You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Confederate Flag
November 22 2026 2.20am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Confederate Flag


Page 11 of 18 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >
Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Jul 14 8.39am

Quote Kingvagabond at 20 Jul 2014 11.17pm

Quote adrian b at 20 Jul 2014 11.05pm

Quote Kingvagabond at 20 Jul 2014 11.00pm

Quote adrian b at 20 Jul 2014 10.52pm
But it's not irrelevant. There has not been a policy statement banning flags in the ground. But what flag? There's the question we are discussing, this is the hornets nest you have sprouted.

Hmm, would you at least agree that the Swastika was a deliberately extreme example intended to provoke reaction?


Not the point of this thread, but I would be appalled. There again, some on this thread will say that if the person flying this flag was of the opinion it was not harmful, then he should be allowed to fly it. And to them I say think about Palace.

I think Stirling's point was more that the feeling against the Confederate flag comes from across the pond and not here. The Swastika has become universally (i.e. globally) recognised as a symbol of oppression and hatred. The confederate flag has not thus far.


I repeat my earlier point

Would you want an LTTE flag flown at SP? After all, the atrocities in Jaffna are nothing to do with us, so why not? Could also be viewed as a flag celebrating the will of a few people that want freedom from oppression.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 21 Jul 14 8.41am

No, wrong. Stirlings point is if a person flying a flag does not think the flag, in his opinion, is offensive, then he should be allowed to fly it. By allowing this he must mean all flags and if he objects to the Swaztica and expects me to accept his feelings, then I object to the Confederate flag and expect him to accept mine. Simps peeps

 

npn Flag Crowborough 21 Jul 14 8.57am

F**k me, is this really on 17 pages?

Flag spotted.
May possibly offend someone on the other side of the world.
Flag removed.

Have I missed something?

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Jul 14 11.56am

Quote adrian b at 21 Jul 2014 8.41am

No, wrong. Stirlings point is if a person flying a flag does not think the flag, in his opinion, is offensive, then he should be allowed to fly it. By allowing this he must mean all flags and if he objects to the Swaztica and expects me to accept his feelings, then I object to the Confederate flag and expect him to accept mine. Simps peeps


My reading of your note is that you are agreeing with me. My point is that I would not want an LTTE flag flown, it has awful connotations even if originally it was simply a flag of protest. And, as I now have been taught that the confederate flag has awful connotations, I would not want it flown as it isn't correct to grossly upset a group of people without an extremely strong rationale to do so. Freedom of individual expression is simply not a strong enough reason.

 

Moose Flag In the sewer pipe... 21 Jul 14 12.07pm

Quote npn at 21 Jul 2014 8.57am

F**k me, is this really on 17 pages?

Flag spotted.
May possibly offend someone on the other side of the world.
Flag removed.

Have I missed something?


Hit the nail on the head. The only suggestion I can give is to change your profile to view 50 posts a page, then it's only 5 pages. Doesn't make the guff any less pointless but might save your sanity a bit.

 


Goodness is what you do. Not who you pray to.

Kingvagabond Flag London 21 Jul 14 12.10pm

Quote Mapletree at 21 Jul 2014 11.56am

Quote adrian b at 21 Jul 2014 8.41am

No, wrong. Stirlings point is if a person flying a flag does not think the flag, in his opinion, is offensive, then he should be allowed to fly it. By allowing this he must mean all flags and if he objects to the Swaztica and expects me to accept his feelings, then I object to the Confederate flag and expect him to accept mine. Simps peeps


My reading of your note is that you are agreeing with me. My point is that I would not want an LTTE flag flown, it has awful connotations even if originally it was simply a flag of protest. And, as I now have been taught that the confederate flag has awful connotations, I would not want it flown as it isn't correct to grossly upset a group of people without an extremely strong rationale to do so. Freedom of individual expression is simply not a strong enough reason.

And the fact that half the Americans I spoke to in the chatroom said the flag had nothing to do with racism?

