You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up
November 16 2026 8.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer Window Summing Up


Page 12 of 18 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 01 Feb 18 11.48am

This window is now closed. We are where we are.
All the 'we shoulds' and 'why didn't theys' in the world
will not change the situation now.
Lets put this behind us now and do what we do after each
window - get behind the club,the manager and the players that we have.Personally am looking forward to the next 13 games and no doubt the continuing roller coaster ride that is Palace.

Edited by rob1969 (01 Feb 2018 11.50am)

 

Username Flag Horsham 01 Feb 18 11.49am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You make a good case apart from the keeper.

We could've sorted that out earlier. No excuses there. It was possible and probably not going to cost much more from abroad or just a loan.

Despite what most people think though, keeper just wasn't the biggest priority. It's not like we've been getting spanked every week with lots of goalkeeping howlers.

There are not many games to go, and as good as this Getafe keeper could be, it would be asking an awful lot to drop a guy in for his first Premier League action behind a constantly rotating back four, not to mention the potential language barrier issue in a position where communication is so important.

It often takes time for keepers to settle, and I'm not that bothered about Hennessey, who is familiar with this defence and they with him, getting through until the end of the year.

The biggest things we needed were outfield. We badly needed a striker, we got one. We needed a midfielder who can pass the ball, we got one. We needed some cover at the back, we got that.

Was it perfect? No, but I think we have addressed our biggest needs.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Midlands Eagle Flag 01 Feb 18 11.50am

Originally posted by silvertop

And "untried in the prem"

I hear that's why we didn't sign Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Feb 18 11.52am

Perhaps we could have a thread where members can mark our transfer activity on a scale of 1 to 10.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Feb 18 11.56am

Just because there's half a season left we could still come a cropper with only having 2 keepers. Let's hope it doesn't happen but please don't tell me it won't because it could happen within 2 games and please nobody say it would've cost us an absolute fortune to have sorted it out a week earlier. I'm not talking about the Getaffe keeper who we understandably want to wait till the summer for a free transfer, eveyif it means losing out on him. I'm just talking about a bit of cheap insurance. We've done that in the past yet when it comes to a priority position we leave it late. Even the Brondby fans think it would've happened if we were earlier to give them time to sign a replacement, just like Tosun.

 


COYP

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 01 Feb 18 12.07pm

Originally posted by collier row eagle

For a start we missed out on a striker in the last window al, we left it to late this time to sort the Lille defender, the striker from Norway is unproven in the premier league, we didn't sign a goalkeeper, and we still have a couple of players we should have got of the payroll and haven't. Did we even go after sturridge I think he would have come to London.......is that enough?

Not really.
We got a Striker.
My understanding was that it was Lille’s fault but we might as well blame Parish.
Goaly can wait until the Summer.
Somebody needs to purchase Mutch but again blame Parish.
Sturridge is a crock.(If he stays fit could do well for West Brom).
Anyhow stop moaning FFS.
See you Sunday.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 01 Feb 18 12.13pm

Originally posted by Littlebogreek

Yawn. all this constant slagging off of our transfer dealings is getting a bit boring. None of us are privy to 99% of what goes on in the background, even those tedious souls that claim to be in the know - they aren't. If they were they'd be making a fortune from the bookies and not spending most of the day on this site.

We have very clearly been screwed over for Ammadou and the keeper by the selling clubs. What some people on here expect is total nonsense - should we pay double what someone is worth just to get it done? How long do you think that business model would e sustainable for? If you were buying a watch that's worth £1,000 and the shop told you they wanted £2,000 would you pay it from your own pockets? Or perhaps we should get agreements in place for 2 players then pull the plug once we sign one - how many clubs would do sensible business with us after we've done something like that? How much would we moan if another club did that to us?

Transfers are not simple things and can't be done without a lot of hurdles to jump over unless you are one of the mega rich clubs which we are not, we can't just throw money at it and hope for the best. I'm personally glad and grateful that we are being run in a way that won't lead to administration again any time soon.

Trust me, if you take an approach to actually supporting your club and the decisions that they make when you genuinely feel that they have the clubs overall long term interests at heart, you'll find the stress in your life decreases. If anyone on here doesn't honestly think we have one of the best boards out there they are mistaken.

Edited by Littlebogreek (01 Feb 2018 11.51am)

Very nice read.Good post.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Dman Palace Flag Brixton 01 Feb 18 12.13pm

Originally posted by Littlebogreek

Yawn. all this constant slagging off of our transfer dealings is getting a bit boring. None of us are privy to 99% of what goes on in the background, even those tedious souls that claim to be in the know - they aren't. If they were they'd be making a fortune from the bookies and not spending most of the day on this site.

