You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Freedman is back
November 16 2026 9.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Freedman is back


Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
est1905 Flag 22 Aug 17 4.38pm

Originally posted by bexleydave

I can't be bothered to read the whole of this thread, but as I posted on the other thread on this subject, Freedman had a decent record of identifying transfer targets and it's a position I think we should have filled long ago, so I'm quite happy to give him a chance.

That could not be further from the truth!
The only players that Freedman brought in on his own recommendation were Aaron Wilbraham and the flop striker we had on loan from Southampton (forget the name).
All the others were identified or recommended by Lennie Lawrence, Curtis Fleming and Tony Popovic.
That's to say, all the ones that were any good. You know like Murray, Bolasie, Jedi

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 22 Aug 17 4.40pm

What I love is now some people are saying Freedman was right to grass us up because we should not have been doing something wrong. (on Twitter and Facebook)

Why not go one stage further and say we should have accepted a points deduction as punishment because we were in the wrong.

He is what he is and has done what he's done. I forgive him but I won't forget what he did and I won't like the guy.

We all make mistakes and we should have to earn trust and respect again not have people get a semi because a 'legend' has returned 'home' a home he was happy to dump on twice or more.

He loves us all so much, right?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Aug 17 5.05pm

Originally posted by est1905

That could not be further from the truth!
The only players that Freedman brought in on his own recommendation were Aaron Wilbraham and the flop striker we had on loan from Southampton (forget the name).
All the others were identified or recommended by Lennie Lawrence, Curtis Fleming and Tony Popovic.
That's to say, all the ones that were any good. You know like Murray, Bolasie, Jedi

Freedman did go and watch Murray. There were more. Moxey, KG etc.

Can't remember on Bolasie. Happened so quickly after the car park showdown talks at Bristol City. Maybe Yannck overheard them whilst rapping and tagging up the car park and told them to check the videos on his website.

DF does know about emerging formations of the day and about them being what you build a squad around, and fitting those pieces of the jigsaw together, which could be useful.

I just doubted him in the dugout, which isn't his remit, and hopefully it doesn't become his, although I have to admit I've posted he'd suit prem management more than championship promotion hunting management.

 


COYP

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 22 Aug 17 5.21pm

Originally posted by Leecpfc

Glad to have Dougie back where he belongs. Yeah he made a mistake, but he's done enough for Palace over his career to warrant forgiveness and a second chance.

I do wonder how many fair weather fans even know who he is. You know, like the ones who haven't seen us play Chanpionship football.

Edited by Leecpfc (22 Aug 2017 3.06pm)

Exactly this,good post.

Welcome back DF

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 22 Aug 17 6.32pm

Originally posted by est1905

That could not be further from the truth!
The only players that Freedman brought in on his own recommendation were Aaron Wilbraham and the flop striker we had on loan from Southampton (forget the name).
All the others were identified or recommended by Lennie Lawrence, Curtis Fleming and Tony Popovic.
That's to say, all the ones that were any good. You know like Murray, Bolasie, Jedinac

[/quote

Bolasie signed by Freedman for £350k sold with a profit of £18.8m
Jedanic, Delaney etc. Not to be sniffed at!

 


Bring back Brolin

Username Flag Horsham 22 Aug 17 7.00pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

Understandably after everything that's happened, people are debating if we need a Director of Football, If FDB is happy with it, if we forgive Dougie for what happened, if it's just a ruse to get Dougie the Manager job.

They are all very exciting points to talk about which is probably why this subject has been glossed over a bit - what the hell qualifications or experience does Dougie have to do this job?

He was a player, than a coach, then a FAILED manager, now a Premier League Director Of Football.

That doesn't seem right to me. I'd love to at least know that since his last Management stint, he's been to University and done a degree in this field.

Going back to the point about whether FDB is happy to have a DoF, I think it's evident he is as he has always had one but why would he listen to the likes of Freedman? He's not a DoF, he's a random club legend that has been slapped with a new Title.

So pretty much exactly the same career path as Les Reed, who has been extremely successful since he has been at Southampton.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Username Flag Horsham 22 Aug 17 7.15pm

Originally posted by weaselpop

Well, I've re-listened to the HOL interview, I've read the whole thread here, and I STILL don't understand this appointment, its timing, or how it actually happened. There was no hint or rumour that we were looking right now, no gossip (that I've seen), no other names in the frame, no betting odds for us to lol over, none of the usual media paraphenalia. So did SP just ring him up and say "Hi Dougie, I've got a job for you, let bygones be bygones, and btw you start on Monday".

Why is that a bad thing? That we might get something done without someone writing a rumour about it?

Quote

Other posters have argued that we have needed a Director for a while, so why now? And then there's the 'theory' that he's there in case FDB fails badly - laughable to me. So maybe SP has been mulling this for a while but the timing wasn't right before, maybe he also ran it past FDB from the start but wasn't able to activate it until now... But as I say, without any kind of information (fact or fiction) I can't begin to get my head round it. Personally I've no objection to the post, I've no great hatred for DF because of past errors of judgement, and I think he's a pretty shrewd thinker - apart from the Bolton debacle...

Why now? Why not? If it's been needed for awhile why put it off any longer?


Edited by Username (22 Aug 2017 7.15pm)

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Jacey Flag 23 Aug 17 1.27pm

Dougie had a knack for signing quality and I welcome his return.

Surprised he hasn't insisted that Lenny Lawrence join him in his new role.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 23 Aug 17 2.57pm

If it helps, I spent some time with Dougie Freedman a few years back. We were on the same coaching course, he had just taken on the reserves at Palace (I think) having been mentored by Warnock.

Freedman came across as a polite but reserved man. Happy to talk frankly about football when approached, but certainly not one for the pub or the limelight. Even considering that many of the class didn't know each other, I was still surprised at how distant he seemed. Plenty of big names in our class relaxed and thawed out, but Dougie remained slightly detached. He was meticulous and very professional, and though he loved football he was at pains to avoid any of the celebrity side of it, and seemed to be there exclusively for the qualification rather than to make friends with anyone. I found professional footballers to be a nice bunch, but it is a bit of a closed shop / old pals network sort of gig, so Freedman stood out as bit by showing no interest in forming contacts or social climbing.

His attitude to being a Palace legend sort of summed him up. He was very appreciative of what palace had given him, and proud of what he had given back, but these seemed like professional achievements more than emotional ones. He lived in Essex rather than South London partly because he wasn’t comfortable with being a ‘legend’ as he went about his daily business. When he became manager I think a lot of us saw a continuation of Dougie the player, this brilliant, skilful, imaginative goalscorer who gave Palace so many highlights and was so loved for it, and couldn’t accept that he could break that bond to go to Bolton. In actual fact, whether as a player or a manager I think we are talking about a very professional man rather than an emotional one. He played for and managed us because we were his best employment option, gave us full value for money and then some every time, and that’s doubtless what he’ll be doing this time round.

He’s a serious guy, will be here for serious reasons. It's irrelevant that he played here, managed here, and left here before.

 

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 23 Aug 17 2.58pm

Frankly I don't know why it's DF, but I can see having a Sporting Director could be useful.
FDB knows Europe, and I'm sure people will take his calls (I doubt the big clubs know who DF is, let alone take his calls.)

BUT one area why I think DF could help is selling our surplus squaddies to Championship teams. While I'm sure they'd take FDBs call, he has to focus on getting players in, not convincing Leeds to buy Mutch, Wolves to buy Sako or Bolton to buy Lee back.

DF may be clueless in the Prem and Europe, but he could be useful selling to lower league team, or identifying and getting diamonds in the rough.

Still don't know why it had to be DF though!

 

est1905 Flag 23 Aug 17 4.59pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Originally posted by est1905

That could not be further from the truth!
The only players that Freedman brought in on his own recommendation were Aaron Wilbraham and the flop striker we had on loan from Southampton (forget the name).
All the others were identified or recommended by Lennie Lawrence, Curtis Fleming and Tony Popovic.
That's to say, all the ones that were any good. You know like Murray, Bolasie, Jedinac

[/quote

Bolasie signed by Freedman for £350k sold with a profit of £18.8m
Jedanic, Delaney etc. Not to be sniffed at!

Bolasie-spotted by Curtis Fleming, Jedi-Popovic, Delaney-Fleming, Murray-Lennie Lawrence

 

paperhat Flag croydon 23 Aug 17 5.05pm

Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation

Frankly I don't know why it's DF, but I can see having a Sporting Director could be useful.
FDB knows Europe, and I'm sure people will take his calls (I doubt the big clubs know who DF is, let alone take his calls.)

BUT one area why I think DF could help is selling our surplus squaddies to Championship teams. While I'm sure they'd take FDBs call, he has to focus on getting players in, not convincing Leeds to buy Mutch, Wolves to buy Sako or Bolton to buy Lee back.

DF may be clueless in the Prem and Europe, but he could be useful selling to lower league team, or identifying and getting diamonds in the rough.

Still don't know why it had to be DF though!

because he's our next manager when they get shot of FDB

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


est1905 Flag 23 Aug 17 5.14pm

Sadly, I cant see any other reason for bringing him in.
I just pray even harder now that Frank makes it work, and stays!

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 23 Aug 17 5.24pm

Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation

DF may be clueless in the Prem and Europe, but he could be useful selling to lower league team, or identifying and getting diamonds in the rough.

Still don't know why it had to be DF though!

If DF is "clueless" because he hasn't managed in the Premiership doesn't that make all of HOLs subscribers clueless too?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 23 Aug 17 5.25pm

Originally posted by paperhat

because he's our next manager when they get shot of FDB

You obviously have little faith in Steve Parish's ability as a chairman then


 

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 23 Aug 17 8.55pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

If DF is "clueless" because he hasn't managed in the Premiership doesn't that make all of HOLs subscribers clueless too?

I doubt many of us would fulfill the minimum requirements of the Sporting Director job. But I'm sure there are more than a few who are sure they could do a better job than DF.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 23 Aug 17 9.38pm

Out of interest can anyone tell me who are the DoF's at the other prem clubs and what their qualifications are? Can anyone tell me what each club expects their DoF's to do? Thanks in anticipation.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 23 Aug 17 9.55pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

Out of interest can anyone tell me who are the DoF's at the other prem clubs and what their qualifications are? Can anyone tell me what each club expects their DoF's to do? Thanks in anticipation.

The general job description of a DoF is to be snidey and sneery about everything a football manager does, watching from up high above them in the stands on a match day. Secondly, always be looking to stab the manager in the back and jump in their warm dugout, after you've manipulated their demise.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

tonymikejoe Flag UK 23 Aug 17 10.30pm

It always amuses me that the Freedman Out! thread on the Bolton Wanders' Fans forum reached a monstrous 269 pages.

[Link]

He has clearly only secured the role because of his CPFC links, but to be fair he is a net contributor to the club - a rarity.

Surely judged on his achievements at Bolton, then Nottingham Forest, he fails to warrant senior appointment at a Premier League club.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 23 Aug 17 10.36pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

Surely judged on his achievements at Bolton, then Nottingham Forest, he fails to warrant senior appointment at a Premier League club.

Why don't you tell Steve Parish that he doesn't know what he is doing then

 

Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Freedman is back