This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Willo
If Mr Hodgson was still in situ and the results mirrored that of the 'Glasner era', he would have pilloried with the focus on him rather than the depth of the squad. I'm not sure what that post is trying to achieve Willo? Any manger would be 'pilloried' after the run we've had however the one in situ has only been so for a short period, with unanimous acknowledgement of the state of the squad. A very different scenario to that we saw with Roy.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
The overall squad is not of sufficient strength in terms of quality and depth and this has been apparent for a while. When important players, in that already limited squad, are missing through injury IE Johnstone, Guehi, Doucoure, Olise, not forgetting that Eze and Olise's appearances together have been limited, it is little wonder that results are less than impressive. Tbh, that's the equivalent of City losing Ederson, Stones, Rhodri, Bernardo, De Bruyne and Haaland. Would they be the same? City can barely win without Rhodri. Our best players are all out injured or have been at one time or other. A fully fit squad or close to that and we win a lot more games. However, Glasner putting Ozoh at LCB was an awful decision. Lerma was doing fine there and there was no need to change a back line that was comfortable. Eze/Hughes/Ayew were wasteful in the first half, we would have been out of sight by half time had they picked the right passes. In the end, we got punished.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I'm not sure what that post is trying to achieve Willo? Any manger would be 'pilloried' after the run we've had however the one in situ has only been so for a short period, with unanimous acknowledgement of the state of the squad. A very different scenario to that we saw with Roy. What I attempted to articulate is that the discussion has gallivanted down the 'Squad' alley whereas in the era of 'Mr Hodgson' somehow he was the 'Lightning Rod' for criticism even though he was constrained by squad depth as is Glasner at the present time. Only last night I was whimpering to my dear wife about our squad before the game had commenced.She has heard all of this before !
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I'm not sure what that post is trying to achieve Willo? Any manger would be 'pilloried' after the run we've had however the one in situ has only been so for a short period, with unanimous acknowledgement of the state of the squad. A very different scenario to that we saw with Roy. I’m second guessing of course but I think the point is that results under Glasner are broadly what we could have expected under Hodgson. And Hodgson would have been coming in for criticism for a run in which we have only won one game against a dire Burnley team. Many on here blamed Hodgson rather than the state of the squad. On a positive note, I think overall performances have been better under Glasner while it’s clear that his tactics and style require more from our players and some of them are struggling with it. However last nights decision to bring Ozoh on in a central defensive role backfired completely. And I think it cost us a point. Hard to see where another win is going to come from at this stage.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by Oddball2021
Part of me is so annoyed at Parish and his 'just tweak things to avoid relegation' pathetic approach that I wouldn't mind seeing Palace relegated just to p1ss him off. How many seasons have we 'just, by the skin of our teeth', avoided the drop? Joel Ward (God bless him) still starting after all these years! We've seen what Munoz does haven't we? It's not rocket science! We've been identifying the two or three gaps we need attending for yonks. Solanski... We apparently could have got him on loan FFS? But we didn't? Even Zaha wasn't the out-and-out dedicated striker we needed (but he saved our backsides anyway). I am sick of this sh1te! Last season, last few games, we all know we only needed: a Solanski, a Munoz, and not much else. PLENTY of funds to more than cover this. But, NO oh f**king NO. So now, we're watching this boring drivel trying to get a point to...who? F**KING B-MOUTH! And you know what? Before watching that game, I wasn't even expecting any more. What happened (non-dedicated strikers like Eze getting chances but failing to score) was what I predicted and expected. I only watched to see guys like Wharton developing. FU Parish. The team now 11 games unbeaten save to Man City and Liverpool?? I am not one to blame bad luck, but this season not enough credit has been given for it. Take Bournemouth. Look where they are in the league. To be there they must have lost loads and been cr@p a great deal, but also have gone through purple patches to steer them clear. We lost twice to them this season. And on both occasions we managed to time it perfectly for their purple patches.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
I’m second guessing of course but I think the point is that results under Glasner are broadly what we could have expected under Hodgson. And Hodgson would have been coming in for criticism for a run in which we have only won one game against a dire Burnley team. Many on here blamed Hodgson rather than the state of the squad. On a positive note, I think overall performances have been better under Glasner while it’s clear that his tactics and style require more from our players and some of them are struggling with it. However last nights decision to bring Ozoh on in a central defensive role backfired completely. And I think it cost us a point. Hard to see where another win is going to come from at this stage. This is the point I have been making but not as succinctly as you.
|
|
|
I think you're correct to an extent,but Glasner is in his honeymoon period and we did turn in lame performances under Hodgson this season even when our better players were fit. Originally posted by Willo
If Mr Hodgson was still in situ and the results mirrored that of the 'Glasner era', he would have pilloried with the focus on him rather than the depth of the squad.
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
This side misses Doucoure. I have always preferred a hard working midfield above all else; Doucoure partnered with Wharton and I think we will be getting somewhere. Amen!