We have very clearly been screwed over for Ammadou and the keeper by the selling clubs. What some people on here expect is total nonsense - should we pay double what someone is worth just to get it done? How long do you think that business model would e sustainable for? If you were buying a watch that's worth £1,000 and the shop told you they wanted £2,000 would you pay it from your own pockets? Or perhaps we should get agreements in place for 2 players then pull the plug once we sign one - how many clubs would do sensible business with us after we've done something like that? How much would we moan if another club did that to us?

Transfers are not simple things and can't be done without a lot of hurdles to jump over unless you are one of the mega rich clubs which we are not, we can't just throw money at it and hope for the best. I'm personally glad and grateful that we are being run in a way that won't lead to administration again any time soon.

Trust me, if you take an approach to actually supporting your club and the decisions that they make when you genuinely feel that they have the clubs overall long term interests at heart, you'll find the stress in your life decreases. If anyone on here doesn't honestly think we have one of the best boards out there they are mistaken.

Edited by Littlebogreek (01 Feb 2018 11.51am)

Best post in the entire thread.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Feb 18 12.16pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Not really.
We got a Striker.
My understanding was that it was Lille’s fault but we might as well blame Parish.
Goaly can wait until the Summer.
Somebody needs to purchase Mutch but again blame Parish.
Sturridge is a crock.(If he stays fit could do well for West Brom).
Anyhow stop moaning FFS.
See you Sunday.

Probably can wait for a good keeper till the summer. But Roy's said and anyone sensible knows you need 3.

Sturridge was available on loan so not an option for us.

I appreciate we've not spent any of the summer budget and Adamou probably was a case of getting him in now instead of in the summer when we need to anyway but, let's hope this keeper situation doesn't turn out to be negligent because it's pure hope it won't rather than management of the situation we're relying on with that issue.

Actually Hennessy's a complete pussy so he's unlikely to be out for too long so maybe we'll be lucky after all.

 


COYP

silvertop Flag Portishead 01 Feb 18 12.20pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Just because there's half a season left we could still come a cropper with only having 2 keepers. Let's hope it doesn't happen but please don't tell me it won't because it could happen within 2 games and please nobody say it would've cost us an absolute fortune to have sorted it out a week earlier. I'm not talking about the Getaffe keeper who we understandably want to wait till the summer for a free transfer, eveyif it means losing out on him. I'm just talking about a bit of cheap insurance. We've done that in the past yet when it comes to a priority position we leave it late. Even the Brondby fans think it would've happened if we were earlier to give them time to sign a replacement, just like Tosun.

What?! Tosun chose Everton over us. Most players would have made the same decision. More money; bigger club.

I stand by my uninformed belief that we have been chasing the Brondby keeper for months until somebody proves otherwise.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 01 Feb 18 12.21pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Not really.
We got a Striker.
My understanding was that it was Lille’s fault but we might as well blame Parish.
Goaly can wait until the Summer.
Somebody needs to purchase Mutch but again blame Parish.
Sturridge is a crock.(If he stays fit could do well for West Brom).
Anyhow stop moaning FFS.
See you Sunday.

Yup

I can't believe the idiocy of so many Palace 'fans' and the fact we are told on this site we are lickspittles if we say the club did OK considering it's the January window.

Personally I would be upset if I were a Hammers or Stoke fan but am fairly pleased with what we did. Guata should come in the summer and looks excellent. With luck so will Amadou.

We brought in 3 players, same as almost every other club. They all look decent buys in terms of value and also potentially to hit the ground running. It's a step up of course but that would apply to anyone we can afford to buy.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 01 Feb 18 12.21pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Probably can wait for a good keeper till the summer. But Roy's said and anyone sensible knows you need 3.

Sturridge was available on loan so not an option for us.

I appreciate we've not spent any of the summer budget and Adamou probably was a case of getting him in now instead of in the summer when we need to anyway but, let's hope this keeper situation doesn't turn out to be negligent because it's pure hope it won't rather than management of the situation we're relying on with that issue.

Actually Hennessy's a complete pussy so he's unlikely to be out for too long so maybe we'll be lucky after all.

Again, where is the negligence? Selling clubs would not release.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 01 Feb 18 12.25pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Doesn't look good I agree. However, what would you have done to have made it better in the January transfer window?

Poor luck - remember, we are not responsible for what happened at the selling club's end - not to have got another keeper and DM; and equally poor luck we are without key players for the season through injury...

Actually, I am not sure you are trying to say here? I think we are slowly and carefully growing a good squad within our limited budget and with our limited brand name. I know we are not there yet. Does that still make me rose tinted?

