for us yesterday he would have been introduced into the fray instead of LM.

Edited by Willo (31 Aug 2022 7.11pm)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 31 Aug 22 7.11pm

Originally posted by dg1937

First of all I share the massive disappointment with the result.

But I'm going to stick my head above the parapet and defend PV - a bit.

As far as the subs were concerned, Brentford had just thrown on three sets of fresh legs. Sometimes you need to respond to what the other guy does.

Clearly PV thought we needed fresh legs, especially in midfield. Sending Ayew on made sense. Eze wasn't having his best game in my view and, whatever his faults, Ayew is always energetic.

Who could he send on for a tiring Schlupp? There really weren't many options on the bench. No one is going to pretend Luca is the player he once was and I do get a sense of foreboding when he comes on but he really isn't as awful as some on here seem to think. People have suggested Hughes is a better option but he wasn't even on the bench (injured?). MacArthur would have been ideal but he wasn't available either. The only other option on the bench was Phillips who I have hardly seen play.

The problem with going to five at the back with Mitchell on for Olise seemed to be that the players didn't then have a clue what they were supposed to be doing. They have played five at the back before, they train for that formation, they should have been able to handle it better than they did. Instead there was a collective mental breakdown with even Guaita making some God awful clearances. And the centre backs have to take responsibility for the absolutely appalling defending for the equaliser.

We do need a couple of incoming transfers that's for sure and clearly we need to keep Wilf.


I commend you trying to defend, however:

At the point of our subs we were pushing for a 2nd. Brentford hasn't gone close, threatened, or shown any signs that they were starting to take control. If anything they looks lost and devoid of any ideas of how to break us down.

Luka looked slow, always late to the ball, sloppy passing and clumsy fouls. How he even gets on the pitch it beyond my understanding.

As we have seen in almost every example of drastically shifting formation in a game, it causes more problems than it solves.


In summary, we controlled them pretty well all game. Especially in the 2nd half, hence Frank making a triple and double substitution. PV reacted to a potential threat vs an actual threat and in the process weakened the personnel, added confusion and removed our ability to hold the ball and get out. Inviting pressure. And to be fair we were very lucky not to have lost that, which is madness considering how the game was poised at 75 mins

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Aug 22 7.14pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I commend you trying to defend, however:

At the point of our subs we were pushing for a 2nd. Brentford hasn't gone close, threatened, or shown any signs that they were starting to take control. If anything they looks lost and devoid of any ideas of how to break us down.

Luka looked slow, always late to the ball, sloppy passing and clumsy fouls. How he even gets on the pitch it beyond my understanding.

As we have seen in almost every example of drastically shifting formation in a game, it causes more problems than it solves.


In summary, we controlled them pretty well all game. Especially in the 2nd half, hence Frank making a triple and double substitution. PV reacted to a potential threat vs an actual threat and in the process weakened the personnel, added confusion and removed our ability to hold the ball and get out. Inviting pressure. And to be fair we were very lucky not to have lost that, which is madness considering how the game was poised at 75 mins

To my ageing mind, he is now not an asset but a liability.

Apropos last night's game, I actually predicted 1-1 which I strongly suspect is the first prediction I have got right since I joined HOL in 2013 !

Edited by Willo (31 Aug 2022 7.24pm)

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 31 Aug 22 8.01pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

We are missing the aerial presence and experience of Kouyate imo.

Edited by steeleye20 (31 Aug 2022 6.24pm)

Came on for forest v spuds. 3 errors, one got him booked one conceded a goal.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 31 Aug 22 8.46pm

Couldn't help but think today that Phillips would have been a better sub than Luka. More of an engine, a bit more pace plus hungry for a game. Not great but if he made a mistake we blooded him, if he did well a bonus and food for thought.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 31 Aug 22 9.07pm

Everyone laying into Luka here - don’t think he did a lot wrong to be honest.

Always difficult as a sub to judge the pace of the game. Complaint is that’s he is slow and Phillips for example would have more energy. Well Richards came on at the weekend and he couldn’t judge the pace of the game. Mitchell didn’t get up and running either /

Personally I’d like to see us put our foot on opponent more, but to blame the players coming on is foolish. Tactics yes, players no.

 

adelaar Flag Edgware 31 Aug 22 9.35pm

Originally posted by robdave2k

Everyone laying into Luka here - don’t think he did a lot wrong to be honest.

Always difficult as a sub to judge the pace of the game. Complaint is that’s he is slow and Phillips for example would have more energy. Well Richards came on at the weekend and he couldn’t judge the pace of the game. Mitchell didn’t get up and running either /

Personally I’d like to see us put our foot on opponent more, but to blame the players coming on is foolish. Tactics yes, players no.


Richards played against Man City. Luka made average Brentford suddenly look good.
Chalk and cheese comparisons.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 31 Aug 22 9.41pm

Originally posted by adelaar


Richards played against Man City. Luka made average Brentford suddenly look good.
Chalk and cheese comparisons.

Luka didn’t make them look good. Sitting back did.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 31 Aug 22 9.41pm

Originally posted by robdave2k

Everyone laying into Luka here - don’t think he did a lot wrong to be honest.

Always difficult as a sub to judge the pace of the game. Complaint is that’s he is slow and Phillips for example would have more energy. Well Richards came on at the weekend and he couldn’t judge the pace of the game. Mitchell didn’t get up and running either /

Personally I’d like to see us put our foot on opponent more, but to blame the players coming on is foolish. Tactics yes, players no.

