You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson has to go
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hodgson has to go


Page 11 of 18 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 14 Jan 19 11.30pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

I'm sure if he could he would love to bring in Jesus or Salah, but seeing as he is such a bad manager what would be the point.

For avoidance of doubt I have never viewed Hodgson in this way.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 15 Jan 19 12.21am

If Roy '' must go '' then I'd be interested to hear those calling for this to happen give their suggestions as to who should take over....

 


Old, Ungifted and White

michaelpearce Flag grays 15 Jan 19 6.48am

Originally posted by NEILLO

If Roy '' must go '' then I'd be interested to hear those calling for this to happen give their suggestions as to who should take over....

not sure about going but with Wagner available wouldnt mind him, and maybe he can get Aguero on loan from his mate Pep

 

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 15 Jan 19 6.52am

Originally posted by michaelpearce

not sure about going but with Wagner available wouldnt mind him, and maybe he can get Aguero on loan from his mate Pep

I trust the smiley was relating to the whole of your post and not just Aguero?

 


Most certainly not European.

leejaneagles Flag 15 Jan 19 7.48am

There is no one else now. We've burned through the list of secure Premier League Managers. Next one has to be a younger character we are taking a chance on.

Could go the way of Eddie Howe or could go the way of Frank De Boer.

Either way, our next Manager needs to be recruited without a panic button in place, at the end of the season with a shortlist of specific candidates and hopefully some guidance and transition from Roy.

Doing the whole emergency sacking mid-season because we are struggling simply won't work anymore and we'll likely go down.

A new young Manager probably won't have the infrastructure or knowledge to keep us up and we have run out of Allardyce, Pulis, Pardew's etc.

Roy is our only option for this time until the end of the season. Considering it's probably only his objective to keep us up rather than mid-table security that the fans crave, he's probably more than capable (injuries to Sakho and Zaha would probably see us down though).

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 15 Jan 19 7.55am

Originally posted by moylerg

I trust the smiley was relating to the whole of your post and not just Aguero?

no for Aguero only,
opening statement not sure about going let me translate i not saying Roy to go if he does Wagner not a bad replacement

 

waxonwaxoff Flag kent 15 Jan 19 8.09am

Roy Hodgson is one of the most respected football coaches in Europe.

We are lucky to have him, he's had no money to spend and he has masterminded victories against billionaires of Man city and Wolves away in past few weeks.

I'm going to Anfield on Sat and will get behind him and the team. Lets go ruin another party, cos thats what we like to do.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 15 Jan 19 8.32am

Originally posted by waxonwaxoff

Roy Hodgson is one of the most respected football coaches in Europe.

We are lucky to have him, he's had no money to spend and he has masterminded victories against billionaires of Man city and Wolves away in past few weeks.

I'm going to Anfield on Sat and will get behind him and the team. Lets go ruin another party, cos thats what we like to do.

Hear ear enough negativity save it for Brexit.
COYP title wreckers.

 


One more point

leejaneagles Flag 15 Jan 19 8.45am

Originally posted by waxonwaxoff

Roy Hodgson is one of the most respected football coaches in Europe.

We are lucky to have him, he's had no money to spend and he has masterminded victories against billionaires of Man city and Wolves away in past few weeks.

I'm going to Anfield on Sat and will get behind him and the team. Lets go ruin another party, cos thats what we like to do.

Excellent post and puts things into perspective.

I think it's his own team letting him down because it does take a Tactical masterclass to beat Man City away. That would have taken a lot of technical knowledge and also decades of soft-skill knowledge to put it in the players heads it was actually possible.

It's just so frustrating to go and get 3 points from City and then lose 2 points at home to Cardiff. Go to Wolves away where we'd of taken a 2-1 defeat and win but then lose 2-1 to Watford at home.

If you look at it as an outsider, it's completely the Player's fault, you can even point to which player in certain matches, James McCarthur against Watford for example.

Roy just doesn't take the pressure off himself by doing Subs at 60 minutes. I think if he did and showed fans 'look, I can put Wickham and Meyer on at 60 but it doesn't make a blind bit of difference we still can't score' then there would be 0 fans calling for his head.

There'd be a lot of annoyance at the Team's failing attackers and the Board's lack of investment but not Roy. Where fans grow frustrated is when they think they know better and see a player they think can help score (Meyer) only come on after 80+ minutes. I wonder if Roy does it to protect the Team?

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 15 Jan 19 8.55am

Originally posted by leejaneagles

Excellent post and puts things into perspective.

I think it's his own team letting him down because it does take a Tactical masterclass to beat Man City away. That would have taken a lot of technical knowledge and also decades of soft-skill knowledge to put it in the players heads it was actually possible.

It's just so frustrating to go and get 3 points from City and then lose 2 points at home to Cardiff. Go to Wolves away where we'd of taken a 2-1 defeat and win but then lose 2-1 to Watford at home.

If you look at it as an outsider, it's completely the Player's fault, you can even point to which player in certain matches, James McCarthur against Watford for example.

Roy just doesn't take the pressure off himself by doing Subs at 60 minutes. I think if he did and showed fans 'look, I can put Wickham and Meyer on at 60 but it doesn't make a blind bit of difference we still can't score' then there would be 0 fans calling for his head.

There'd be a lot of annoyance at the Team's failing attackers and the Board's lack of investment but not Roy. Where fans grow frustrated is when they think they know better and see a player they think can help score (Meyer) only come on after 80+ minutes. I wonder if Roy does it to protect the Team?

yes i will be behind Roy and the team every game because thats what true supporters do,

as for subs yes he does leave it late always has if it dont work at least he has given it a fair chance of changing the game i have no probs with that

as for investment Roy come in when we already spent out,the club has invested 180million more than whats come in from sales since 2013

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 15 Jan 19 9.12am

Think he should retire in the summer, has struggled to make decisions this year with subs and we always seem to make them after we have gone behind instead of when we can all see the tide turning in matches.

We need a manager with top league experience but still with some youth on their side.

 

Den1923 Flag 15 Jan 19 11.20am

Originally posted by steven_t92

Think he should retire in the summer, has struggled to make decisions this year with subs and we always seem to make them after we have gone behind instead of when we can all see the tide turning in matches.

We need a manager with top league experience but still with some youth on their side.

Do you not think the problem might be the weakness of his bench?, in any event it would be madness to change now and as for the end of the season, well that depends on what league we are in!

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 15 Jan 19 11.40am

Originally posted by leejaneagles

There is no one else now. We've burned through the list of secure Premier League Managers. Next one has to be a younger character we are taking a chance on.

Could go the way of Eddie Howe or could go the way of Frank De Boer.

Either way, our next Manager needs to be recruited without a panic button in place, at the end of the season with a shortlist of specific candidates and hopefully some guidance and transition from Roy.

Doing the whole emergency sacking mid-season because we are struggling simply won't work anymore and we'll likely go down.

A new young Manager probably won't have the infrastructure or knowledge to keep us up and we have run out of Allardyce, Pulis, Pardew's etc.

Roy is our only option for this time until the end of the season. Considering it's probably only his objective to keep us up rather than mid-table security that the fans crave, he's probably more than capable (injuries to Sakho and Zaha would probably see us down though).

This is correct however the work should already have started on identifying and monitoring potential candidates that fit the club. History tells us that this probably isn't the case and we'll be scrambling as usual when Roy decides to call it a day.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Jan 19 11.59am

Originally posted by michaelpearce

yes i will be behind Roy and the team every game because thats what true supporters do,

as for subs yes he does leave it late always has if it dont work at least he has given it a fair chance of changing the game i have no probs with that

as for investment Roy come in when we already spent out,the club has invested 180million more than whats come in from sales since 2013

That’s the point. By leaving it late to make subs he hasn’t given it enough time.

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Jan 19 12.01pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

This is correct however the work should already have started on identifying and monitoring potential candidates that fit the club. History tells us that this probably isn't the case and we'll be scrambling as usual when Roy decides to call it a day.

Southampton had (And might still have)a dossier of potential managers that was constantly updated, with intelligence on those considered the best fits for Southampton.

They appointed Puel who only lasted a season, then Pellegrino who never lasted a season and he was followed by Hughes who wasn't there that long.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 15 Jan 19 12.10pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

That’s the point. By leaving it late to make subs he hasn’t given it enough time.

sorry Rudi yes thats what i was trying to say, more time for the subs to change things,seems it reads like i agree with Roy leaving it late doh

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Jan 19 12.33pm

Originally posted by Willo

Southampton had (And might still have)a dossier of potential managers that was constantly updated, with intelligence on those considered the best fits for Southampton.

They appointed Puel who only lasted a season, then Pellegrino who never lasted a season and he was followed by Hughes who wasn't there that long.

They hired the wrong style of manager in Pellegrino and then got so panicky about relegation they hired Mark Hughes. Whoever was in charge of decisions at the time made a bad one I could see happening beforehand and then felt had to not take any other risk and so hired a British merry go round manager.

Not havian idea of who you may have as options to approach is amateur and criminal at this level but something that happens with us all the time because there’s always an escape artist available. Not any more there isn’t. Parish, Freedman and Brighty looking on google it’ll be then.

 


COYP

Painter Flag Croydon 15 Jan 19 1.31pm

Originally posted by rikz

Apart from Huddersfield have the smallest budget in the league and we have the 9th biggest. They're where you would expect them to be. Hodgson is underachieving, lose against Liverpool and with the other results going against us which could quite easily happen and we're battling Cardiff for survival.

Huddersfield have spent over £100m since they were promoted, we haven’t the 9th biggest. Check your facts first.
Roy’s teams have performed well except for maybe 2-3 games, just not had the rub of the green in some and poor finishing in most.
Why aren’t we going to be battling Fulham, Huddersfield and Newcastle for survival, they are in the bottom 3 now.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 15 Jan 19 1.37pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

I'm sure if he could he would love to bring in Jesus or Salah, but seeing as he is such a bad manager what would be the point.

What is your definition of a bad manager?

A number of ex international players have publicly stated Roy was the best club manager they played under. When have you ever met him or played for him?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Jan 19 1.55pm

Originally posted by Painter

Huddersfield have spent over £100m since they were promoted, we haven’t the 9th biggest. Check your facts first.
Roy’s teams have performed well except for maybe 2-3 games, just not had the rub of the green in some and poor finishing in most.
Why aren’t we going to be battling Fulham, Huddersfield and Newcastle for survival, they are in the bottom 3 now.

My figures indicate that their Net Spend is not quite as high as that - Around £80 Mill.

 

Page 11 of 18 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson has to go