You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 9.48am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Marco Silva (LOCKED)


Page 12 of 30 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
chateauferret Flag 25 May 17 4.56pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Silva will be a totally useless appointment and take us down

If Hull had had him for the whole season they would've stayed up. Not sure you could say the same about Monk.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Mad4palace Flag 25 May 17 5.04pm

As long as he's pragmatic and doesn't ignore the defensive side of the game then he should do alright. With Hull he had similar results to us with Sam but will a vastly inferior squad.

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 25 May 17 5.16pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

If Hull had had him for the whole season they would've stayed up. Not sure you could say the same about Monk.

Clueless , if the club dont appoint a big manager we will lose Zaha, Cabaye , possibly Benteke and forget about Sakho !!!
Marco Silva is a nobody in the premier league and Palace arent a club that can attract big players unless the manager has a pedigree

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 May 17 5.19pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Clueless , if the club dont appoint a big manager we will lose Zaha, Cabaye , possibly Benteke and forget about Sakho !!!
Marco Silva is a nobody in the premier league and Palace arent a club that can attract big players unless the manager has a pedigree

Yes, Silva would be a very "Underwhelming" appointment.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 25 May 17 5.21pm

Originally posted by Monty the Eagle

My thoughts for what they are worth are that he is a great up and coming manager who has had success wherever he has gone. I include Hull in this due to the fact that they were on target for one of the lowest EPL points totals and am amazed that they lasted so long with all the problems on and off the pitch.

However, I just do not think he is right for Palace. For the 30+ years of supporting Palace we have never been a free flowing team. It has always been counter attacking or route one in the old days. Steve P even said in his interview on Hol radio that the problems at the start of the season were that we tried to change our style too quickly and I think this is what will happen if we sign a manager in the style of Silva. Mancini also falls into this category.

Personally I would rather see a manager who has built his career on the same style played by Palace. This is one of the reasons why Pulis and Allardyce did so well.

Edited by Monty the Eagle (25 May 2017 12.46pm)

Edited by Monty the Eagle (25 May 2017 12.46pm)

From Mancini's Wiki page :

Mancini places great emphasis on building from the back, stressing the importance of not conceding a goal means the team will always have an opportunity to win, going as far to say, "I like 1–0 wins. When you don't concede a goal and you have players like Edin Džeko, Carlos Tevez or David Silva, you win 90%. I prefer we are boring for two to three matches and we win 1–0. If you watch teams that won titles, they conceded very few goals."

Sounds straight out of the Allardyce manual.

Edited by Booted Eagle (25 May 2017 5.24pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Master Coin Flag 25 May 17 5.42pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Clueless , if the club dont appoint a big manager we will lose Zaha, Cabaye , possibly Benteke and forget about Sakho !!!
Marco Silva is a nobody in the premier league and Palace arent a club that can attract big players unless the manager has a pedigree

Not like Monk (the other name in the frame) is gonna attract these calibre either. I'd rather, if I was a player, play for Silva than Monk personally.

 

comeonyoueagles20 Flag caterham 25 May 17 5.45pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Clueless , if the club dont appoint a big manager we will lose Zaha, Cabaye , possibly Benteke and forget about Sakho !!!
Marco Silva is a nobody in the premier league and Palace arent a club that can attract big players unless the manager has a pedigree

So a team in the most popular league in the world , based in one of the most popular cities to live and who pay pretty decent wages to top players can't attract big players ? Think it's you who is clueless , Silva has a better contact than all of our previous managers.

 

Portuguese Flag Porto 25 May 17 6.11pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Silva will be a totally useless appointment and take us down

Clearly it is an opinion based on a conservative, even biased permisses, revealing the lack of ability to think outside the box.
Carlos Carvalhal was someone known before joining the Owls!? ...
Based on this perspective it will be impossible to do new and different things and discover forthcoming talents.
Mate I don't have a stagnant vision of the world, plus most of the previous recipes, year after year, brought us somehow different headaches and we still want to continue doing the same things.
Now to finish if we continue to always make the same choices, in the same way and with the same criteria it will be plausible to believe that we'll obtain the qualitative leap that this club already deserves???...

Edited by Portuguese (25 May 2017 6.13pm)

 


1861 Football Club

FPL

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 May 17 6.12pm

If anyone isn't aware Macro Silva is best mates with Jorge Mendes so to think he won't have contacts is absurd!

(Sorry if the spelling is wrong)

 

Portuguese Flag Porto 25 May 17 6.28pm

Just to make clear about some arguments presented by some let me remind you about something I know very near.
Once upon a time there was a manager training a team call U. Leiria that until then didn't had won nothing (I don't even know if you ever heard about such team?).
Well that manager went to a much bigger club with lots of trophys and international background. The result in 2 years was that he won the UEFA League and the Champions League, the team in question was F.C. Porto...
Just for the record the manager that was nothing at that time and it hasn't no relevant curriculum was...
José Mourinho!!! Intriguing...

Edited by Portuguese (25 May 2017 6.43pm)

 


1861 Football Club

FPL

twist Flag Miami, Florida 25 May 17 6.31pm

Silva has an excellent track record when you look at the resources he had to work with at the clubs he managed.

