This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
Huh? So not firing Pardew soon enough (by several months) allowing all confidence to erode and players like Puncheon and Dann suffer majorly form wise was down to having too much ambition? This could also be seen as having faith in your team/management team to turn us around, and actually attempting to have some Stabilty at The club - something that we have not had for a while at That point (or since!) Quote
Not signing a goalkeeper thus leaving us with 1 fit keeper (as Jules immediately got injured) is down to too much ambition? Not signing a striker last time around leaving us with 1 fit striker (who immediately got injured) was down to too much ambition? Not properly addressing glaring squad depth issues like left back before Souare went down was down to too much ambition? Not his job..The Manager needs to address those glaring squad depth issues, then work with SP to get suitable candidates in. If The Manager says he has enough cover, it's his call. We do not know what the Managers have asked parish to provide. Quote
Not firing Holloway sooner....hiring Neil Warnock (wtf)....down to too much ambition? Different scenario, we'd just arrived in The PL. Holloway had gotten us here. How many Times have we been astonished when a manager was not given the opportunity. Quote
Nah mate, these errors are down to Parish being a weak chairman in the context of other men in this league. Very, very poor chairman with poor judgement and poor planning skills. Only someone with a bizarre sense of judgement would laud themselves for signing a goalkeeper 6 months from now, when we desperately need one now. The only Thing that I can see can be levelled at SP is that he tends to tryget players on the cheap - i.e. trying to shave a few mill or doing some crazy buy now pay later deal, and ending up losing them. but this is most likley down to FFP. After all, we have splased the cash before, on CB and Mama (two that spring To mind).. neither have been an overwhelming success considering the cash spent. He's at least trying to learn from his mistakes.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
Huh? So not firing Pardew soon enough (by several months) allowing all confidence to erode and players like Puncheon and Dann suffer majorly form wise was down to having too much ambition? Not signing a goalkeeper thus leaving us with 1 fit keeper (as Jules immediately got injured) is down to too much ambition? Not signing a striker last time around leaving us with 1 fit striker (who immediately got injured) was down to too much ambition? Not properly addressing glaring squad depth issues like left back before Souare went down was down to too much ambition? Not firing Holloway sooner....hiring Neil Warnock (wtf)....down to too much ambition? Nah mate, these errors are down to Parish being a weak chairman in the context of other men in this league. Very, very poor chairman with poor judgement and poor planning skills. Only someone with a bizarre sense of judgement would laud themselves for signing a goalkeeper 6 months from now, when we desperately need one now. You can pick holes but SP has generally done a superb job - he has his faults re dawdling with transfers and going for proven quality manager or player wise rather than talent that's on the up, but his reign has been a success - no question. But there does not seem to be a model - it's fire fighting with a bit more conviction thanks to the American money, and the stadium plan to grow us as a club. There are no youth players coming through and a squad with no depth - that needs to be addressed because we can't rely forever on managerial changes and expensive transfer windows to keep us up - we are not bringing players through, be they our own or other clubs' youngsters - maybe the three we got this Jan will be more the types of buys we'll be getting in future.
|
|
| Brentmiester_General |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
People who keep banging in about this being our longest spell in the top flight in our history miss the point of threads like this completely. It’s been nothing but scraping survival at all costs. Now, I completely understand that approach in the first few years, but the reason so many of us harp on about progression isn’t because we’re getting too big for our boots, it’s because if we go down we will literally have nothing to show for the 5 years we’ve been here. We’ve come nowhere as a club. The problem with parish is every decision he makes is based on appeasing people short term & hoping he can get a tv appearance portrayed as a footballing guru, but he’s not even very good at achieving that. He normally gets about 3 weeks work a season because the rest of the time he’s back to desperately pulling off some great escape again. Our priorities are completely wrong, and it’s utterly pointless not to target progression with the amount of money you take in as a premier league club. Unless something changes, we’re goinf down anyway. Going down isn’t the worrying part, what worries me more is going down, having not progressed the footballing culture at the club at all meaning that coming back up quickly will be extremely difficult. Being in the premier league for 5 years is great, but we will hugely regret being so short sighted & failing to capitalise on what is a once in a history opportunity. Edited by Mstrobez (15 Feb 2018 10.02am) How well up on Palace history are you? It can’t be overlooked what we have achieved by staying up this long. Not even for your arguments sake.
"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ... |
|
| Brentmiester_General |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
Not being privvy to Steve's thought processes makes it difficult to form an opinion. The numerous Managers may have stories they'd like to tell. just hope steve has a plan I imagine he has a plan. And he’s pretty tidy at pulling things off on the business side with minimal fuss. He’s pulled in investment and sponsorship deals without anyone knowing about them until they have been completed.