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Jul 14 12.16pm

Quote Kingvagabond at 21 Jul 2014 12.10pm

Quote Mapletree at 21 Jul 2014 11.56am

Quote adrian b at 21 Jul 2014 8.41am

No, wrong. Stirlings point is if a person flying a flag does not think the flag, in his opinion, is offensive, then he should be allowed to fly it. By allowing this he must mean all flags and if he objects to the Swaztica and expects me to accept his feelings, then I object to the Confederate flag and expect him to accept mine. Simps peeps


My reading of your note is that you are agreeing with me. My point is that I would not want an LTTE flag flown, it has awful connotations even if originally it was simply a flag of protest. And, as I now have been taught that the confederate flag has awful connotations, I would not want it flown as it isn't correct to grossly upset a group of people without an extremely strong rationale to do so. Freedom of individual expression is simply not a strong enough reason.

And the fact that half the Americans I spoke to in the chatroom said the flag had nothing to do with racism?


Good point, so it would only upset a maximum of 159 million people.

Ah, sorry Mike, plus 18 million Canadians.

Edited by Mapletree (21 Jul 2014 12.19pm)

 

Kingvagabond Flag London 21 Jul 14 4.38pm

Quote Mapletree at 21 Jul 2014 12.16pm

Quote Kingvagabond at 21 Jul 2014 12.10pm

Quote Mapletree at 21 Jul 2014 11.56am

Quote adrian b at 21 Jul 2014 8.41am

No, wrong. Stirlings point is if a person flying a flag does not think the flag, in his opinion, is offensive, then he should be allowed to fly it. By allowing this he must mean all flags and if he objects to the Swaztica and expects me to accept his feelings, then I object to the Confederate flag and expect him to accept mine. Simps peeps


My reading of your note is that you are agreeing with me. My point is that I would not want an LTTE flag flown, it has awful connotations even if originally it was simply a flag of protest. And, as I now have been taught that the confederate flag has awful connotations, I would not want it flown as it isn't correct to grossly upset a group of people without an extremely strong rationale to do so. Freedom of individual expression is simply not a strong enough reason.

And the fact that half the Americans I spoke to in the chatroom said the flag had nothing to do with racism?


Good point, so it would only upset a maximum of 159 million people.

Ah, sorry Mike, plus 18 million Canadians.

Edited by Mapletree (21 Jul 2014 12.19pm)

And if flags with Eagles on them become associated with racism, or homophobia do we then change our badge? Nickname etc? I mean of course we all know Eagles were a major symbol for the Nazi party.


Edited by Kingvagabond (21 Jul 2014 4.40pm)

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 21 Jul 14 5.16pm

Quote adrian b at 20 Jul 2014 10.45pm

I really think it is difficult to understand why a few people should be allowed to do something that could restrict the commercial viability of CPFC. What is more difficult to understand why they should be prevented from doing that and if someone points out the problems this raises, it is just stiring a hornets nest. Be more mature and objective to face the issue for what it is, not a question of the freedom for them to do as they please, more the correct decision to prevent them from harming Palace. It doesn't matter if only one person saw it and didn't understand the implications to Palace's standing, the point is the potential for everyone to see it and find it objectionable. I think that would harm the perception of Palace.


You keep mentioning the commercial viability, is it that which is a concern or the actual pontential racial connotation of the flag?

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Jul 14 5.26pm

Quote Kingvagabond at 21 Jul 2014 4.38pm

Quote Mapletree at 21 Jul 2014 12.16pm

Quote Kingvagabond at 21 Jul 2014 12.10pm

Quote Mapletree at 21 Jul 2014 11.56am

Quote adrian b at 21 Jul 2014 8.41am

No, wrong. Stirlings point is if a person flying a flag does not think the flag, in his opinion, is offensive, then he should be allowed to fly it. By allowing this he must mean all flags and if he objects to the Swaztica and expects me to accept his feelings, then I object to the Confederate flag and expect him to accept mine. Simps peeps


My reading of your note is that you are agreeing with me. My point is that I would not want an LTTE flag flown, it has awful connotations even if originally it was simply a flag of protest. And, as I now have been taught that the confederate flag has awful connotations, I would not want it flown as it isn't correct to grossly upset a group of people without an extremely strong rationale to do so. Freedom of individual expression is simply not a strong enough reason.

And the fact that half the Americans I spoke to in the chatroom said the flag had nothing to do with racism?