Meanwhile, who highlighted in red to reflect "not fit for purpose". Total bollox re keepers... and Lee as occasional back-up. And "untried in the prem" - I suspect it won't take long to make an extensive list of players currently plying their trade in the prem who are having a very nice career, thanks very much, but who had no prem experience... before they had prem experience! And 2 injured players are likely to return for the run-in.

I could turn this on its head and say you are unnecessarily pessimistic.

Just as an FYI, I did not produce that table it was emailed to me.

And I'm sorry but there are so many arguments on here surrounding people 'not knowing what goes on behind the scenes' but to be honest that is nonsense without producing the rhetoric of 'neither do you'

I actually think we have a decent squad given realistic expectations, but to not have any other options up front, apart from a youngster from the Danish league now (admitted I don't know anything of him really) and have two GKs, one who is much loved but too old now and another who might potentially be a reasonable no.2, for more than one window is ridiculous and infuriating. Even Newcastle have brought in a Gk and Slimani!

Transfer windows should not be anything new to those involved and they had plenty of time for risk assessment and to draw up a viable list of potential signings. The fact we have not solved these 2 issues is shambolic and further insulting that the club powers that be have on numerous occasions referred to these issues falsely alluding to a resolution.

It's not good enough at this level and I'm not pessimistic I see us staying up, but that's not a certainty, especially now.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 01 Feb 18 12.29pm

Lille did not screw us at all.

The player, Amadou, is valued at 18 millions.

So that's what they wanted.

What would SP's reaction be to a similar loan deal for a Palace star, he would laugh it off, rightly.

But you can't have it both ways SP.


 

Username Flag Horsham 01 Feb 18 12.29pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Just because there's half a season left we could still come a cropper with only having 2 keepers. Let's hope it doesn't happen but please don't tell me it won't because it could happen within 2 games and please nobody say it would've cost us an absolute fortune to have sorted it out a week earlier. I'm not talking about the Getaffe keeper who we understandably want to wait till the summer for a free transfer, eveyif it means losing out on him. I'm just talking about a bit of cheap insurance. We've done that in the past yet when it comes to a priority position we leave it late. Even the Brondby fans think it would've happened if we were earlier to give them time to sign a replacement, just like Tosun.

It's 13 games, which is just over a third of a season, and you are outlining a doomsday scenario which is incredibly unlikely to happen. This is very different to starting a season with 1 striker.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Feb 18 12.32pm

Originally posted by silvertop

What?! Tosun chose Everton over us. Most players would have made the same decision. More money; bigger club.

I stand by my uninformed belief that we have been chasing the Brondby keeper for months until somebody proves otherwise.

Everton weren't in for Tosun on 31st August or before. They were afterwards.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Feb 18 12.34pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Again, where is the negligence? Selling clubs would not release.

There are more than 2 keepers in Europe and Brondby couldn't or didn't get a replacement on the last day.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Feb 18 12.38pm

Originally posted by Username

It's 13 games, which is just over a third of a season, and you are outlining a doomsday scenario which is incredibly unlikely to happen. This is very different to starting a season with 1 striker.

You're right, it takes 38 games for 2 players in the same position to get injured. How silly of me and the 20 prem managers. They should all be pointed in your direction for reassurance it'll never happen.

And we've never had 2 players in the same position be injured recently before have we?

I'm sure we could call on Salako to put Hennessy's massive gloves just like 25 years ago.

 


COYP

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 01 Feb 18 12.42pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Probably can wait for a good keeper till the summer. But Roy's said and anyone sensible knows you need 3.

Sturridge was available on loan so not an option for us.

I appreciate we've not spent any of the summer budget and Adamou probably was a case of getting him in now instead of in the summer when we need to anyway but, let's hope this keeper situation doesn't turn out to be negligent because it's pure hope it won't rather than management of the situation we're relying on with that issue.

Actually Hennessy's a complete pussy so he's unlikely to be out for too long so maybe we'll be lucky after all.

Yes everyone says you need 3 goalies,so hopefully we get a New number one in the Summer.
I’m not privy to the “summer budget” I’ll leave that to Parish.
Anyhow onwards and upwards.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 01 Feb 18 12.51pm

Palace 'desperate for strikers' in the transfer window.

So what happened in the window.

Well 3 strikers left Palace and one joined.

One player only of those has PL experience and been part of a first team squad in the PL, that is Kalkai.

Eagles have less cover for the front men, the opposite of what the managers stated needs, which he identified last October.

No Eagles talent coming through, still, SP and DF not addressing the fundamental problems IMO.


 

Page 12 of 18 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up