"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ... |
|
|
Originally posted by Andy_G
It is becoming increasingly difficult to maintain even a mid-table position. Southampton, Stoke, West Brom were all sides who looked established in the mid-table and are now struggling. So unless we have buckets of money so make a play for the top 6 then I guess we will always be fighting relegation. This season has not been the best for Steve Parish he's made some blunders but I still believe he is the best man for the job. If we stay up he needs to learn lesson, that worries me as I'm not sure he's great at that. Largely agree Andy but I don't know why you say SP isn't great at learning. FdB was clearly a major screw up which SP admits. That had an obvious knock on effect on our summer hiring. Personally I find it hard to complain about the January window, we did as well as most but it does appear we could have converted the second goalkeeper opportunity had we been better planned.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
Not being privvy to Steve's thought processes makes it difficult to form an opinion. The numerous Managers may have stories they'd like to tell. When Sammy Lee left he had dinner with Ronald Koeman and the latter was quoted afterwards as saying that he was amazed at some of the things that went on although no clues were ever left as to what he was talking about
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
I personally think Roy will step down this summer. At the very least there is a reasonable chance given his age and the pressures of the job. It would be nice if Parish was ready for that. Goodness I hope not. Surely one year with a clear run at it would be a great opportunity for Roy.
|
|
| Brentmiester_General |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
I personally think Roy will step down this summer. At the very least there is a reasonable chance given his age and the pressures of the job. It would be nice if Parish was ready for that. I honestly don’t think that Roy feels the pressure we all do. Seems very cool, calm and collected. In an article I reward today for he even said that there is no point in panicking as it does no good. Said the time to panic was when he took over and we’re past that that now. He’s an absolute don the man.
"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ... |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
I personally think Roy will step down this summer. At the very least there is a reasonable chance given his age and the pressures of the job. It would be nice if Parish was ready for that. I agree with this opinion. Roy is starting to look a little tired. We could find ourselves needing a manager and a major player recruitment drive given the numbers of players out of contract, holes already in the squad and possible injuries carrying across to next season. As I said on an earlier thread if we stay up this year next season could very easily be worse than this if we don't prepare for the summer period properly or have the finances. Of course if we go down this season it may be handy to lose the manager and a number of players off the wage bill and start again.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
When Sammy Lee left he had dinner with Ronald Koeman and the latter was quoted afterwards as saying that he was amazed at some of the things that went on although no clues were ever left as to what he was talking about That's like a Willo comment without as much information! What does it mean?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
That's like a Willo comment without as much information! What does it mean? Koeman was shocked over the behind the scenes stories at Palace Sammy Lee told him about. What else could it mean?
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
That's like a Willo comment without as much information! What does it mean?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Koeman was shocked over the behind the scenes stories at Palace Sammy Lee told him about. What else could it mean? Its totally wild speculation and typical newspaper crap and tells you nothing, thats what. It's a nothing quote. It doesn't tell you anything about what was said, to who, or about who. It just says he was shocked. It could actually mean anything, FDB was crap? Well we know that. He didn't get on with the players? Well there were lots of rumours on here about that. Couldn't believe Parish got rid of him? We all know the reason for that, even Parish admitted it. Does it also mean that Sammy Lee goes around spreading malicious gossip about 'behind the scenes' stuff at other clubs, well that wouldn't be good for his management career if that is true. Finally if, as the Mirror is perhaps trying to suggest, that Koeman is disturbed by the turnover of managers at Palace then he should have a little look closer to home at his own career as a manager. 8 clubs and now sacked in 16 seasons is not what I call a manager who should be appalled by the turnover of managers especially when you consider one of his appointments was 4 seasons long. Now if you think I am completely wrong in my interpretation, then you will have rather answered your own question, as it could mean literally anything, hence my post. My post was in fact supposed to be pretty lighthearted and a little jibe at Willo's "I know" posts, so why did you feel the need to post on behalf of Midlands Eagle. Are you two a tag team?
|
|
|
Hysteria rules
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
Lots of polarised views about whether Parish is a) Mr Bean or b) St George. Heaven forfend that we should go the way of West Brom and throw the baby out with the bathwater (although it's true that thinking Pardew was worth hiring and Sturridge would stay fit are evidence of stupidity of at least the same order as anything we have seen). The problem is just the wrong people doing the wrong jobs. That's been addressed to some extent by bringing in Freedman to look at recruitment prospects and helping us identify talent that doesn't cost £30m. He's got the right idea with the signings we have made but the ones we should have made are symptomatic of the problem persisting in the area of completing player transfers and contracts. We've persued the right targets, avoided the duds (Diafra Sakho, Sturridge, looks like Tosun might be a dud too based on Allardyce's latest remarks), but failed to turn enough of those targets into signings and that's happened twice now (granted last time one of the targets was the aforementioned Tosun). FFS Parish just needs to step away from closing the deals and let someone who's good at it do it. And he needs to do that in good time for the next window and make clear that he's doing that because it will only get harder if other clubs see him as a national joke, a reputation which would seriously damage us and which his other work doesn't deserve. No need to make it into a pogrom. I tend to agree with a lot in this post ^^^ You don't buy a dog and continue barking yourself, and you also don't surround yourself with 'yes' people. New stadium/stand plans are a case in point. Did Steve get proper experienced football architects to do the plans ? C'mon Steve, sort your 5hlt out.
I disengage, I turn the page. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.