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
I’m second guessing of course but I think the point is that results under Glasner are broadly what we could have expected under Hodgson. And Hodgson would have been coming in for criticism for a run in which we have only won one game against a dire Burnley team. Many on here blamed Hodgson rather than the state of the squad. On a positive note, I think overall performances have been better under Glasner while it’s clear that his tactics and style require more from our players and some of them are struggling with it. However last nights decision to bring Ozoh on in a central defensive role backfired completely. And I think it cost us a point. Hard to see where another win is going to come from at this stage. All true, but the point I am making is that there was far more depth to the criticism of Roy beyond just the state of the squad. There were historical criticisms of the 'style' and the expectation upon a manager who had been around the club for many years is surely different to one who has shortly arrived, brand new, to a pretty dire state. That's not to say Roy deserved 'shot and shell' and that Glasner is immune from the criticism, but they're two very different circumstances.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
I’m second guessing of course but I think the point is that results under Glasner are broadly what we could have expected under Hodgson. And Hodgson would have been coming in for criticism for a run in which we have only won one game against a dire Burnley team. Many on here blamed Hodgson rather than the state of the squad. On a positive note, I think overall performances have been better under Glasner while it’s clear that his tactics and style require more from our players and some of them are struggling with it. However last nights decision to bring Ozoh on in a central defensive role backfired completely. And I think it cost us a point. Hard to see where another win is going to come from at this stage. It's a worry. My concern is that I imagine the Glasner deal had been a long time coming. I suspect it was scheduled for the season end but had to be brought forward due to Hodgson's health. The point is that a canny cup winning coach - still valued in Germany - had been doing his homework on the club and the league for some time and should have come in hitting the ground running. However, the changes appear more tinkering than transformatory. On a hope side, Bournemouth's coach took time to set and we can see their recent form establishes them as EPL regulars. Give OG to the end of the season to know his players better (and he does appear to be rotating at a rate that would have alarmed Hodgson), upgrade a few players to the Wharton/Munoz standard, and pray that Doucoure recovers to his last season quality and we could be watching a very different Palace come August.
|
|
|
Originally posted by XKudu
We need Olise back playing and Mitchell pushed firmly back to left back or on the bench. Glasner needs to find someone else as wing back who doesn’t panic in advanced positions. I can’t believe he’s stuck with Mitchell there and actually feel sorry for the lad who doesn’t look comfortable at all. It's why we banked everything on Lewis Hall, but he went to Newcastle. They were willing to pay full wages and agree an obligation to buy. They have more money than us. We couldn't compete. And we couldn't get a LW in the winter as we (thankfully) blew the budget on Wharton and Munoz.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Oddball2021
Part of me is so annoyed at Parish and his 'just tweak things to avoid relegation' pathetic approach that I wouldn't mind seeing Palace relegated just to p1ss him off. How many seasons have we 'just, by the skin of our teeth', avoided the drop? Joel Ward (God bless him) still starting after all these years! We've seen what Munoz does haven't we? It's not rocket science! We've been identifying the two or three gaps we need attending for yonks. Solanski... We apparently could have got him on loan FFS? But we didn't? Even Zaha wasn't the out-and-out dedicated striker we needed (but he saved our backsides anyway). I am sick of this sh1te! Last season, last few games, we all know we only needed: a Solanski, a Munoz, and not much else. PLENTY of funds to more than cover this. But, NO oh f**king NO. So now, we're watching this boring drivel trying to get a point to...who? F**KING B-MOUTH! And you know what? Before watching that game, I wasn't even expecting any more. What happened (non-dedicated strikers like Eze getting chances but failing to score) was what I predicted and expected. I only watched to see guys like Wharton developing. FU Parish. So i take it you are not a Parish Fan boy
This could be heaven or this could be hell . |
|
|
Originally posted by Elpis
Its not but then the Newcastle one wasn't a penalty either Having sobered up and calmed down you are right it was not the same. However the defender impeded Schlupps attempt to shoot, a penal for some teams
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
This is the point I have been making but not as succinctly as you. Hodgson was getting criticised for basic coaching points e.g. not being able to defend a set piece. Glasner has fixed that in 5 minutes, and we've looked a lot more likely to score from one. We all know the squad is short of depth, but at least Glasner has got to the point where it is actual inability causing the issues - Anderson at Spurs, the missed chances v Luton, the missed chances at Forest, the missed chances last night... Glasner also, unlike Hodgson, hasn't actively contributed to the injury issues. I still hold that he should have been sacked within minutes of the Brighton game finishing.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
Hodgson was getting criticised for basic coaching points e.g. not being able to defend a set piece. Glasner has fixed that in 5 minutes, and we've looked a lot more likely to score from one. We all know the squad is short of depth, but at least Glasner has got to the point where it is actual inability causing the issues - Anderson at Spurs, the missed chances v Luton, the missed chances at Forest, the missed chances last night... Glasner also, unlike Hodgson, hasn't actively contributed to the injury issues. I still hold that he should have been sacked within minutes of the Brighton game finishing. Well said. Results aren't there yet, but performances are miles up on where they were under Hodgson. Glasner has come in, immediately found a system which gets more out of our squad and already shown more willingness to integrate some of the young players into the squad. Even yesterday, the solution of playing Lerma at CB is not something Roy would have done in a million years, and it worked very well for the most part. I'm very excited for next season under Glasner if we can get the recruitment right - some of our patterns of play yesterday were better than anything I saw under Roy. We need to get the squad a hell of a lot fitter, and add some depth throughout, but I think this 'free hit' spell at the back end of this season is going to be really valuable in terms of Glasner getting a feel for the team and vice versa.
|
|
|
Originally posted by XKudu
Glasner is all about his attacking goal threat and making chances. There was absolutely NOTHING of that tonight. Quite pathetic. Ozoh looks like another lemon. He comes on and like Ahamada just looks awful. We lack depth. We need answers to what went wrong with Glasner’s strategy.
Like when FDB, when he came in he wanted us to play the Ajax system but the players couldn't adjust within a short time. Now with Glasner, he wants us to play fast attacking football but with key players injured we couldn't do that we an unbalanced squad in terms of quality. I am afraid some of the players are still ingrained in Roy's style.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.