You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread
November 21 2026 12.10pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Holmesdale Fanatics thread


Page 102 of 122 < 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Sep 18 7.35pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Atmosphere undoubtedly plays its part.

But the actual reality is that the atmosphere at Selhurst has been going downhill every year since promotion. It’s pretty much become a myth, one that we desperately cling onto in the desire of a sense of identity as a club.

Moving them behind the goal really is not gonna have the effect people think it will in the long term. The problems they’re having generating a proper atmosphere in Block B should be a pretty broad hint of that.

You probably have a point there, and there should probably be some kind of online season ticket swap shop so those who know they’re not really singing or not into as they were might vacate it for good seats elsewhere.

Our atmosphere was still better than most, even though it was declining.

 


COYP

bicycle repair man 26 Sep 18 7.41pm

I must give a final opinion.
So it really is mob rule at Selhurst Park,and a complete bottle job by Steve Parish,very sad.
So a lot of people who've stuck by Palace in the dark days of the old Third Division, and turned up when attendances were less than 10,000,are now going to be turfed out so a few glory hunters clad in black can jump about waving flags.
And to hell with the rest of the guys in the lower Holmesdale,because everyone there will be affected now, young and old.
If God forbid, we did start plummeting down to the lower divisions,I wonder how many of those selfish drum thumping rascals would still turn up
?
I know the people who will be forced to change their seat will always attend,it's in their blood.But they will be bitterly disappointed by their treatment.
All because a few selfish,selfish people,and a weak chairman couldn't show a little patience.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 26 Sep 18 7.47pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

I must give a final opinion.
So it really is mob rule at Selhurst Park,and a complete bottle job by Steve Parish,very sad.
So a lot of people who've stuck by Palace in the dark days of the old Third Division, and turned up when attendances were less than 10,000,are now going to be turfed out so a few glory hunters clad in black can jump about waving flags.
And to hell with the rest of the guys in the lower Holmesdale,because everyone there will be affected now, young and old.
If God forbid, we did start plummeting down to the lower divisions,I wonder how many of those selfish drum thumping rascals would still turn up
?
I know the people who will be forced to change their seat will always attend,it's in their blood.But they will be bitterly disappointed by their treatment.
All because a few selfish,selfish people,and a weak chairman couldn't show a little patience.

Don't worry... judging by some of the comments on here we will never lose a home game again once the HF are back in place and can look forward to a 100% home record for many years to come...

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Sep 18 7.50pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Neither do the HF!

This has been the most ridiculous argument from day one and a quite pathetic attempt to demonise other Palace fans who sit in Block E.

If you wanna force people out of their seats that’s fine. But for FFS, own your position instead of trying to act like them “not owning their seats” makes this somehow justifiable.

It’s absoltely ridiculous to think that other Palace fans are forced to sit elsewhere because a group has been deemed to support the club better.

It’s a kick in the teeth to long-serving Palace fans who I’m sure include those who could quite easily make a case for contributing more in support than the HF.

And this isn’t coming from the position of some bigoted, bitter and twisted old git. This is coming from a 24 year old who’s just being honest about what’s right and proper in this situation.

Forcing fans to move for other fans isn’t and never will be. How anyone could disagree is beyond me.

Edited by Mstrobez (26 Sep 2018 7.24pm)

The board own the seats and everyone is probably just intimating that the board view this decision on the seats they own is the right one for the club. They wouldn’t do it if it wasn’t.

If this was handled properly and professionally in the first place the fallout wouldn’t be as bad as it has and there’d be less division.

In the case of long term season ticket holders, if it came down to whether they can be more crucial these days compared to the atmosphere, then you know what the board would be thinking. It’s unfortunate but that’s the case. We’re really lucky to be where we are and relegation could happen very easily. I’m sure Parish would rather have everything possible in our favour, and that goes beyond any crucial points I believe an atmosphere can have in relegation battles.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Sep 18 7.54pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

Don't worry... judging by some of the comments on here we will never lose a home game again once the HF are back in place and can look forward to a 100% home record for many years to come...