Good point, so it would only upset a maximum of 159 million people.

Ah, sorry Mike, plus 18 million Canadians.

Edited by Mapletree (21 Jul 2014 12.19pm)

And if flags with Eagles on them become associated with racism, or homophobia do we then change our badge? Nickname etc? I mean of course we all know Eagles were a major symbol for the Nazi party.


Edited by Kingvagabond (21 Jul 2014 4.40pm)


Yes

 

billyjack Flag Providence RI 21 Jul 14 7.53pm

No American politician in 2014, especially for national office, even a Southern politician, would ever consider flying a Confederate flag at a political rally. They'd immediately be recognized as a backward crackpot racist nut. If a supporter of theirs waved it, the politician would run from an association with that person and that flag. This really should answer the question as to whether the general American public has a problem with it.

South Carolina I think still flies it on the state capitol grounds, but no one person "owns" it... and the result of flying it is the boycotting of the state by many groups (the NCAA for example won't hold tournament games there...).

Not even a 2014 Tea Party lunatic candidate would choose to fly one of these flags. (this isn't to say that privately these nuts don't hoard these flags in their attics).

The only past use that anyone can think of that is not blatantly offensive is a low-budget TV show written for 7-year-olds from 1979, and a rock band from the 70's that died in a plane crash (so their use of it is frozen in time and so they had no opportunity to modernize their thinking over the years and maybe distance themselves from it)(and which had gotten into a lyrics-war with Neil Young over segregation etc)... both of these uses are from 30-35-40 years ago... a time where the Alabama football team had just been integrated (really almost all Southern college teams had no black players til the late 60's early 70's), and when blacks-and-whites couldn't be seen on a date in America, especially the South, without the guy getting the sh!t kicked out of him...

Little-known Dukes of Hazzard trivia to lighten this thread up a little: Boss Hogg had the initials "J.D." for Jefferson Davis, and was made to be a corrupt moron... but on one show, his brother appeared, whose initials were "A.L." (for Abraham Lincoln), and who was made to be ethical and a sensible guy.

EDIT: Rather than using a swastika comparison, maybe an IRA flag would make this more understandable... if Notre Dame or the orange-and-green Miami Hurricanes flew an IRA flag, I think that would be pretty offensive and inappropriate... though a decent percentage of people wouldn't understand the problem I guess?

P.S. Everyone has the right to fly anything they want (everyone has the right to pick their nose in public too). Once the person is told of the sensitivity of the flag, if they still fly it, then people have the right to consider them an idiot.

Edited by billyjack (21 Jul 2014 8.10pm)

 

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 21 Jul 14 9.47pm

Quote billyjack at 21 Jul 2014 7.53pm

No American politician in 2014, especially for national office, even a Southern politician, would ever consider flying a Confederate flag at a political rally. They'd immediately be recognized as a backward crackpot racist nut. If a supporter of theirs waved it, the politician would run from an association with that person and that flag. This really should answer the question as to whether the general American public has a problem with it.

South Carolina I think still flies it on the state capitol grounds, but no one person "owns" it... and the result of flying it is the boycotting of the state by many groups (the NCAA for example won't hold tournament games there...).

Not even a 2014 Tea Party lunatic candidate would choose to fly one of these flags. (this isn't to say that privately these nuts don't hoard these flags in their attics).

The only past use that anyone can think of that is not blatantly offensive is a low-budget TV show written for 7-year-olds from 1979, and a rock band from the 70's that died in a plane crash (so their use of it is frozen in time and so they had no opportunity to modernize their thinking over the years and maybe distance themselves from it)(and which had gotten into a lyrics-war with Neil Young over segregation etc)... both of these uses are from 30-35-40 years ago... a time where the Alabama football team had just been integrated (really almost all Southern college teams had no black players til the late 60's early 70's), and when blacks-and-whites couldn't be seen on a date in America, especially the South, without the guy getting the sh!t kicked out of him...

Little-known Dukes of Hazzard trivia to lighten this thread up a little: Boss Hogg had the initials "J.D." for Jefferson Davis, and was made to be a corrupt moron... but on one show, his brother appeared, whose initials were "A.L." (for Abraham Lincoln), and who was made to be ethical and a sensible guy.