Managing Estoril in Portugal, he took them to new heights they had never seen before. Won the second division, got them qualified for Europa league for 2 seasons straight after promotion.

Went on to manage Sporting, where he won them the cup, finished 3rd, but was fired at season end for not wearing the clubs official suit at a game !

At Olympiacos he had an 80% win rate, including a memorable 3-2 win at Arsenal.

Like people have said before, he had the worst team in the league to work with, and came close to saving them. This guy would be fantastic to have here.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 25 May 17 6.31pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have been speaking to a couple of Palace supporters tonight and they were BOTH totally against Silva joining, in fact they asked me to pass their feelings on to Parish !

One of them didn't have an alternative in mind, the other one was pro-Hodgson.

You are keeping bad company then. So just are you going to pass this information to SP. I am beginning to think you live in cloud cuckoo land.

 

Portuguese Flag Porto 25 May 17 6.40pm

Originally posted by twist

Silva has an excellent track record when you look at the resources he had to work with at the clubs he managed.

Managing Estoril in Portugal, he took them to new heights they had never seen before. Won the second division, got them qualified for Europa league for 2 seasons straight after promotion.

Went on to manage Sporting, where he won them the cup, finished 3rd, but was fired at season end for not wearing the clubs official suit at a game !

At Olympiacos he had an 80% win rate, including a memorable 3-2 win at Arsenal.

Like people have said before, he had the worst team in the league to work with, and came close to saving them. This guy would be fantastic to have here.

Mate you're spot on!
I don't want to be right I deeply want success for the Palace and joy to all of us!
COYP

Edited by Portuguese (25 May 2017 6.40pm)

 


1861 Football Club

FPL

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 May 17 6.41pm

Originally posted by Spiderman


You are keeping bad company then. So just are you going to pass this information to SP. I am beginning to think you live in cloud cuckoo land.

Absolutely NOT.

I regret posting what they asked me to do.
Must refrain from posting after imbibing intoxicating fluids !

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 25 May 17 6.42pm

Originally posted by Willo

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Marco Silva ??? ~ You are joking right ???' by Guntrisoft

I am not solely judging him on the Hull experience because I have said there were "Extenuating circumstances".

What I am saying is that he arrived at Hull as a relative 'Unknown' as far as supporters in this country are concerned on the back of a record with major clubs in lesser leagues, yet he suffers a relegation and all of a sudden he is the "Flavour of the month" and many might conclude the "Real deal". !

Just like Luka then! I suppose you think he is not up to it as he has mainly played in Belgium and Greece. You seem to be taking great pleasure in dismissing any sensible suggestions.

 

oghash Flag 25 May 17 6.43pm

Wouldn't be that bad a choice.

 


Why would anyone chose to be a Seagull? The Eagle is a far superior creature.

The Seagull lives under it's damp pier meekly looking out, blinded by the sheer quality of the Eagle's palace.

Petereagle Flag Brockley 25 May 17 6.43pm

Originally posted by Portuguese

Just to make clear about some arguments presented by some let me remind you about something I know very near.
The manager in question was in a team call U. Leiria and at that point didn't had won nothing (I don't even know if you ever heard about such team?.
Well that manager went to a big club with history and international background. The result in 2 years was taht he won the UEFA League and the Champions League, that team was F.C. Porto...
Just for the record the manager that was nothing and at that time it hasn't no relevant curriculum was...
José Mourinho!!! Intriguing...

Edited by Portuguese (25 May 2017 6.30pm)


[Link]

Just found this really good article which describes his coaching approach. Rather to my surprise, he seems a very good fit for Palace. He seems to emphasise a defense first approach, with meticulous attention to defensive formation, and favours a counter attacking style going forward.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 25 May 17 6.56pm

Originally posted by Willo

Yes, Silva would be a very "Underwhelming" appointment.

Presumably then, if this goes ahead you will no longer grace this board with your doom mongering and attention seeking drivel.

 

Portuguese Flag Porto 25 May 17 7.01pm

Originally posted by Petereagle


[Link]

Just found this really good article which describes his coaching approach. Rather to my surprise, he seems a very good fit for Palace. He seems to emphasise a defense first approach, with meticulous attention to defensive formation, and favours a counter attacking style going forward.

Good point but neverthless this review needs to be context in a way like Ortega y Gasset says: "I am plus my circumstances."
What I want to enphasize is that shows what is done in the past with the resources that he had. It doesn't necessarily means what he will do in the future with different resources.

Edited by Portuguese (25 May 2017 7.07pm)

 


1861 Football Club

FPL

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 May 17 7.13pm

Originally posted by Spiderman


Just like Luka then! I suppose you think he is not up to it as he has mainly played in Belgium and Greece. You seem to be taking great pleasure in dismissing any sensible suggestions.

You are being very selective only highlighting part of my message.Please look at my overall message.

Don't know why you believe I am deriving "Great pleasure" etc etc. All I am doing is giving my honest opinions and I stand firm by what I have written.

 

Page 12 of 30 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic