You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 9 dead in USA Church Shooting.
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

9 dead in USA Church Shooting.


Page 12 of 14 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Ray in Houston Flag Houston 22 Jun 15 5.37pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 4.17pm

Yes, choice is the key phrase. Dignitas won't kill you unless you can a) pay their fee b) terminally ill or suffering terribly c) capable of making the decision yourself.


Things get further complicated as administering lethal drugs is a comprehensive breach of the Hippocratic Oath, which is why doctors in the death chambers are merely observers, not protagonists. The lethal injections are set up and administered by non-medical personnel because a doctor can't do it and the "patient" won't.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 22 Jun 15 5.37pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 5.09pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 4.42pm

Thanks Syd,i also enjoy your posts as i do Jamiemartin and others.

i meant what i said about animals i used to have cats whom i love.

it's just people like Roof sicken me which maybe make me say things that i should'nt.

i should'nt refer to Roof as an animal as it's disrespectful to animals,i still believe people like Roof should be punished for what he did,i saw a picture of him and he looks pure evil.
.

That Roof should be punished -- savagely so -- is beyond doubt. To me, justice has to serve the dual purpose of both punishment and, in so far as possible, rehabilitation but the punishment comes first. He should serve life without parole and the early part of that sentence should be unremittingly and mercilessly hard, whatever that may entail. At some point the punishment element has to be considered largely discharged simply because it makes no sense to have a human being that you don't make some effort to rehabilitate but he has to suffer for what he's done wrong before any attempt should be made to encourage him to do right.

Roof sickens me but -- and you may dislike this -- just as society takes credit for the good it creates so the evil it produces is also a reflection of the society as a whole. Roof didn't emerge from his mother's womb a fully formed hatred machine; society at least helped to shape him. That is not to let him off the hook or blame society for what he did. No way; he alone is responsible for his actions and he alone should pay for them. But as a society, it would be irresponsible not to ask ourselves "where does race hate come from?" If we don't ask the question then we miss the chance to address the problem.

Is Roof pure evil? It's an interesting question. I doubt it. When I look at his photo I see pure stupidity; a child masquerading as a man, hiding under the iconography of race hate as if that somehow bestowed on him adult status and legitimised his view of himself as a "freedom fighter" (sic), an emancipator of his race. Evil in one way yes, but confused, stupid, low IQ, easily led, almost a cartoon villain in another. Roof is the answer for a village in search of an idiot.

He, it seems to me, lacked the wit to even articulate his position as a mass murderer to any great effect; he's ended up as just another dumb southern white kid with a gun. Evil? In one way, yes. But more witless, pointless and ignorant in another. I doubt Roof is really clever enough to be evil. That, if nothing else, requires guile and intelligence. Like most people who do stupid things he probably just wanted attention and lacked the nous to even go about something that simple in an effective way. He's two-bit scum, but not even really capable of evil; just rank, base and utterly destructive idiocy.

His story is a mixture of ignorance, tragedy and despair. I hope he burns in hell, but not at the behest of the state.

Edited by sydtheeagle (22 Jun 2015 5.12pm)


I'd be interested to know if Roof has brothers and sisters and if so what type of up bringing they had as well as Roof of course.
also has Roofs family condemmed the killings?

 

derben Flag 22 Jun 15 6.08pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 5.37pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 5.09pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 4.42pm

Thanks Syd,i also enjoy your posts as i do Jamiemartin and others.

i meant what i said about animals i used to have cats whom i love.

it's just people like Roof sicken me which maybe make me say things that i should'nt.

i should'nt refer to Roof as an animal as it's disrespectful to animals,i still believe people like Roof should be punished for what he did,i saw a picture of him and he looks pure evil.
.

That Roof should be punished -- savagely so -- is beyond doubt. To me, justice has to serve the dual purpose of both punishment and, in so far as possible, rehabilitation but the punishment comes first. He should serve life without parole and the early part of that sentence should be unremittingly and mercilessly hard, whatever that may entail. At some point the punishment element has to be considered largely discharged simply because it makes no sense to have a human being that you don't make some effort to rehabilitate but he has to suffer for what he's done wrong before any attempt should be made to encourage him to do right.

Roof sickens me but -- and you may dislike this -- just as society takes credit for the good it creates so the evil it produces is also a reflection of the society as a whole. Roof didn't emerge from his mother's womb a fully formed hatred machine; society at least helped to shape him. That is not to let him off the hook or blame society for what he did. No way; he alone is responsible for his actions and he alone should pay for them. But as a society, it would be irresponsible not to ask ourselves "where does race hate come from?" If we don't ask the question then we miss the chance to address the problem.

