You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread
November 21 2026 12.10pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Holmesdale Fanatics thread


Page 101 of 122 < 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 >
spartakev2 Flag Anerley 26 Sep 18 6.17pm

Originally posted by rikz

Those directly involved don't own the club and also don't own a certain part of the ground.

No 100 'fans' in black do.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 26 Sep 18 6.28pm

Originally posted by brownsugar

At last......the club has arrived at the correct decision. If only the principle of the statement had been accepted before the start of the season..... we would still have the HF singing, the great atwe mosphere and would have easily beaten Newcastle! Ok...Maybe. However, better late than never. We need the HF! Would also have saved 170 pages on the message board. I am delighted for the HF and all Palace supporters.....hope that the way can be found for the HF to improve the rest of season atmosphere. Top half finish, Wilf and Roy player and manager of the season!

What a load of nonsense to suggest we would have beaten Newcastle with the HF there. Perhaps you could tell me how we have won four away games and scored seven goals WITHOUT the HF being there?? It's an insult to the highly paid and professional players to insinuate that they can't win a game without 100 or so chanting, flag waving and drum bashers in the ground.
Atmosphere never wins football matches, players do.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Mstrobez Flag 26 Sep 18 6.35pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

What a load of nonsense to suggest we would have beaten Newcastle with the HF there. Perhaps you could tell me how we have won four away games and scored seven goals WITHOUT the HF being there?? It's an insult to the highly paid and professional players to insinuate that they can't win a game without 100 or so chanting, flag waving and drum bashers in the ground.
Atmosphere never wins football matches, players do.

Atmosphere undoubtedly plays its part.

But the actual reality is that the atmosphere at Selhurst has been going downhill every year since promotion. It’s pretty much become a myth, one that we desperately cling onto in the desire of a sense of identity as a club.

Moving them behind the goal really is not gonna have the effect people think it will in the long term. The problems they’re having generating a proper atmosphere in Block B should be a pretty broad hint of that.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 26 Sep 18 6.36pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

No 100 'fans' in black do.


^^^^^ AGREED ^^^^^


BTW, WHY is this thread STILL going, wtf

-.-'

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

michaelpearce Flag grays 26 Sep 18 6.47pm

this has made me sick to my stomach, that fellow palace fans are celebrating the ejection of other fellow fans from there seats, because they wanted to support the club from the seats they have had for along time,true palace fans think not you lot make me sick shame on you all

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 26 Sep 18 6.53pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

this has made me sick to my stomach, that fellow palace fans are celebrating the ejection of other fellow fans from there seats, because they wanted to support the club from the seats they have had for along time,true palace fans think not you lot make me sick shame on you all

Its going to get worse . . .

They have got what they wanted from CPFC, a 'singing' section in Block E LH. There will be loads of grief if the 'impose' their will on other fans, me incl.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Bangell Flag Oxford 26 Sep 18 6.58pm

Good to have a resolution.

I hope the club goes about re-seating the people who have had their season tickets there for a long time in an appropriate and helpful manner, but ultimately those seats are simply rented from the club, and seating re-organisations happen all the time. This isn't telling a couple of hundred season ticket holders to f*** off because the HF want to take your seats - it's creating a much larger, more general singing section, for which some moving is required.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 26 Sep 18 7.01pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Good to have a resolution.

I hope the club goes about re-seating the people who have had their season tickets there for a long time in an appropriate and helpful manner, but ultimately those seats are simply rented from the club, and seating re-organisations happen all the time. This isn't telling a couple of hundred season ticket holders to f*** off because the HF want to take your seats - it's creating a much larger, more general singing section, for which some moving is required.

Oh but it is

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 26 Sep 18 7.06pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Good to have a resolution.

I hope the club goes about re-seating the people who have had their season tickets there for a long time in an appropriate and helpful manner, but ultimately those seats are simply rented from the club, and seating re-organisations happen all the time. This isn't telling a couple of hundred season ticket holders to f*** off because the HF want to take your seats - it's creating a much larger, more general singing section, for which some moving is required.

Glad it is resolved. Given when the negotiations started perhaps with a more proactive approach from the club this could already be sorted out for some point this season, but the past is the past.

I wonder if this will have an impact in some way this season, based on recent games at Selhurst I think the only way is up, noise wise?

We humans do get very attached to our beloved footy teams and when given the same seat year after year it does become something you want to protect, and not give up.

But the reality is you do not own those seats, the club does. I hope most of all that Parish and co get their thinking caps on and really compensate the affected people properly.

Time heals all, as someone once said.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Sep 18 7.10pm

I would be in a steaming bate with nostrils flared akin to two open drain pipes if I had been a season ticket holder in Block E for many a year and had to relocate to accommodate the HF who incidentally flout the ground regulations by their persistant standing.Blocks either side are going to be affected by the HF standing and blocking their view.

I suspect there will be polarised views regarding the recent club announcement with the smorgasbord of opinions attracting some ordure and being the catalyst for strident debate.

Edited by Willo (26 Sep 2018 7.16pm)

 

AERO Flag 26 Sep 18 7.13pm

You don’t own your seat ! Am sure they will be adequately compensated £££

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Sep 18 7.14pm

Originally posted by iheartcpfc

After so many fans showed their support for the idea this is a victory for the fans,

I think that you'll find that most of the fans showing their support by signing petitions were either fictitious or Brighton fans trying to wind us up

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 26 Sep 18 7.15pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Oh but it is

Only if you take the view that it's 'your' seat. I don't see why the club aren't entitled to designate seats as part of a singing section in the interest of the atmosphere - with people already there free to stay if they want to, of course.

Should the club not be able to change the way the stadium is organised?

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 26 Sep 18 7.15pm

Really great news, I'm delighted. Well done CPFC. What a difference this will make. As per the club statement, there has been overwhelming support for this, the clubs needs to cater for the majority.

No one is celebrating fans getting kicked out their seat, hopefully they are all well compensated for this - free season ticket next year and first choice seats once the new stand has been built is fair. People are celebrating how exciting it will be once its up and running.

I for one will be back for my first season ticket in a while if I can get in the Holmesdale.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 26 Sep 18 7.21pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

No 100 'fans' in black do.

Not exclusive to them tho is it ? It's a singing section for 400 people. Just a 100 of them will be the hf who funnily enough want to sing. Like me moaning about a disabled section taking priority over me.

 

Mstrobez Flag 26 Sep 18 7.22pm

Originally posted by AERO

You don’t own your seat ! Am sure they will be adequately compensated £££

Neither do the HF!

This has been the most ridiculous argument from day one and a quite pathetic attempt to demonise other Palace fans who sit in Block E.

If you wanna force people out of their seats that’s fine. But for FFS, own your position instead of trying to act like them “not owning their seats” makes this somehow justifiable.

It’s absoltely ridiculous to think that other Palace fans are forced to sit elsewhere because a group has been deemed to support the club better.

It’s a kick in the teeth to long-serving Palace fans who I’m sure include those who could quite easily make a case for contributing more in support than the HF.

And this isn’t coming from the position of some bigoted, bitter and twisted old git. This is coming from a 24 year old who’s just being honest about what’s right and proper in this situation.

Forcing fans to move for other fans isn’t and never will be. How anyone could disagree is beyond me.

Edited by Mstrobez (26 Sep 2018 7.24pm)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

laddo Flag london 26 Sep 18 7.27pm

Genuinely don't get the outrage. Things move on. Do we not build the main stand because it would interfere with current seats? If lower holmesdale goes to safe standing, do we all kick off because some will need to move seats?

I love watching palace. I don't give a sh*t from what seat I watch them. And if it's a choice of remaining in my seat in an awful atmosphere, or moving and the ground is buzzing, I take the latter option every time.

 


laddo

"People say, live fast, die young. I say live fast, die old. That's me, the non-conformist".
David Brent.

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 26 Sep 18 7.27pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Really great news, I'm delighted. Well done CPFC. What a difference this will make. As per the club statement, there has been overwhelming support for this, the clubs needs to cater for the majority.

No one is celebrating fans getting kicked out their seat, hopefully they are all well compensated for this - free season ticket next year and first choice seats once the new stand has been built is fair. People are celebrating how exciting it will be once its up and running.

I for one will be back for my first season ticket in a while if I can get in the Holmesdale.

So 100 fanatics are now the majority of the 25000 people who attend Palace home games are they? As for the online petitions as has been pointed out they have no validity unless only Palace season ticket holders were allowed to vote. And in case it escaped your notice there are plenty of people on here celebrating the very fact of people being moved out of their seats. This thread has done nothing but set fan against fan, something I never thought would ever happen to the Palace family.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

tinribzzz Flag BROMLEY 26 Sep 18 7.30pm

Change sometimes happens in life, embrace it. Block E can speak up for themselves so let's stop jumping to defend them.

We're all Palace and the club felt this was the right move so let's back them. For those in Block E that are sad, Just be grateful you got to experience those seats.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 26 Sep 18 7.31pm

Not browsed this thread lately but the recent announcement is a reasonable solution to this situation.
I sympathise with those who will be moved but I would suggest to them that this is in the best interests of their beloved club.
I hope the HF will now return to their position for the time being as available seating allows. They should now hopefully feel the appreciation that they crave and recognise that 'striking' was detrimental to the club they support, albeit with a happy ending.

Everybody wins here. The clubs reputation will be restored and let's face it, we will never have the best stadium but at least we can make a great atmosphere.

Well done SP on this one.

 

Page 101 of 122 < 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread