You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish unable to progress us
November 16 2026 8.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Parish unable to progress us


Page 11 of 16 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Feb 18 1.05pm

Originally posted by Aray

Maybe I wasn't clear who the subject was in my sentence. I was talking about the chairman's qualities. I agree however we definitely need another keeper. Like yesterday. We should be picking up a free agent soon. Maybe Parish agreed the strategy with Roy...

I doubt it. Bang on about it for weeks and there be a good chance we'll still have 2 on Feb 1st.

For clarity, Parish is a very very good chairman. The transfers are a serious issue though. He now has 2 knowledgeable people either side of him he apparently trusts and it still happens. He needs to stop coming out of these windows with us vulnerable to the likely.

 


COYP

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 14 Feb 18 1.14pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I do not disagree on the qualities of Roy.

The keeper situation just shows how Parish must view the manager once he's got him in. When he hires him it's full of promises but when he's in the necessities aren't delivered. We'll need Guaita and the Ronnow fella next season. Therefore aim for both and if it's only one in then fine. But no, can't do that and satisfy the man we have when he's in charge and him to stay.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (14 Feb 2018 12.08pm)

Whilst I agree in principle, what happens if you get both in the January window? We are precariously close to FFP limits with our wages & need some gone (thankfully there are a few that'll have disappeared by the summer window).

It's entirely possible there was such a plan that hinged on Mutch &/or Chungy going (even on loan) to reduce the problem.

I agree that we were let down in both the previous windows but as I'm not privy to the actual reasons why then the reality is I either accept that there were valid reasons or speculate there weren't.

IIRC, Bournemouth were the last EPL team to break FFP & were fined heavily but it was said they escaped lightly as the new regime had not come into force for the period concerned. Is it not now the case that a club can be fined, have points deducted, transfer embargos and even promotion blocked? If that is the case (I heard it on 5 Live so it may not be) then could we really risk it? We are Palace after all & the authorities seem to like sticking it to us when they get the chance.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Maine Eagle Flag USA 14 Feb 18 1.18pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Rudi,I might be saying very little because the sensible posters cannot get a word in.
Anyhow back to my question,what position would we be in ?
1-20.?

LOL, Alan. Cant get a word in? Just trying typing longer before pressing enter?

Cant get a word in on an online forum....?

Also you said on another thread you would support my gran in goal if she was our number 1 - maybe not so sensible?

LOL.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 14 Feb 18 1.27pm

Mate as you know, you are 100% bang on the nail.
Next time some moonbeam comes up with a load tosh like this. Surly it is in the power of the MODS to just send them your response so we can all get back to enjoying the ride the best we can.

Originally posted by Aray

Yes. Thank you. My simple argument is that we could do a lot worse than this and those that think we're bigger than we are risk making the same mistake as Charlton.

I like simple arguments me as I find the complicated ones are full of sh!t. And that brings me back to your various points on Charlton.

Of course Charlton had several years of being mid-table on a consistent basis. Not many clubs have achieved this - as its the nether region of the premier league. You cant compete with the expanding number of big boys with billionaire owners using the club to buy publicity or respectability.

Seems like your argument hinges on Charlton wanting to be part of a group they didn't belong to. Then I'd say the OP and others are making the same mistake as their fans did back then.

I'd argue surviving is as much as we can expect while we consolidate in the top league.

No? Then what is our level? Southampton? Ah they are struggling too. Who else? West Brom? Ooops. Next? Burnley? Oh how many games have they won since their key defender got injured?

This season injuries are killing us and the club is borrowing money to buy players so Parish has to find bargains. That is our level.

As for the rest of your response. Of course it is "excusable" that Parish - with Pardew and FdB wanted to take us to another footballing level. Just dont do it while leaving us short of a left-back (Pardew admitted it was his mistake) or with only a few short weeks of training. In retrospect he should have gone for Roy then. But lets face it - we all wanted a young dynamic progressive man. I doubt Dyche would have come - his next club will be bigger.

Which brings us to another key point. The role of the manager in all this. The likes of Curbishly don't come around very often. Sorry but Pulis and Allardyce are not in that mode. Coppell was our last equivalent and a previous chairman threw away that legacy.

We seem to disagree on the qualities of the current one. Good day

 

Den1923 Flag 14 Feb 18 1.35pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

I never said it wasn't an investment nor did I say he was doing it for 'fun'. He's a fan as well as a business man & has been quite clear that whilst he is here he wants to try & get the club to realise its full potential - the fact that mistakes get made is far from unusual in any business.

