You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread
November 20 2026 1.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Benteke thread


Page 110 of 166 < 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 >
sprites Flag Auckland 12 Aug 19 5.09am

Originally posted by Bangell

I'm amazed there are still people with hope that he'll turn himself around. He is absolutely finished.

I'm one of those still holding out hope. I'll admit it.

I just don't buy that you can lose ability like that. You lose confidence, form...or the team doesn't play to your strengths. Not sure...but can't believe that he's suddenly just become a bad player. But I very much agree he needs to start banging them in soon.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 12 Aug 19 6.24am

It makes you wonder what they do on the training ground. You would have thought that by now there might be some understanding between the players who put a ball in and Benteke as to when to anticipate, make a run etc. It's quite obvious that he can't create something on his own out of nothing, and needs it on a plate (head) to even look like scoring, which he mostly messes up anyway

 

traevor Flag 12 Aug 19 6.49am

He seems to give most people the impression of being a target man who scores more with his head but throughout his career he has mostly scored with his feet. I would think that his problems are more psychological and we should perhaps hire a mental coach to work with him.

 

EddieMac Flag 12 Aug 19 7.59am

I have been one of his biggest supporters the last couple of years and have tried to find any reason to give him the benefit of the doubt but I am really struggling at the moment.

I understand the role he plays can be thankless at times but the main issue his his movement when the ball is near the box, he just stands still or puts himself in a position where he cant be found.

I am very close to giving up on him.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 12 Aug 19 8.07am

Originally posted by sprites

I'm one of those still holding out hope. I'll admit it.

I just don't buy that you can lose ability like that. You lose confidence, form...or the team doesn't play to your strengths. Not sure...but can't believe that he's suddenly just become a bad player. But I very much agree he needs to start banging them in soon.

I think there might have been an injury after his first season with us too? There are certainly some mental issues, which could theoretically be resolved, but after 2 full seasons of nothing (61 appearances, 4 goals), I've given up hope.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 12 Aug 19 8.26am

Originally posted by Bangell

I think there might have been an injury after his first season with us too? There are certainly some mental issues, which could theoretically be resolved, but after 2 full seasons of nothing (61 appearances, 4 goals), I've given up hope.

Yes, I think most fans heart sink when they see him take the field, Seriously though, I wonder if he needs Phycological help to regain some confidence

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 12 Aug 19 8.28am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Yes, I think most fans heart sink when they see him take the field, Seriously though, I wonder if he needs Phycological help to regain some confidence

He needs to score, that will be his psychological help.

Think Sheffield United is a massive game for Benteke. If he could get a goal and result there it may set him up for the season.

If he does not score, which is more likely than unlikely, in the next 2-4 games we could be in for a repeat season.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Teddy Eagle Flag 12 Aug 19 8.32am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Yes, I think most fans heart sink when they see him take the field, Seriously though, I wonder if he needs Phycological help to regain some confidence

Could well be an answer. Jonathan Trott’s description of how his cricket career unravelled through anxiety problems sounded similar to what he seems to be going through.
Sportsmen aren’t treated very sympathetically on these issues but their money doesn’t make them any less likely to have problems than anyone else.

 

sultan pepper Flag 12 Aug 19 8.39am

No doubt unpopular for me to say so - but I think he plays some brilliant balls perfectly weighted through for team mates - two clear goal scoring passes which were only thwarted by an excellent Pickford performance.

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 12 Aug 19 8.40am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Yes, I think most fans heart sink when they see him take the field, Seriously though, I wonder if he needs Phycological help to regain some confidence

There's no denying his form in front of goal has been woeful and that is due to injuries and confidence. But a big part has also been a lack of delivery. I can hardly remember a cross going into the box against Everton. The only attempt that sticks in my mind was when Andros launched one in that the wind to hold of and it sailed about 20m above Bentekes head.

The question is would we be better off changing our style to suit his strengths or play a style that suits other players strengths (counter attack) but diminish our strikers best attributes. I believe we are currently trying to do a bit of both but not doing either so well which is why we usually appear pretty disjointed in attack.

The increased playing time of Meyer and addition of Camarasa should at least start to improve quality and quantity of crosses into the box this season. Once this happens we will really be able to judge whether he'll turn things around after a run off games.

 

EddieMac Flag 12 Aug 19 9.15am

I actually thought he had a decent game yesterday but it means nothing if he is not scoring.

We can blame the lack of crosses to him but when you watch him his movement is non existent. He always seems to hide behind the back post when someone hits the byline.

Look at Billy Sharp the weekend, He was in the right place to shin the ball over the line. Benteke is never in the right place or his goal tally would be no where near as dismal.

I posted on a different thread that he had 1 touch in Evertons box over 80 minutes, where as Zaha had 8 in 25 minutes.

Edited by EddieMac (12 Aug 2019 9.30am)

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 12 Aug 19 9.44am

Originally posted by EddieMac

I actually thought he had a decent game yesterday but it means nothing if he is not scoring.

We can blame the lack of crosses to him but when you watch him his movement is non existent. He always seems to hide behind the back post when someone hits the byline.

Look at Billy Sharp the weekend, He was in the right place to shin the ball over the line. Benteke is never in the right place or his goal tally would be no where near as dismal.

I posted on a different thread that he had 1 touch in Evertons box over 80 minutes, where as Zaha had 8 in 25 minutes.

Edited by EddieMac (12 Aug 2019 9.30am)

I would agree with the Billy Sharp analogy...but we dont play that way...how many time do we put the ball across the penalty box from the wings???

If we did, then i'd agree that we need a fox in the box...but we dont we almost always go wide and then come back in to attack centrally.

I agree that Big Ben is pretty much done now, but I would also say that saturday was perhaps his best all round performance for a season and a half..he won the ball back many many more times than I've seen him do before....so on that basis he at least seems to be fit...

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 12 Aug 19 10.00am

Originally posted by Lyons550

I would agree with the Billy Sharp analogy...but we dont play that way...how many time do we put the ball across the penalty box from the wings???

If we did, then i'd agree that we need a fox in the box...but we dont we almost always go wide and then come back in to attack centrally.

I agree that Big Ben is pretty much done now, but I would also say that saturday was perhaps his best all round performance for a season and a half..he won the ball back many many more times than I've seen him do before....so on that basis he at least seems to be fit...

This is the worry, we just are not going to put the ball in the net anywhere near enough (again). Benteke is finished in front of goal. Hes just an faint memory of the player who scored that lovely touch and dink at Stamford bridge. We are relying on Ayew, who doesnt score and Wilf who is NOT a striker. Not sure he can be relied about to get 10 again let alone 10-15. I'm very concerned about how this is going to pan out this season. A few more scoreless games at home and the atmosphere is going to turn for the worse again at selhurst. I think we are going to be ok at the back and midfield but we are going to have little to show for it as we have no real number 9 with that ruthless streak.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Aug 19 10.07am

Originally posted by samprior

There's no denying his form in front of goal has been woeful and that is due to injuries and confidence. But a big part has also been a lack of delivery. I can hardly remember a cross going into the box against Everton. The only attempt that sticks in my mind was when Andros launched one in that the wind to hold of and it sailed about 20m above Bentekes head.

The question is would we be better off changing our style to suit his strengths or play a style that suits other players strengths (counter attack) but diminish our strikers best attributes. I believe we are currently trying to do a bit of both but not doing either so well which is why we usually appear pretty disjointed in attack.

The increased playing time of Meyer and addition of Camarasa should at least start to improve quality and quantity of crosses into the box this season. Once this happens we will really be able to judge whether he'll turn things around after a run off games.

Thanks for the laugh.

 


COYP

EddieMac Flag 12 Aug 19 10.12am

Originally posted by Lyons550

I would agree with the Billy Sharp analogy...but we dont play that way...how many time do we put the ball across the penalty box from the wings???

If we did, then i'd agree that we need a fox in the box...but we dont we almost always go wide and then come back in to attack centrally.

I agree that Big Ben is pretty much done now, but I would also say that saturday was perhaps his best all round performance for a season and a half..he won the ball back many many more times than I've seen him do before....so on that basis he at least seems to be fit...

I agree completely about his perfomrmance on Saturday, he chased back and won a few balls and looked a lot more comfortable on the ball which is positive. To me he just looks too nice, he should be demanding the ball and pushing players around to get to it.

Maybe Sunday will be the day our suffering ends, I would be over the moon for him to score a couple.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Aug 19 10.25am

Originally posted by EddieMac

I agree completely about his perfomrmance on Saturday, he chased back and won a few balls and looked a lot more comfortable on the ball which is positive. To me he just looks too nice, he should be demanding the ball and pushing players around to get to it.

Maybe Sunday will be the day our suffering ends, I would be over the moon for him to score a couple.

He might be up against 3 central defenders against Sheff Utd.
In the Championship they played this way and were very adventurous with their centre halves coming forward like wing-backs - overlapping central defenders !
Maybe they will not be so adventurous in the PL.

 

AERO Flag 12 Aug 19 10.27am

Not a fan of Benteke at all but will say he had a decent game Saturday.But Ian Wright made a valued comment on motd, when he said he said he doesn’t put himself in scoring positions when the crosses come in , basically he doesn’t read situations quick enough to get the
the tap in’s etc. Will never get 14/15 goals a Season

 

slubglurge Flag welling 12 Aug 19 10.29am

The ball from PVA that has been mentioned was a strikers dream just dart forward and its a tap in. The ball bypassed 4 defenders and he was standing behind the fourth who cleared. I know he's injury prone but somebody like Sturridge who is a free agent would have buried that

 

EddieMac Flag 12 Aug 19 10.35am

Originally posted by slubglurge

The ball from PVA that has been mentioned was a strikers dream just dart forward and its a tap in. The ball bypassed 4 defenders and he was standing behind the fourth who cleared. I know he's injury prone but somebody like Sturridge who is a free agent would have buried that

I think he is terrified to get a simple tap in case he misses that is why he would much rather someone else shoot so he can't be blamed. He is quite happy having the ball outside the box because he is not expected to score from there. Meyer was looking for a pass on a couple of occasions and Benteke was just standing there. He should have been screaming for the ball.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 12 Aug 19 10.53am

Originally posted by slubglurge

The ball from PVA that has been mentioned was a strikers dream just dart forward and its a tap in. The ball bypassed 4 defenders and he was standing behind the fourth who cleared. I know he's injury prone but somebody like Sturridge who is a free agent would have buried that

Yep, that was the one time we got in a good position and the ball was slid across looking for him..and Wrighty/yourself are correct...he 'hid' behind the defender.

Sturridge would be a good shout ONLY if like Andy Carroll he comes in on a pay as you play basis...otherwise its a no for me...i'd sooner have Dwight Gayle back

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Page 110 of 166 < 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread