You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we allowed to start slating pardew again yet?
November 16 2026 11.44am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are we allowed to start slating pardew again yet?


Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Mstrobez Flag 25 Oct 16 11.15pm

Originally posted by KAOS

No mate, I agree with ya 100% but can't be bother arguing with people on here anymore. I'll wait to pick up the argument again this time next month when nothing has improved and see what they say then!

I was exactly the same mate. Disappeared long ago from this site and contemplated the whole thread but as stated just realised I didn't really give a s*** about the abuse anymore.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

palace-metros Flag Redhill 25 Oct 16 11.15pm

Originally posted by KAOS

Surely if you were positive in Pardew you'd tell me I was talking rubbish and that what I'm suggesting won't be the case! Instead you infer that I'm looking forward to the inevitable! I rest my case ...

Just an observation not a criticism btw. And I would have hoped my use of certain emojis conveyed my tone but alas not ... so sorry for any confusion there

Oh not at all. I infer that you believe this will be inevitable and will be pleased to remind us of it after the event. (emojis notwithstanding ). Whilst I am not an ardent supporter of Pardew, I happen to believe that your criticism is over zealous - although not to the same extent as the OP who gives the impression he would be more than happy to see a contract onAP before he is offered a new one!

 


Before you criticise someone, you should walk a mile in their shoes. That way, when you criticise them, you're a mile away and you have their shoes.

Mstrobez Flag 25 Oct 16 11.21pm

Originally posted by palace-metros

Oh not at all. I infer that you believe this will be inevitable and will be pleased to remind us of it after the event. (emojis notwithstanding ). Whilst I am not an ardent supporter of Pardew, I happen to believe that your criticism is over zealous - although not to the same extent as the OP who gives the impression he would be more than happy to see a contract onAP before he is offered a new one!

That's where your wrong. I'd love more to be utterly embarrassingly proved wrong, more than anything. Its actually more a case of I strongly believe I won't be.

Can we please stop stating that anyone who doesn't like the manager hopes we lose. It's bulls***, we support the same club whether your ashamed of that or not.

Edited by Mstrobez (25 Oct 2016 11.21pm)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

palace-metros Flag Redhill 25 Oct 16 11.28pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

That's where your wrong. I'd love more to be utterly embarrassingly proved wrong, more than anything. Its actually more a case of I strongly believe I won't be.

Can we please stop stating that anyone who doesn't like the manager hopes we lose. It's bulls***, we support the same club whether your ashamed of that or not.

Edited by Mstrobez (25 Oct 2016 11.21pm)

I think sometimes it's the vehemency of the argument that can lead to that impression. I know it's BS as we are all Palace fans in our different ways. I'd be more interested to know how you manage CPFC with your glass half empty though? For me, my day to day is such that I need to at least keep the football positive!

 


Before you criticise someone, you should walk a mile in their shoes. That way, when you criticise them, you're a mile away and you have their shoes.

MandurahEagle Flag Mandurah 26 Oct 16 12.09am

Dangermouse makes some good points. As a Palace supporter you should be well used to the ups and downs. You could argue that we are not a big money team so AP has to make do with the players that Palace can afford but when they get injured it presents a real problem as we do not have the depth of talent that other teams have available. Having said that some of the decisions made are probably not down to AP but done on a purely financial basis. For instance selling Gayle and keeping Campbell. Some of the late changes in a game are more down to panic than tactical. There is little point changing managers at this stage as there is no magic wand that can be waved. With all the money at their disposal and buying the most expensive player in the World, Manure under Jose are not doing too well either!

 

Mstrobez Flag 26 Oct 16 12.20am

Originally posted by palace-metros

I think sometimes it's the vehemency of the argument that can lead to that impression. I know it's BS as we are all Palace fans in our different ways. I'd be more interested to know how you manage CPFC with your glass half empty though? For me, my day to day is such that I need to at least keep the football positive!

I think the vehemency fully comes from both sides. It's what riles me up to this extent anyway. I have tried to have many reasonable debates about pardew (during bad AND good times) on here/in the pubs before games etc. And have constantly been shut down in quite an aggressive fashion.

With regards to the half glass empty, I don't view it that way. I think we should be playing better. As I've said it's the style of football we play under pardew + the players we have that = the negativity (the results that have invariably come with it also). I'm massively optimistic about the future of the club, being able to go to selhurst and see Christian Benteke leading the line with Mandanda in goal and Cabaye in the middle is something else. Im just not convinced at all with pardew in charge, and I think that viewpoint is more than justified!

I may not have been around as long as some but trust me I've grown up with palace being relatively s*** and I love them all the same, win or lose. But we're not in that phase anymore, we gotta drop this losers mindset, and I just can't understand how people can defend Pardews record in the past year.

Edited by Mstrobez (26 Oct 2016 12.24am)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

RH8Eagle Flag Oxted 26 Oct 16 12.39am

Originally posted by Mstrobez

I think the vehemency fully comes from both sides. It's what riles me up to this extent anyway. I have tried to have many reasonable debates about pardew (during bad AND good times) on here/in the pubs before games etc. And have constantly been shut down in quite an aggressive fashion.