EDIT: Rather than using a swastika comparison, maybe an IRA flag would make this more understandable... if Notre Dame or the orange-and-green Miami Hurricanes flew an IRA flag, I think that would be pretty offensive and inappropriate... though a decent percentage of people wouldn't understand the problem I guess?

P.S. Everyone has the right to fly anything they want (everyone has the right to pick their nose in public too). Once the person is told of the sensitivity of the flag, if they still fly it, then people have the right to consider them an idiot.

Edited by billyjack (21 Jul 2014 8.10pm)


Sums things up pretty well. This thread as been a genuine learning experience for me - had no idea the feelings ran so deep but symbols are important things.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 22 Jul 14 3.27pm

Yes, my main concern is the commercial loss this could cause. I try not to moralise. If many people are upset by the image Palace present, that will cost Palace lost revenue. And the problem with that?

 

EaglesY'all Flag Washington, DC 14 Jul 15 4.22am

Just remembered this thread tonight and was wondering what has happened within the past year. I'm an American who started watching with the start of the NBC contract and decided Palace was going to be my team after it won the 6 points in 2 games in December '13. And it's been fun to watch ever since. I rarely post since y'all know more about the sport than I do.

Being mindful of the events in the past few weeks, were people flying Confederate flags during this past season, and was that immediately dealt with? As much as I've enjoyed watching Palace, if this is going to be allowed, than it's a club and a fan base I want no part of.

Updates? Thoughts?

Edited by EaglesY'all (14 Jul 2015 4.23am)

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 14 Jul 15 4.47am

It is a symbol of racism and bigotry in the USA. It is also the unabashed symbol of insurrection against the nation. I don't think Alan Pardew wants to see it at a Palace match given his statements concerning diversity. However, to be fair, there is a difference in that here in the US African American churches are being burned down and nine members of one of the oldest Black churches in the US were murdered by a 21 year old man who worshiped that flag's most obscene meanings. Churches are not burning in the UK as far as I know and no one is shooting up congregations there either. It would be much better if that flag were not seen associated with Crystal Palace, one of the most diverse clubs anywhere including the USA (take a good look at your average MLS club. What don't you see?). Leave that kind of spiteful nonsense to Scumwall.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

grump Flag Milford On Sea 14 Jul 15 6.22am

This is a complex issue, personally I don't see the confederate flag as a symbol of racism, although I can't deny certain racist groups have adopted the flag. To me it is the battle flag of the Confederate army in their fight to separate themselves from the union. In that respect it was the flag of ordinary working people most of whom were as downtrodden as the black slaves being abused by wealthy landowners. To me it represents the way of life of these ordinary working people and the freedom they fought for for themselves, nothing to do with race.

If you want to ban flags because they have been adopted by racist groups then we should be banning our own Union flag (Union Jack), as this too has been adopted by racist groups such as the National Front, British National Party, as well as the use of the English national flag by the EDL.

I don't believe in banning a flag just because a bunch of nut jobs want to use it for their own ends.

 


Stay out the way of the Southern thing.

jimmyc Flag 14 Jul 15 6.39am

Quote grump at 14 Jul 2015 6.22am

This is a complex issue, personally I don't see the confederate flag as a symbol of racism, although I can't deny certain racist groups have adopted the flag. To me it is the battle flag of the Confederate army in their fight to separate themselves from the union. In that respect it was the flag of ordinary working people most of whom were as downtrodden as the black slaves being abused by wealthy landowners. To me it represents the way of life of these ordinary working people and the freedom they fought for for themselves, nothing to do with race.

If you want to ban flags because they have been adopted by racist groups then we should be banning our own Union flag (Union Jack), as this too has been adopted by racist groups such as the National Front, British National Party, as well as the use of the English national flag by the EDL.

I don't believe in banning a flag just because a bunch of nut jobs want to use it for their own ends.


Mate please don't take this the wrong way but I think your understanding about the American civil war is a massively off base. This was not a class war, the poor were used as soldiers for both sides, with the north signing up immigrants right of the ships and sending them to war...the poor always seem to do the fighting and dying! The reality is the southern economy and the whole structure of the south was based on slavery...so while you might be able to claim that they wanted freedom from the north, that freedom would have allowed slavery to continue.


