This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Quote Seth at 11 Jan 2005 4:24pm
did anything Dr James have to say ring any bells with you, or do you reject it all as Oxbridge b*lls***? He aint really saying anything I didn't already know, or indeed believe. He's simply saying it's misleading to use the term 'Celt' or 'Celtic' because this indicates ONE people instead of the many tribes of slightly differing people they actually were. The Gauls were not the same people as the Iceni, granted, but having said that, I see the use of the term 'Celtic' as pertaining to the origins - or racial grouping if you like - of the people who populated Britain and Gaul in the dark-ages. Anyway, if the Roman scribes of the day saw fit to describe the people living on the isle of Britain – or Britannia - as 'Britons', then why shouldn't we? He also says that while the ancient Britons were of the same genetic source, ie the same race, as time advanced their division into differing tribes brought on regional and tribal cultural diversity which is pretty obvious really and no surprise at all, they still looked alike, worshipped the same pagan gods, ate the same food, told the same stories, fought the same way, celebrated the same pagan festivals. Even when England's national identity was at it's strongest (in Tudor times), healthy regional cultural diversity existed even then. But the people of England were still English first and foremost and proud of it.
My Rocksteady band... |
|
|
Well I don't really see the point coz we're just gonna go round and round in circles. If you believe that England or indeed Britain has no identifiable culture of it's own, then by the same standard you must believe also that Germany has no culture, France, Italy, India, anywhere, and if you believe that, then your definition of an identifiable national culture differs greatly from mine and that being the case; what's the point of continuing this argument? I believe England and the English way of life is under threat, you don't! I believe the English are being forced to accept many aspects of foreign culture they find alien and abhorrent, you don’t! I believe the English are worth fighting for, you don’t! I believe the English way of life is worth preserving, you don’t! End of argument.
My Rocksteady band... |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.