With regards to the half glass empty, I don't view it that way. I think we should be playing better. As I've said it's the style of football we play under pardew + the players we have that = the negativity (the results that have invariably come with it also). I'm massively optimistic about the future of the club, being able to go to selhurst and see Christian Benteke leading the line with Mandanda in goal and Cabaye in the middle is something else. Im just not convinced at all with pardew in charge, and I think that viewpoint is more than justified!

I may not have been around as long as some but trust me I've grown up with palace being relatively s*** and I love them all the same, win or lose. But we're not in that phase anymore, we gotta drop this losers mindset, and I just can't understand how people can defend Pardews record in the past year.

Can you tell me how long you have been around as for me and many others we are actually on the crest of a wave ATM. So just how long have you been aboard the rollercoaster ?


 

Mstrobez Flag 26 Oct 16 12.50am

Originally posted by RH8Eagle

Originally posted by Mstrobez

I think the vehemency fully comes from both sides. It's what riles me up to this extent anyway. I have tried to have many reasonable debates about pardew (during bad AND good times) on here/in the pubs before games etc. And have constantly been shut down in quite an aggressive fashion.

With regards to the half glass empty, I don't view it that way. I think we should be playing better. As I've said it's the style of football we play under pardew + the players we have that = the negativity (the results that have invariably come with it also). I'm massively optimistic about the future of the club, being able to go to selhurst and see Christian Benteke leading the line with Mandanda in goal and Cabaye in the middle is something else. Im just not convinced at all with pardew in charge, and I think that viewpoint is more than justified!

I may not have been around as long as some but trust me I've grown up with palace being relatively s*** and I love them all the same, win or lose. But we're not in that phase anymore, we gotta drop this losers mindset, and I just can't understand how people can defend Pardews record in the past year.

Can you tell me how long you have been around as for me and many others we are actually on the crest of a wave ATM. So just how long have you been aboard the rollercoaster ?


Im 22. Possibly very young to many but vividly remember administration, promotion, relegation and general mediocrity whilst all my mates were moaning that the new arsenal kit wasn't as nice as last years.

I too am at the highest point ever of being a palace fan. Don't see the correlation between that and thinking the manager is s***e but am sure another smart Alec will find a link between the 2 and make it out as Me just being an immature plastic bed wetter.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

RH8Eagle Flag Oxted 26 Oct 16 1.11am

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Im 22. Possibly very young to many but vividly remember administration, promotion, relegation and general mediocrity whilst all my mates were moaning that the new arsenal kit wasn't as nice as last years.

I too am at the highest point ever of being a palace fan. Don't see the correlation between that and thinking the manager is s***e but am sure another smart Alec will find a link between the 2 and make it out as Me just being an immature plastic bed wetter.

I am not looking for a stick to beat you with but I am looking for reasons why you are thinking so differently from me. It could be a generation thing I have kids older than you and quite a few of their age group just don't seem to have the patience of our generation. But you should be careful what you wish for in this game as it's littered with broken dreams, Leeds, Bolton, Charlton, Forest to name but a few would give their right arm for what we've got. We are currently the 11th best team in the land and AP is at the helm, he may have a few querks ( who hasn't ) but that will do for me. If it all goes belly up SP will act and life goes on but while he's here I support him and when the next man comes in I will support him also. Simple for me

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Oct 16 9.52am

Originally posted by RH8Eagle

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Im 22. Possibly very young to many but vividly remember administration, promotion, relegation and general mediocrity whilst all my mates were moaning that the new arsenal kit wasn't as nice as last years.

I too am at the highest point ever of being a palace fan. Don't see the correlation between that and thinking the manager is s***e but am sure another smart Alec will find a link between the 2 and make it out as Me just being an immature plastic bed wetter.

I am not looking for a stick to beat you with but I am looking for reasons why you are thinking so differently from me. It could be a generation thing I have kids older than you and quite a few of their age group just don't seem to have the patience of our generation. But you should be careful what you wish for in this game as it's littered with broken dreams, Leeds, Bolton, Charlton, Forest to name but a few would give their right arm for what we've got. We are currently the 11th best team in the land and AP is at the helm, he may have a few querks ( who hasn't ) but that will do for me. If it all goes belly up SP will act and life goes on but while he's here I support him and when the next man comes in I will support him also. Simple for me

This is what does for me. If AP goes on another long bad run or we're fighting the bottom 3 then SP will have AP out.

The last 2 runs of fixtures really say it all. He beat the sh1t and struggled vs the better and got nothing really. Played well in parts but prepared badly. Next up is Liverpool in hot form. If that continues into the beatable sides then we and he have a problem.

Unless SP has a target lined up its not worth moving AP out. The risk of it falling apart and being relegated for 1 or 2 extra places in the league. Kind of similar happened to Charlton. But if we're near the drop then the risk factor changes. He's just extended his contract so that's really how it is.

But that doesn't mean fans can't vent their frustrations with AP. He is average for this level but if average keeps us here then ok. When it looks like he won't they bye bye.