For years now many on here (& elsewhere) have bemoaned our lack of infrastructure & blamed it for all sorts from managers leaving to lack of player development - why cant we be like Southampton, Stoke etc? Well at least there's an effort to get there.

IF the worst was to happen, we'll stand a much better chance of bouncing back than without the changes made.


Edited by Nobbybm (14 Feb 2018 8.36am)

The mistakes are repetitive and will cost the Club millions in lost revenue, we would have to rebuild from scratch, as the few good players we have would be off, with exit clauses in their contracts being activated on relegation, getting back will never be easy and the lost revenue would mount each season we are out of PL !

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Feb 18 1.40pm

Originally posted by johnmcormick8

Mate as you know, you are 100% bang on the nail.
Next time some moonbeam comes up with a load tosh like this. Surly it is in the power of the MODS to just send them your response so we can all get back to enjoying the ride the best we can.

Bang on with that passage about the Pardew and De Boer experiment being excusable. Of course it was, then lambast anyone for saying just keep us from being vulnerable in crucial positions. No no, open and expansive football was absolutely fine with the players we had. Sure it was. So mental I can't get over it. Lucky Roy was willing to save our sorry &rses.

Sure let's enjoy the ride, but is it unavoidable to write off blocks of the season due to a project that was in fact to take us to the next level, then rely on saviour no 4,5,6 etc and then claim we shouldn't question the repeated mistakes because we desire the next level when that is a major reason we're in poo.

 


COYP

Aray Flag South London 14 Feb 18 2.15pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Bang on with that passage about the Pardew and De Boer experiment being excusable. Of course it was, then lambast anyone for saying just keep us from being vulnerable in crucial positions. No no, open and expansive football was absolutely fine with the players we had. Sure it was. So mental I can't get over it. Lucky Roy was willing to save our sorry &rses.

Sure let's enjoy the ride, but is it unavoidable to write off blocks of the season due to a project that was in fact to take us to the next level, then rely on saviour no 4,5,6 etc and then claim we shouldn't question the repeated mistakes because we desire the next level when that is a major reason we're in poo.

My post was in response to the OP (Parish unable to progress us). So not sure exactly what you're referring to. No one sane can argue we should have a back up keeper. But some of us do not think that failing to secure certain players justifies the abuse Parish gets. As for needing management saviors...that is a whole different discussion. But not many teams have stable management...Especially in our "league"


 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 14 Feb 18 2.26pm

Originally posted by Aray

My post was in response to the OP (Parish unable to progress us). So not sure exactly what you're referring to. No one sane can argue we should have a back up keeper. But some of us do not think that failing to secure certain players justifies the abuse Parish gets. As for needing management saviors...that is a whole different discussion. But not many teams have stable management...Especially in our "league"


So you were just lambasting me then, Aray?

Basic, simple, continual errors will be highlighted when someone is in the public eye, like a football chairman.

If that is abuse, then I am guilty.

When Mandanda was signed, it was for a reason. When Mandanda left, we failed to replace him, that is very poor from the chairman. Window after window we did not address the GK situation, again, very poor. This window our manager says 20 times we need to sign a keeper, we have a long protracted back and forth with Getafe, and at the end of it, we sign the guy IN THE SUMMER. Its comedy. Parish then pats himself on the back for signing a GK in the summer, after the relegation run in.

I dont think you could make that up.

Add in the repeated failures over the years on transfers and managers (hiring mistakes, firing mistakes), and its amateur hour year after year....after year.

Again, if pointing out how poor the performance of the chairman is in these areas in abuse, then I am guilty as charged.

Problem is once you start its like peeling an onion, layer after layer, mistake after calamitous mistake....not firing Pardew....not signing a striker....left back cover....right back cover....cant ever sell any of our deadwood and move them off the wage bill.....Holloway not being fired soon enough....Warnock (wtf)...Now De Boer.

It goes on and on and on.

Is it so hard to understand if some fans would like someone else calling these all important shots? Relegation is a time bomb with these continual mistakes and mismanagement of squad depth going on. We have a chance to establish ourselves in this league but not running things like a mickey mouse operation.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Feb 18 2.29pm

Originally posted by Aray

My post was in response to the OP (Parish unable to progress us). So not sure exactly what you're referring to. No one sane can argue we should have a back up keeper. But some of us do not think that failing to secure certain players justifies the abuse Parish gets. As for needing management saviors...that is a whole different discussion. But not many teams have stable management...Especially in our "league"


Answering people on twitter with something like 'what if the sun doesn't come up tomorrow' probably wasn't the best way to go about it from his side. Being on twitter probably isn't wise at all.

 


COYP

palacepolak Flag Toronto 14 Feb 18 4.17pm

Nail on the head! Buy this man a pint! Like i said previously there is the "He saved our club" Parish and believe me he dragged that out on purpose to make himself look like our "Messiah". I have been in business for some time and these deals are not done at the last minute trust me.

The other side is the penny pinching small business mindset chairman that has control over every aspect of what happens withing his business. I can imagine he has probably tried to micromanage every aspect from cleaners to first team affairs. I am sorry if some people are offended of criticism of him but I am not a Parish apologist. He is proving himself to be a huge chancer and is gambling our prem status so he can have an extra few quid in his pocket.

Has he done great work? Yes without a doubt.

Do I want him out? No BUT things have to change in the summer with his approach to the club. Some of his mistakes are criminal and are showing that his is an amateur Bromley Barrow Boy who made a few quid back in the day. Approach needs to change or we are just another chancing season away from relegation. I hate to say it but the likes of Burnley are now even ahead of us.

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

So you were just lambasting me then, Aray?

Basic, simple, continual errors will be highlighted when someone is in the public eye, like a football chairman.

If that is abuse, then I am guilty.

When Mandanda was signed, it was for a reason. When Mandanda left, we failed to replace him, that is very poor from the chairman. Window after window we did not address the GK situation, again, very poor. This window our manager says 20 times we need to sign a keeper, we have a long protracted back and forth with Getafe, and at the end of it, we sign the guy IN THE SUMMER. Its comedy. Parish then pats himself on the back for signing a GK in the summer, after the relegation run in.

I dont think you could make that up.

Add in the repeated failures over the years on transfers and managers (hiring mistakes, firing mistakes), and its amateur hour year after year....after year.

Again, if pointing out how poor the performance of the chairman is in these areas in abuse, then I am guilty as charged.

Problem is once you start its like peeling an onion, layer after layer, mistake after calamitous mistake....not firing Pardew....not signing a striker....left back cover....right back cover....cant ever sell any of our deadwood and move them off the wage bill.....Holloway not being fired soon enough....Warnock (wtf)...Now De Boer.

It goes on and on and on.

Is it so hard to understand if some fans would like someone else calling these all important shots? Relegation is a time bomb with these continual mistakes and mismanagement of squad depth going on. We have a chance to establish ourselves in this league but not running things like a mickey mouse operation.

 



chateauferret Flag 14 Feb 18 4.35pm

Lots of polarised views about whether Parish is a) Mr Bean or b) St George. Heaven forfend that we should go the way of West Brom and throw the baby out with the bathwater (although it's true that thinking Pardew was worth hiring and Sturridge would stay fit are evidence of stupidity of at least the same order as anything we have seen).

The problem is just the wrong people doing the wrong jobs. That's been addressed to some extent by bringing in Freedman to look at recruitment prospects and helping us identify talent that doesn't cost £30m. He's got the right idea with the signings we have made but the ones we should have made are symptomatic of the problem persisting in the area of completing player transfers and contracts. We've persued the right targets, avoided the duds (Diafra Sakho, Sturridge, looks like Tosun might be a dud too based on Allardyce's latest remarks), but failed to turn enough of those targets into signings and that's happened twice now (granted last time one of the targets was the aforementioned Tosun).

FFS Parish just needs to step away from closing the deals and let someone who's good at it do it. And he needs to do that in good time for the next window and make clear that he's doing that because it will only get harder if other clubs see him as a national joke, a reputation which would seriously damage us and which his other work doesn't deserve.

No need to make it into a pogrom.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 14 Feb 18 4.51pm

Originally posted by Den1923

The mistakes are repetitive and will cost the Club millions in lost revenue, we would have to rebuild from scratch, as the few good players we have would be off, with exit clauses in their contracts being activated on relegation, getting back will never be easy and the lost revenue would mount each season we are out of PL !

If we did come back up, we’d have to go through the first season without any real quality in our side and go through that struggle all over again.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 14 Feb 18 8.07pm

IMO Parish’s only real mistakes have arisen from trying to make us something we’re not on a couple of occasions and having too much ambition rather than too little.

