Quote billyjack at 21 Jul 2014 7.53pm
No American politician in 2014, especially for national office, even a Southern politician, would ever consider flying a Confederate flag at a political rally. They'd immediately be recognized as a backward crackpot racist nut. If a supporter of theirs waved it, the politician would run from an association with that person and that flag. This really should answer the question as to whether the general American public has a problem with it.
South Carolina I think still flies it on the state capitol grounds, but no one person "owns" it... and the result of flying it is the boycotting of the state by many groups (the NCAA for example won't hold tournament games there...).
Not even a 2014 Tea Party lunatic candidate would choose to fly one of these flags. (this isn't to say that privately these nuts don't hoard these flags in their attics).
The only past use that anyone can think of that is not blatantly offensive is a low-budget TV show written for 7-year-olds from 1979, and a rock band from the 70's that died in a plane crash (so their use of it is frozen in time and so they had no opportunity to modernize their thinking over the years and maybe distance themselves from it)(and which had gotten into a lyrics-war with Neil Young over segregation etc)... both of these uses are from 30-35-40 years ago... a time where the Alabama football team had just been integrated (really almost all Southern college teams had no black players til the late 60's early 70's), and when blacks-and-whites couldn't be seen on a date in America, especially the South, without the guy getting the sh!t kicked out of him...
Little-known Dukes of Hazzard trivia to lighten this thread up a little: Boss Hogg had the initials "J.D." for Jefferson Davis, and was made to be a corrupt moron... but on one show, his brother appeared, whose initials were "A.L." (for Abraham Lincoln), and who was made to be ethical and a sensible guy.
EDIT: Rather than using a swastika comparison, maybe an IRA flag would make this more understandable... if Notre Dame or the orange-and-green Miami Hurricanes flew an IRA flag, I think that would be pretty offensive and inappropriate... though a decent percentage of people wouldn't understand the problem I guess?
P.S. Everyone has the right to fly anything they want (everyone has the right to pick their nose in public too). Once the person is told of the sensitivity of the flag, if they still fly it, then people have the right to consider them an idiot.
Edited by billyjack (21 Jul 2014 8.10pm)
My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.