Is Roof pure evil? It's an interesting question. I doubt it. When I look at his photo I see pure stupidity; a child masquerading as a man, hiding under the iconography of race hate as if that somehow bestowed on him adult status and legitimised his view of himself as a "freedom fighter" (sic), an emancipator of his race. Evil in one way yes, but confused, stupid, low IQ, easily led, almost a cartoon villain in another. Roof is the answer for a village in search of an idiot.

He, it seems to me, lacked the wit to even articulate his position as a mass murderer to any great effect; he's ended up as just another dumb southern white kid with a gun. Evil? In one way, yes. But more witless, pointless and ignorant in another. I doubt Roof is really clever enough to be evil. That, if nothing else, requires guile and intelligence. Like most people who do stupid things he probably just wanted attention and lacked the nous to even go about something that simple in an effective way. He's two-bit scum, but not even really capable of evil; just rank, base and utterly destructive idiocy.

His story is a mixture of ignorance, tragedy and despair. I hope he burns in hell, but not at the behest of the state.

Edited by sydtheeagle (22 Jun 2015 5.12pm)


I'd be interested to know if Roof has brothers and sisters and if so what type of up bringing they had as well as Roof of course.
also has Roofs family condemmed the killings?

I understand he has a brother named Flat and a sister called Thatched, his father's name is Corrugated I. Roof.


Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 6.14pm)

 

derben Flag 22 Jun 15 6.10pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 22 Jun 2015 5.32pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.09pm

Not too bothered about the 35+ people killed by the released murderers then?


What if that one innocent person was you?

I would be pissed off.

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 22 Jun 15 6.14pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 6.10pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 22 Jun 2015 5.32pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.09pm

Not too bothered about the 35+ people killed by the released murderers then?


What if that one innocent person was you?

I would be pissed off.


You'd be dead.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

derben Flag 22 Jun 15 6.16pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 22 Jun 2015 6.14pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 6.10pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 22 Jun 2015 5.32pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.09pm

Not too bothered about the 35+ people killed by the released murderers then?


What if that one innocent person was you?

I would be pissed off.


You'd be dead.

God might choose to save me, just to spoil Legaleagle's celebrations.

 

TUX Flag redhill 22 Jun 15 6.17pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 6.08pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 5.37pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 5.09pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 4.42pm

Thanks Syd,i also enjoy your posts as i do Jamiemartin and others.

i meant what i said about animals i used to have cats whom i love.

it's just people like Roof sicken me which maybe make me say things that i should'nt.

i should'nt refer to Roof as an animal as it's disrespectful to animals,i still believe people like Roof should be punished for what he did,i saw a picture of him and he looks pure evil.
.

That Roof should be punished -- savagely so -- is beyond doubt. To me, justice has to serve the dual purpose of both punishment and, in so far as possible, rehabilitation but the punishment comes first. He should serve life without parole and the early part of that sentence should be unremittingly and mercilessly hard, whatever that may entail. At some point the punishment element has to be considered largely discharged simply because it makes no sense to have a human being that you don't make some effort to rehabilitate but he has to suffer for what he's done wrong before any attempt should be made to encourage him to do right.

Roof sickens me but -- and you may dislike this -- just as society takes credit for the good it creates so the evil it produces is also a reflection of the society as a whole. Roof didn't emerge from his mother's womb a fully formed hatred machine; society at least helped to shape him. That is not to let him off the hook or blame society for what he did. No way; he alone is responsible for his actions and he alone should pay for them. But as a society, it would be irresponsible not to ask ourselves "where does race hate come from?" If we don't ask the question then we miss the chance to address the problem.

Is Roof pure evil? It's an interesting question. I doubt it. When I look at his photo I see pure stupidity; a child masquerading as a man, hiding under the iconography of race hate as if that somehow bestowed on him adult status and legitimised his view of himself as a "freedom fighter" (sic), an emancipator of his race. Evil in one way yes, but confused, stupid, low IQ, easily led, almost a cartoon villain in another. Roof is the answer for a village in search of an idiot.

He, it seems to me, lacked the wit to even articulate his position as a mass murderer to any great effect; he's ended up as just another dumb southern white kid with a gun. Evil? In one way, yes. But more witless, pointless and ignorant in another. I doubt Roof is really clever enough to be evil. That, if nothing else, requires guile and intelligence. Like most people who do stupid things he probably just wanted attention and lacked the nous to even go about something that simple in an effective way. He's two-bit scum, but not even really capable of evil; just rank, base and utterly destructive idiocy.

His story is a mixture of ignorance, tragedy and despair. I hope he burns in hell, but not at the behest of the state.