We’ll stand more of a chance in relegation battles, which happen to us in 4 of every 5 seasons. Ever see a quiet or toxic crowd near the bottom and you fancy them for relegation. We’ve never had that. We get thumped 0-4 by halftime and then next game everyone knows time is running out so no time to waste, moan or argue. Just full back from 100+500 people joining in.

 


COYP

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 26 Sep 18 7.59pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

I must give a final opinion.
So it really is mob rule at Selhurst Park,and a complete bottle job by Steve Parish,very sad.
So a lot of people who've stuck by Palace in the dark days of the old Third Division, and turned up when attendances were less than 10,000,are now going to be turfed out so a few glory hunters clad in black can jump about waving flags.
And to hell with the rest of the guys in the lower Holmesdale,because everyone there will be affected now, young and old.
If God forbid, we did start plummeting down to the lower divisions,I wonder how many of those selfish drum thumping rascals would still turn up
?
I know the people who will be forced to change their seat will always attend,it's in their blood.But they will be bitterly disappointed by their treatment.
All because a few selfish,selfish people,and a weak chairman couldn't show a little patience.

You seem to be completely ignoring the interests of the club. This is not about prioritising one set of supporters over another, it is about improving the match day atmosphere. Surely that is worth the sacrifice. Ultimately the board can do as they please. It is their club. I understand that some fans might feel disrespected, but they need to see the bigger picture. It ain't personal. The HF have not behaved well in this but they are a valuable part of the Palace image in 2018 and we need something that is pure Palace, especially while our ground remains a cow shed.

 

20 Spaces Isnt Enoug Flag Bolton 26 Sep 18 8.04pm


When the club phone those in Block E,

I assume they will ask " Do you want to stay in

your seat in a singing section? "

If that's the case, what's to stop everyone in

the block answering "Yes" thereby in effect blocking

the move.

 

tinribzzz Flag BROMLEY 26 Sep 18 8.05pm

Just so I am clear... those currently in Block E may have to move seats next season ? They aren't being ejected from the ground or losing any limbs?

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 26 Sep 18 8.05pm

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

Well he has weighed up the options and views, hence why he has made this decision. Unfortunately, you can not please everyone and people have been for and against the move on this forum. But at the end of the day, he is he chairman and it’s his decision.

I’m confident Steve knows all about the ground regulations etc...otherwise we would have been fined years ago for any breaches.

Have you heard the noise from the lower holmesdale from our 3 home games. It might aswell be closed


you will have your wish I feel this will be what authorities decide and also objecting to ground expansion (new stand). So those that wanted a quieter Selhurst Park will get their wish

 

becky Flag over the moon 26 Sep 18 8.12pm

Originally posted by AERO

You don’t own your seat ! Am sure they will be adequately compensated £££

Price of everything and value of nothing!

For those seated there (as I was for very many years) all the £££££ in the world will not compensate for not being able to watch the game from behind the goal. It's not everyone's favourite view of a match, but for many, it is simply the best there is, so £££s, seats in the new stand (down the long side of the pitch, remember) or even seats in the Director's box with free champagne for 2 years ain't gonna make no difference. There were groups there who had stood in the same place when it was terracing, moved back when the HOL was built, and generally knew most people around them. They had their own matchday 'atmosphere' but obviously, one of less value than peoplewho don't even wear team colours.

(And, NO, upper Hol or Sainsburys will not be the same either)

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 26 Sep 18 8.14pm

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood


you will have your wish I feel this will be what authorities decide and also objecting to ground expansion (new stand). So those that wanted a quieter Selhurst Park will get their wish

please stop chatting s***. Wolves' whole South Bank stands. Both of Chelsea and Leeds' ends stand (fair play to them for this). Every club in the country has an area where fans stand, no one gives a f*** now and with safe standing coming it it will only be further encouraged

 

zico murphy Flag woking 26 Sep 18 8.14pm

Great news but still people moan. I despair, I’m sure a certain proportion of the population actually enjoy complaining. Whatever solution the club came up with it’s obvious it was impossible to please everyone. Sometimes decision makers have to make what they deem the best solution for the majority and they don’t get the benefit of sitting on the fence or just voicing their opinion.

