You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up
November 16 2026 8.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer Window Summing Up


Page 11 of 18 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >
europalace Flag Europe 01 Feb 18 10.09am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Yes but we only approached them very late on....why? It has been obvious for weeks that Guiata would not be coming until the summer, so why didn't we give Brondby more time? This is happening all the time and is very amateurish (and I have been very vocal in my support of SP). My son spoke to Brondby fans on twitter who were gobsmacked we left so late as he would have joined. No excuses I am afraid.


How do you know it was 'left so late' with Brondby? Simply because you saw the first report about it late on? Most business is well under way a significant time before any media gets hold of any information, again basing your opinions on media stories and other clubs fans, who again won't know more than the media, is simply naive.


Edited by europalace (01 Feb 2018 10.09am)

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 01 Feb 18 10.10am

Originally posted by silvertop

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

If both Jules and Hennessey are injured we should be entitled to an emergency loan.

See the attached. I am pretty sure that emergency loans are not available. I guess it is our own fault if we don't get a suitable third choice goalkeeper in.

[Link]

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 01 Feb 18 10.19am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Are you happy with Hennessey as our number 1? He is the worst keeper in the league. Your question seems somehow not serious, is it?

Guaita is a whole lot better than Hennessey, check his stats and reputation.

Well your obviously like General you dislike Wayne.
If Guaita is better than him,excellent if we do get him in the Summer.
As for poor goalkeepers Cech was abysmal for the Arse the other day.
I think he needs “upgrading “.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

askyourself Flag 01 Feb 18 10.20am

Anyway, shouldn't this all be in Transfer Talk.

There is a case for a new topic "Moans"

 


We move in the direction of our thoughts.
Just think a little.

silvertop Flag Portishead 01 Feb 18 10.25am

Originally posted by askyourself

Anyway, shouldn't this all be in Transfer Talk.

There is a case for a new topic "Moans"

It would be crash under the weight.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 Feb 18 10.25am

Originally posted by europalace


How do you know it was 'left so late' with Brondby? Simply because you saw the first report about it late on? Most business is well under way a significant time before any media gets hold of any information, again basing your opinions on media stories and other clubs fans, who again won't know more than the media, is simply naive.


Edited by europalace (01 Feb 2018 10.09am)

So you don't think we could have secured this goalkeeper within the month? or even since last summer? Thanks for calling me naive (which at 61 years of age I am most definately not) nor do I frequent social media so maybe it is you that is being naive.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 01 Feb 18 10.42am

Originally posted by Spiderman

So you don't think we could have secured this goalkeeper within the month? or even since last summer? Thanks for calling me naive (which at 61 years of age I am most definately not) nor do I frequent social media so maybe it is you that is being naive.

If you can furnish evidence to prove that we only approached at the 11th hour then you will win this mini argument. If not, then you will not.

My guess: we try to do business under the radar given the number of poaches we suffer. I suspect Dougie et al have been forced to sweat for months waiting to see if the hoped linked deal will come off at Brondby. For no fault of our own it did not.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 01 Feb 18 10.42am

Originally posted by Painter

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

How is it poor, CB, Midfielder and Striker signed, just because you don’t know who they are. I guess you are influenced by the media with a thirst for big money signings.
Average window, could of been better if Lille didn’t piss about.

When neither 3 start a game in the next few months you may want to review this post.

3 young players, none of whom have any English, yet alone Prem experience, will not trouble our starting X1 unless we get injuries.

Why were we even trying to buy Adamou? We have defensive midfield players and centre backs we need more attacking players.

We have no No10 and no cover on the wings. None of the 3 signings fill these positions.

Who can we bring on for the last 20 to provide some creativity - Chungy??

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 01 Feb 18 10.51am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

I'm not sure how anyone can spin this as a positive window when, regardless of the players we have recruited, we have failed to strengthen the areas actually identified by the manager as needing improvement. We have the weakest goalkeepers in the division and a frighteningly shallow pool of attackers. Hopefully Sorloth will prove to be useful but we are still totally reliant on Zaha and Townsend staying fit with Sako now out. It isn't just this window either, we haven't adequately addressed the goalkeeper and striker situations since we got promoted.

totally agree that you cannot spin this as a positive window.

I've always defended SP but back on Sept 1st it was obvious what we needed and here we are on Feb 1 with the squad still unbalanced and lacking creativity.

Roy has done a great job but the lack of substitutions in recent games has highlighted the lack of depths we have. With Sako now injured we have to hope that Wilf and Townsend are injury free (and no suspensions!) for the rest of the season.

I have no issue with the 3 we have bought in - but they are all young and inexperienced. They will be bit part players this season

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Feb 18 11.06am

Paul Merson rated out Transfer dealings as 'B Minus'

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 01 Feb 18 11.17am

Please see attached for all those with rose tinted glasses!

That sums up our transfer window

ac60e988-df3f-4cfd-911f-4715943fec0a.jpg Attachment: ac60e988-df3f-4cfd-911f-4715943fec0a.jpg (22.83Kb)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Feb 18 11.19am

Originally posted by europalace


How do you know it was 'left so late' with Brondby? Simply because you saw the first report about it late on? Most business is well under way a significant time before any media gets hold of any information, again basing your opinions on media stories and other clubs fans, who again won't know more than the media, is simply naive.


Edited by europalace (01 Feb 2018 10.09am)

Dear oh dear. No you don't wind me up. Reading this rubbish, how could you?

We confirm we want the keeper earlier, Brondby find another earlier enough. This is unless we thought Gaialta (sp) might be coming, which it looks like he isn't, if at all, seeing as we're saving the £8 mil or so and probably watching him go to Stoke or somewhere.

I get this slight feeling Parish doesn't want to put himself in the position where he has to move Speroni out. We need 3, then when we get THE number 1 in the summer, one of Hennessy or Speroni have to go. Or both go and 2 came in to add to the Brondby lad. Speroni could've gone onto coach if Parish didn't want to finally call time.

 


COYP

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 01 Feb 18 11.20am

Originally posted by Willo

Paul Merson rated out Transfer dealings as 'B Minus'

I would have been pretty chuffed with any B when I was at school.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Feb 18 11.22am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Please see attached for all those with rose tinted glasses!

That sums up our transfer window

13 outfield players plus the new additions plus souare, Delaney, Lee and Mutch? Sh1t.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Feb 18 11.23am

Originally posted by topcat

I would have been pretty chuffed with any B when I was at school.

Naught little rascal.

 


COYP

Bangell Flag Oxford 01 Feb 18 11.25am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Please see attached for all those with rose tinted glasses!

That sums up our transfer window

Don't forget to add Schlupp to the injured list.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 01 Feb 18 11.37am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Please see attached for all those with rose tinted glasses!

That sums up our transfer window

Doesn't look good I agree. However, what would you have done to have made it better in the January transfer window?

Poor luck - remember, we are not responsible for what happened at the selling club's end - not to have got another keeper and DM; and equally poor luck we are without key players for the season through injury...

Actually, I am not sure you are trying to say here? I think we are slowly and carefully growing a good squad within our limited budget and with our limited brand name. I know we are not there yet. Does that still make me rose tinted?

Meanwhile, who highlighted in red to reflect "not fit for purpose". Total bollox re keepers... and Lee as occasional back-up. And "untried in the prem" - I suspect it won't take long to make an extensive list of players currently plying their trade in the prem who are having a very nice career, thanks very much, but who had no prem experience... before they had prem experience! And 2 injured players are likely to return for the run-in.

I could turn this on its head and say you are unnecessarily pessimistic.

 

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 01 Feb 18 11.38am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Dave how on earth was last January and August poor. ?

For a start we missed out on a striker in the last window al, we left it to late this time to sort the Lille defender, the striker from Norway is unproven in the premier league, we didn't sign a goalkeeper, and we still have a couple of players we should have got of the payroll and haven't. Did we even go after sturridge I think he would have come to London.......is that enough?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Feb 18 11.42am

Originally posted by silvertop

Doesn't look good I agree. However, what would you have done to have made it better in the January transfer window?

Poor luck - remember, we are not responsible for what happened at the selling club's end - not to have got another keeper and DM; and equally poor luck we are without key players for the season through injury...

Actually, I am not sure you are trying to say here? I think we are slowly and carefully growing a good squad within our limited budget and with our limited brand name. I know we are not there yet. Does that still make me rose tinted?

Meanwhile, who highlighted in red to reflect "not fit for purpose". Total bollox re keepers... and Lee as occasional back-up. And "untried in the prem" - I suspect it won't take long to make an extensive list of players currently plying their trade in the prem who are having a very nice career, thanks very much, but who had no prem experience... before they had prem experience! And 2 injured players are likely to return for the run-in.

I could turn this on its head and say you are unnecessarily pessimistic.

You make a good case apart from the keeper.

We could've sorted that out earlier. No excuses there. It was possible and probably not going to cost much more from abroad or just a loan.

 


COYP

Littlebogreek Flag 01 Feb 18 11.43am

Yawn. all this constant slagging off of our transfer dealings is getting a bit boring. None of us are privy to 99% of what goes on in the background, even those tedious souls that claim to be in the know - they aren't. If they were they'd be making a fortune from the bookies and not spending most of the day on this site.

We have very clearly been screwed over for Ammadou and the keeper by the selling clubs. What some people on here expect is total nonsense - should we pay double what someone is worth just to get it done? How long do you think that business model would e sustainable for? If you were buying a watch that's worth £1,000 and the shop told you they wanted £2,000 would you pay it from your own pockets? Or perhaps we should get agreements in place for 2 players then pull the plug once we sign one - how many clubs would do sensible business with us after we've done something like that? How much would we moan if another club did that to us?

Transfers are not simple things and can't be done without a lot of hurdles to jump over unless you are one of the mega rich clubs which we are not, we can't just throw money at it and hope for the best. I'm personally glad and grateful that we are being run in a way that won't lead to administration again any time soon.

Trust me, if you take an approach to actually supporting your club and the decisions that they make when you genuinely feel that they have the clubs overall long term interests at heart, you'll find the stress in your life decreases. If anyone on here doesn't honestly think we have one of the best boards out there they are mistaken.

Edited by Littlebogreek (01 Feb 2018 11.51am)

 

Page 11 of 18 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up