Unfortunately the talk of the FA cup final in the future will now have the memory of Pardew doing a stupid and embarrassing dance when he could've been sending out instructions. Shame.

 


COYP

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 26 Oct 16 10.03am

I think the next couple of games are going to be very important. If we lose them, not only is this board going to go into meltdown, the players might start wondering if they're going to go on another long loosing run. If that happens we're in trouble.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Oct 16 10.23am

Originally posted by spartakev2

I think the next couple of games are going to be very important. If we lose them, not only is this board going to go into meltdown, the players might start wondering if they're going to go on another long loosing run. If that happens we're in trouble.

I agree with these sentiments.
You and I on the same "Wavelength" is a very worrying development as far as you are concerned !

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Oct 16 10.24am

Originally posted by spartakev2

I think the next couple of games are going to be very important. If we lose them, not only is this board going to go into meltdown, the players might start wondering if they're going to go on another long loosing run. If that happens we're in trouble.

Yes I was thinking the same. Unfortunately because of these types of runs a lot of expectation will be on the Burnley away game which you preferably don't want.

In fact until Christmas the next 9 games have us play the very very hard games at home and the more winnable games away. That can either be a good or bad thing. Let's just hope it's ok or better or it could be all change. See, I don't want him sacked purely because that'll mean our failure.

Thank God we beat Mboro, Stoke and Sunderland and played them when we did or I think we'd be in serious trouble and asking Keith Millen to draw a couple of games during the headhunting process.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (26 Oct 2016 10.25am)

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Oct 16 11.15am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Unless SP has a target lined up its not worth moving AP out.

A chairman should always be aware of who is available and who might be approachable as that is part of the chairman's role

 

Kingvagabond Flag London 26 Oct 16 11.42am

Have people forgotten we have Liverpool next. We always beat Liverpool!

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

Diagonal Flag 26 Oct 16 12.40pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Yes I was thinking the same. Unfortunately because of these types of runs a lot of expectation will be on the Burnley away game which you preferably don't want.

In fact until Christmas the next 9 games have us play the very very hard games at home and the more winnable games away. That can either be a good or bad thing. Let's just hope it's ok or better or it could be all change. See, I don't want him sacked purely because that'll mean our failure.

Thank God we beat Mboro, Stoke and Sunderland and played them when we did or I think we'd be in serious trouble and asking Keith Millen to draw a couple of games during the headhunting process.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (26 Oct 2016 10.25am)

You know, it seems to me as though the confidence of the squad (or it's lack of confidence) mean that we stand more of a chance winning against the better sides than we do against those who are 'meant' to be beating or at least competing with. Having said that, we seem to have a greater freedom against better teams away from home.

It's going to be very interesting this next run of games. If things don't go well at Selhurst Park against the big teams - I don't think we'll get a result against Liverpool, but we might against some of the others - AND we underperform against our contemporaries away, then I think the writing will be on the wall for Pardew. Curiously, if Pardew is to consolidate his position, I think it'll be because we achieve the former.


Edited by Diagonal (26 Oct 2016 12.45pm)

 


If only it were White, rather than Yellow!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Oct 16 12.42pm

Does that last paragraph need editing?

 


COYP

Painter Flag Croydon 26 Oct 16 1.59pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

I think the vehemency fully comes from both sides. It's what riles me up to this extent anyway. I have tried to have many reasonable debates about pardew (during bad AND good times) on here/in the pubs before games etc. And have constantly been shut down in quite an aggressive fashion.

With regards to the half glass empty, I don't view it that way. I think we should be playing better. As I've said it's the style of football we play under pardew + the players we have that = the negativity (the results that have invariably come with it also). I'm massively optimistic about the future of the club, being able to go to selhurst and see Christian Benteke leading the line with Mandanda in goal and Cabaye in the middle is something else. Im just not convinced at all with pardew in charge, and I think that viewpoint is more than justified!

I may not have been around as long as some but trust me I've grown up with palace being relatively s*** and I love them all the same, win or lose. But we're not in that phase anymore, we gotta drop this losers mindset, and I just can't understand how people can defend Pardews record in the past year.

Edited by Mstrobez (26 Oct 2016 12.24am)

Reading through your many posts, I get you don't like Pardew. I have yet to see anyone offer a credible alternative to him.
Finding a manager to take a club forward is very difficult, look at Moyes and Mouriniho who both were held in high esteem a short while ago, now seen as failures.

The board and SP have the opinions that count, it looks obvious they want an element of stability within the club, as past Chairmen have chopped and changed without any success, just cost a lot of money.

I cannot see Pardew being relieved of his post anytime soon, unless there is a real alternative.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 26 Oct 16 3.06pm

Remember Charlton? Fans moaning that they were fed up with Alan curbishley keeping them in the lowerhalf/middle of the prem and not moving on to "the next level". The board finally caved in and made a change, and thats gone well hasnt it! Be careful what you wish for.

 

cpj Flag Kent 26 Oct 16 3.25pm

Originally posted by Kingvagabond

Have people forgotten we have Liverpool next. We always beat Liverpool!

Not last season, nor in the Cup the previous year.

 

Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we allowed to start slating pardew again yet?