We’ve made a good recovery from such a poor start but there’s the top six and a fag paper between the rest.

It’s not his fault we sh1t ourselves in front of goal irrespective of broader squad issues.


 

Den1923 Flag 14 Feb 18 8.08pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

If we did come back up, we’d have to go through the first season without any real quality in our side and go through that struggle all over again.

Very well put and all thanks to SP!

 

Den1923 Flag 14 Feb 18 8.25pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

IMO Parish’s only real mistakes have arisen from trying to make us something we’re not on a couple of occasions and having too much ambition rather than too little.

We’ve made a good recovery from such a poor start but there’s the top six and a fag paper between the rest.

It’s not his fault we sh1t ourselves in front of goal irrespective of broader squad issues.



Parish has already proved he is a poor PL chairman just by the number of managers we have had in the period, then there are the half fit players that we bought in, the botched transfers, allowing us to start this season with only one fit striker, the GK that Roy so much wanted in the last not mention other key areas where we were down to our last fit player, the constant inability to make decisions, brokering the deal with the Americans and endless hours and funds reserved for a refurbished stadium which will be half empty in the championship. It's a big if, as to what will happen this season but it's not looking good as our form against those around us is not making full of confidence!

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 14 Feb 18 8.34pm

Originally posted by Den1923


Parish has already proved he is a poor PL chairman just by the number of managers we have had in the period, then there are the half fit players that we bought in, the botched transfers, allowing us to start this season with only one fit striker, the GK that Roy so much wanted in the last not mention other key areas where we were down to our last fit player, the constant inability to make decisions, brokering the deal with the Americans and endless hours and funds reserved for a refurbished stadium which will be half empty in the championship. It's a big if, as to what will happen this season but it's not looking good as our form against those around us is not making full of confidence!

We came up via the play offs after being favourites for relegation to league one and are in our fifth season in the top flight and been not far from winning the FA Cup. Not a bad record IMO.

As I’ve said mistakes been made but not at fault for players missing from two feet. Personally couldn’t give a fvck about the stadium.


 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 14 Feb 18 8.45pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

IMO Parish’s only real mistakes have arisen from trying to make us something we’re not on a couple of occasions and having too much ambition rather than too little.

We’ve made a good recovery from such a poor start but there’s the top six and a fag paper between the rest.

It’s not his fault we sh1t ourselves in front of goal irrespective of broader squad issues.


Agreed Rachid

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 14 Feb 18 9.51pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Very well put and all thanks to SP!

Nothing to do with SP. The problems that now face are purely down to us being CPFC and not Chelsea or Arsenal. Nothing more and nothing less.

Edited by Brentmiester_General (14 Feb 2018 9.59pm)

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Maine Eagle Flag USA 15 Feb 18 3.05am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

IMO Parish’s only real mistakes have arisen from trying to make us something we’re not on a couple of occasions and having too much ambition rather than too little.

We’ve made a good recovery from such a poor start but there’s the top six and a fag paper between the rest.

It’s not his fault we sh1t ourselves in front of goal irrespective of broader squad issues.


Huh? So not firing Pardew soon enough (by several months) allowing all confidence to erode and players like Puncheon and Dann suffer majorly form wise was down to having too much ambition?

Not signing a goalkeeper thus leaving us with 1 fit keeper (as Jules immediately got injured) is down to too much ambition?

Not signing a striker last time around leaving us with 1 fit striker (who immediately got injured) was down to too much ambition?

Not properly addressing glaring squad depth issues like left back before Souare went down was down to too much ambition?

Not firing Holloway sooner....hiring Neil Warnock (wtf)....down to too much ambition?

Nah mate, these errors are down to Parish being a weak chairman in the context of other men in this league. Very, very poor chairman with poor judgement and poor planning skills. Only someone with a bizarre sense of judgement would laud themselves for signing a goalkeeper 6 months from now, when we desperately need one now.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 15 Feb 18 3.07am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Nothing to do with SP. The problems that now face are purely down to us being CPFC and not Chelsea or Arsenal. Nothing more and nothing less.

Edited by Brentmiester_General (14 Feb 2018 9.59pm)

What club around us (not Chelsea and Arsenal) has weaker depth in goal and up front? Please name another club in this entire division that is weaker than us depth wise in these critical areas.

Thats down to the chairman not getting transfers completed.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Page 11 of 16 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish unable to progress us