This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Very surprised at that. Sunak is driving the UK over a precipice, he is an economic dunce. We've already had a huge increase in taxes now he wants more, trying to cove his disastrous running of the economy. WE honestly. Blaming any individual, Chancellor or road sweeper, for the situation we face because of the events of the last 2 years, is daft. We could have avoided Brexit, but not Covid, or Putin's aggression, and it's impact on the price of energy and food. There are no magic money trees. We cannot just keep borrowing. Taxes will have to be raised, and the best way to do that, which avoids impacting the most vulnerable, is via income tax. Which conflicts with Sunak's most recent statement, so he may well not be Chancellor for much longer. There may well also have to be higher corporation taxes, and a wealth tax, but rise they must.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Does that mean that those who have been so badly impacted by the energy and food price increases would be ignored by you? Governments exist to manage economies, but we fund them. They don't manage anything, they waste money hand over fist and most of their projects are financial disasters providing little or no benefit.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
They don't manage anything, they waste money hand over fist and most of their projects are financial disasters providing little or no benefit. Whether, or not, you think you could do it better doesn't change facts. Governments administer how we raise taxes and how we spend the money. That's not the issue. What I asked was whether you proposed to just ignore the plight of the severely affected and just blame the government for their plight?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Whether, or not, you think you could do it better doesn't change facts. Governments administer how we raise taxes and how we spend the money. That's not the issue. What I asked was whether you proposed to just ignore the plight of the severely affected and just blame the government for their plight? They do set policy, and have a large say in how our money is spent and so I certainly don't think we should let government off the hook. There's an element of 'you get the government you deserve' but still as representatives of the people they should represent. They seem very able to fill their own pockets, but less so hard working people.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
They do set policy, and have a large say in how our money is spent and so I certainly don't think we should let government off the hook. There's an element of 'you get the government you deserve' but still as representatives of the people they should represent. They seem very able to fill their own pockets, but less so hard working people. Bashing governments has been a popular sport for centuries and will likely never cease to be popular. Offering green grass after 5 years of being fed hay is why we get swings. It doesn't though address the issue. We face a crisis, which cannot be solved via even more borrowing. The only solution I see , unless we are prepared to see a section of society in genuine poverty, is to increase taxation. The only way to get people to accept that is for the parties all to be honest about it and not pretend it can be avoided via spurious promises of green grass next door.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Bashing governments has been a popular sport for centuries and will likely never cease to be popular. Offering green grass after 5 years of being fed hay is why we get swings. It doesn't though address the issue. We face a crisis, which cannot be solved via even more borrowing. The only solution I see , unless we are prepared to see a section of society in genuine poverty, is to increase taxation. The only way to get people to accept that is for the parties all to be honest about it and not pretend it can be avoided via spurious promises of green grass next door. I'm certainly not saying that we should rule out increasing taxes, just that criticism of governments is fair, that they often put us into the situations we find ourselves in, and are unreliable in terms of how they use public funds, hand out contracts etc. That is as much a conundrum to be solved really, as whoever is in power there is always 'at least the other guy didn't get in!' as a distraction to their inept management of the country, public services, and so on. Many politicians are firmly in it for themselves, and decent more principles people who are less easy to sway or influence often don't rise to the heights of power because there is less in it for other people in those instances. Human nature is partly responsible for that no doubt, but still.. it would be nice to have a government who at least appear to be somewhat in it for the people. Family firm of Rishi Sunak's non-dom status wife won £50m in taxpayer-funded deals - [Link] We are a piggy bank to these people. Edited by BlueJay (09 Apr 2022 1.25am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
They don't manage anything, they waste money hand over fist and most of their projects are financial disasters providing little or no benefit. Governments don't spend it personally though.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Whether, or not, you think you could do it better doesn't change facts. Governments administer how we raise taxes and how we spend the money. That's not the issue. What I asked was whether you proposed to just ignore the plight of the severely affected and just blame the government for their plight? I didn't say I could do it better, you are putting words in my mouth. Certainly governments set taxation rates. Taxes are collected by all sorts of people and organistations. How it is spent, within government (national and local) specified budgets, is largely down to the many and various bureaucracies where waste, inefficiency, corruption and incompetence are commonplace. People are relatively poor for a great number of reasons - one of them is governments, another is heavy taxation, particularly VAT.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
I didn't say I could do it better, you are putting words in my mouth. Certainly governments set taxation rates. Taxes are collected by all sorts of people and organistations. How it is spent, within government (national and local) specified budgets, is largely down to the many and various bureaucracies where waste, inefficiency, corruption and incompetence are commonplace. People are relatively poor for a great number of reasons - one of them is governments, another is heavy taxation, particularly VAT.
