You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread
November 16 2026 8.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread


Page 12 of 13 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
boo909 Flag Figeac 21 Oct 17 8.55pm

Originally posted by Willo

I've not seen their bloody goal but from all accounts. McArthur got to the ball first but headed it against Merino and it ricocheted in.How bloody unlucky can one get ?

At the end of the day, the performances in the last 2 games give grounds for optimism and we are certainly better placed than we were a couple of games ago so we are making progress.

Have to hand it to you Willo, I never thought I'd be more pessimistic than you this season, right I'm going to pull my socks up, dust off my optimists hat and we'll start again next week.

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 21 Oct 17 9.09pm

The fact is Wilf had the easiest chance to score in th3 match today and missed. He was taken off because he had a yellow and we cannot afford to lose him for any more games. He had been stopped all game by their defence and so no point in risking keeping him on.
We were in control virtually all game but they scored a fortunate goal and we did not . No point in getting downhearted about this performance we were just unlucky to lose it. When we we return to the De Boar crap then we should start getting worried. As we are we still have a chance.
COYP

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Oct 17 10.02pm

Originally posted by boo909

Have to hand it to you Willo, I never thought I'd be more pessimistic than you this season, right I'm going to pull my socks up, dust off my optimists hat and we'll start again next week.

Same here. I've given up any real hope and found myself trying to enjoy last week but being honest I didn't really. It just felt like 3 points we should've had 2 months ago on the long road to 40 we won't make. All down to a bit of:

Feeling it won't last;

So much more to be done;

So long since any joy that small doses of excitement do very little.

If you've played football without a striker you know how much of a losing and often demoralising battle it is, despite how up for it you might get as a player. What the players must think after they've gone would be interesting, although they haven't covered themselves in glory with a striker either.

 


COYP

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 21 Oct 17 10.17pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Its just not fair. We didn't have a single shot on target but deserved to win....

We came closer to scoring on a few occasions. Did you watch the game?

Edited by Brentmiester_General (21 Oct 2017 10.30pm)

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

DulwichFan Flag West Dulwich 21 Oct 17 10.48pm

I was there today and we looked pretty good, composed and in control most of the game. We should have done better in a few attacking situations but were solid in defence. That is until the last 10 minutes or so when they made a couple of subs and we didn’t... they started to look stronger and we were a bit slow with our subs - I would have brought on Fosu-mensah and Loftus-Cheek - as last week. Zaha should have been left on (unless injured) as he always worries the defenders and keeps them pinned back.
In the end we were a bit unlucky and that’s football - Newcastle are a good side but most of the match we were the better team - you just have to take something when you’re in the ascendancy or you can come a cropper. Play like that every week and we’ll pick up points - not going to worry about relegation - it could happen but there’s enough time and matches for the averages to even out in our favour.

 


I long to accomplish a great and noble task, but it is my chief duty to accomplish small tasks as if they were great and noble.
Helen Keller

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 21 Oct 17 10.57pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

We came closer to scoring on a few occasions. Did you watch the game?

Edited by Brentmiester_General (21 Oct 2017 10.30pm)

Yes I did. And you don't deserve to win a game if you don't get a single shot on target. Doesn't matter hiw well you play, and how many near misses you have, to not get a single shot on target in 94 mins is shocking.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 22 Oct 17 12.07am

Having just seen the goal for the first time, I’m fairly sure Hennessey would have saved it? Not having a dig at Speroni but most of us including me wanted us to keep the same 11 this week after the Chelsea result. So, who plays in goal next week - perhaps Hennessey gets his chance midweek to prove he should be number 1 verses Westham?

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 22 Oct 17 12.57am

Originally posted by palace chick

Having just seen the goal for the first time, I’m fairly sure Hennessey would have saved it? Not having a dig at Speroni but most of us including me wanted us to keep the same 11 this week after the Chelsea result. So, who plays in goal next week - perhaps Hennessey gets his chance midweek to prove he should be number 1 verses Westham?

Don't start getting all sensible.

 

McPalace Flag Carshalton Village 22 Oct 17 3.29am

I was there watching the game in the “God’s” and didn’t see Wolf being booked and neither did anybody around me
Not seen MOD so can somebody enlighten me when he was booked and what for ?

 

HKfan Flag Hong Kong 22 Oct 17 3.44am

Originally posted by McPalace

I was there watching the game in the “God’s” and didn’t see Wolf being booked and neither did anybody around me
Not seen MOD so can somebody enlighten me when he was booked and what for ?

He wasn't booked.

 

McPalace Flag Carshalton Village 22 Oct 17 8.03am

Originally posted by HKfan

He wasn't booked.

Then why the hell was he taken off ?
Soon as he left the pitch the game changes

 

Flightsequence Flag 22 Oct 17 8.09am

Originally posted by McPalace

I was there watching the game in the “God’s” and didn’t see Wolf being booked and neither did anybody around me
Not seen MOD so can somebody enlighten me when he was booked and what for ?

Was it taken off because he had a howler?

Edited by Flightsequence (22 Oct 2017 8.10am)

 

The Dolphin Flag 22 Oct 17 8.13am

Under normal circumstances a 1-0 loss away at Newcastle would be annoying/frustrating but because we had such a dreadful start every game where we don't get something hurts more than it normally would.
This was a game where we need a point I'm afraid and whilst we did well (considering) I see it as a point dropped.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 22 Oct 17 8.39am

Originally posted by McPalace

Then why the hell was he taken off ?
Soon as he left the pitch the game changes

He was poor second half of 2nd half - he was annoyed at all the fouls and wasn't getting involved. I mentioned to the guy next to me we should take him off about 5 mins before he was.
We let Newcastle back in big time. my biggest surprise of the day was meeting a team who looked worse than Palace!