Edited by sydtheeagle (22 Jun 2015 5.12pm)


I'd be interested to know if Roof has brothers and sisters and if so what type of up bringing they had as well as Roof of course.
also has Roofs family condemmed the killings?

I understand he has a brother named Flat and a sister called Thatched, his father's name is Corrugated I. Roof.


Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 6.14pm)

I think you've mistaken the sister for the mother

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 22 Jun 15 6.18pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 5.37pm

I'd be interested to know if Roof has brothers and sisters and if so what type of up bringing they had as well as Roof of course.
also has Roofs family condemmed the killings?


They went to church Sunday to grieve for the victims and their families.
[Link]

"They are grieving in a different way, but they are grieving for those nine families, and they expressed great grief and sorrow for them," said Rev. Herman R. Yoos of St. Paul's Lutheran Church, which Roof's family attends.


They also released a formal statement:
[Link]

Edited by Ray in Houston (22 Jun 2015 6.19pm)

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

derben Flag 22 Jun 15 6.18pm


Has anyone noticed that Dylan Roof looks like Gareth in The Office? I expect Mackenzie Crook could get into character and come up with a few imaginative suggestions as to how Roof could be executed.

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 22 Jun 15 6.22pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 6.18pm


Has anyone noticed that Dylan Roof looks like Gareth in The Office? I expect Mackenzie Crook could get into character and come up with a few imaginative suggestions as to how Roof could be executed.


Electric chair would be nice,what do you think?

 

Stuk Flag Top half 22 Jun 15 6.26pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 5.14pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 4.35pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 4.22pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.09pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 3.06pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.55pm

How many innocent people were executed in the last ten years of the death penalty? If less then 35, then I would say we would be ahead of the game in having a death penalty.

Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 2.56pm)

I would say that if a single innocent person was executed, ever, then you have all the reason you need for not having the death penalty.


Not too bothered about the 35+ people killed by the released murderers then?

The option isn't simply kill them or release them. There's the third option of not letting them out, to kill again.


I think you have to have some capacity by which 'society forgives and freedom' can be earned, even allowing for very serious crimes. Only those who have given a whole life tariff should arguably face the inevitability of death behind bars.

If someone goes on a rampage with either a gun, machete or any other weapon that should be a starting point for a whole life tariff regardless of how many people they killed or injured.

I'd put those who plant bombs in the same bracket too, regardless of their "cause".

[Link]

Another prime example.

 


Optimistic as ever

sydtheeagle Flag England 22 Jun 15 6.43pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 5.37pm

I'd be interested to know if Roof has brothers and sisters and if so what type of up bringing they had as well as Roof of course.
also has Roofs family condemmed the killings?

I believe that as soon as the shootings were announced on the TV news (almost immediately) along with a photo of the suspect, Roof's father called the police, identified his car and license plate number, as assisted them in helping to track him down as he fled the scene.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

derben Flag 22 Jun 15 6.51pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 6.43pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 5.37pm

I'd be interested to know if Roof has brothers and sisters and if so what type of up bringing they had as well as Roof of course.
also has Roofs family condemmed the killings?

I believe that as soon as the shootings were announced on the TV news (almost immediately) along with a photo of the suspect, Roof's father called the police, identified his car and license plate number, as assisted them in helping to track him down as he fled the scene.

I expect he knew he was a few tiles short of a roof.

 

legaleagle Flag 22 Jun 15 8.02pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 6.43pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 5.37pm

I'd be interested to know if Roof has brothers and sisters and if so what type of up bringing they had as well as Roof of course.
also has Roofs family condemmed the killings?

I believe that as soon as the shootings were announced on the TV news (almost immediately) along with a photo of the suspect, Roof's father called the police, identified his car and license plate number, as assisted them in helping to track him down as he fled the scene.


Its been reported his uncle also contacted the police.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 22 Jun 15 9.09pm

Quote legaleagle at 22 Jun 2015 8.02pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 6.43pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 5.37pm

I'd be interested to know if Roof has brothers and sisters and if so what type of up bringing they had as well as Roof of course.
also has Roofs family condemmed the killings?

I believe that as soon as the shootings were announced on the TV news (almost immediately) along with a photo of the suspect, Roof's father called the police, identified his car and license plate number, as assisted them in helping to track him down as he fled the scene.


Its been reported his uncle also contacted the police.

So there you go. I think anyone who has children knows they have minds of their own which often in no way reflect on their parents or their upbringing. Believe me, Dylan Roof's family are victims in this tragedy too. I can only imagine how they feel right now, having both "lost" a child and having a child who's a mass murderer simultaneously. Their suffering; a mixture of guilt and despair, must be almost beyond comprehension.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 22 Jun 15 9.26pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 9.09pm

Quote legaleagle at 22 Jun 2015 8.02pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 6.43pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 5.37pm

I'd be interested to know if Roof has brothers and sisters and if so what type of up bringing they had as well as Roof of course.
also has Roofs family condemmed the killings?

I believe that as soon as the shootings were announced on the TV news (almost immediately) along with a photo of the suspect, Roof's father called the police, identified his car and license plate number, as assisted them in helping to track him down as he fled the scene.


Its been reported his uncle also contacted the police.

So there you go. I think anyone who has children knows they have minds of their own which often in no way reflect on their parents or their upbringing. Believe me, Dylan Roof's family are victims in this tragedy too. I can only imagine how they feel right now, having both "lost" a child and having a child who's a mass murderer simultaneously. Their suffering; a mixture of guilt and despair, must be almost beyond comprehension.


yeah i agree Roofs family must be in bits right now,must of been hard for his uncle to call the police but i admire him for letting them know.

Roofs family will be living a life sentence from now on.

their despair shared by the families who lost loved ones in the shootings.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 22 Jun 15 10.22pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 9.26pm

Roofs family will be living a life sentence from now on.

They will feel the same sense of grief as the victims on top of which, rightly or wrongly, they will also feel they are in some way responsible where the victims are simply victims. And they will continue to love Dylan, for all the anguish that doing so will cause them, because that's what families do. It must have taken enormous moral courage for the uncle to call the police in a country that has the death penalty, knowing that so doing would likely contribute to the demise of his nephew. It just goes to show that the line between someone who is a good and courageous person and someone who is evil is wafer thin; they share the same DNA.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

derben Flag 22 Jun 15 10.50pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 10.22pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 9.26pm

Roofs family will be living a life sentence from now on.

They will feel the same sense of grief as the victims on top of which, rightly or wrongly, they will also feel they are in some way responsible where the victims are simply victims. And they will continue to love Dylan, for all the anguish that doing so will cause them, because that's what families do. It must have taken enormous moral courage for the uncle to call the police in a country that has the death penalty, knowing that so doing would likely contribute to the demise of his nephew. It just goes to show that the line between someone who is a good and courageous person and someone who is evil is wafer thin; they share the same DNA.

Yes, his music can be quite therapeutic during hard times.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Jun 15 9.25am

Quote Ray in Houston at 22 Jun 2015 5.37pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 4.17pm

Yes, choice is the key phrase. Dignitas won't kill you unless you can a) pay their fee b) terminally ill or suffering terribly c) capable of making the decision yourself.


Things get further complicated as administering lethal drugs is a comprehensive breach of the Hippocratic Oath, which is why doctors in the death chambers are merely observers, not protagonists. The lethal injections are set up and administered by non-medical personnel because a doctor can't do it and the "patient" won't.

Doctors at Digitas don't administer the fatal dose either, its the patient or someone with the patient.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Jun 15 9.41am

Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 5.14pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 4.35pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 4.22pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.09pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 3.06pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.55pm

How many innocent people were executed in the last ten years of the death penalty? If less then 35, then I would say we would be ahead of the game in having a death penalty.

Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 2.56pm)

I would say that if a single innocent person was executed, ever, then you have all the reason you need for not having the death penalty.


Not too bothered about the 35+ people killed by the released murderers then?

The option isn't simply kill them or release them. There's the third option of not letting them out, to kill again.


I think you have to have some capacity by which 'society forgives and freedom' can be earned, even allowing for very serious crimes. Only those who have given a whole life tariff should arguably face the inevitability of death behind bars.

If someone goes on a rampage with either a gun, machete or any other weapon that should be a starting point for a whole life tariff regardless of how many people they killed or injured.

I'd put those who plant bombs in the same bracket too, regardless of their "cause".

I'd generally agree with you, and the legal system pretty much would put those kinds of offences in the 35 to 40 years or whole life tariff category.

Often of course people in the UK who have gone on rampages, particually without guns, have been sectioned under mental health acts, and treated, usually for a form of paranoid schizophrenia which complicates the matter somewhat.

Its generally the assumption of the Judicary that a 35-40 year minimum tariff is a whole life sentence barring 'dramatic evidence of rehabilitation'.

With active terrorists, who've actually committed an act, whole life makes sense, with release being explicitly only being available where miscarriage of justice occurred, the individual provided key information and intelligence* or as part of a peace process.

* In return for which the tariff is lowered, or a set sentence or suspended is applied (such as where the individual turned themselves in before committing the act). Ideally the leverage can be very useful in creating double agents.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 12 of 14 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 9 dead in USA Church Shooting.