Edited by jimmyc (14 Jul 2015 6.56am)

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 14 Jul 15 6.57am

Quote grump at 14 Jul 2015 6.22am

This is a complex issue, personally I don't see the confederate flag as a symbol of racism, although I can't deny certain racist groups have adopted the flag. To me it is the battle flag of the Confederate army in their fight to separate themselves from the union. In that respect it was the flag of ordinary working people most of whom were as downtrodden as the black slaves being abused by wealthy landowners. To me it represents the way of life of these ordinary working people and the freedom they fought for for themselves, nothing to do with race.

If you want to ban flags because they have been adopted by racist groups then we should be banning our own Union flag (Union Jack), as this too has been adopted by racist groups such as the National Front, British National Party, as well as the use of the English national flag by the EDL.

I don't believe in banning a flag just because a bunch of nut jobs want to use it for their own ends.

US History disagrees. The "peculiar" institution that was African slavery was the root cause of the Civil War. Yes, Northern business interests, particularly New England maritime interests profited greatly from the slave trade until importation was banned. Then inbreeding began. It was the Confederacy that fired the first shots of the war at Fort Sumter and a great deal of documentation has proved that racism was at the foundation of Southern philosophy, such as the "white race is superior to the Negro." Racism is and will always be the original sin of the United States. It was enshrined in the Constitution (slaves were counted as 3/5 a person for census purposes) and it took the 13th, 14th and 15th Amendments to partially undo that. 100 years later, the Civil Rights and Voting Rights Acts were needed to reinforce the Constitutional Amendments passed a century earlier. The Confederate battle flag is seen in this country as fundamentally racist by more and more people. The South Carolina Governor, as Republican as it gets and the South Carolina State Legislature, as staunchly conservative and jealously guarded of their traditions as can be, voted themselves into special session and ordered the battle flag removed in near record time. This wasn't PC run amok. It was the revulsion they felt over the wanton murder of nine more people, including one of their own, due to racist extremism in their own backyard. It was Philadelphia, Mississippi in 1965, when three young civil rights workers were murdered on orders from the KKK to local law enforcement. It was the firebombing of an AME Church in Birmingham, Alabama that killed several black youth worshipping there. Not for one minute do I think consigning that flag to a museum will change much. As far as the Union Flag is concerned, yes there have been some pretty rotten things done in its name. There have been some pretty rotten things done in the name of the Stars and Stripes, most recently the needless invasion of Iraq. There have also been some pretty good things done as well. The only thing the Confederate Battle Flag and the Stars and Bars (the official flag of the Confederacy) represent is a system where some considered themselves superior human beings to others based on their skin color. That is racist to its core and that is what the Confederacy was all about. To anyone who believes themselves to be a superior life form, let me remind them that we all put our trousers on the same way, one leg at a time. Before anyone says I sympathize with the North because I am a New Yorker, I should tell you that no member of my family lived in the United States before 1895 and that my father emigrated from Germany in October 1935, stayed in London for a time and arrived in the US aboard RMS Berengaria in February 1936. That makes me a first generation American on my father's side and third on my mother's. No member of my family had a stake in the United States from the founding of the first colonies until the last five years of the 19th Century. No member of my family was involved in the lead up to the Civil War, the actual war or the events that followed it known as Reconstruction.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

npn Flag Crowborough 14 Jul 15 7.38am

Quote kenbarr at 14 Jul 2015 6.57am

Quote grump at 14 Jul 2015 6.22am

This is a complex issue, personally I don't see the confederate flag as a symbol of racism, although I can't deny certain racist groups have adopted the flag. To me it is the battle flag of the Confederate army in their fight to separate themselves from the union. In that respect it was the flag of ordinary working people most of whom were as downtrodden as the black slaves being abused by wealthy landowners. To me it represents the way of life of these ordinary working people and the freedom they fought for for themselves, nothing to do with race.

If you want to ban flags because they have been adopted by racist groups then we should be banning our own Union flag (Union Jack), as this too has been adopted by racist groups such as the National Front, British National Party, as well as the use of the English national flag by the EDL.

I don't believe in banning a flag just because a bunch of nut jobs want to use it for their own ends.

US History disagrees. The "peculiar" institution that was African slavery was the root cause of the Civil War. Yes, Northern business interests, particularly New England maritime interests profited greatly from the slave trade until importation was banned. Then inbreeding began. It was the Confederacy that fired the first shots of the war at Fort Sumter and a great deal of documentation has proved that racism was at the foundation of Southern philosophy, such as the "white race is superior to the Negro." Racism is and will always be the original sin of the United States. It was enshrined in the Constitution (slaves were counted as 3/5 a person for census purposes) and it took the 13th, 14th and 15th Amendments to partially undo that. 100 years later, the Civil Rights and Voting Rights Acts were needed to reinforce the Constitutional Amendments passed a century earlier. The Confederate battle flag is seen in this country as fundamentally racist by more and more people. The South Carolina Governor, as Republican as it gets and the South Carolina State Legislature, as staunchly conservative and jealously guarded of their traditions as can be, voted themselves into special session and ordered the battle flag removed in near record time. This wasn't PC run amok. It was the revulsion they felt over the wanton murder of nine more people, including one of their own, due to racist extremism in their own backyard. It was Philadelphia, Mississippi in 1965, when three young civil rights workers were murdered on orders from the KKK to local law enforcement. It was the firebombing of an AME Church in Birmingham, Alabama that killed several black youth worshipping there. Not for one minute do I think consigning that flag to a museum will change much. As far as the Union Flag is concerned, yes there have been some pretty rotten things done in its name. There have been some pretty rotten things done in the name of the Stars and Stripes, most recently the needless invasion of Iraq. There have also been some pretty good things done as well. The only thing the Confederate Battle Flag and the Stars and Bars (the official flag of the Confederacy) represent is a system where some considered themselves superior human beings to others based on their skin color. That is racist to its core and that is what the Confederacy was all about. To anyone who believes themselves to be a superior life form, let me remind them that we all put our trousers on the same way, one leg at a time. Before anyone says I sympathize with the North because I am a New Yorker, I should tell you that no member of my family lived in the United States before 1895 and that my father emigrated from Germany in October 1935, stayed in London for a time and arrived in the US aboard RMS Berengaria in February 1936. That makes me a first generation American on my father's side and third on my mother's. No member of my family had a stake in the United States from the founding of the first colonies until the last five years of the 19th Century. No member of my family was involved in the lead up to the Civil War, the actual war or the events that followed it known as Reconstruction.


Apu's application for US citizenship in the Simpsons:

Examiner: All right, here's your last question. What was the cause of the Civil War?
Apu: Actually, there were numerous causes. Aside from the obvious schism between the abolitionists and the anti-abolitionists, there were economic factors, both domestic and inter...
Examiner: Wait, wait... just say slavery.
Apu: Slavery it is, sir.

 

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 14 Jul 15 1.02pm

Quote billyjack at 01 Jul 2014 4.54am

Hey guys,
Regular lurker here on your site, and Palace admirer from New England in the USA. Please don't adopt and support the Confederate flag in your fans' groups. I know it was 150 years ago when the South first flew this flag in our Civil War, and in a sane world it shouldn't be a big deal, but the US has some rough history and some insane people, and the flag still has bad undertones and dog whistle meanings.

Sorry to butt into your message board, but thought it might be helpful to get an American's take on the flag... and I'd recommend strongly that you don't associate yourself with it.

Best of luck this coming season...!


Edited by billyjack (01 Jul 2014 5.17am)

to echo this, quite disturbing. lest anyone try to dissuade you, the civil war was about slavery. nothing more or less. of course some other things around that.

the flag has been hijacked by people who adhere to some sentimental notion that things were better in the past. they aren't all out and out racists; but they liked things better when minorities better "knew their place." and they had freedom to use racist words, and act like heathens, etc.

you'll never see anyone other than whites with this flag so what's that tell you? sadly, years on and we have to see this in society - the flag is massively disparaging to anyone non-white but singularly pointed to anyone african-american. sad that some can't understand that.


 

Page 11 of 18 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Confederate Flag