Oh yes he did! Should not be let on the pitch. He's done well, but not any more.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

sprites Flag Auckland 01 Sep 22 2.03am

Originally posted by robdave2k

Everyone laying into Luka here - don’t think he did a lot wrong to be honest.

Always difficult as a sub to judge the pace of the game. Complaint is that’s he is slow and Phillips for example would have more energy. Well Richards came on at the weekend and he couldn’t judge the pace of the game. Mitchell didn’t get up and running either /

Personally I’d like to see us put our foot on opponent more, but to blame the players coming on is foolish. Tactics yes, players no.

Absolutely. But that's what people do on here...like to single people out. Then everyone jumps on the bandwagon.

The whole team sat back and invited pressure. That's why we conceded. But much easier to throw the blame at Luka. Pretty pathetic.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 01 Sep 22 2.06am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

theory : we lose our winning position when Luka comes on for the last twenty minutes.

anybody bothered to crunch the data ?

Don't need to bother. Stupid, inaccurate (coincidental at best) theory. We lost last night becasue we chose to sit back and invite pressure.

 

adelaar Flag Edgware 01 Sep 22 2.21am

I sense a lot of fans on here agree that when Luka comes on now it just fills you with dread. You should not feel that about a player, knowing he has a mistake or a bad performance in him.
Happy to be proved wrong this season but I suspect come the seasons end in May they'll be plenty of evidence to prove the case.
His crossfield pass in an attack fired well over for a goal kick.
Chickened out of a 50-50 in the middle of the park allowing a break. I could go on. We see it all far too often in his performances. A few years ago he was the first name on the teamsheet It's just hard to take to see his sharp decline.

 

The Dolphin Flag 01 Sep 22 6.58am

He has been brilliant for us over the years and we owe him some respect.
It is must be difficult as the game speeds up and you slow down and at the same time you only get minutes here and there.
Chickened out - I doubt it!
He made an absolute monster of a tackle in front of the dug outs on Tuesday night - a real 50-50 cruncher!
Give the man a break

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 01 Sep 22 7.35am

The reason we didn't win is entirely PV fault, not luka or Mitchell, when we took Olise and Eze off 2/3 of our attacking options were removed, and we invited Brentford to attack, i have no doubt that with the subs Brentford had made we would have scored another 1 or 2 goals, last night Southampton with a one goal lead over Chelsea made 2 attacking subs in the second half, and didn't bring a defender on until the 86th min, PV can attract players to the club that other managers cant, but he is tactically a poor manager.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Sep 22 7.39am

It's easy to scapegoat one individual for the result. Luka's still on the payroll and will get called upon to play from time to time. If, as many think, he is not PL standard ask instead why is the midfield so paper tissue thin? What has the club been doing to ensure the most competed area of the park is staffed with the correct level of player for the role? With the departure of Gallagher and Kouyate, and the injury to McArthur we are woefully thin in this area.
Heaven forbid Doucoure picks up an injury, or we'll be left with the prospect of Hughes, Eze, and Schlupp as our midfield. A frightening prospect.
If the club has a couple of signings lined up, players who will go straight in, I could understand the strategy. If not, our season is going to be a long one.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (01 Sep 2022 8.36am)

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 01 Sep 22 9.51am

Originally posted by sprites

Don't need to bother. Stupid, inaccurate (coincidental at best) theory. We lost last night becasue we chose to sit back and invite pressure.

We drew.

But it felt like a loss and I agree your point. Every year there is one player who all the fans adopt as their scape goat; and this year it is Luca.

Luca is far from what we need and is something of a dead horse being flogged until Jimmy Mac is fit, or we can afford to replace him, or - more likely given what appears Parish's long term aims - be replaced by youth feeding through the ranks.

Until then, he is what he is and he is one of ours. You just need to just accept that and get off his back.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 01 Sep 22 9.56am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

The reason we didn't win is entirely PV fault, not luka or Mitchell, when we took Olise and Eze off 2/3 of our attacking options were removed, and we invited Brentford to attack, i have no doubt that with the subs Brentford had made we would have scored another 1 or 2 goals, last night Southampton with a one goal lead over Chelsea made 2 attacking subs in the second half, and didn't bring a defender on until the 86th min, PV can attract players to the club that other managers cant, but he is tactically a poor manager.

I didn't understand Eze but his injury takes YEARS to fully heal, so perhaps it is a bit of that. Spreading his effect over a long season.

Olise definitely take him off. Anyone that soon back from injury needs to be sparingly used at first, especially if he is also going to be playing France U21 where I suspect his use will be less than circumspect and they will not care a fig if he is returned to us injured (like the last time he played for them).

I wholly agree they should not have come off but I suspect it was the need to preserve our best resources.

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 01 Sep 22 9.59am

Originally posted by silvertop

We drew.

But it felt like a loss and I agree your point. Every year there is one player who all the fans adopt as their scape goat; and this year it is Luca.

Luca is far from what we need and is something of a dead horse being flogged until Jimmy Mac is fit, or we can afford to replace him, or - more likely given what appears Parish's long term aims - be replaced by youth feeding through the ranks.

Until then, he is what he is and he is one of ours. You just need to just accept that and get off his back.

I don't consider his a 'scapegoat'. As he has passed his prime in the EPL he is being called upon to come on and salvage a point/keep a win/turnaround a defeat. That is how poor our depth of squad is. No reflection on him and surely PV would not play him if he didn't have to. Would he!?

 

Page 10 of 12 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs Brentford - Match Thread