You are addressing another issue. Complaining about government inefficient and corruption, especially that done by the tribe you disapprove of, is a routine. It won't though make the cake any bigger, and if some are now only getting crumbs, we will need to make the slices taken by others a little smaller. What I am addressing is whether and how we do that. Do people accept the need, or are going to demand their slice stays the same size? In which case, some will be eating only crumbs. As we will now be spending a greater proportion of our income on energy and food, the amount of VAT raised will decrease. Energy attracts only 5% VAT, food nil. That alone means the tax take elsewhere must increase. I cannot see any alternatives to tax hikes coming down the road later this year.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You are addressing another issue. Complaining about government inefficient and corruption, especially that done by the tribe you disapprove of, is a routine. It won't though make the cake any bigger, and if some are now only getting crumbs, we will need to make the slices taken by others a little smaller. What I am addressing is whether and how we do that. Do people accept the need, or are going to demand their slice stays the same size? In which case, some will be eating only crumbs. As we will now be spending a greater proportion of our income on energy and food, the amount of VAT raised will decrease. Energy attracts only 5% VAT, food nil. That alone means the tax take elsewhere must increase. I cannot see any alternatives to tax hikes coming down the road later this year. The bakery is being run by those who have no skill in efficiently making cake. Edited by georgenorman (09 Apr 2022 9.12am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Blaming any individual, Chancellor or road sweeper, for the situation we face because of the events of the last 2 years, is daft. We could have avoided Brexit, but not Covid, or Putin's aggression, and it's impact on the price of energy and food. There are no magic money trees. We cannot just keep borrowing. Taxes will have to be raised, and the best way to do that, which avoids impacting the most vulnerable, is via income tax. Which conflicts with Sunak's most recent statement, so he may well not be Chancellor for much longer. There may well also have to be higher corporation taxes, and a wealth tax, but rise they must. Sunak has cancelled corporation tax increases and will not hear of wealth or windfall taxes, he has already hiked general taxation by record levels not seen since WW2. He has no connection or understanding of normal people and lives in a world of tax breaks for his rich banker mates. His tax rises are only making matters worse and he knows it, now he is stuck trying to repair the damage he has done by inflicting more. But it is a doomed cycle of depressed incomes without the ability to pay or contribute, economies need stimulus not looking under the carpet for a 10p piece. High prices rampant inflation are not caused by borrowing extra for covid, they are to pay for his and the tories world of being asset rich as an economy. He even had to admit that brexit is harming trade (by 15%) it's even penetrating to him. The Chiltern Hundreds for Sunak, or be exiled to Cornwall to join you WE, you would go well together.
|
|
|
The serial numbers on the rocket motor of the missile should be able to determine who inherited/built the rocket and fired it....well, in theory as you can never be certain. Western journalists filmed the serial number of Tochka-U that exploded at the train station in Kramatorsk. According to Russia, the ownership of the missile belongs to Ukrainian Armed Forces. This doesn't mean that it's correct because I have no way of verifying this and there is also the reality that munitions could have been taken or kept back....then again, survival of the rocket is unlikely. Anyway I'll be interested to see how this is reported.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Russia to fast-track adoptions of Ukrainian children 'forcibly deported' after their parents were killed by Putin's troops, authorities say - [Link] "In a statement on Facebook, Lyudmila Denisova said that the Russian Federation is changing legislation to allow "the accelerated procedure of adoption of children from Donbas." "Now the Russians, firing rockets and tanks at the homes of Ukrainian citizens, kill parents and kidnap our children in the occupied territories of East and South Ukraine," she said. "The first cases of deportation to Russia were reported at the end of March, when Pyotr Andryuschenko, an assistant to Mariupol's mayor, said that 4,000 to 4,500 Mariupol residents were "forcibly" moved, without their passports, to the Russian city of Taganrog. Wel, I mean we could just call it what it is. Human trafficking, genocide etc. The Nazis Lebensborn policy essentially. This isn't a 'both sides' point in time for anyone with normal sensibilities. Edited by BlueJay (09 Apr 2022 3.42pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Sunak has cancelled corporation tax increases and will not hear of wealth or windfall taxes, he has already hiked general taxation by record levels not seen since WW2. He has no connection or understanding of normal people and lives in a world of tax breaks for his rich banker mates. His tax rises are only making matters worse and he knows it, now he is stuck trying to repair the damage he has done by inflicting more. But it is a doomed cycle of depressed incomes without the ability to pay or contribute, economies need stimulus not looking under the carpet for a 10p piece. High prices rampant inflation are not caused by borrowing extra for covid, they are to pay for his and the tories world of being asset rich as an economy. He even had to admit that brexit is harming trade (by 15%) it's even penetrating to him. The Chiltern Hundreds for Sunak, or be exiled to Cornwall to join you WE, you would go well together.
I think you will find it's caused by the huge rises in the cost of energy, which is now exacerbated by Putin's war, as are the rises in food prices, which started with Brexit and made worse during Covid's impact on world trade. I am not a fan of this government, but to believe our problems can be laid at the door of greedy bankers is clear and obvious nonsense.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.