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

laddo Flag london 22 Oct 17 9.15am

People can be so dumb after a loss. Wilf was taken off because he's played little football. He was replaced by RLC who on another day would have had an assist if PVA's big toe was millimetres bigger.

Yes, it's hugely frustrating but yesterday was another good performance. We're getting there.

 


laddo

"People say, live fast, die young. I say live fast, die old. That's me, the non-conformist".
David Brent.

Bullhorn76 Flag Darlington 22 Oct 17 10.33am

Originally posted by Flightsequence

Was it taken off because he had a howler?

Edited by Flightsequence (22 Oct 2017 8.10am)

He got the “silver “ bullet for missing that sitter of a header

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 22 Oct 17 10.43am

Originally posted by McPalace

I was there watching the game in the “God’s” and didn’t see Wolf being booked and neither did anybody around me
Not seen MOD so can somebody enlighten me when he was booked and what for ?

Sorry my mistake I watched it on TV and thought he got booked but I was clearly wrong about that. Wilf I thought was not as effective as he was last week we had trouble in getting in behind their defence because of that. I guess Roy just felt he would be no more effective in the r3mainder of the game than when he was on the pitch.

 

boo909 Flag Figeac 22 Oct 17 12.04pm

Wilf often has a bad game because the other team shuts him down and all the while they've got at least half an eye on him they are less effective. I think it was telling that Newcastle upped their game when he came off. I'm not a Roy hater at all but I think that was his first big mistake so far. It was an almost Pardew-like substitution.

Personally, with my admitted limited knowledge of management, I would have taken Cabaye off at or near HT and brought RLC on then. Cabaye was at risk of blowing his top (good on him that he didn't in the end), he was letting the crowd and the other team get to him. We may have had to change shape slightly but I think that's an ok risk to take. Having Wilf on the pitch gives the other team something to think of and ties them up.

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

TheFish Flag 23 Oct 17 9.40am

Alright lads, agree with the people saying that had Benteke been on the pitch, you might have got something. Mind you Cabaye should have seen red with only 28 minutes gone, so had the ref not bottled it it may not have panned out the way you'd like.

Zara loves a tumble, doesn't he? Don't get me wrong, we've all had players who dive or whatever, but he's not afraid to "go down easy" is he? He got increasingly frustrated that he wasn't getting much change out of Yedlin and that the ref wasn't buying his theatrics and had a wee strop as he went off. If he worked harder for the team he'd be a very good player. Too selfish imo

We've become a very good defensive outfit, so a lot of teams leave thinking they deserved something from the game, because they had the lions share of possession, or had a load of shots or whatever. Trouble is the possession and shots are generally not in/from dangerous areas. Elliott didn't need to make a save and because you played 2 wingers up front youmight have launched in plenty of crosses, but there wasn't anyone there to get on the end of them. Had Benteke been playing we probably would have sacrificed our wide play even more, to stop the crosses.

Think it was a below par performance from us, Ritchie, Perez and Hayden were poor. Joselu got very little joy from your centrebacks too. But this was a game that could have been trickier than it was. You on a high, bit of complacency from us, Zaha or Townsend doing something special. Nice to grind this out, fans have total faith in Rafa to guide us through games like this now.

I think you'll pick up wins now that Hodgson has you better defensively than you were and when you've a fit striker you'll improve at that end of the pitch too. But it may be too little too late I'm afraid.

Good luck with the rest of the season.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 23 Oct 17 9.56am

Originally posted by TheFish

Alright lads, agree with the people saying that had Benteke been on the pitch, you might have got something. Mind you Cabaye should have seen red with only 28 minutes gone, so had the ref not bottled it it may not have panned out the way you'd like.

Zara loves a tumble, doesn't he? Don't get me wrong, we've all had players who dive or whatever, but he's not afraid to "go down easy" is he? He got increasingly frustrated that he wasn't getting much change out of Yedlin and that the ref wasn't buying his theatrics and had a wee strop as he went off. If he worked harder for the team he'd be a very good player. Too selfish imo

We've become a very good defensive outfit, so a lot of teams leave thinking they deserved something from the game, because they had the lions share of possession, or had a load of shots or whatever. Trouble is the possession and shots are generally not in/from dangerous areas. Elliott didn't need to make a save and because you played 2 wingers up front youmight have launched in plenty of crosses, but there wasn't anyone there to get on the end of them. Had Benteke been playing we probably would have sacrificed our wide play even more, to stop the crosses.

Think it was a below par performance from us, Ritchie, Perez and Hayden were poor. Joselu got very little joy from your centrebacks too. But this was a game that could have been trickier than it was. You on a high, bit of complacency from us, Zaha or Townsend doing something special. Nice to grind this out, fans have total faith in Rafa to guide us through games like this now.

I think you'll pick up wins now that Hodgson has you better defensively than you were and when you've a fit striker you'll improve at that end of the pitch too. But it may be too little too late I'm afraid.

Good luck with the rest of the season.

Never a red for Cabaye, funny that just after Yedlin was sprinting like a racehorse despite going down as if he was shot when Cabaye fouled him, yes a foul but never a red.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Page 12 of 13 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread