This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
all 5 were from susssex to so most likely brighton fans Pretty sure one was from croydon . Another was 15 ffs
When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC |
|
| Kodg |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ashamed to be Palace tonight' by Midlands Eagle Where is the evidence of such Police brutality and 'Heavy handed' tactics ? Let's NOT deflect attention away from the errant hoodlums who decended on the town and the football ground. Where is the evidence? Oh come on. Stop being such a pompous knob. There's countless firsthand testimonies from people telling you what happened to them. But instead your arrogance prevents you from deviating from your prejudice. If you're not prepared to listen, maybe stop posting
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Kodg
This is totally in keeping with my experience of the night too. The level of incompetence from the police was extraordinary and as a result my son got to see his father smack a brighton support who tried to attack him, something I had hope he would never have to see. Likewise, the police at Brighton station where beyond stupid stopping those of us with cars or hotel rooms from getting out of the station and trying to force us on to train. This is disgusting. I hope anyone who was treated like this by the police makes a formal complaint and insists on its being sent to the police complaints authority (whatever it's called now). And anyone who was hurt sues the scum. Remember that getting hurt doesn't just mean visible injuries - being scared s***less by being kettled in a cordon with dogs and horses such that it affects you afterwards counts too. It's not even as if Palace have a reputation for troublemaking. It's not the job of the police to punish all the away fans just because a few idiots decide to use a football match as an excuse for violence and thuggery. The whole point of the police is to stop them from ruining it for everone else.
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
This is disgusting. I hope anyone who was treated like this by the police makes a formal complaint and insists on its being sent to the police complaints authority (whatever it's called now). And anyone who was hurt sues the scum. Remember that getting hurt doesn't just mean visible injuries - being scared s***less by being kettled in a cordon with dogs and horses such that it affects you afterwards counts too. It's not even as if Palace have a reputation for troublemaking. It's not the job of the police to punish all the away fans just because a few idiots decide to use a football match as an excuse for violence and thuggery. The whole point of the police is to stop them from ruining it for everone else.
Was probably my winter coat which prevented me from having visible bruising.. No wonder when I got home at gone 1am it took me several hours laying there to actually manage to get to sleep. Like running on fumes all day today. Slightly buzzy anxious feeling. Sat in bed now and can't sleep despite being dog tired
When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC |
|
| Kodg |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by so many memories
Well said, this Wilko, is nothing more than a male Hyacinth Bucket – a lazy caricature, a pathetic sham with access to a 70s vocabulary that he believes impresses, when in reality people are simply laughing at him
|
|
|
Originally posted by Kodg
Where is the evidence? Oh come on. Stop being such a pompous knob. There's countless firsthand testimonies from people telling you what happened to them. But instead your arrogance prevents you from deviating from your prejudice. If you're not prepared to listen, maybe stop posting It really is a shame that people seemingly cannot argue their case without resorting to such personal attacks. At least I can give you my honest opinions without such virulent personal slurs. Your angst should NOT be directed at 'Yours Truly' but to those hoodlums whose actions resulted in the events that followed which affected genuine supporters with tickets. Let's NOT derail this thread by ad hominem attacks and get back to the subject under discussion.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Kodg
Well said, this Wilko, is nothing more than a male Hyacinth Bucket – a lazy caricature, a pathetic sham with access to a 70s vocabulary that he believes impresses, when in reality people are simply laughing at him Kindly refer to my previous post.Thank You.
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
It really is a shame that people seemingly cannot argue their case without resorting to such personal attacks. At least I can give you my honest opinions without such virulent personal slurs. Let's NOT derail this thread by ad hominem attacks and get back to the subject under discussion. We've established on numerous occasions that Willo has no idea what evidence is and cannot tell the difference between an argument supported with evidence on the one hand and a load of hot air and unsubstantiated bulls*** on the other. He doesn't seem to know what argumentum ad hominem means either. It means arguing that an argument is invalid because of some opinion about the character of the person making it, or that of someone he cites. The substance of your argument is that there are many witness accounts that contradict Willo's position, which is evidence, not a personal attack.
============ |
|
|
I agree with Willo - our fans were disgusting and worser than anything i've seen before.
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by NeaKnuck
I agree with Willo - our fans were disgusting and worser than anything i've seen before. What, all of them?
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
What, all of them? Of course not, but there was a nasty element I've never seen before. Yes I know it was Brighton but we should have shown them how to support a team - a non stop wall of noise, not knives & knuckledusters. Leave that to Millwall - We are better than that
|
|
|
Originally posted by NeaKnuck
I agree with Willo - our fans were disgusting and worser than anything i've seen before. Bear in mind willo wasn't even there
When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC |
|
|
Originally posted by NeaKnuck
Of course not, but there was a nasty element I've never seen before. Yes I know it was Brighton but we should have shown them how to support a team - a non stop wall of noise, not knives & knuckledusters. Leave that to Millwall - We are better than that Knives and knuckle dusters found on people but no arrests? Hmmmm. Sounds as fictional as Brighton Rock.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
We've established on numerous occasions that Willo has no idea what evidence is and cannot tell the difference between an argument supported with evidence on the one hand and a load of hot air and unsubstantiated bulls*** on the other. He doesn't seem to know what argumentum ad hominem means either. It means arguing that an argument is invalid because of some opinion about the character of the person making it, or that of someone he cites. The substance of your argument is that there are many witness accounts that contradict Willo's position, which is evidence, not a personal attack. I just had to guffaw at some of the claims about "Evidence" and "Arguments" for reasons which I shall keep to myself. At the end of the day it has been well documented that reprobates were the source for the events at the Amex yet somehow their disgraceful behaviour has been 'Lost' in a haze of accounts of Police behaviour towards our genuine supporters. I have already stated that I am NOT privy to events surrounding Police activity concerning our supporters so I am NOT in a position to comment on the specifics but I have also added that IF the Police have a case to answer this should be dealt with by the relevant authorities. That said,I fully appreciate that in a highly-charged situation involving hostile supporters the Police are in a very difficult situation and have to deal with an array of emotions. To summarise, I am not defending the Police regards last night's activities as I am not Au Fait with precisely what went on, but I fully condemn those who went hell-bent on wreaking havoc and in doing so adversely affected genuine supporters.Shame on these darned oafs. Edited by Willo (30 Nov 2017 12.39am)
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I just had to guffaw at some of the claims about "Evidence" and "Arguments" for reasons which I shall keep to myself. At the end of the day it has been well documented that reprobates were the source for the events at the Amex yet somehow their disgraceful behaviour has been 'Lost' in a haze of accounts of Police behaviour towards our genuine supporters. I have already stated that I am NOT privy to events surrounding Police activity concerning our supporters so I am NOT in a position to comment on the specifics but I have also added that IF the Police have a case to answer this should be dealt with by the relevant authorities. That said,I fully appreciate that in a highly-charged situation involving hostile supporters the Police are in a very difficult situation and have to deal with an array of emotions. To summarise, I am not defending the Police regards last night's activities as I am not Au Fait with precisely what went on, but I fully condemn those who went hell-bent on wreaking havoc and in doing so adversely affected genuine supporters.Shame on these darned oafs. "Adversely affected"? Reads like Treat Officially correspondence from a policy branch. Zero empathy. Pathetic.
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
whether people like his tone & language or not, Willo is right. some t***s made it so that some of our most loyal fans with tickets couldn't get in to the away game of the year. it is by definition failed policing and securuty that the t***s got in, and after that failure, the police panicked and decent fans were seemingly treated appallingly. but the t***s are first in line for blame. Except no one's defended them and have rightly been denounced by pretty much everyone else. People are blaming the stewards and police because they failed miserably to stop 30 kids getting through a fire door, closing the turnstiles before aforementioned rush rush after the police escort turning up stupidly late and then being bang out of order to the 95% who were fine. Oh, and clearly lying about the weapons being brought in.
|
|
|
Originally posted by so many memories
Thanks
|
|
| Kodg |
|
|---|---|
|
So, the FSF (http://www.fsf.org.uk) are complying a report on the inadequate policing and poor stewarding at brighton, anyone who would like to share their personal experience of the night can do so by sending an email to Amanda Jacks on amanda.jacks@fsf.org.uk What good it will do I don't know, but to remain silent is to allow those with an alternative agenda to win. Edited by Kodg (30 Nov 2017 7.51am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
It really is a shame that people seemingly cannot argue their case without resorting to such personal attacks. At least I can give you my honest opinions without such virulent personal slurs. Your angst should NOT be directed at 'Yours Truly' but to those hoodlums whose actions resulted in the events that followed which affected genuine supporters with tickets. Let's NOT derail this thread by ad hominem attacks and get back to the subject under discussion.
How about looking at why and how these individuals thought they could get in and if they did indeed get in how that happened. What caused them to think that? I'm certainly not condoning their actions, but as I said earlier on in the thread, I was told by an officer on the night that a SMALL number breached a fire exit which had been left open by BHA staff/steward. Don't just look at the fans and then say they affected everything else look at the stewards and the policing and how they affected the thought process for those that made the attempt to get in. It just exposes your lazy thought processing and generally miopic thinking.
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.