 

AERO Flag 26 Sep 18 8.16pm

Been supporting palace for 50 years ,Don’t want to go back to ground with no atmosphere,would sit anywhere to watch palace with the ground rocking winning or losing.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Sep 18 8.26pm

Originally posted by 20 Spaces Isnt Enoug


When the club phone those in Block E,

I assume they will ask " Do you want to stay in

your seat in a singing section? "

If that's the case, what's to stop everyone in

the block answering "Yes" thereby in effect blocking

the move.

The club have made their decision and I highly doubt they’ll change it again. Instead of asking everyone in D-F and getting the answers they didn’t want, they may have decided to do it anyway rather than go round in circles and have more time to find some solutions to those who do actually want a certain number of decent view seats together for a few seasons and aren’t just creating more of a problem just because they think they can.

 


COYP

stujii Flag 26 Sep 18 8.26pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I think that you'll find that most of the fans showing their support by signing petitions were either fictitious or Brighton fans trying to wind us up

Kind of shot themselves in the foot then haven't they !!

We'll get our atmosphere back and some

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Sep 18 8.31pm

Originally posted by becky

Price of everything and value of nothing!

For those seated there (as I was for very many years) all the £££££ in the world will not compensate for not being able to watch the game from behind the goal. It's not everyone's favourite view of a match, but for many, it is simply the best there is, so £££s, seats in the new stand (down the long side of the pitch, remember) or even seats in the Director's box with free champagne for 2 years ain't gonna make no difference. There were groups there who had stood in the same place when it was terracing, moved back when the HOL was built, and generally knew most people around them. They had their own matchday 'atmosphere' but obviously, one of less value than peoplewho don't even wear team colours.

(And, NO, upper Hol or Sainsburys will not be the same either)

And there have been fans who go with different mates for years and grab any tickets there are.

The end decision would’ve been made based on the bigger picture, what everyone and the club and players get from an atmosphere that will no doubt be the best there is for a while before some more swaps might need to happen. All of those factors would be more crucial and worth doing than not doing to keep a few content compared to the majority.

 


COYP

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 26 Sep 18 8.35pm

Originally posted by iheartcpfc

please stop chatting s***. Wolves' whole South Bank stands. Both of Chelsea and Leeds' ends stand (fair play to them for this). Every club in the country has an area where fans stand, no one gives a f*** now and with safe standing coming it it will only be further encouraged

the fans you stated may stand...but the atmosphere created by them over the whole match is nothing compared to the HF.

also a year or so ago, i sat in the south bank at wolves with my mate & there were people handing out sheets of paper with chant lyrics on then


Edited by braunstoneagle (26 Sep 2018 8.37pm)

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


the.universal 26 Sep 18 8.38pm

For me, got to be the right decision.

From a comedy perspective, looking forward to at least one ‘hold out’ who resolutely refuses to get involved with the atmosphere spends the whole time trying to get everyone to sit down.

 


Vive le Roy!

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 26 Sep 18 8.41pm

It's the right decision in the best interests of the club. Obviously some are not going to be happy but I suspect that most of the outraged on here are not going to be affected by the decision but are using it to knock the club and or the HF.

Be good to have an atmosphere back again. There are only 100 of them but they get the rest of the stand, and sometimes the whole ground, going.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

SelhurstEagle Flag 26 Sep 18 8.47pm

It is a real shame for those who have to move. I can understand how muh history some fans have in those seats and I hope they get a real good deal out of it.

However, it is the best thing the club could have done, and I’m over the moon to hear our atmosphere is going to return. We were slowly turning into Arsenals and it was clearly effecting the players performances, so it’s going to improve results at home for sure.

 

Page 102 of 122 < 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread